Catholic Dating Part 4: How Far Is Too Far, and a Better Question Instead

“How far is too far?” is one of the most common questions about dating and chastity. Joseph and Crystal offer a better question that helped them while dating and still helps in marriage: is this arousing, or is this affirming? They talk through why the distinction matters, how to use it out loud, and what to do when everything seems to be arousing.

A Word from Our Outpost, a Catholic podcast: Catholic dating and chastity

Episode 68 · 21 min · With Joseph and Crystal Gruber

Catholic Dating Part 4: How Far Is Too Far, and a Better Question Instead

Spotify Apple Podcasts Pocket Casts

Free · 4 minutes

Take the Our Outpost Quiz

A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.

Take the Quiz →

Key takeaways on Catholic dating and chastity

  • Ask a better question. Instead of looking for a line, ask: is this arousing or affirming? The distinction comes from the Creighton Model.
  • Always affirm. Love says, “It is good that you exist.” Every touch can carry that message.
  • Do not arouse what you cannot complete. Inflaming passions with no intention of consummating is a kind of lie told with the body, and it sets both people up for frustration.
  • Say the words out loud. The same touch can be affirming one day and arousing another, so check in plainly with each other.
  • Have an exit plan. Avoid situations like late nights alone on the couch, invite friends along, and go to confession often.

“If you feel like we’re taking the fun out of dating, we’re not. We’re taking out the heartbreak, the confusion and the mixed messages.”

Joseph and Crystal Gruber

Try this

If you are dating someone, have this conversation soon:

Agree to use the words “arousing” and “affirming,” and to honor each other’s answer.

Plan a few wholesome dates: a hike, geocaching, or an old radio drama listened to together.

Chapters

  • ~0:00 Opening prayer
  • ~0:55 The question people ask
  • ~3:50 A better question: arousing or affirming?
  • ~5:40 Telling the truth with our bodies
  • ~8:00 Say it out loud
  • ~9:10 Context and the cycle
  • ~11:15 Practice now, for marriage too
  • ~12:50 Dating should be fun
  • ~16:45 Red flags
  • ~17:25 When everything seems arousing
  • ~19:50 Confession and couches
  • ~20:50 Closing prayer

Mentioned in this episode

  • The Creighton Model FertilityCare System, a method of natural family planning
  • The original Superman radio show from the 1940s
Full transcript

Opening prayer

~0:00 Hey, Joseph. Hey, Crystal. How far is too far? In dating? Yeah. Listen in to find out more. Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.

Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration, and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee, and by Thee be happily ended. Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. You told me not to call it a dumb question?

Yes. Okay, so let’s talk about this fine question then.

The question people ask

~0:55 People often ask the question, once they’re into a romantic relationship, about the physical aspect of things. The question is, how far is too far to go physically with another person, you know? In a romantic relationship. Yeah. Where they’re not married. Yeah. Oh. Or like, what’s the line? Like, where does it become inappropriate?

Now, I do want to say, when we’re addressing this question, just so that we’re all on the same page, dear listener, we are making an assumption. We’re presenting this with this in mind? Yes, we’re presenting this with something in mind, and that something is that sleeping around, i. e. , having multiple sexual partners in your life, is not a healthy choice.

Physically, emotionally, intellectually, or spiritually. We could unpack that and convince you we’re not going to in this episode. We’re just taking it at a given. Yes. And so, the following advice is intended for people who are desirous of having one sexual partner that exists in the context of marriage. I think that sounds fair, based on, you know, all of the episodes we’ve recorded thus far, our tagline, the little intro that we do over the music, the description of our podcast, the name of our podcast, which I loaded with extra descriptors, so people might find it if they’re searching Apple Podcasts.

For Catholic disciples who want to be missionary minded. Now, if, dear listener, you’re not convinced that sleeping around isn’t a good idea for your overall well-being, we’d be interested in recording a podcast on that. But that’s not what this one is about. Because we want to get to the heart of the matter.

