Chastity: Window to Beauty

Dostoevsky once wrote that beauty will save the world. We wrap up our series on the virtues that open us to the transcendent with chastity, the virtue that lets us see each person as an icon, a window into God, rather than a spectacle to be consumed.

A Word from Our Outpost, a Catholic podcast: chastity

Episode 40 · 47 min · With Joseph and Crystal Gruber

Chastity: Window to Beauty

Listen on Spotify Apple Podcasts Pocket Casts

Free · 4 minutes

Take the Our Outpost Quiz

A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.

Take the Quiz →

Key takeaways on chastity

  • Learn to read the love letter. A piece of paper can be studied for its pulp and ink, and still be missed entirely if we never notice it’s a love letter. Being blind to the transcendent is a kind of illiteracy.
  • Icon or spectacle. We can treat stories, and people, as something to watch for pleasure, or as windows into something deeper. Chastity chooses the icon.
  • Every person is a whole world. The flesh and blood in front of us carries thoughts, desires, dreams and the movement of the Holy Spirit. The moment we see someone as something to use, we stop being chaste.
  • Sit with the desire. Like reaching for marshmallows when we’re really hungry, we often chase what won’t satisfy. Chastity grows when we ask what we’re actually hungering for.
  • God wants union with us. Our desire for intimacy points to God, who will never use us and who has extended to us a wedding invitation.

“Each person is a window into who God is in a unique and unrepeatable way.”

Joseph and Crystal Gruber

Try this together

Talk with your spouse about where you’re tempted to settle for the spectacle instead of the icon. Then pray together:

“Lord, help me see the people in front of me the way You see them.”

“When I’m tempted to take, teach me to receive.”

Chapters

  • Beauty will save the world
  • Three virtues for the transcendent
  • The love letter analogy
  • Spectacle versus icon
  • Rewatching The Truman Show
  • Seeing each person as an icon
  • The marshmallow problem
  • Sexual desire and the future
  • What malforms us
  • Ordering our loves
  • Our dating fast as missionaries
  • Future tripping
  • When the heart grows
  • Running toward the real desire
  • You are beautiful to God
  • The wedding invitation
  • Closing and prayer

Mentioned in this episode

As an Amazon Associate, Our Outpost earns from qualifying purchases.

Full transcript

Beauty will save the world

Joseph: Do you know what Dostoevsky used to say, or at least he said once in The Idiot?

Crystal: Beauty will save the world.

Joseph: Let’s talk about chastity. Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.

Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration, and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee, and by Thee be happily ended. Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.

Amen.

Crystal: I think this might be a good one, I just accidentally poured tea all over myself.

Joseph: Oh wow.

Crystal: Is that a good sign? I hope so.

Joseph: What’s going to spill out now?

Crystal: Well, hopefully something beautiful, because apparently beauty will save the world.

Joseph: I think so. Dostoevsky thinks so. That’s two people, which is pretty good.

Three virtues for the transcendent

Anyway, today we’re going to talk a little bit about the virtue of chastity. We’ve been going through three virtues that are especially important for our ability to be aware of, to live in the world of transcended reality.

That we can see just material things and accept that, or we can see beyond them, through them, alongside them, and that element of the transcendent is something that we’re made for, that completes us, that we can never get enough of, and without these virtues we’re closed off to.

Crystal: Yeah, and they help us to understand the fullness of what it means to be human, the particular essence of being a human person. That a human person is not just the physical realities, but that we also are integrated body-soul composites that have these hearts that desire, and desire a fullness of depth that we know we don’t have access to unless we’ve encountered God who is infinite.

Our hearts desire the infinite, and that it can only be found in God.

The love letter analogy

Joseph: So I don’t know how good this analogy is, but it’s been in my head for a while, so I’ll use it. It’s as if I slip you a piece of paper and ask you to really look at it hard, and you decide to take that piece of paper to a laboratory and figure out exactly what kind of tree pulp was used in its manufacture.

You see that there’s ink on it, you find out what kind of ink, what kind of pen, you find out how deeply it was impressed upon the paper, but at no point do you realize that the piece of paper was a love letter, that there is something more than just a piece of paper with ink on it, but a piece of paper with ink on it can transcend just a piece of paper with ink on it, because it has more to it than that.

Yes, I like that. And to be blind to the transcendent is to be illiterate, to be willfully sometimes, and sometimes maybe not so knowingly, illiterate to the larger meaning around us.

Crystal: Yes, and we have a name for the things that when we learn to see them as a window, as a way that shows us into the transcendent, and that’s an icon.

Joseph: Right, oh, before we do that, real quick, because I realize we should have summarized a bit more, truth is guarded by the virtue of sobriety, and goodness is guarded by a fundamental disposition toward excellence, to choose the excellent moment to moment by responding to the love that created us.

And now we’re going to talk about chastity, which is this window, this icon to beauty. Now you’re ready.

Spectacle versus icon

Crystal: Well, so I think it’s really helpful to contrast the icon, the being able to see the love letter versus what happens when we’re not looking at the thing as a window, which can be a spectacle.

Joseph: Right, and I think it’s helpful to use more real cultural examples. A movie that I enjoyed very much, film even, is Thor Ragnarok. But honestly though, it is more of a spectacle than anything else, right? Really meaningful things happen all throughout the movie.

There’s a loss of a father, there’s a potential loss of a brother, there’s drunkenness to avoid pain, there’s a literal gladiatorial combat, there’s a man who’s on the verge of losing himself. All of these things very deep, but they’re treated as a humorous spectacle, right?

Like the gladiatorial games of old that were treating conflict as something to just be watched for pleasure. So too was Thor Ragnarok saying, here, just have a pleasant time watching these heart-wrenchingly painful things, because we’re going to offer comic relief. We’re going to resurface from this painful moment and not allow you to reflect, but rather we’re going to do the opposite of reflecting.

We’re just going to keep moving.

Crystal: Yeah, and that spectacle compares to…

Joseph: A more iconic movie, which would be something like The Shawshank Redemption, which it’s in my top five. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 is my top movie. And my top five though is Shawshank Redemption.

Crystal: And it’s iconic because it hurts. You’re looking into the window and you’re seeing the hard realities of what it means to be human, and they don’t just move on.

Joseph: You have to sit with the things that are painful. But even in that, you see someone who’s essentially good and his effect in a world that’s so twisted. There’s so much depth to the movie, and it’s not just because it’s narrated so beautifully by Morgan Freeman, though that does help, but there are moments where life is given to us to see more depth than we otherwise would have access to.

And it’s accomplished so beautifully. There’s a scene where Andy Dufresne has just gotten a shipment from various libraries, and in it there’s a record player, and he plays music over the loudspeakers. And everyone in the prison yard stops, transfixed, by the beautiful singing of these two women.

And it’s this moment where Morgan Freeman says something to the effect that for just a moment, every man in Shawshank felt free. Something beautiful, iconic moment, that lifts the soul and helps us to realize the goodness of life in a new way. We see something beautiful, made even more beautiful because of the harshness around it.

It’s beauty that survives, beauty that endures.

Crystal: And the thing that’s interesting to me is, talking about movies, so some movies keep on moving, and they are a spectacle. We can take the time to have a conversation about how this could have been iconic, how it could have pointed us on, and dive into that.

But then it’s not the movie that’s being the icon, it’s the conversation that’s allowing us to talk about the transcendent. But I think there are some movies that are easy to watch as a spectacle, that actually are and could be an icon. Like Shawshank Redemption, you’re not going to watch like for funsies as a spectacle.

It just is iconic. Whereas I think there are other movies that can kind of go either way.

Rewatching The Truman Show

And I recently had the opportunity to watch, rewatch the Truman Show because I got to go to the Theology of the Body head-to-heart immersion course that Christopher West does, the five-day course.

And one of the things you do, spoiler alert if you ever go, is you watch all of the Truman Show and essentially talk about how it’s iconic and how it unfolds, what it means to be human, and a lot of what John Paul II teaches in his Wednesday audiences that we call the Theology of the Body.

And that was something that was really interesting and powerful to me to realize. When I watched it years and years ago, originally, I didn’t think about the deeper meaning. I thought it was entertaining, I thought it was interesting, probably acknowledged that it was thought-provoking, but rewatching it, it’s so, I mean…

Joseph: Can you give an example?

Crystal: Like there’s one character who is sort of this like maternal Marian figure of sorts, and she, her clothes are, oh, I wish I, no, I’m having trouble remembering, but there’s details like what she’s wearing. Who’s the character? It’s the woman that kind of breaks in and is the one that Truman kind of actually falls in love with, but then she gets taken off the show.

Joseph: Oh, was it Rachel or something?

Crystal: Yeah, I don’t remember. And there are things like the name of the boat, which again, I’m forgetting.

Joseph: All of this to say, maybe you should watch the Truman Show again and notice the details.

Crystal: I mean, the names of the streets and the colors that people were wearing and these different just very small details that we’re pointing towards, there’s something more going on here than just what meets the eye on the surface.

Joseph: But it took a little bit of training to see that, right? Yes. To approach it saying, I’m going to see this for what is more, right? There’s however many frames per second projected on a screen of various colors. There’s the story that the movie is telling, and then there’s the deeper meaning of the

Crystal: story.

Joseph: And you’re approaching it with that level of I’m going to watch it as an icon.

Crystal: Yes. And the thing that’s interesting to me, I mean, we talk about this with film, with entertainment, but this is true about every single solitary human being that we meet. We can either see the spectacle of somebody’s life, which a lot of people willingly display on social media, or we can take the time to really see each person is an icon.

Each person is a window into who God is in a unique and unrepeatable way.

Seeing each person as an icon

Joseph: And so chastity, then, we can describe it as this virtue of seeing the other person rightly as an icon, right? There’s the flesh and blood in front of me, but that flesh and blood actually betokens a whole world inside of that person, right?

There’s an interior life going on. There are thoughts, there are feelings, there are desires, there are dreams, there’s the Holy Spirit prompting them, there are other spirits around them, they literally have a whole world of perception in them. And the moment that I choose to not see them as that person, but rather to see them as someone, as something to be used, I have ceased to be truly chaste.

Crystal: Yes.

Joseph: And the decision to see every person as an icon is a decision to be chaste, right?

Crystal: And it takes, to do that, takes a rightly ordering of our desires.

Joseph: And that’s tough, because our desires are all out of whack. Yes.

The marshmallow problem

There’s a story that I sometimes tell. For whatever reason, we had a bag of marshmallows in the house. And my son, Philip, knew this. Maybe we had had, I don’t know, we probably had a fire and we’re doing some mores at one point, but we had leftover marshmallows.

And he would wander through the house and say that he was hungry. And I would say, all right, what would you like to eat? And he would say, marshmallows. And my response would be, would marshmallows actually fill you up? Will you actually be satisfied if you have marshmallows, if you’re really hungry?

And he said, I don’t know. And then I would ask, have they ever satisfied you in terms of your hunger? No. Do you think that they will now? Maybe. And that, like, eternal optimism, right, like, say, this hasn’t ever satisfied me before. Every other time that I’ve gone to this source, it has never been satisfactory.

But maybe this time will be different.

Crystal: And it’s funny because it is pleasurable. Now I want to go eat a marshmallow.

Joseph: Why we have a bag of marshmallows in the house again? I don’t know. But we do.

Crystal: Philip saw them in the grocery store and asked for them. And I said yes.

Joseph: You didn’t have the longer conversation.

Crystal: I didn’t. I just bought the bag of marshmallows because I like them too. It’s pleasurable to eat them. But it doesn’t. It doesn’t actually satisfy the hunger. And the satisfaction of the sweet tooth lasts all of, like, four seconds after the marshmallow

Joseph: is gone.

Crystal: But boy, while I’m eating that marshmallow, I sure do like it. And yet, that’s not allowing me the space to enter into what’s actually going on, what’s actually good.

Joseph: That you are desiring.

Crystal: Mm-hmm.

Joseph: Right? Like, if you actually have hunger and you’re going to something that won’t fill it, you’re never actually sitting with that question, what am I hungering for?

Crystal: Mm-hmm.

Joseph: And being able to face that question head-on, it’s a tough thing to do.

Crystal: It really is. Because sometimes the answer is a peach or some other piece of fruit. And other times the answer is real love or… Oh, yeah.

Joseph: There’s that line from Lego Movie 2, which is also in my top five movies, I think. Where the man who’s actually an ice cream cone interjects that you can’t eat ice cream just to try to solve your problems or something like that. He had a personal bias against it.

But sometimes we go to satiate one desire by going after another one.

Crystal: Mm-hmm.

Joseph: We say, well, I don’t have this thing that I want, therefore I’m going to go have ice

Crystal: cream. Mm-hmm. And learning how to sit in that desire is where we actually learn the virtue of chastity, is when we learn to rightly order that.

Sexual desire and the future

So when we talk about chastity, the sort of obvious desire that people like to think about is that of sexual desire. And yet hunger is very helpful in trying to understand properly ordering sexual desire. In fact, I believe in Introduction to the Devout Life…

Joseph: Yeah, I think we’ve mentioned that in a podcast.

Crystal: Okay, yeah.

Joseph: Were you just reading it, or?

Crystal: No, I just remembered it, but St. Francis de Sales essentially says, I’m going to talk about food as a metaphor, but really I’m talking about sex, although I don’t think he says that explicitly. Essentially he does, yeah. And this is interesting, because what is it that the sexual desire is?

Joseph: Are you going to answer that, or are you going to leave me hanging?

Crystal: I guess I can answer that. So this is, it’s interesting because I think oftentimes in today’s culture we forget that sex makes babies, or at least it can.

Joseph: Wait.

Crystal: It doesn’t always. It makes babies? But yeah, procreation is a thing that can happen when people have sex. And we’ve divided this apart culturally, and that’s a whole other thing. But the fact that it makes babies, for one thing, it shows that it’s connected to the future.

Joseph: Yeah, so I don’t endorse this comedian, but I’m going to reference him in part because he’s hilarious. Louis C.K., I understand that he’s also on the out and out because he has a lot of perversions himself, but he’s got a bit where he talks about how when a young man is looking at pornography, he’s looking at women, and his desire is saying, I wish to create a child with you.

The things that are desirable about the women he’s looking at are the things that lend themselves toward babies. Men tend to be fixated very much on a woman’s chest and on her hips. And in large part, that’s because those two areas of her body are pretty essential to the having of babies and the nourishing of babies.

So the thing that’s attractive, if you ever stop to think, it’s like, I want a child with this person.

Crystal: And I want a future with this person. And obviously, this is not what’s going on in the conscious mind or even once it is all thought through, there’s this realization, oh, maybe I don’t actually want that with that person. And yet, that’s the attraction, the desire that’s weaved in there is this idea of, I want to make a person with this person.

And this is interesting because when chastity, when the sexual act is rightly lived out, regardless of whether or not a new baby is created, persons are made more person-y.

Joseph: We’re very, very technical on this podcast. But this sense like the affirmation of the other and saying, I think that you are so good that I desire you to live into the future in a way that’s totally new. And in a way that’s totally united with me in the form of another person.

And to say, it’s an act of affirming the other person to engage in a sexual relationship chastely.

Crystal: And it also is allowing for that vulnerability and that willingness to be seen and to see the icon, the window into the heavenly reality and to be able to say, I want all of you, I want to see all of you, I want to know all of you more fully.

That that is a chaste approach to the marital act, to the sexual act, that that actually allows me to see you more of who you are as a person. So even if a new person isn’t created, I know you as a person more fully.

Joseph: And this emphasis on futurity, I get wrapped up in this, but it’s saying, I want you to be the mother of my children and I want to father them alongside you. The act is saying, in the moment, I’m giving you my future and I desire your future.

And because it’s a reciprocal act, it’s one in which neither person’s will is being abrogated, but both wills are being affirmed.

Crystal: And this drives a further continuing to reshape how we see the world and continuing to reshape how I now approach the future, which is interesting because when we look at unchaste acts, they also reshape how we see.

Joseph: Right. Same thing first with food, because if I say I’m going to eat food for the sake of pleasure, I’m going to become less and less attached to the idea of food as a nutritive source of nourishing.

Crystal: Well, and it’s amazing because sugar is like, what, eight times more addictive than cocaine, apparently. Something like that. It’s like, I like to call it the socially acceptable white powder, right? That there’s this, the thing that is pleasurable in the moment, but not actually iconic to the infinite.

It doesn’t actually satisfy. And so we keep going back for more, hoping that maybe more will do the trick, but it’s not more of the thing that is not the highest good that we need.

Joseph: But it’s also changing the way each time I choose marshmallow over healthy snack or sometimes not snacking. I’m choosing to view food as primarily pleasurable, right? And pleasure should be the byproduct of the nutritive, right? I should enjoy good food, and my palate should be trained such that I enjoy good food.

Crystal: And our palate gets thrown off when we’re eating pure sugar all the time, whereas if we’re eating good, hearty meals, those actually satisfy on a deeper level because they’re meeting a needs, but they are also pleasurable to eat.

Joseph: And if they’re not yet, that means that we still have some ways to grow. Yes. And so the same things happen when we look at people as primarily pleasurable, or useful, as primarily so, and not as individuals with free wills whom we ought to respect.

We see them as things, and that changes how we interact with them. And if we know that, no, if I see you as a good in and of yourself, as an end unto yourself, that I’m not going to be using you for my own ends, the moment that I do use you as a means to my ends, I’m changing my whole view of reality.

I’m saying some persons are going to be less than, and it’s a total, it’s a deformation of the heart, and the deformation of the passions.

Crystal: Yeah, which then malforms us such that we’re unable to make better choices moving forward and to be able to see rightly moving forward.

What malforms us

So I think I’d like to fly through pointing out the biggest things that can cause that malformation. We could probably do a whole podcast on each one of these things.

Joseph: If our audience would like.

Crystal: Why and how it malforms, but I’m just going to say them and let it hang in the air, and then I think we’ll probably keep moving. So pornography is a way that we’re malformed, where we’re just using the sight of something for pleasure.

Contraceptive sex, again, it’s not having the openness to all of the person. It’s saying, I don’t want the future with you, so I’m going to put something in the way of that. Contraceptive sex doesn’t, takes away, it makes it, it’s unchaste, short-term sexually active relationships.

These are outside of marriage, typically, hopefully your marital relationship isn’t short-term. Again, it’s not committing to the future, it’s not desiring to know all of the person.

Joseph: It’s just wanting something pleasurable for the moment. It’s settling for the spectacle rather than seeking the icon.

Crystal: Yeah, and all three of these things are, they’re shortcuts, which then is also limited and fleeting and isn’t going to give us the fullness of what we’re made for.

Ordering our loves

Joseph: In what we’re made for, St. Augustine has this phrase, I don’t know where it is in St. Augustine’s work, but C.S. Lewis talks about it in The Abolition of Man. He talks about ordo amoris, the ordering of our loves, right? That the virtuous person, virtue, is the ordering of our loves, the virtuous person has well-ordered loves, and will love each thing and each person rightly.

To become such a person, a person of virtue, to love rightly, is to become beautiful. Josef Pieper talks about how beauty is basically the radiance of the true and the good. It’s the radiance of the well-ordered soul, and the drive behind becoming chaste, part of it is to become truly beautiful, to desire rightly, and it’s a difficult process.

Our dating fast as missionaries

When I first joined the Fellowship of Catholic University Students as a missionary, they asked all of the missionaries to go on a dating fast. There are other details, but basically just fasting for romantic relationships for the first year of being a missionary, in order to be free to serve more fully than that year.

And I discovered immediately upon getting onto campus that the campus was filled with beautiful women. And I realized this is because I don’t know how to see them rightly, that I was being attracted to them, and I had to actually sit with that question.

What is it that I’m being attracted to, and what is it I actually desire in these relationships? And seeing like, no, I’m called to love these women as sisters, and I’m called to be a guardian of their future, and of their future relationships.

And so I treated my teammates that way as well. And then my second year on staff, my first year teammate, female, named Crystal, was on a dating fast, and I had had an entire year of training myself to see women first and foremost as persons, as sisters, as people to get to know in an appropriate way, and so I spent that year loving my teammate as rightly as I was able.

Crystal: And I had not had that training yet, but was really excited about the dating fast and to get to learn to reorder my mind and the way that I would interact with the men in my life, and was really blessed to have two male teammates that were also working really hard at that, and to realize, to have the opportunity to be discerning about who am

I attracted to and why, and what do I do with that, and instead of just being a huge flirt where everybody knows who I’m attracted to because of the way I’m sort of throwing myself at that person, I was able to learn how to get to know appropriately the different men that

I had the opportunity to interact with, but also make sure that I was nurturing relationships with the women in my life that was building me up and helping me grow in virtue, and that allowed when I started to be attracted to you, Joseph, that

I was able to check that frequently and not try to be manipulative or use you to fulfill my desires for whatever, the knight in shining armor or something, and then it forced me into seeing who are you really, and where is this attraction coming from and why.

Future tripping

Joseph: There’s a term that’s often thrown about called future tripping, where we take not a walk down memory lane, but a walk up future trail, where we just start imagining what would life be like with this person, what would it be like to raise children with this person before we even start dating, much less, get to know one another.

Crystal: Super dangerous, it’s unchaste, because it’s not saying who are you, and how do I get to know you, it’s saying I want this, that, and the other thing, and I’m imagining that you could fulfill this for me.

Joseph: And not allowing the person to actually react and respond and be present and interact. It’s reducing them to the most superficial. And this is one of the elements of chastity that I think is so important to get at. It’s that when we choose to be chaste, we look to the depths of the others.

Not that we should be looking at pornography if we’re trying to be chaste, but if we do come across images that are pornographic, which happens in this culture, to not be swayed the way that the people who created it want us to be swayed, to become lustful, but to have real sorrow.

There are these people who think that love is something to be used, that bodies are something to be used, and to see the persons, and to pray for them, and to pray that they find true love, and they find redemption, and they find real, abiding happiness, that we can see, they say to the pure, all things are pure.

And that’s something we don’t get by looking at pornography, but we do get by looking at people as people. And the more that we see the depths of the others, the more our depths become deeper. We become a more well-rounded person. We become a fuller and richer human person by acknowledging the reality of the other person.

Crystal: And this is one of the hard parts about growing in the virtue of chastity, is that hurts. It is wounding. To see the true beauty, or the lack thereof, it’s painful to see misuse and name it as that. And to enter into the virtue of chastity is to enter into that pain instead of retreating from it.

Joseph: Yeah. And part of the pain comes from realizing that we live in a world with other people, like we’re not the center of the universe, we’re not the most important thing, right?

Crystal: Shoot.

Joseph: Yeah. So there’s that element of humility, but in that element of humility also carries with it magnanimity.

When the heart grows

And this is seen most epically in How the Grinch Stole Christmas, where the Grinch’s heart has been shrinking throughout the course of the movie. And when he sees the people down in Whoville singing, and he realizes that there might be something just a little bit more to Christmas, right, he has this notion that there’s something transcendent over and above the material world.

Because he had taken everything material from them, and there was yet something left over that could still elicit singing. And in the beauty of the song, his soul is pierced, and it’s said that his heart grew three sizes that day. And the image in the cartoon is that his heart grows and grows and actually explodes out of the bounds of the little x-ray machine, which is humorous because it’s an x-ray machine.

But that sense of bursting asunder is also a painful thing. It’s also something that, you know, in order for my heart to grow, it has to stretch. In order for my heart to stretch, it has to change in an uncomfortable way. Things have to move around.

This is what beauty does to us.

Crystal: And the thing that’s incredible about that is it does that, it transforms our hearts, and we experience that pain, but also the sweetness of that. And when we allow ourselves to endure that, we actually also become more beautiful ourselves. So it’s like the thing that we’re grasping for that we want is only actually received when we receive.

We don’t get there by taking, we get there by receiving.

Joseph: And to think, I mean, this makes sense, right? If I reduce people to the most superficial, I become more shallow, right? When I say I’m going to use people, I’m going to only get pleasure from them, my world constricts. I’m limiting myself to a different kind of calculus that says, what can I get out of this relationship?

And it precludes me from a kind of calculus that says, what can I give into it? And what is the more beautiful? It’s the giving of the self.

Crystal: Yeah.

Running toward the real desire

And this is something I think people are often well advised when they’re first starting to battle chastity or lack thereof to run away, literally run away from temptation.

Joseph: Because just FYI, sexual desire is a huge temptation. This is not something, this is like playing with biological dynamite.

Crystal: And so that is a very good first step to run away, but then to think, but what am I running towards? What is the desire of my heart actually? And that, when we run towards the real beauty, the real depth, the iconic, that opens us up to God.

Joseph: And that seems like a funny thing, right? To say, I’m experiencing sexual temptation. Most people, I don’t think their immediate response is, I should turn to God right now. They think, my temptation, my desires, and God have nothing to do with one another.

And it’s that weird sort of dichotomy that doesn’t hold water, really, if you actually think about it, like, no, God is here. God is present. God desires us. God is moving. At all times and in every place, God draws close to man. And that means in my time of temptation, God is still drawing close for me to look to him.

Crystal: And it’s so cool to me because he is what we ultimately desire, the infinite, and he is the only infinite. And so if we try to satisfy our desires in other places, not only will that desire not be satisfied, but we’ll miss him.

We’ll miss what we’re actually looking for.

Joseph: Yeah, I mean, think about it. We have the ability, apparently, to use people, to seek pleasure from them. People may devote their entire lives to seeking of pleasure from other people. But God is not like that. When theologians talk about him being impassable, when they talk about him being the unmoved mover, one of the things that that means is that we can’t manipulate him.

We can’t move him. We cannot say, you will succumb to my desires, as I say. He’s the ultimate of persons. There’s nothing about him that is subject to us. So there’s nothing about God that allows for use. And if our hearts are conditioned toward using people, yeah, you’re right.

We’ll miss him. But if our hearts are conditioned toward using people, he still desires us. He is still calling us forth incessantly, constantly.

Crystal: And as soon as we turn, it makes me think, I just remember about a friend of mine who was demonstrating this in a way, he was holding one of his hands right next to his face, but looking the other direction and saying, God, where are you?

Where are you? And then he turns around and runs his nose into his hand to paint that picture of God is always right there reaching for us. And if we feel like he’s not there, we just need to turn around because he is right there.

Joseph: Always. We talked about this in our last episode about excellence. That first move is to turn away from the world and to turn toward God. And that applies in the realm of chastity as well, that we should turn toward God and remember who he is.

Because if we really desire intimacy, shortcuts will not satisfy us. And we’re just, we’re a moment away from the true path, the true way.

Crystal: And we don’t have to trample it first. I mean, we’re talking about how, how painful it can be to allow that, that beauty in and to enter into, to the reality of another person. But Jesus did it all the way to death.

Joseph: Yeah.

You are beautiful to God

To remember that to Jesus, you are beautiful in his eyes. He has not taken his eyes from you. Our Lord suffered for our sins, yes. But his human heart also suffered the sight of your beauty. He allowed his heart to be pierced because he couldn’t bear to use you.

He could only choose to receive you and to continue to offer himself to you. In creating us to be free, God created us as beautiful. He will not manipulate, abuse, or ignore you. You literally cannot be anything but beautiful to God. And Jesus suffered your beauty in the hopes that you would reciprocate and see his.

Crystal: Incredible. So he teaches us how to do it. He showed us the way.

Joseph: And he’s looking at us right now. This moment, this moment that we’re saying it and the moment that you’re listening to it, he’s looking at us and loving us. And he actually created us free, which means he created us not to be used, not to be sources of his own pleasure, but as ends unto ourselves.

That the most chaste love is the love of God. It’s also the love that’s actually satisfying.

The wedding invitation

There’s this image of St. Teresa of Avila and it’s called like the Ecstasy of St. Teresa or something like that. I think it’s a statue. It is a statue. I don’t think that. I know that. I googled it beforehand. But it’s based on a vision that she had where she was transfixed.

Crystal: And her heart was pierced in the vision. And she talks about how the agony and the bliss of this piercing of her heart. And the facial expression is just a radiant…

Joseph: Ecstatic.

Crystal: Ecstatic, yeah. Facial expression of sheer desire being fulfilled.

Joseph: And that’s actually what the spiritual life is supposed to become. We talk about, in Catholic circles, about the purgative way, the illuminative way, and then the unitive way. St. Teresa of Avila talks about how within our soul, within our heart, there is this castle.

And in the innermost chamber is the bed chamber where we meet the bridegroom. To see that our sexual desire is meant to point us to God, who does desire union with

Crystal: us. And this is something where I realize, and I think where, I mean, especially the theology of the body is so mind bending, is it makes me realize, for one, how disordered my appetite is, how disordered our culture has made me think about and understand the sexual desire and that of Eros, this idea of desiring unitive love.

And that God wants that for us in a way that the sexual act is iconic for, but it is not. It’s not the same thing. In fact, the kind of unity that God wants to have with us is like, pales, sorry, the sexual act pales in comparison to the unitive love that God has for us and wants to have for us, which is pretty incredible, and I don’t understand that yet.

Joseph: But this is the reason to be Christian, to be Catholic, is that he’s actually extended to us a wedding invitation.

Crystal: Yes, God wants to marry us.

Joseph: And to see that when we sin, we’re turning our backs on that invitation, we’re saying, I’m going to settle for something less, and I’m going to distrust the invitation, right? And that distrust is, it makes us shallow, you know, the sort of cynicism that sees only the surface and won’t pierce into the depths, and it’s not worth it.

But to be chaste, to perceive and to honor beauty as we find it, that is to be drawn into our own beauty and all that we are made for through coming to trust the Father.

As we grow in trust of the Father and who we are in the light of Him, our eyes are, they’re actually opened to the beauty around us, and we grow in freedom to receive beauty and to receive the other in a rightly ordered way.

So you might say that when we love God and neighbor rightly, we glow with the radiance of truth and goodness. When we love as we are meant to love, we ourselves become fire.

Crystal: Burn. I was going to say burn, baby burn, but that feels, shoot.

Joseph: That’s a little bit like they say at the end of Fiddler on the Roof. Somebody should have set a match to this place years ago. And that’s what should happen too. We should become radiantly ablaze by loving rightly.

Crystal: And we can, because it’s been done before we have a witness, we have an example, and

Joseph: we have the gift of grace, and we do have the gift of grace, and the gift of confession.

Crystal: Yes. Which we will probably talk about next week.

Joseph: Maybe. Maybe. I like to under-promise and over-deliver.

Closing and prayer

Anyway, that’s our podcast for today. Feel free to subscribe if you don’t already subscribe. That’s the easiest way for it to show up in your playlist, because if you check it every day at the same day of the week, sometimes we don’t post it the same day.

Also feel free to rate it, share it, like it on Facebook, send us feedback, ouroutpost at gmail.com. It’s probably the easiest way, otherwise you could call us or text us.

Crystal: That happens sometimes. We like that.

Joseph: Thanks, guys.

Crystal: Yeah.

Joseph: Any other notes? That would be my final note.

Crystal: It’s a nice one. I liked it. Shall I pray? Yeah. The Father, Son, the Holy Spirit, Amen.

The Holy Spirit teaches us to pray, teaches us to be receptive to the love of the Father, teaches us to trust in our identity as His children, teaches us to follow in Christ’s footsteps as we learn to enter into beauty, enter into seeing persons rightly as the icons that they are, and enter into seeing ourselves rightly as the icons that we are.

We ask all this in your Holy Name.

Joseph: Amen. The Father, Son, the Holy Spirit, Amen. From our outpost to yours, thanks for listening, and a special thanks to JohnMarc Skoch, for

Crystal: the music.

Joseph: Check him out on Spotify.

Keep listening

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *