What does it mean to be physically spiritual? Joseph and Crystal talk with Andrew Reinhart, host of the Physically Spiritual podcast, about the connection between health and holiness. Andrew shares how leaving the seminary, discerning marriage and changing his own health habits showed him that we are body and soul together, and why relationships, worship and virtue matter more than any self-help technique.

Episode 157 · 62 min · With Joseph and Crystal Gruber and Andrew Reinhart
Being Physically Spiritual with Andrew Reinhart
Take the Our Outpost Quiz
A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.
Take the Quiz →Key takeaways on physically spiritual
- We are a body-soul unity. Andrew used to think of exercise as caring for his body and prayer as caring for his soul. Every prayer changes the body, and every bit of exercise affects the soul.
- Faith and reason make one symphony. Science is provisional and revelation comes from the divine mind, but the two can’t contradict each other. Our tradition also hands down a deposit of wisdom, like Chesterton’s fence.
- Hearts are changed through relationships. When we’re hungry, angry, lonely or tired, we decide by asking what our people do. Andrew’s own change came through his wife, friends, a doctor, a spiritual director and others.
- We worship first and are transformed along the way. The Mass isn’t primarily therapeutic, and prayer isn’t a technique. We only grow in prayer as we grow in virtue.
- Health isn’t the highest good. Jesus is the model, and he chose to lay down his life. Get clear on what you want, write it down, tell someone, and focus on the simple things that make the biggest difference.
“We only grow in prayer when we grow in virtue.”
Andrew Reinhart
Sit with this in prayer
Two questions to bring to the Lord this week.
Where have I split my life into a spiritual bucket and a physical one?
Whom am I really serving in the way I care for myself?
Chapters
- 0:00 Opening prayer and welcome
- 2:31 The Physically Spiritual podcast
- 3:52 From seminary to marriage
- 7:05 Grasping at certainty
- 9:04 Teaching about the body, neglecting his own
- 12:03 A body-soul unity
- 16:28 Faith, reason and science
- 21:40 Chesterton’s fence
- 24:00 Transforming the head and the heart
- 31:14 Prayer changes the body
- 32:16 The people who helped
- 38:25 Too relevant, not irrelevant
- 42:21 Worship comes first
- 48:49 Health isn’t the highest good
- 51:15 Whom do we serve?
- 56:52 Practical first steps
- 60:59 Closing prayer
Mentioned in this episode
- Becoming Gift, Andrew Reinhart’s website and the Physically Spiritual podcast
- Second Vatican Council, Gaudium et Spes 24, on finding ourselves through a sincere gift of self
- John Senior, The Restoration of Christian Culture
- Josef Pieper, Leisure: The Basis of Culture
- Christopher West on the theology of the body
- 1 Samuel 17, David and Goliath, and Matthew 5:8
As an Amazon Associate, Our Outpost earns from qualifying purchases.
Full transcript
Opening prayer and welcome
0:00 Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.
Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration, and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee, and by Thee be happily ended. Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.
Amen. Hello, Andrew. Hello. Hello. Oh, our pleasure. Thanks for joining us. We’re excited to get in more interviews in general and excited to, yeah, interview you in particular. Yeah, definitely. Yeah, it’s been fun to reconnect. What we ran into each other feels like a long time ago now.
That’s because it was a long time ago. With a mutual friend, Amber, who I think you were her team lead, right Joseph? I was. I think we tagged along at a retreat center when she was in the area near our home. Since then, it’s exciting to see what you all are up to with the ministry.
Yeah, then you led for… My wife and I joined a couple weeks ago. You led us through an evening of prayer and reflection together, which was a real blessing for us. I hope it’s something that you can continue to do, because it was awesome.
Well, thanks. Great. We liked doing it. We sent out a survey, but it’s hard to get intonation from surveys. It sounded like it was actually okay. Yeah, it was good. It was good in two ways. One, you didn’t try to do too much.
It wasn’t like we showed up and you blasted us with a fire hose for three hours and sent us home bewildered with a head full of information. And it was very much like the couples in the room, we were all… We’re all into our faith.
We’re living it. We don’t really need the basics, and you gave us something really solid to chew on and digest and practical and fun. Yeah, so it was a lovely evening. Yay, that’s like exactly what we were aiming for, so I’m glad to hear that that’s where we hit.
Awesome. Yeah, and it was fun to reconnect with you and hear that you’ve been podcasting and sharing more about your journey, which I’m very excited to hear more about. Yeah, how can we just tee you off so that you talk for a while?
That is what I most want to have happen right now.
The Physically Spiritual podcast
2:31 Yeah, well, my podcast is called Physically Spiritual, and in it I basically explore the connection between health and holiness from a Catholic perspective. And the presumption that I make is if we can kind of combine the symphony of truth through faith and reason, through things like biology, psychology, philosophy, and theology, that we can discover God’s design for living.
So that’s kind of the basic foundation of the podcast. So what I’m doing there isn’t really like basic catechesis, you’re not going to log in there and hear the hundred phrases that you hear thrown around on the internet all the time about the church.
It’s not apologetics, but we’re really trying to explore and go deeper and do some theoretical stuff, and likely I’m making some mistakes and errors along the way. But I’m willing to admit when I’m wrong. But the idea is to kind of take the dialogue deeper and provide people with something more substantial to chew on.
And where that came from in my life was I’ve been on this journey for about 20 years now. I can’t really believe it at this point, but that’s kind of where I’m at. When I thought of myself 20 years ago and I thought where I would be in my late 30s, I thought I’d be a lot further along the way, but yeah,
From seminary to marriage
3:52 part of my journey was four years in the seminary and I went into the seminary thinking, you know, the Lord’s going to kind of through the formation, tidy me up a little bit and I’ll come out of the seminary like a saint and ready to change the world as a holy priest.
4 years sounds about right for that. Yeah, 4 years sounds about right. But what the Lord did with me during that time wasn’t so much make me the saint that I thought I would be, you know, like reading all these old beautiful wonderful books, but like The Imitation of Christ and Introduction to the Devout Life and you know, all the kind of the solid classics.
What the Lord did with me during that time was to make me more human. And with that really began a healing journey in my life. Interestingly enough, a few years into the seminary, I started getting a word for mission. Now we had these like meditation times we’d make during the day.
I just started getting this word mission and prayer. It just kept coming up mission, mission, mission. And at first I was like, okay, Lord, do you want me to like go into the missions? I’ll go off to Africa’s and by the way, join the missionaries of charity priests or something like that.
And it became clear that no, the mission was here, you know, the new evangelization was here. Like this is quickly becoming mission territory around us every day. And in the moment that clarified in my mind that the Lord was really calling me a missionary where he kind of grew me in my home diocese.
The very next word that started coming up in my prayer was marriage. And I thought, okay, like this is a temptation, you know, I want to be a priest.
All my formation directors are giving me the thumbs up, the diocese is giving me the thumbs up, you know, like, if I want to be a priest and everyone else wants me to be a priest, Lord, like, why wouldn’t that be what’s going to happen here?
But the word marriage just kept coming into my heart and mind when I turned to the Lord and it got to the point where I literally couldn’t reflect without it being there. It’s like, like an elephant in the room, my mind had grown and grown and grown and grown to the point where there wasn’t space for anything else.
So I made the prudent decision and decided to stop praying, which I don’t recommend. And that wasn’t the right answer, but I went back to the seminary and this kind of gives you a snapshot into my life at the time. I was meeting with my spiritual director and he said, Andrew, like, why can’t you look at this?
Like, why can’t you think that this is the Lord speaking to you? And I said, I don’t know. And he just told me to sort of try to be open to it. And I left the meeting frustrated. And at the time, you know, I think I went and played some video games and then stepped outside and had a smoke.
And you know, that’s kind of giving a window into the kind of where my health was at that point. Yeah. And, and that evening or soon after, you know, memory is a weird thing. It kind of gets blended up.
Grasping at certainty
7:05 I had just had this meditation that Lord had given me that, you know, that the fruit in the garden was the knowledge of good and evil and Adam and Eve weren’t dumb, right? They were wise. They knew the Lord, they had named the animals, they, you know, their mind wasn’t darkened by sin.
So it wasn’t that they were ignorant of good or potential evil, but what it was was really they were grasping at it, right? The fruit, taking the fruit was them taking it for themselves and not relying on the Lord. And I realized like, that’s what I was doing with my vocation, that I didn’t trust what the Lord was placing in my heart.
Like I didn’t want to make a choice until I was certain, until I was sure, until I had this kind of like apodictic certainty that I was doing the right thing. And when the Lord opened my eyes up to that, it’s like, it just changed my whole perspective one.
And then over the next month, as I was kind of praying with that and sitting with that in the chapel, it’s like this distance that had been my heart as I was resisting the Lord’s words became harmony. And it was like a fog kind of lifted from my soul.
And so at that point, I, I left the seminary to discern marriage. And that’s, that’s all kind of like the background of what I’m doing now is that like clear call, one to mission, and then two to marriage.
And then putting that together, I, I jumped into parish ministry when I discerned out of the seminary and had, with some, some good friends and a lot of passion had helped start an apostolate to teach the theology of the body.
And you know, was teaching at the parish while I was working, but then was also getting more and more invitations to go and do teachings kind of regionally at, you know, places where teachers are being trained or people that worked at churches were being trained or going and giving a talk to that group or this group.
Teaching about the body, neglecting his own
9:04 And frankly, that I just started experiencing like dissonance again, this, this rub. And what the rub was, was I was going around talking about the theology of the body, but my body was frankly, a mess. You know, I was, I gained a bunch of weight.
I was smoking, like I already said, my sleep was awful. The way I was dealing with stress, like across the board, my health was just not very good. You know, so it was like, you know, your, your body’s an icon of God. Like I’m sitting up there thinking like, well, my body’s kind of a train wreck right now.
So I, I just took a step back.
Like I just stopped saying yes to go and give the talk to do whatever I basically kept my job and did fulfilled the duties, but let go of the rest of the ministries that I was involved in, boards of directors that I was on, all this stuff that I was involved with thinking I was building the kingdom and just tried to focus on being healthy for a while to like live the life that I was recommending other people to live to.
And in my, my weight at its height got up to about 400 pounds. And I say about because my scale stopped giving me numbers at 350. So I wasn’t really sure how big I was. I know at one point I stepped on a scale and it said 376 outside of my home.
And so let’s just say it was ballpark 400. And like the whole vision I had for my life, you know, of growing old and having grandkids and retiring, like that all like melted out of my mind, realizing like I’m probably going to die in my fifties at this rate.
And, and that was a real wake up call for me. And with that kind of took that deeper call seriously to get my life in order.
And over the next three years, I’d quit smoking, I threw diet and a very generous doctor who met with me every few months and, and eventually adding an exercise when I could with my, as my weight came down, managing stress, learning like new kinds of meditation, working on my sleep.
I ended up doing a sleep study, getting a CPAP just like across the board, sort of changed my health. And, and by God’s grace was able to lose about 200 pounds. And now I sleep seven, eight hours a night and I haven’t smoked in a decade or so.
And yeah, it’s sort of, I look at it and I wonder like, how the heck did I ever pull that off? Because like, I don’t have that kind of willpower anymore. I realize it was a work of grace along with all the good stuff that I was trying.
A body-soul unity
12:03 Um, but, but in the process of all that, my spiritual life also was revolutionized.
Like, like just my ability to show up and pray to on a consistent basis, wake up and give some of my time to the Lord, to focus in when I was trying to meditate, um, my ability to, to be moral, to be virtuous, you know, just to, to break other bad habits, like all of these other dominoes sort of went along with it as I was growing healthier.
And um, it, it helped me to see in many ways, like I was professing the faith with my mind, but I still had all these like heresies deep down that like my worldview wasn’t fully Catholic. You know, I would think things like, Oh, I’m going to go exercise and that’s going to help me be physically healthier.
And then I’m going to go pray and that’s going to help me be spiritually healthier. You know, not because like I’m a body, soul unity, I’m a person and, and every prayer I’ve ever said has changed my body and every bit of exercise I’ve ever done has also affected my soul.
You know, like I just had this weird dichotomy and buckets that I kind of had my life in and um, and I, I was just kind of set on fire to start trying to discover like what all this means because we often do a lot of apologetics in the veins of integrating faith
and reason, like that we do integrate faith and reason and us Catholics aren’t like against science and, and that, um, you know, you can reconcile ideas like creation and evolution and all these other things that our church is open to, but we don’t often take the next step and say, well, if this is true, what does this mean for our lives?
Like a faith and reason are, are, uh, you know, harmonious with one another. If what science is discovering is true, um, you know, this means that the way that we think about things like asceticism, the way we think about the way we fulfill the obligations of our faith, the way that we raise people in the faith, the way that we approach formation, you know, human formation,
pastoral formation, spiritual formation, and intellectual formation, like all of these, all of these various disciplines in the church need to be informed by, um, this full symphony of truth that we have available to us in our faith. Yeah. Something that, are you a student of Christopher West?
Yeah. So when I, I first studied theology of the body, I had his old naked without shame. Yeah. It was, there were cassette tapes and I had a summer job where I did, um, landscaping and that whole summer, man, I drove around with a weed whacker and a lawnmower and listened to those tapes on repeat.
So I, I asked the question in part because, um, having been to some of his week long courses, he talks a lot about dualism and the impact of dualism, right? This separation that we, that the world tells us exists, that we have a hard time really rooting out of our own lives as Catholic Christians.
And hearing you talk about how it seems like that, that tension you experienced when you were talking to people about theology of the body. And I think oftentimes people associate the theology of the body with the sexual ethics of the church.
But I think you’re, you’re bringing this really beautiful, um, again, there’s still a dualism even in that where it’s like, no, this is about the fact that we are body soul composites, that we’re integrated whole persons and that everything that we do impacts everything that we do.
And I, I love that you were able to see that that wasn’t the reality that you were living and that you had the grace and the courage to say, okay, then I’m going to pull the plug and I’m going to try to figure out how to live that way and figure out what, what can that look like?
And how do I explore that? And what does that mean for me? And that meant a lot for you to, you know, half your size and quit highly addictive habits. Yeah. Yeah.
Faith, reason and science
16:28 And, and, and it’s difficult because, you know, science is always provisional, meaning like the, the mode of knowledge we gained through the scientific method is different than that by which we gained through studying revelation through theology. So this is where people struggle with it is that like, like by definition, everything we think we understand about science will probably someday not think anymore, right?
You know, we’ll, we’ll understand things more deeply, more clearly. And yet that doesn’t mean that it’s not true, right? There’s kind of this, this constant focusing that’s happening through a scientific inquiry. But, but with that said, we also have to hold our, our understanding through reason very gently and very loosely.
I mean, we have to be very ready to let go of our ideas in a lot of what you find around the thought space around popularizing science today is a lot of like religiosity, you know, like just look at like the diet field between like vegans and keto and carnivore and you know, people who follow Ray P and all like, there’s, there’s a thousand different ideologies that people follow.
None of which honestly are probably completely true, right? There’s in 10 years, people are going to look back and laugh at, you know, the way people assume the body’s working, but frankly, probably each one of those methods could have some kind of positive benefit in your life.
But on the other hand, like what we know through revelation is it’s a totally different kind of knowledge because it, because the deposit of faith isn’t contingent upon our faculty of reasoning, right? It’s coming from the divine mind. So there’s a certainty of the raw material.
And then our understanding of it is assisted by the gifts of the Holy Spirit, especially in first and foremost, you know, the magisterium of the church and the Pope’s gift of infallibility. Right. So, so there’s, so we have to like clearly understand the relationship between those different kinds of knowing.
But with that said, like Aquinas quotes in the Summa, St. Augustine, when he’s talking about scripture and he basically says that since, you know, interpreting scripture and the scripture kind of sharing in the divine nature that, you know, many interpretations can be held together in tension.
He basically says when there isn’t a doctrine of the church at play, if knowledge we discover through reason contradicts the way we’re interpreting the scripture, he says that we should change our interpretation of the scripture so as not to bring scandal to people when they’re trying to enter into the faith, you know, which is pretty strong language that Aquinas and Augustine are using when they’re talking about reading scripture from that context.
So there really is a way that our understanding of the universe through scientific inquiry like needs to be taken into account. And if we don’t, right, we’re bringing scandal to our faith.
This was one of the huge things as a college campus missionary doing a lot of outreach to atheists and agnostics, where they felt like the Christian faith was at odds with science and be like, like fathers of our church, church fathers have said very clearly that these are cannot be contradictory, like the book of nature and the book of God’s word in scripture.
It’s the same author, it’s speaking, he’s not going to contradict himself. And since I was one of the only people who had ever said that to them, I wasn’t always taken very seriously, but I do like to think that saying it at least once to them, or having one source for it, is helpful.
And now we have Andrew saying it, but quoting Aquinas and quoting Augustine, and now the chain is massive. Yeah, not a direct quote, definitely an interpretive quote, but I’d be happy to provide the citation for any show notes. Yeah, and I really like the idea of the symphony, because you have different kinds of instruments, but they come together to create something that no one on its own could provide.
And also, it brings out the element of beauty that’s in it when you bring the different modes of knowing together. I think of, and this is like, it’s so built into the DNA of our church, you’re thinking of something like the liturgy, and how much wisdom there is built in the liturgy, not only wisdom that we have from Revelation, but so much wisdom that we just have from the ancient world.
The ancients knew so much about human nature, just frankly, out of trial and error. They figured out what worked to make humans flourish, and they thought about it, and they pondered it, and they understood a heck of a lot.
And what we have in our faith and in the scripture and in the liturgy is in many ways a bit of like a time capsule that unlocks a lot of that ancient wisdom for us.
Chesterton’s fence
21:40 I’m thinking of a recent book by Brett Weinstein and Heather Hoyne, and it’s about applying basically evolutionary biology to our modern lives. And in that book, he talks about a concept called Chesterton’s Fence, the basic idea that if you don’t know why the fence is there, don’t tear it down.
You never know what’s on the other side. You never know, or what purpose it served in the first place. And by discarding our ancient religions, our modern culture is unwittingly tearing down a lot of those fences. They don’t even know why they’re there in the first place.
So in and through our church, we’re also receiving a deposit of reason, not just a deposit of faith.
And then now as we think of applying this into a new context, thinking of our evening together a few weeks ago, of just getting together, having dinner, sitting down as friends and having a conversation, receiving something from someone that’s a big brother or sister in the faith, someone that’s perceived both as relatable and yet also perceived as somebody who has some kind of expertise or something to offer.
Well, those kinds of experiences go deep into our human history. Sharing a meal together, sitting around a campfire, telling stories, this goes all the way back. You’re tapping into something deep in the human body and in the human soul by doing this. Just having that level of connection, you’re forming the head and the heart.
My phone wouldn’t let me do not disturb, if you want to cut that out, you can. We’ll leave it. Did it come through on the mic? A little bit. No worries. We’ve now talked about it enough that it can stay. All right, perfect.
My IP phone updated and there’s no longer a do not disturb button on it. Sometimes upgrades aren’t always for the better.
Transforming the head and the heart
24:00 Understanding that we need not just the transformation of the head, but also the transformation of the heart. We could translate those concepts into our neurobiology and what neurologists have discovered about our brain is it’s essentially like a dual processor. It’s that idea of the lateralization of the brain.
There’s the left brain and the right brain. There was an old idea that some people are left brain, others are right brain and that’s not really true. Everyone’s like a whole brain person, but the sides of the brain are more or less different ways of processing the world around us.
The one side of the brain deals with language and logic and that’s where we get concepts and ideas. This is where we pick up a book and read it. The other side of the brain deals with attachment, love and emotion.
What they’ve discovered is when you’re dysregulated, when you’re hungry, angry, lonely, tired, when you feel unsafe, when you’re overwhelmed, the side of the brain that’s more involved in your decision making is actually that attachment, love, relational connection side of the brain. When you’re making decisions when you’re dysregulated, you’re not thinking through like, oh, what did I read in that book last week?
What was my plan of action? What’s the next right step? The brain just isn’t functioning in that way. What it’s doing is it’s asking the question, what do my people do? It’s solving the equation with attachment, love. The way to transform the heart isn’t to just learn new ideas.
That’s important. You need to be put in the right direction. You need to know the truth, but the way to transform the heart is to have relationships of love. The way we deliver the gospel in a ministry like Focus is, it makes perfect sense.
You get people together, you get to know them, you build friendships, and you give the truth to them. You’re addressing the head and the heart, but then there’s also a neural architecture in the human body that correlates with what’s happening. This is really fascinating.
Some of what you just shared is very familiar to me, but I don’t think that I have heard it said explicitly that when we’re dysregulated, we don’t use our logic brain for decision-making. Just like on a side note, it’s interesting in terms of discernment, how we say we don’t change a discernment decision when you’re in desolation because that’s not your brain.
You’re just saying that neurobiology affirms that your brain isn’t operating in the correct space. But the thing I’d like to spend more time on is this idea of… Real quick, we shouldn’t make desolation and dysregulation totally overlapping fears. Just as long as everybody knows.
I’m not trying to say they’re the same. But they’re related for sure, but not identical. We could probably talk for a whole other podcast on that topic on itself. But the relationship wasn’t something that I had thought about at all. The fact that we fall back on relationships for decision-making and those kinds of things.
We’re yearning for connection, for intimacy. We’re going to do things that we think are going to create. Do we have the kinds of relationships in our life that when we are in a state of either dysregulation and or desolation? Do we have people in our life that know what are the decisions that we already discerned and can they help us continue to walk in that?
Do we trust God enough that we’ll keep listening to Him? Are we just going to stop praying and go play some video games and have a smoke? Or do we trust Him? Do we keep listening? Or do we have friends and people in our life that we’re willing to hear out?
Oh, go ahead. Well, and I think one of the things, Andrew, that we have talked about in many, many, many of our podcasts is how is the topic that we’re talking about and considering, how does it relate to love of God, love of neighbor and love of self?
And by love of self, I don’t mean like this popularized self, love, self-care, whatever. But truly, if my body is a temple, how do I like these things that you’re talking about? And I think, yeah, just that even our brains have this like, not just visceral, but like actively important need for good, very real relationships to be healthy and functional.
Yeah, the human person, if you think of it from, and I’m agnostic about whether God created through special creation or evolution happened, I think it’s just a really good way to think about the natural world and understand it. But if you look at the species that whom biologists believe preceded the human animal, what’s particularly different about them is their ability to socially organize.
When you get up into the great apes, they have very complex relationships with one another. So in many ways, one of our superpowers as humans is to be in relationship. The way that we’re able to connect, to relate. And then you add into that reason, the ability to have language and share ideas.
It’s like our one thing that’s better than anything else in the world. So you then pull in the theological idea that we’re made in God’s image and likeness as a communion of persons. There’s something deeper here.
So when we’re thinking about something like character change then, like overcoming a vice, making it become a virtue, so much of what’s in the self-help world, which even what I’ve shared already should make the term self-help just seem absurd. It leads us to believe that if we want to become a different person, where we need to lean into is relationships.
And we think of those layers of God, others the self. Foundationally, our motivation when we’re in difficult places is attachment love. It makes perfect sense then that when God comes to us, He presents Himself to us as Father. Because our foundational attachment comes from our relationship with our primary caregivers.
Well, God comes to us as a new primary caregiver. So He’s offering us not just a new set of ideas, but an experience of Him that will renegotiate our nervous systems.
Prayer changes the body
31:14 Like literally our brains change when we’re praying. Like the really old part of the brain that regulates all the autonomic functions of the body doesn’t distinguish well between what’s in our imagination and what’s in our senses. And we all know this, right? If you wake up from a dream, your heart rate’s different.
If you fantasize, your body gets aroused. Like there’s all these functions of the body. Our body acts as if what’s happening in our imagination is true. So when we’re praying, our body’s changing too. We’re laying down new neural pathways. And this is one of the most powerful effects of stories.
The way that the brain interacts with narrative is your body literally starts to react as if you’re in the story at some point when the book fades away and your mind is completely captured in the text. That the things we read become our experiences and change our heart.
And we have bodies that make this all make sense.
The people who helped
32:16 So to return to your story a little bit, you had mentioned this graced period of time when many habits changed, your body changed. You also then noticed the kind of spiritual clarity and the increase in discipline allowing for a virtuous cycle rather than a vicious cycle.
Were relationships more majorly at play in that? Was this really and truly just more like divine intervention? Looking back, are there people that you would say, their example, their friendship, their mentoring, their coaching, the stories that I took in at this time, any of those kinds of things?
I’m curious. Yeah, there’s a lot of layers to that. I tried to ask the same question rather than a series of questions. The heart of it was still the same. It’s a great question. And part of the timeline is there was kind of a neutral zone where the Lord had put this inspiration on my heart to live a healthier life until I actually then started living that healthier life.
And we’re talking years of space. And then we’re talking years again when the transformation was happening. And I think both periods were important during that period when I was in neutral. My wife and I got married during that time. I switched from being in campus ministry to working at a parish.
And a big part of that shift was a lot of the people whom I had mentored and discipled in that earlier phase were now graduated from college and they became my friends. So continuing on living life with them, recognizing that a lot of them, frankly, ran past me in our mentoring relationships and starting to do basically a weekly men’s group with them was a big part of it.
So having the relationship with my wife and that relationship, having the men who I was kind of living life with, the doctor, who frankly, I literally picked them because he was overweight too. I didn’t want some skinny person who had never been fat telling me how to lose weight.
So I looked up a fat doctor. Incredible. And like the first year I met with them and he was like, well, I think you should try Weight Watcher. So I did that and it kind of worked. And the next year he’s like, I’ve been doing some research.
And he literally got out his prescription pad and started writing, eat this, don’t eat that. It kind of described more of like a low carb diet, but it had a real feeling of it, of like we were on a sinking ship trying to get off together.
So he was really journeying and trying to think about it and consider it too. Then he started meeting with me every three months as opposed to annually. So just having that reassurance that there’s a medical professional, giving me feedback on what I’m eating, tracking my weight.
We were taking my blood and doing testing to make sure everything was in line. And so that was a huge piece. I had an uncle who was a sleep specialist and he helped me to do a study and get my sleep sorted out.
I’ve had a spiritual director all through this time. I was in counseling. So there were different periods of time where my wife and I were in couples counseling and also I was in individual counseling. So there’s all these different layers of relationship and connection that were part of that journey.
And I know I couldn’t have done it without all that support. Like I said, this is spread out over five or six years when all this is happening. So thanks for fleshing that out. That was helpful. Yeah, for sure. Yeah. And such a beautiful witness on, you know, I think so often I know I am guilty of being like, oh, this will fix it.
Like this one thing is like the golden ticket to like me having more energy or me sleeping better or me, you know, whatever, or this, this one thing will be the golden ticket for my kid to not do this or to do that, you know, and realizing like, no, that there is,
I mean, this is another place where there’s a symphony of where we’re often in so much discord because we’ve got so much information coming at us and we keep hoping that, oh, maybe this piece of information will be the one thing that fixes all my problems.
And I think what you just shared is such a beautiful testimony to that, A, it’s not just one thing that there’s a lot of things. Yeah. That B, any one of those things takes a lot of work and a lot of time in and of itself.
It’s not a silver bullet that works overnight. Although I’m guessing a CPAP probably made a pretty big difference overnight. Yeah, it did. But even to get to that point can be a journey. And then to undo decades of not good sleeping, I’m sure that took time to really come to fruition.
And that there were the layers of both professional help and just the people that were willing to walk alongside you is such a great reminder to the depth of need that we have as humans to seek a fuller life and the importance of relationships to make that happen.
How do I tie what you just said with what I want to say? Just say it. I can tie it together. I’m then tying it together. Oh, good. Weight is off our shoulders, Andrew.
Too relevant, not irrelevant
38:25 I think meeting people who think that the Catholic faith is a relatively irrelevant thing, right? Like they go to church on Sunday, this is, oh no, you froze. Do we lose? I’m still here. Oh, there you are. You’re back. Okay. Oh, I came back.
Okay. Oh, it says our internet connection is unstable. Looks like we’re back in action. Oh, we’re back. Okay. Okay. Catholic faith irrelevant. Catholic faith irrelevant. And people saying, you know, I go to mass every Sunday and it doesn’t really change anything. And I’ve been listening to your podcast over the last few weeks, read of episodes.
And it seems like you’re convinced that the Catholic faith is relevant, like deeply relevant. And this disconnect between people’s lived experience of, you know, I was raised Catholic and it’s not doing anything for me. Or, you know, I came into the Catholic church and I’ve stopped practicing really.
It’s almost like instead of being irrelevant, it is too relevant. It is too transformative potentially, if we take it seriously, almost to the point of being overwhelming in terms of what all might need to change or might be changed over time. I’ve been pondering recently.
There’s a story that I heard a long time ago about a woman who is Catholic and like mediocrely practicing and her husband wasn’t, and he started looking into things. And he came to her one day and he said, if you really believed that the creator of the universe was truly present in that bread that you eat on Sundays, how can you not go to mass every day?
And I probably heard that when I was like first becoming a missionary and was like all excited. I was like, I want to go to daily mass forever and always, and it’s going to be awesome. And this is really inspiring.
And, you know, and but thinking about that of like, if we actually take the time to be intellectually honest about what we say we believe and confront that with the people that we’re sharing life with, it’s uncomfortably life changing. And I think that maybe this is like sort of tying this is partly my attempt to tie things together.
But to what you’re saying, Joseph, it’s like people don’t want to face that reality oftentimes. And Andrew, your story sort of almost proves the point, right? Like it’s a hard reality to face. It takes a long time and it leads to major changes.
But I think the beautiful thing about your story is that it also says that it’s worth it. And that the gospel is so much richer than… Well, let’s check before we assume. Was it worth it, Andrew? Was it? Definitely worth it. Okay. Definitely worth it.
Then yeah, keep going, Crystal. Yeah. I think the opposite question is equally as applicable. Like, if what we say about the Eucharist is true, why would we ever have to receive it more than once? But I think that’s God understanding our human nature, right?
And what we’re doing there is also something…
Worship comes first
42:21 And it was one of the key insights I’ve pulled out of Dietrich von Hildebrand is that what we’re doing there in worship isn’t primarily or the primary purpose isn’t therapeutic, right? We’re not there to be transformed, we’re there to worship God. And we’re secondarily or accidentally we’re transformed in the process of that worship.
And by flipping it on the head, we actually end up sterilizing it. If we’re there to be transformed and not to worship the Lord. Yeah. Yeah. Have you ever read John Seniors, The Restoration of Christian Culture? No. Oh, okay. Well, it’s worth it.
But he also talks about that tension. Culture is fundamentally going to be coming from the liturgy and from the mass, but we don’t celebrate these things. We don’t worship God so that we can make a culture. The culture is the end product of right worship.
And so people would say, I really want to change the culture. Like, this is a fundamentally disordered way to talk about it. We should say, I want to worship God rightly. My whole body, mind, soul, and strength devoted to the worship of God.
And that will, believe it or not, we have a three year old. Oh, nice. Yeah. He came into the room and then Christel took him away. And that was just you and me and our audience. That sounds good. I have a two year old.
He’s not in the room with me though. So it’s good. Yeah. But yeah, John Senior talks about this, Joseph Pieper in Leisure of the Basis of Culture. He talks about like, we need true festivity. We need true leisure. Culture is going to come from that, but leisure has to be a good unto itself.
Otherwise it’s not real leisure. And this tension like, oh, yeah, I mean, we’re sort of inundated with like the culture war and culture warriors and such. It’s like, that’s actually the wrong way to go about it. Yeah. And the same is true. Like I spend a lot more time in kind of the self-help literature world and like the idea of self-actualization or like becoming the best version of yourself.
Like all of this really isn’t what Christianity is all about. You know, like this, like my overcoming sin, my becoming the person that God’s calling me to, all this happens in the process of me seeking to worship God rightly. And this is, you know, that off quoted phrase from John Paul II or the Second Vatican Council that we only truly find ourselves by becoming a sincere gift of the self.
And with that, I think that’s an important thing to continue to hold together because then there’s the opposites true, right? That it’s not that like overcoming sin isn’t important. Like one of the deepest flaws in contemporary spirituality is disconnecting the growth of virtue from the growth in prayer.
And a lot of people think praying better is a matter of technique, you know, like learning a better technique. And that’s a very kind of Eastern idea. But we only grow in prayer when we grow in virtue. The truth will set you free.
And only the pure in heart will see God. Yeah, blessed with the pure in heart. Exactly. So with these ideas in mind, and this is where I like to pull in the classic idea of like mysticism versus asceticism. And basically like a mysticism is basically what God’s doing to us, asceticism is what we’re doing for God.
And so I think a lot of these kind of behavioral changes need to be positioned in the context of the church’s ascetical tradition, right? Because I’m not going to mass, you know, it’s like mass means Thanksgiving, but it’s not the same thing as doing my gratitude journal.
And then similarly, like prayer is good for me, like it transforms my nervous system. But I’m not doing my prayer in order to have a different brain, right? I want to have a relationship with a person who loves me and whom I love.
And in the process of loving that person, my brain happens to be different on the other side of that relating. So that’s a point that continually needs to be held out. Yeah, and when we make the transformation of our brain, mind, body, the goal, we’re much more likely to take shortcuts.
We’re much more likely to also to pretend like we’re further along than we are. This is a very huge temptation for people who are involved in different evangelical or ministerial kinds of positions to pretend that we’re not where we really are. Yeah.
And that I think is interesting because it goes also then when you’re in a ministerial position, people will often pretend that people want you to be further along than you are also. They want a guru. Yeah. We have some friends that have become very dear to us.
And the first time we met them and had them over, they’re like, oh, the Holy Family, the groupers. And we’re like, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. And they very quickly were like, oh yeah, you’re right. You’re not the Holy Family. Easily dispelled, unfortunately.
So it was nice to get like, you know, but we could not have developed the friendship that we’ve developed with them if they had kept us up on a pedestal. And oftentimes I think people do that because they want to think it’s possible to be further along than we are without whatever effort and work.
And so if we can imagine that somebody we know is that maybe just maybe I can get there and it’s like, no, we’re not. And you can’t either be either. And sorry. Yeah.
Health isn’t the highest good
48:49 Jesus is the mode and the model. You know, the whole self-help world is filled with people who are objectifying themselves as the advertisement for their product. You do a diet and you do a workout and then you take a bunch of photos of yourself, you know, after your workout and you put them on your Instagram, like that’s the way you get the followers.
So there’s a whole pressure in the community to basically like make your body into the billboard for the product you’re selling, the ideas you’re selling. You know, so sometimes I joke and say, well, I’m going to be the pudgiest person on YouTube talking about health.
Not that I want to be overweight, but the reality is like the idea of health that people have in their mind is often thin or like a six pack or, you know, these things that for a lot of people, frankly, is probably being underway.
It isn’t really what health is. But I try to make very intentional choices to make sure that Jesus is being held out as the example. And that means that like health isn’t an absolute value. Like we have to face the fact that we have a saver that chose to die young to like sacrifice his life for something.
So that means like, you know, you might discern, well, God’s calling me to have another child. Like understanding like your psychological health is probably going to be worse when you don’t sleep and, you know, you’re probably going to gain some weight, like things aren’t going to look so good afterwards.
But we’re not thinking you’re not going to be able to afford all that organic produce anymore. You know, like, like, like we’re making choices that in our context, you might not have optimum health, but that’s okay. That’s not the ultimate goal. Yeah. Right.
When we hold up martyrs as some of the best examples of people holding on to the Christian faith, it’s hard to say like the six pack abs and the organic apples are the root to self actualization. Yeah.
You know, I think that’s such a beautiful point of, you know, do we make an idol of our health and, and being aware of when that is a danger when, when we’re running the risk of that being dangerous, I think. Oh yeah, that’s a whole nother can of worms, but I think it’s a really important one to at least.
Yeah. And the, the question of whom do we serve?
Whom do we serve?
51:15 I was studying the story of David and Goliath with a couple of guys last night and it was fascinating. There are several instances when the question of who, who are we actually serving as the army of Israel came up in one, you know, Goliath identifies the opposing army as the army of King Saul.
He doesn’t say you’re the army of the one true God. He doesn’t say you are the army of the people of Israel, those who fight with God, wrestle with God. He said, no, you’re Saul’s. And then the second time Goliath comes out that we have in the story 40 days later, and he issues his challenge again.
The men around say, Oh, if only we killed him, we would be rich. We could marry King Saul’s daughter. And then our, our household will experience a kind of freedom, right? We will experience riches and sex and power. If we face this guy who will tear us limb from limb.
And that wasn’t enough to motivate them, right? Like the only person who was motivated to face Goliath was the one who said, we are the army of the living God. I want his name to be known. This is why I’m going to fight because he will fight for me.
And that’s obviously King David. But this question of why are we doing this? Who are we serving in what we’re pursuing? And this realization, Oh, there, there are many days when I, the only reason I don’t only serve myself is because I put people into my house who make me get outside of myself.
And like, that’s not a great thing. That’s not, that’s not a great day, but it’s certainly a better day when I’m only serving myself. And then the days when I get up and I’m like, I am here to serve the Lord. And he has given me these people to serve.
And I’m going to take care of myself as part of this whole thing. Everything is better integrated. Everything makes sense in that context. And I think too, it gives a proper lens to suffering. I think I see a lot with stay at home moms where they’re like, Oh, I’m suffering for the kingdom.
And they’re, there’s like neglect going on of themselves and of their relationship with the Lord, because they don’t think they even have time to pray. And, and like, that’s also not a proper understanding of sacrificial love, that it’s this, no, like what am I who the Lord is who I am here to serve.
And he might actually want me to like go for a quick walk in the woods in the morning, so that I’m fresher and energized and moving my body and these things. And, but there might be some days where he asks me to sacrifice that because my husband is sick, or because my child is sick.
And that the proper thing isn’t to not do it at all, because I need to sacrifice everything. The proper thing is to try to do the good and be willing to sacrifice it when asked. Yeah.
And it’s so hard though, like disentangle our, our feelings from our environment sometimes, because we do live in a rather wicked environment with, you know, like the world we live in has been, has been forged and crafted with ideas that aren’t Christian, you know, so even something as simple as like everyone owning an acre and having a mansion.
Like, like we’re kind of weirdly far from each other all the time, in a way that our ancestors rarely would have been. Like if you pick up an old novel that gets into the day-to-day life of people who lived in Christendom, like they were pretty radically close to each other, thinking of like Christian, sovereigns daughter or something like that.
Right. Like they just live together. Like it was weird for people to sleep alone, you know, even when they weren’t married or whatever. Like they just, they had this very like it also got cold in Norway to be fair. Yeah. But you know, I think people today would just freeze to death.
Yeah. Because, because we were just so far. So like we have to, to face the reality that we’re not just sometimes feeling bad because of our choices, but we’re actually in environments that don’t, don’t allow us to flourish.
So we’re also called to create a world around us that, that matches, you know, basically that’s our Catholic social teaching that we’re called to forge a world around us that, that corresponds with what we profess. So Andrew, in the interest of starting to wrap things up, I think I wanted to talk to him about this stuff.
I know. I, we, we might have to have you on again. I feel like we like open five cans of worms, which I would like to, to play in for a little while. I live in the cans of worms. We keep using this metaphor.
I have bad metaphors. She took it to a weird place. I’m not good at metaphors.
And then, yeah, so to, to wrap things up, speaking of, of changing our, like, you know, do, I guess the question is, is do you have a practical thing for our listeners of how, what is like a thing that somebody could do if they’re like, you know, I think I would like to do something a little bit differently.
What, what’s something that that could look like? Yeah. Two, two things.
Practical first steps
56:52 One, the, the part of your brain that deals with aspirations and the part of your brain that deals with decisions are different parts. So oftentimes we have like vague notions, which we aspire to and like, I’m going to be healthy, which doesn’t really give you a whole lot.
So, so you always need to get clarity, like what exactly do you want and be, be like rigorously honest with yourself. Like if you just want to look hot, like just denying the fact that that’s where your heart is, isn’t going to help you.
Like you need to lay that bear to the Lord and to your loved ones and, and, and beg for mercy, right? So you can have a different vision. But then once you have clarity and, and clarity that’s moving in the direction the Lord wants you to be in, then you need to make specific decisions.
Right. And some of the, I mean, this isn’t rocket science. Some of the things that, that help to, to bridge that gap between aspiration and decision are just simple things like writing it down. Don’t just write it down, put it in a public place where other people are going to see it.
Tell your loved ones, you know, some people will like advertise all this stuff on social media and that can be a little much like you don’t need to overshare on your Instagram to make a decision. But if, if that’s what works for you, I guess that’s what works.
But, but writing it down and telling other people can really help to bridge that gap. And I encourage people to live, live in the Pareto principle. That’s the old 80-20 rule, where like you get 80% of the results from doing 20%. And, and I think that really bears in the health world also.
Like if, if you’re thinking of your diet, your sleep, there’s probably 20% of the energy you could put in, in all these areas that will give you the vast majority of the results, you know, and, you know, like getting your butter from some Himalayan yak that’s been massaged with magnesium, like that’s probably isn’t what it takes.
Delicious. But like, but like not having pop and French fries, you know, like that’ll actually get you pretty far. Yeah. Yeah. So sometimes we can get caught up in the stuff that’s more on the fringe, thinking that’s going to make the difference. When really like, it’s just the real, like practical day-to-day stuff, like not watching TV before bed can really help you sleep better.
You know, putting your phone in a box when you get home and not getting it out until you go to work the next day can make a huge difference. Throwing all the candy away can make a huge difference.
So those are all, all things where I think people can make a lot of ground and also buying more candy afterward or not, not buying more candy after telling everybody that you throw out all the candy and then having your husband find the stash that you didn’t actually.
Yeah. Then you get to experience being loved. I love that. That’s awesome. Thank you very much for that, Andrew. I think that’s, those are really practical things. Where can our listeners find you? Yeah. So everything I do, I publish on my website at BecomingGift.com.
The podcast Physically Spiritual is published by Waking Catholic. So you can look up Physically Spiritual on Facebook, YouTube, any podcast player, and it’ll be there. Awesome. Could you say the name of your website one more time? BecomingGift, all one word, the word becoming and then the word gift and all in one word.com.
Excellent. All right. We’ll have that linked in our notes. And I try to list different things that we reference, like links to buy books or links to defined material. So I may do that as well. Okay. I’ll give you the actual quote from Aquinas as opposed to my poor pair phrase.
I got a couple of other good ones from the Catechism. They’ll send your way to, yeah, to point people in some good resources. Awesome.
Closing prayer
60:59 Would you like to close us in prayer, Andrew? Let’s. Father, Son, Holy Spirit, Amen. Heavenly Father, thank you so much for this blessed opportunity. Lord, I pray for everyone who’s listened to us that you would richly bless them, give them clarity, give them grace, give them purpose, help them with love.
Lord, I pray in a special way for anyone listening to us who might just struggle with body dysmorphia, with self-hate, with depression. Lord, I pray that you would give them consolation, that you would give them peace, that you would help them to love themselves.
Lord God, I lift up to you all the work we do, and I offer, if your honors we pray together, all glory be to the Father, to the Son, and to the Holy Spirit, as it was in the beginning, as now and ever shall be, rolled without end.
Amen. Father, Son, Holy Spirit, Amen. From our outpost to yours, thanks for listening, and a special thanks to JohnMarc Skoch, that’s S-K-O-C-H, for the music. Check him out on Spotify.
Keep listening
Share this episode
Listen with a friend, then ask each other: what one simple change would help us care for body and soul together?