And the heart of the matter is, how far is too far? So if you know you’re not supposed to have sex, how far is too far? Which is an interesting way to phrase the question, because it’s just a weird image, right? Like, how far… I don’t know, it’s just like a weird… What’s the analogy there?

Because I can’t come up with an analogy where it makes sense. Like, how far to the edge of the line is it okay to go? Like, when do we ask that other times? When you’re like at the edge of a cliff? Like, I don’t want to fall off. That’s not a good analogy.

Yeah, so we have a different question. Oh yeah, so let’s get to a better question. We’re not saying the other one’s a bad question. Crystal said not to do that. We’re just going to give you a better question. Yes.

A better question: arousing or affirming?

~3:50 So our question that was very helpful for us, that we’ve given to lots of other people that have also said they found it really helpful, is arousing or affirming? And this has been the most clear line that we have found. It was very helpful when we were dating, because it’s even helpful now that we’re married.

It’s just a clear language and distinction that’s very helpful. Full disclosure, this is totally stolen from the Creighton Model System. They’re great. If you want to learn natural family planning, I recommend learning the Creighton Model. They talk about this. It’s where I got it, but we’ve unpacked it a whole bunch and used it and love it.

Not just once on a survey, which is where it exists in that. Super helpful. I love language. I love being able to make distinctions. This is a great distinction to have. We always want to be affirming. The essence of love is the affirmation of the other, saying that not only do I exist, not only do you exist, but I want to state in as many ways as possible that it is good that you are here.

So that’s our fundamental disposition toward the other, is to be affirming. So these aren’t contrasting, always be affirming. But arousing is a particular kind of thing, an action way of being affirming where we’re deliberately either trying to inflame our own passions or the passions of someone else, or we’re accidentally inflaming the passions of someone else.

We’re arousing their sexual passions. This is a good line to have because we don’t actually want to arouse somebody’s passions unnecessarily, right?

Telling the truth with our bodies

~5:40 It’s something of a dishonesty to go up to somebody that we like, that we want to affirm, that we want to find ways to love chastely and to do things with them that get their bodies prepared for sexual union when we don’t actually intend to consummate with them. But it’s a matter of telling the truth or of telling a lie with our bodies.

I’m telling the truth when, if I don’t want to consummate, if I don’t want to be in sexual union with somebody, and I try to not arouse them, then that is me being truthful with my body. If I do not have that intention of completing a sexual act and I’m trying to arouse the other, then we’re lying with our bodies.

There’s cognitive dissonance. If I’m intentionally trying to inflame my passions or the passions of the person that I’m dating, there are arguments about how that could actually be a mortal sin, like passionate kissing, that goes a little bit beyond just affirming. Passionate kissing is an arousing thing by itself. I don’t know if I’ve ever come across somebody who said, oh yeah, I can make out with somebody and it actually has no effect on me whatsoever, nor on the person that I’m making out with.

And if that is the case, then that actually in and of itself might be a red flag. That might be weird. But the point being, if we’re intentionally engaging in these activities that inflame the passion, that could be a mortal sin. At the very least, it’s just mean. Yeah, it’s setting people up to be frustrated.

To begin something that we are not intending to finish is a frustrating thing. That is at the root of what frustrating is, is to impede something that has begun. And so practically speaking, to avoid, because here’s the thing, you don’t always know if something is going to be arousing or not. And so to have this language can be really helpful to communicate that.

Right.

Say it out loud

~8:00 These are two words that should not just be in our heads. These actually need to be talked about in order for them to be at all relevant in a dating relationship. And again, this is just a great opportunity to enter into awkwardness together. And clarity. And clarity, which creates freedom. So to be able to say, is this arousing or is this affirming?

And we’ve used this just as a question. Joseph would start giving me a shoulder rub, and he would ask the question, affirming, because he was intending to be affirming. Or if, depending on the circumstance, if one of us was giving the other shoulder rub, then the other one might say, arousing. Because we know that that’s not the intention of the other, and yet that is what is happening.

And so we can just use that word to say, okay, that’s not, let’s not do that right now. And this is an interesting thing too, because again, the clarity and constant communication can be really helpful, because

Context and the cycle

~9:10 the same physical act could be arousing in one circumstance, and affirming in another. As an example, if you’re driving to your grandmother’s funeral, and your significant other puts their hand on your knee, that might be very affirming. If you’re watching a scary movie in the dark alone together, and they put their hand on your knee.

Maybe a romantic movie more so. A scary movie, who knows what’s going to be going on emotionally. It’s true. So a romantic movie, and your significant other puts a hand on your knee, that’s more likely to be potentially arousing. And so to ask those clarifying questions, also, women will often have different responses based on the time of month.

Tell me more. You mean that the day of the month might be affecting them? In terms of where she is in her menstrual cycle. Oh, that thing. Yes, yes. So it tends to be easier to arouse women around the time that they are ovulating, which is also around the time that baby making is possible for women.

And so I think sometimes something you, I think we found challenging is I would tell you one thing wasn’t arousing. And then two weeks later, I would say it was arousing. And that was confusing and frustrating. Like the context didn’t change, the action didn’t change. But you were different. Whether or not I was ovulating changed.

And that made a difference as to whether or not something was arousing. Yeah, as a general rule of thumb, when women are fertile, they tend to be more arouseable. And as another general rule of thumb, doesn’t apply all the time. But men are pretty much always fertile, which means they’re more likely almost always arouseable.

Yes. So that’s a good thing to keep in mind, because men and women, I’m going to be very controversial here, are different.

Practice now, for marriage too

~11:15 This is also, I think, really neat, because I think this is a really poignant example of where practicing something in dating, when practiced well and appropriately, helps prepare you for marriage, regardless of whether or not you’re marrying the person you’re dating. Because this language of arousing and affirming this practice of knowing when you want to be affirming or not is really helpful.

And then if and when you do get married, you get to take that information about what’s arousing and use it, because you can enter in. What does that become once someone is married? I feel like this is like a trick question, because the answer feels really obvious. But no, foreplay? Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Anyway, so going on. Yeah. So this is a helpful practice, not just for dating, but also to be carried into marriage. And there are times in marriage when, for whatever reason, abstaining from sexual union is the appropriate thing to do. And again, to engage in arousing activities, when the intent is not actually to consummate the union, is a bad idea.

We can set aside the moral implications for the moment and just say that it’s just a very confusing and frustrating and unnecessary complication to introduce things that are arousing when it’s actually a time just to be affirming. This also clarifies, you know,

Dating should be fun

~12:50 some people may hear up to this point and then think, well, dating doesn’t sound very fun then. In which case, I would suggest maybe they might want to reconsider what they’re doing while they’re dating. Because the point of dating is to have fun by doing good wholesome things together, whether with other people in the context of double dates or triple dates or group dates, or doing good in terms of doing service in the community, or spending time with each other’s families, or reading, or hiking, or doing fun things that are not arousing.

If we see dating as this arena of just, you know, this is where I go to be aroused, that’s a very weird and distorted notion of how the sexes ought to relate. And that also leads to even greater heartache if the relationship doesn’t end in marriage. Because basically people have been playing with fire, and it does burn.

Who’d’a thunk. Yes, yeah. And if you’re worried about figuring out creative ways to have fun, if the physical aspect has been a primary source of fun in the past, Dr. Google has lots of great ideas. Just like Googling fun date ideas. Fun wholesome date ideas. Fun wholesome activities. I Googled fun wholesome activities the other day, and it came, I found a list of like 25 things to do with your family.

Like geocaching, and going on hikes, and I was like, oh, I could be doing those things. That sounds fun. Yeah, I think one of my favorite random dates that we did was, you can download the original radio show from like Superman, was it? Yeah. Oh, I mean, there are radio shows from the 30s and the 40s that they still have digital copies of.

You can listen to the last son of Krypton being sent to Earth in the first radio presentation of Superman. You can find that online and listen to that with somebody. Pretend like you’re back in the olden days. There are all sorts of cool things people can be doing. Yeah, so if you feel like we’re taking the fun out of things, it’s time to have a come to Jesus moment about that, because we’re not taking the fun out of things by saying you can’t be realizing.

We’re taking the heartbreak, and we’re taking the confusion, and we’re taking the mixed messages, and we’re taking the lack of clarity, and we’re taking the, did I mention, mention frustration? I don’t know if you did in this particular list, but yeah, that’s what we want to take out of dating. Yeah, so you’re welcome.

Yeah, I feel pretty good about that. Anything else we should take away from dating? Well, I think we want to do a couple other little podcasts, but I think that about covers the distinction of arousing versus affirming. And we literally mean it just entered into our conversation, just so we’re super clear. We would just say, oh, was that affirming?

I intended it to be. Or if we notice that our partner seems, you know, maybe a little bit more affectionate, we’re like, oh, are you intending to be arousing right now? Because that’s the vibe that I’m getting. And then and then we’re like, go outside or like call a friend to hang out with us.

Yeah. And if we find that our partner is actually continuing to do things that are arousing, even when we say, please don’t or we should try to do something else,

Red flags

~16:45 that’s actually a really great red flag. We want people who can communicate clearly and be on the same page about what the intention of dating is. And if somebody’s like, oh, no, I’m here for the feels. I’m all about the emotional, the passionate, like, huh, we have to make a decision. Is that why I’m dating?

Is that what I’m dating for? If you are, this podcast is probably not for you so much. And that’s okay. I do think that’s actually maybe one last point is,

When everything seems arousing

~17:25 okay, so you’re in a situation and you want to be affirming, but it seems like everything’s arousing. Don’t think that we maybe said this explicitly. I think it’s worth saying that that very well could happen. In fact, it probably will. And so having sort of an exit strategy, and you find yourself in a situation where you realize okay, this is just us being in these circumstances is leading to we’re having trouble only being affirming.

Knowing, you know, either do you just need to not be together in that moment? Do you need to call a friend? Do you have a roommate that you can have join in and watch the movie with you? Or what have you, but to be able to have that conversation of if and when we end up in a situation where it seems like everything is arousing, how are we going to handle that?

And how are we going to keep ourselves accountable to not going down that train? Yeah, and maybe something else to add to this. This is not to say that we should not find whoever we’re dating attractive. Very much not the case. In fact, if it’s not at least a little bit of a struggle to not be arousing to each other, that’s also a problem.

So just to be clear, if you say, Oh, yeah, we’re affirming all the time, and we don’t struggle with being arousing to each other at all. That is, unfortunately, also a red flag. It might be at least a yellow flag. Yeah, I mean, you might be just doing this whole, wholesome dating thing to a T, in which case, you know, all the more power to you.

Most people don’t, and there will be struggles. And that’s actually to be expected. But to have clear exit strategies, to have clear language, to have a clear shared intent, like, I don’t actually want to do anything that is arousing, because I want to affirm you so very well. And it’s actually the opposite of affirming to intentionally arouse someone when it’s actually improper to do so.

Yes. And if and when you just fall flat on your face, this is

Confession and couches

~19:50 what the sacrament of confession is for. And also, even just if you’re struggling, even before you’re falling flat on your face, using the sacrament of confession regularly will help you have the grace to hold true to this one. And this is, the one confessor said, you know, I’m pretty sure Satan invented couches to ensnare dating couples, something like that, right?

It’s something to be mindful of. Oh, sitting on the couch at night, alone, with the person I’m dating, that almost never ends well. Yeah. And that’s just good to know. Maybe nobody has ever mentioned that before. We’re mentioning it now. Yeah, it might be worth even taking notes, keeping a little logbook or something, things that are not helpful.

All right. In the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit. Amen.

Closing prayer

~20:50 Heavenly Father, thank you for this conversation. We just lift up to you. Any couples in pursuit of their vocation? Any people desiring their vocation that this would be helpful in growing in holiness while seeking to do your will? We ask all this in your holy name. Amen. In the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit.

Amen. Yes, I know. From Our Outpost to yours, thanks for listening and a special thanks to JohnMarc Skoch for the music. Check him out on Spotify.

Keep listening

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *