Christianity as the One True Religion

In the third talk of Joseph’s post-Christian apologetics series for missionaries, he lays out what the Church teaches about other religions and makes a case for Christianity: the resurrection, the way Jesus fulfills the Old Testament, and how the faith accords with reason. Through it all, the goal is love, not winning.

A Word from Our Outpost, a Catholic podcast: one true religion

Episode 28 · 44 min · With Joseph Gruber

Christianity as the One True Religion

Listen on Spotify Apple Podcasts Pocket Casts

Free · 4 minutes

Take the Our Outpost Quiz

A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.

Take the Quiz →

Key takeaways on one true religion

  • There’s no magic bullet. No single argument convinces everyone. Find out what people mean by the words they use, and what they do believe.
  • Love comes first. The goal of apologetics is to love God and love our neighbor. If we aren’t doing that, people won’t listen, and they shouldn’t.
  • Other religions are really other. Disagreement isn’t exclusion. The Church rejects nothing true and holy in other faiths, and invites people into the fullness of truth.
  • The resurrection is the heart of it. The empty tomb, the witnesses and Paul’s conversion are hard to explain any other way than that Jesus truly rose.
  • Jesus is hidden in the Old Testament. Prophecies and types point to Him again and again. Inviting someone to read Scripture with you can be the start of a beautiful friendship.

“Winning is not the goal of apologetics.”

Joseph Gruber

Try this together

Next time someone pushes back on the faith, try listening before answering:

“When you say you don’t believe in Christianity, what do you mean by that?”

“Would you want to read a story from the Old Testament with me and see if we can find Jesus in it?”

Chapters

  • The third talk
  • Modest goals for this class
  • Defenses we won’t cover
  • Why people think Christianity is false
  • Words matter
  • The goal is love, not winning
  • Other religions are really other
  • Religious freedom
  • Rejecting nothing true and holy
  • Outside the Church, no salvation
  • The desert island question
  • Jesus and the resurrection
  • Five explanations for the evidence
  • Not a game of telephone
  • Prophecies fulfilled
  • Types of Christ in the Old Testament
  • Audience question: is this just another lens?
  • Christianity accords with reason
  • I am who am
  • Is Jesus worth getting to know?

Mentioned in this episode

  • Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae (on religious freedom) and Nostra Aetate (on other religions)
  • G.K. Chesterton
  • St. Thomas Aquinas on miracles and the resurrection
  • Episode 29, “Ongoing Intellectual Formation,” where Joseph follows up on questions and corrections from these talks
Full transcript

The third talk

Hello friends, have you been wondering what the third talk in the post-Christian apologetics series is? Well, wait no longer. Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives.

Modest goals for this class

Alright, Christianity is the one true faith. We have rather modest goals for this class. We’re not explicitly going to be talking about why the Catholic Church is the one true church. We’ll mention that a little bit at the beginning, but most of the arguments are going to be with Christianity, but Christianity, in its fullness, is the Catholic Church, so moving on.

So we’ll explain the Church’s teachings about other religions for a little bit, and then we’ll construct a defense for why Christianity is the one true religion for a little bit. And then I think some of us are going to have lunch, which I’m excited about.

All students should be able to do these two things. This is why there is an aspect. All students should be able to. It’s an act great, endless type. The defenses we’re going to cover are Jesus and the resurrection, Judaism and Christianity, and the fact that Christianity has an accordance with reason.

Defenses we won’t cover

Defenses we are not going to cover. We’re not going to cover because the Bible says so. We will look at Scripture, but for people who are saying why is Christianity true, they are going to become circular if we’re just saying because the Bible says so.

Why should we take the Bible seriously? They actually have to be a little bit more grounding. I was born a Christian, so you know, which I think a lot of atheists, a lot of non-Christians think this is why we are Catholic, because we were raised Catholic.

It totally flies in the face of why people would convert from one religion to another, or from no religion to religion. My wife was raised with no religion. Hi, wife. She’s now Catholic. Not sure anything of why I’m doing it happened well before I met her.

But a lot of people think, well, you were raised Hindu. That’s why you’re Hindu. You were raised Christian, therefore you’re Christian. It’s a very insulting position to take, but it’s so hard to call people out for that because then you have to explain why they’re wrong and be all uncomfortable and be like, actually, I’m the moral objectivist, or not a moral objective morality.

So I’m sort of compelled to concede that people can be wrong. Anyway, Pascal’s Wager, we’re not going to talk about that very much. In my previous talk when I was talking about beauty, this is actually part of the heart of Pascal’s Wager, so that’s why we’re not going to talk about it.

The defense that we’re not going to cover as well, everybody, what is this? A magic bullet. There is no magic bullet to get people to believe in Christianity. There is no one-size-fits-all argument for getting people to concede the truth claims of the Christian church.

Why people think Christianity is false

Okay, reasons why people believe Christianity is false. Anybody have some ready-made reasons for Christianity to be false? People don’t rise from the dead. People don’t rise from the dead. In general, miracles are incredible. Literally, not to be believed, not to be given credit to.

Yes. It’s a conspiracy. They just want your money. They just want your money, kid. Yeah, there’s a plurality of religions. Why should any one of them have any particular claim on us? Yeah, syncretism. You guys are just absorbing other faith traditions and regurgitating them, partially chewed up.

Christianity just makes you feel good when you die. Well, I can see that it will make us feel good when we die. Leaning up to death. There we go. Yeah, great. Too many denominations on enough unity. Another one. Hypocrite. How many of you have been a hypocrite?

Praise God for confession. Yeah, so there are bad arguments for Christianity, but there are also bad argueers for Christianity. And that’s something to be mindful of. And many people have been wounded by bad argueers for Christianity, people who didn’t actually show Christian love and how they were proposing the gospel.

Another reason, it doesn’t seem very intellectual to be Christian. Anybody get that vibe? Again, if an atheist has a British accent, it’s like they automatically win. Because it sounds so gosh darn intelligent. Another one you may have come across is that Christianity doesn’t seem very relevant to the 21st century.

Doesn’t seem very relevant to a particular situation. It’s about somebody who lived 2,000 years ago, far away. Why is that relevant to me right now? So that’s a reason why people might not think that Christianity is true. Those seem like pretty good arguments.

And they have them, they hold them and they have reasons for them.

Words matter

So to be mindful that words really do matter, we need to find out why, when they say they don’t believe in Christianity, what they mean by Christianity, and what it is they do believe in. Because this can get into really dicey territory if we don’t know what people mean, and if we don’t realize that some people have a sort of allergy to words.

My son just left the room, but one day I went up to him and I said, Philip, he was four years old at the time, maybe five, Philip, would you like a sandwich? And he said, no. He said, what would you like? He was very serious.

He said, I want bread, and then meat, and then bread. So a sandwich? No! Alright, Philip. I will give you bread, and then meat, and then bread. Good. Right? Because some people, they are just allergic to words, they don’t. They can’t give any reason for why they think that something is wrong, they just feel like that word is not the thing they believe in.

They don’t want that. But oftentimes the content they do want. So to be mindful, words do matter, but people have their own personal etymologies for words, their own personal history for what words mean. And so to take the time to figure out where somebody is coming from when they’re using these words, they’re actually conveying a whole host of historical facts that we’re just missing unless we sit with them for a while.

The goal is love, not winning

Okay, what is our goal in this conversation? Chesterton. He says, let your religion be less of a theory and more of a love affair. And so we’re having conversations with people about Christianity to make sure that we are loving the Christ of Christianity first, that we love God first.

And then, Chesterton says, doesn’t say this to one another, I pulled these two quotes from two different sources and then put them next to each other, just in case people are confused. And he says, the Bible tells us to love our neighbors and also to love our enemies, probably because they are generally the same people.

Anyway, to love our neighbors. To love God and to love our neighbors is always our goal in apologetics and in everything. And sometimes in apologetics we just want to win. That is not our goal. Winning is not the goal of apologetics.

Other religions are really other

Okay, so a little bit about other religions. The first thing about other religions, write this down, other religions are really other. So if I say that a rabbi, a priest and a mom walk into a bar, you know that I’m talking about three different people with three different worldviews.

They do not all believe the same thing. Other religions are actually other. So when we’re talking about there being other religions, sometimes it can be leveled against us that Christianity is exclusive. Nobody ever heard this, that Christianity is exclusive. Exclusive is a buzzword.

We’re mutually exclusive with any other truth claims. This is just what it means to believe something, is to believe that the converse is not true, right? We believe mutually exclusive things about the world. There’s this Chesterton line, sorry for the Chesterton quotes. I’m not that sorry, no.

If I were sorry, I would stop. He said, there are those who are always insisting that Christianity and Buddhism are very much alike, especially Buddhism. Get it? There are those who are always insisting that Christianity and Buddhism are very much alike, especially Buddhism.

It’s funny. He’s saying that Buddhism is very much like Christianity, but people can’t actually make the same claim that Christianity is like Buddhism. Because they actually do have different truth claims about the world. Buddhism says there is no self. Christianity says, well, we have to deny ourselves, but in denying ourselves, we become truly ourself.

Those are very different claims about the world. They are just as exclusive of us as we are of them. When people say Christians are being exclusive, we just have beliefs. They have beliefs too. If they think that Christianity is wrong, they’re saying, you know, they’re excluding us from what is right.

That just means disagreeing. We should not be afraid of the disagreement. Chesterton has this line. He says, I believe in getting into hot water keeps one clean. Get it?

Religious freedom

Okay, the next point about freedom. This Vatican Council declares the human person has a right to religious freedom.

This freedom means that all men are immune from coercion on the part of individuals or of social groups and of any human power, and such wise that no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs, whether privately or publicly, whether alone or in association with others within the limits.

So this is saying that as far as other religions go, they are free to believe other things. We would also say they’re free to be wrong, but they’re free to do that. They’re free to be wrong. We are not trying to compel anything.

We’re not trying to impose, always propose. So we all have the right to disagree. When people try to deny the right to disagree, that is a totalitarian move on their part. We’re not totalitarian. We’re actually quite fond of this freedom thing. It’s one of the more precious things given to us by God.

Okay, another thing about other religions.

Rejecting nothing true and holy

The Catholic Church rejects nothing that is true and holy in these religions. Here’s a picture of nothing. Get it? She regards with sincere reverence those ways of conduct and of life, those precepts and teachings which go different in many aspects from the ones she holds and sets forth.

We must often reflect a ray of that truth which enlightens all men. We’re really excited when we do agree on anything. I think we should concede that. When other religions say something is true, we’re like, yes, that is true. We should get excited.

I think I see this most clearly in the lives of converts. As I mentioned before, my wife is a convert. She was raised with no religion. The thing that marks her, that I love so much about her, is the gratitude that she has for every true and good and noble thing that her parents gave to her.

They did not give her the gospel, but they did give her true things that she treasures. One of the marks of a convert should be this gratitude for all of the lights along the way that led them to the fullness of truth. This is also an interesting thing.

We say we have the fullness of truth and other people have parts of truth. You might say, that’s a little bit demeaning. No, it’s invitational. The things that you most treasure about your faith system, if they’re really true, you’ll find them brought to fulfillment in the Catholic Church.

We’re trying to lead you to even more truth. It’s actually a joy-filled message that we as missionaries have been given to proclaim.

Outside the Church, no salvation

Another thing about other religions, this is a picture of George Feeny. Culturally, I know this is dating me a little bit. It’s from Boy Meets World, his name is George Feeny. The reason he’s up there is because of a heresy called Feeneyism. I wasn’t going to put a picture of the real Feeney because the heresy that’s named after him, he actually did not let go of.

He repudiated, pronounced, peculiarly. But Feeneyism had a particularly strong reading on this. Does anybody know what this line is? Extra ecclesiam nulla salus. Anyone know what this means? Outside the church, there is no salvation. We have this, I think the earliest sighting we have for this line is from St. Cyprian in the, I think in the 200s or third century.

And people look at this and they say, oh, that makes me feel a little queasy. Outside the church, there is no salvation. That sounds pretty exclusive. It’s like we’re a ritzy club or something, and we’re excluding people. But to unpack what this means, there’s actually a profound beauty to it, and this is why we are missionaries.

The beauty of it is, what are we actually excluding people from? What is it we’re excluding people from? Poorly phrased question because we’re not actually doing the excluding, right? So, what are they being excluded from? Salvation.

And salvation, as we understand it, is a relationship with Jesus Christ and the Holy Trinity, where we live in the beatific vision of their love that brings us to the greatest glory we can possibly contain, right? This is what we need by salvation.

Not everybody wants that, at least right now, right? Some people don’t want to spend time with Jesus. There are times that I don’t want to spend time with Jesus, right? But I’m choosing that. I’m saying I want to be outside of the church in that point.

The other thing, what is the positive formulation of this line? That inside the church, there is salvation, right? And we get this wrong so often. This conception of heaven, like everybody goes to heaven, all dogs go to heaven, and then people say, well, if all dogs go to heaven, then all people should go to heaven.

I don’t even know why we said all dogs go to heaven. But for some reason, that’s a grand premise in most people’s mind. But in the pagan world, the idea of heaven, the idea of salvation, the idea of perpetual bliss, this was not a given.

Pagans did not believe in an eternal life of happiness with their tornadoes when they died. They did not have this conception. Even in a strict sense, the Jews did not have this perfectly worked out either, right? There was quite a bit of conflict about what happened when people died.

That’s why the Sadducees and the Pharisees had arguments, because the Sadducees didn’t actually believe in eternal life. I’m not going to do the pun about why that’s Sadducee, because that’s such a best pun. But people do it all the time. I don’t know if they were sad enough.

That’s just a huge leap that I’m not willing to make. But people have this idea that they have a right to eternal happiness when they die, and that we’re trying to keep them from it. Can we talk this through a little bit? Where did you get this idea of heaven, and how is there any logical connection?

The rich young man says, Lord, what must I do? Teacher, good teacher, what must I do to inherit eternal life? He had this idea that he doesn’t get eternal life automatically. He used the word inherit, which seems to imply you don’t have to do anything.

But then he said, what must I do, which implies you do have to do something. It’s not a foregone conclusion that salvation is going to be for everyone. This is why we’re missionaries. We actually get to offer them a relationship with God that will bring them complete and total joy.

Good job, Joyce. Well done.

The desert island question

And so the other question is, where is the bottleneck when we’re talking about this entry into salvation? And if some people come up with the desert island scenario, and then if you talked with an atheist who came up with this desert island, what about the people on islands that never heard about your God?

Anybody came across it a few times. And I had this starting realization that one of the things they might need is that they feel like they’re on an island. And I know this sounds silly. I’m being serious. I know it sounds silly. But they might actually believe that they’re in some way untouchable, unreachable, and unlovable.

And that they cannot actually receive the truth. So when they’re saying, what about people on this desert island, they may say, I feel so detached from everything that I’m actually revealing my interior disposition for the world. There’s this really happy sounding, really sad song from Simon and Garfunkel where they’re saying, I am a rock, I am an island, and a rock feels no pain, and an island never cries.

They’re like, oh, what a horrible, horrible life. And so some people, when they’re coming up with a desert island scenario, to check, I’m in a relationship with you right now by virtue of our speech. You are reachable. You are lovable. You can be known.

And they feel really awkward to do that. They might just be all in their head, all in their intellect, in which case they’re sort of in an ivory tower, which is kind of like an island. The other thing about this bottleneck to go to, I heard this story on NPR a number of years ago about a Christian pastor whose church no longer believes in hell.

And the reason he doesn’t believe in hell anymore is he was watching a commercial, one of those like tearjerker commercials about the impoverished in Africa. And it was about, you know, he saw these shots of a village. He was like, these poor people, there must be people all over the world who have not heard the gospel, and in his belief, he thought that they would be going to hell.

And he’s like, that doesn’t feel right. And so he decided that there was no hell. Instead of actually responding to that feeling with real action and saying, well, if I had joy, if I had hope, there’s no reason that I shouldn’t go. So it wasn’t really a story about a church that no longer believes in hell.

It’s a story of a pastor who was willing to ignore God’s calling to preach the gospel to people. Right? And that was such a sad story. NPR loved it because they were happy that there was a church that didn’t believe in hell. And I was so sad for that pastor because he was ignoring the fact that his heart was being turned just toward these people.

And instead of reaching out to them, he kept sitting on his recliner and watching TV. Okay, so other religions, that’s basically all I’m going to talk about with that. Now, Christianity. So we’re going to talk about Jesus and the resurrection. We’re going to talk about Judaism and Christianity.

And then we’re going to talk about the importance of reason that Christianity presents.

Jesus and the resurrection

So Jesus and the resurrection. There are some claims about Jesus that basically every reputable scholar will concede. There are some off-the-wall scholars out there who will deny some parts of some of these. But I intentionally try to phrase these in the least objectionable way possible.

So Jesus really and truly lived 2,000 years ago. Very few scholars dispute this. He really and truly died by crucifixion under Pontius Pilate. Pontius Pilate, a not great governor, pretty cool. We have record of his cruelty. Put this man to death by crucifixion, right?

And everything that that entails, crucifixion being the punishment given to rebels, to people who were acting against the interests of the Roman Empire. He was really and truly buried. People don’t contest. Joseph of Arimathea being a member of the ruling class. That’s not just a fact that people would beg God that he would give a tomb to this man.

His tomb is really and truly empty. Virtually every scholar will concede that the body of Jesus has not been discovered. Except around Easter when you see a documentary come out about maybe we discovered the body of Jesus. And then they’re like, ah, whoops, no it wasn’t.

Sorry for the spoiler alert. I didn’t give you the spoiler alert. Spoiler alert, it wasn’t the body of Jesus. So his disciples really and truly said they encountered him post-resurrection. Nobody’s going to argue that they didn’t claim this. They may question about whether or not they did encounter him.

But everyone will concede that they said that they did. And that Saul, also named Paul, a persecutor of Christians, really and truly said he encountered Jesus. And he completely changed his life because of it. We could add to the fact that there were converts to Christianity in just astounding numbers throughout the first few centuries of the Christian era.

Or as they like to call it, the common era. It’s common because Jesus came, someone paid with that. And so there’s this question, how do you reconcile all of these facts? How do you reconcile all of these different things?

Five explanations for the evidence

So there’s five possible explanations for this data. So maybe Jesus didn’t really die. So he was hanging on the cross for a few hours. They took him down. They didn’t notice that he was dead. They wrapped him up in a shroud. They put him in a tomb, airtight, presumably, and left him there for a few days.

And somehow he got out, though he’d been scourged and nailed to a cross and without food or water or medical attention, came out, talked with his disciples, and somehow managed to convince them that he was God. And then his body disappeared. Okay, so I’m just going to walk through each of these.

You guys hopefully have some time at the end where you guys can talk to these ones a little bit more. But all of these, except for the fifth one, there’s something very off about them. So these followers lying about the resurrection, so this conspiracy theory, right, they want our money.

Except, like, why would they lie about it? You know, when people commit crimes, there’s usually a motive. Most people’s motive is not, I want to die for this lie. And it’s not like they wouldn’t have been getting chances to recant. So there’s no reason for them to lie.

And there’s no good way to say, like, they could have pulled that off, right? People just don’t get away with conspiracies that easily. It doesn’t really explain why, you know, 50 days, 59 days after Passover, they came out like a lightning bolt, and people were electrified by their preaching.

People were converting to the way. They were converting to Jesus. They were repentant and being baptized. It doesn’t really explain, like, can you really think that they would just be sitting around, like, a story about their leader dying and coming back from the dead, and then just going out and just selling it bald face like that?

It’s just, it’s a remarkable play. But with all of these, if somebody’s saying, like, well, maybe it was conspiracy, just sit with them. It’s like, what would that mean? What would that look like? Sort of a Chesterton allusion. You know, the idea of the resurrection, most detectives have to solve the problem of how and why somebody died.

In Christianity, we have to solve the problem, how and why someone is now alive, right? And to approach all of these as a detective work, what is the evidence, how strong is it, does it make sense? They hallucinated the resurrection, hallucination theory. Someone who took, like, intro to psychology might try to pull this one off.

Psychologically, though, this isn’t how hallucinations happen, right? To convince a large group of people that over the course of 40 days, they had many interactions with this one person who had been dead. That’s not how hallucinations work. They don’t get to sit down and eat fish with a hallucination.

They don’t have 500 witnesses of a hallucination. They don’t have Saul changing his life completely because of a hallucination. The resurrection areas were intended to be symbolic. It doesn’t really explain the empty tomb thing, and it doesn’t, like, symbolic of what, right? That one gets me, symbolic of what?

I just can’t wrap my head around that one, you know? So somebody’s saying it was just a symbol, but really, though, a symbol of what? And why change my life for that symbol? Like, Batman was a symbol. He said so himself, and Batman begins.

I’m not changing my life because of Batman, or Jesus rose from the dead. And this is so critical, right? Aquinas says, as far as arguments for Christianity, the proof par excellence are the miracles of Jesus, and the miracle of miracles is the resurrection, right?

Like, Jesus was able to do things that defied natural explanation repeatedly, and he did so under his own power, right? That is a revelation of the divine. And so he then would be God, right? That’s where the evidence tends toward. But with all of this, to get into a conversation with somebody and say, like, what do you think happened with the resurrection?

Not a game of telephone

A lot of the scholarship, the past hundred years or so, have been trying to lay claim that the Gospels were written much later than they actually were. They like to say, you know, this was just a telephone game, gone wrong.

They said Jesus was a great moral teacher, and they said it to a few people, who said it to a few people, who said it to a few people, and suddenly we have the message that Jesus is God. That’s not actually how discipleship works.

I mean, somebody was actually a disciple of somebody, and meant that they were being taught. It was an apprenticeship in truth. So they would be given teaching to memorize, checked on the memorization, and checked again and checked again, and then given opportunities to present that information, which is exactly what we see in the life of the apostles.

But they lived with Jesus, who taught them, and they were given chances to bear testimony to his word. It was very different from the telephone game, or that Bart Ehrman loved to talk about the telephone game. It’s just nonsense. Judaism and Christianity.

Prophecies fulfilled

Okay, so this is a two-sided kind of conversation to have with someone. One is the fact that there are prophecies. Literally, there are hundreds of references that point to the coming of the birth of Jesus, and to who he was, what he was going to do, and what kind of writing he was supposed to give.

So, you know, the fact that in Psalm 16, the psalmist say that the body will not see corruption. Isaiah 53, the suffering servant, seen his own offspring post-death. The prophecies in Daniel 2 and Daniel 5 about the coming of the kingdom and coming of the king.

The prophecy in Daniel 9, about 70 weeks of years, which puts from Daniel to Jesus is about 490 years. Well, not from Daniel, from the point of time that he said 70 weeks of years to Jesus is 490 years. So they were expecting the Messiah at that point.

Yeah, so many different prophecies that Jesus brought to fulfillment in his own life, which requires that we become more intimately familiar with the Old Testament. And people don’t have to claim that the Old Testament is inerrant. They don’t have to claim that it’s inspired.

You just have to say, was this written before Jesus? Yes. Does Jesus fulfill these prophecies? Yes. Nobody else in the history of the world has been prophesied. Nobody said before the birth of the Buddha, you know, I think in like a few years, there’s going to be like an enlightened one who will lead us to all knowing and to not nirvana.

Nobody said that. Nobody said, hey, I bet in like some hundred years or so, there’s going to be a Muhammad. Nobody said that. There were no prophecies preparing any of the other major religions in the way that Jesus coming into the world was prepared.

That’s got to, that’s got to mean something.

Types of Christ in the Old Testament

Then there’s also the types of the Old Testament. The Old Testament prefigures Jesus again and again and again and again. And when you have your Jesus goggles on and you’re reading the Old Testament, you’re like, there’s Jesus, there’s Jesus, there’s Jesus. Like every page, Jesus is being revealed again and again.

More dimensions of who he was is of what kind of power he has, of his relationship to God, his relationship to man. The story of Adam, knowing that Jesus is the new Adam, knowing that so many of the lines about Adam, like, you know, he left his father and mother to be joined to his life.

This is what Jesus did. He left his father and he left Mary his mother and joined himself to the church. He did that perfectly in a way that Adam did not. You know, the protoevangelium of Genesis 3:15 as a prophecy, but as also a type because there were several people who stepped upon the head of the serpent.

David notably chopping off Goliath’s head was a partial fulfillment of that type. Oh my goodness. If you go through salvation history again and again, the story of Cain, the really awkward story about Noah and Ham. Have you guys gotten through that in salvation history?

Oh yeah. Do you guys realize that that’s a type of Jesus, right? The son of the father who makes his own mother fruitful. This is what Jesus does in the Annunciation, right? The son of the father makes his own mother fruitful.

And this is what Jesus does on the cross where the son of the father makes his own mother fruitful in that he gives her a new son, John, the beloved apostle, right? This is what Jesus does.

The story of Noah and Ham, the one who becomes, you know, Ham, Cain being the servant of the servants and Jesus coming, you know, not regarding equality with God, something to be grasped at, but empty themselves, taking upon the form of a slave, right?

Elevating servitude. I have come not to be served, but to serve. Taking on the curse of Cain and elevating it to a blessing, right? Like, we feel really awkward when we talk about that story with Noah, but there’s a reason it’s there because it’s preparing the hearts of those who know what they’re looking for for Jesus, right?

This, especially with the weird, like, sexual things, Judah and Tamar, David and Bathsheba, all of these different things, the beginning of children, all of these, you can see glimmers of the Annunciation in twisted ways, in like, film negative ways. They’re all types that are brought into perfect, perfect fulfillment in Jesus.

And wouldn’t it be amazing if you invited a non-Christian to study the Bible with you and to just say, can you see how Jesus fulfills this? Can I tell you about how Jesus fulfills this weird story from the Old Testament? We could be studying the Bible with these men and women, and just posing the question, where is Jesus in this?

And then showing them, again, in the Old Testament, Jesus is concealed there, and he’s revealed in the world.

Audience question: is this just another lens?

Is there a question? Yeah, I was just asking, how do we explain how that’s different from when, in literature, do you feel like somebody that reads, I’m trying to use one of them as like, lens, like, on top of something?

So the question is, how do we distinguish reading the Old Testament with an eye toward the types as different from reading literature with like, a feminist lens, or a post-colonial lens, or queer lens, or something like that, right? Good question. How would you distinguish it?

I mean, I don’t have to be persuasive, but the argument we’re making is that Jesus was written in the comments on that. Yeah, I mean, God wrote in salvation, not just the words, but he spoke to us through the physical story of these people.

Like, the people themselves are speaking to us of Jesus. And it’s different because it’s true. That’s not a satisfying answer, but I’m going to have to think a lot more about that. Good question. I like that. Cool.

Christianity accords with reason

We’ve got about three and a half minutes, so I’m going to go through how Christianity just accords well with reason. So a lot of people will say, you know, this guy of yours doesn’t make any sense. He’s like, no, he absolutely does.

Oh, just as a real kind of aside, just a lesser new atheist, Richard Carrier, he claims that the correspondence between the Old Testament and Jesus is just too spot-on, that it must have been fabricated. And… Okay, there’s no teasing everybody. Okay. That’s bad.

So our concept of God, from nature, from natural reason, it accords us to God as revealed in the Scriptures. This is something we should be confident in. I know people will bring up a lot of different things. They’ll say, well, there’s genocide and slavery and things like that in the Old Testament.

How does that reconcile with God? And believe me, we can talk about that. Those are conversations I love to have. We don’t have time for them right now. I will be available during lunch, so… According to this reason, Genesis 1, a lot of our fundamentalist-separated brothers and sisters have unfortunately botched a lot of Genesis 1.

That’s okay, except it’s not. In Augustine, he also railed against these kinds of people, too. He was like, stop saying things that are just absurd from a natural science perspective. But Genesis 1 is this beautiful image of creation that shows that God speaks, orders into existence, that there’s a fundamental logic from the logos of God to the universe.

The primacy of speech and the primacy of the idea before the thing is just an amazing, astounding claim about the fabric of the universe, to see that he first made time, then space, then life, then populated this space-time continuum with actual things, that the idea preceded first in speech, then in matter.

It’s just a beautiful account of creation, and it is far and away so much to hear to any occasion rendition of creation. It also makes a mockery of all other gods, which I appreciate. We lose this sense because all of the other gods, nobody worships Thor anymore, but nobody worships the sun anymore.

A few people worship the sun now and the earth. Anyway, this makes a mockery of them. These are all created, and there is a creator that is greater than and prior to. There’s also a sense in which Genesis 1 is ongoing. I think we missed this because of our fundamentalist brothers and sisters.

Creation is actually an ongoing thing. Genesis 1 is just as applicable now as it was 6,000 years ago as it was 13 billion years ago, that God is always in the process of creating and sustaining.

I am who am

Okay, real quick, God says to Moses, I am who am, he is the self-subsisting being. This is the kind of God that the philosophers would have been looking out for. This is the kind of God that accords with what they thought God would be.

It’s like, ding, ding, ding. This is the one true God, this answer, I am who am. Also in the beginning was the word, and the word was with God, and the word was God.

The ancient philosophers had this really big struggle, whether everything was ultimately one or many, and to see that issue, I know we forget about this because the matter of modern philosophy has taken a different turn, different emphases, but to see that one and many are brought into beautiful union in the Godhead.

So for the ancient philosophers at least, they were like, oh wow, a trinity? That’s what I’m talking about. That’s philosophically satisfying in a way that I could never have predicted.

Is Jesus worth getting to know?

So the larger point is that Scripture reveals a good, loving, merciful, creative, freedom-given, provident and persistent God, which is what we find in Jesus. If Jesus is actually who he says he is, then everything matters very much about following him. And this is what we’re proposing to people.

Is this Jesus fellow actually worth pursuing? Getting to know better. Even if they’re not willing to say he’s God, to say is he at least somebody worth getting to know better? Invite them to study him. He always surprises. He never does the thing that I would do.

He always does something better and something unexpected. Go through the Gospels, every story and think, what would I do in this situation? Oh, something dumb and worse and not actually addressing the heart of the matter, because he knows the heart of the matter, and I don’t.

He’s revealing the heart of the matter. Does that mean applause when people shake their name tags? Wow. Okay. But again, we’re proposing to Jesus, who is just so much better than we can really describe. And we’re inviting them to get to know him.

And there are legitimate reasons to believe that Christianity is true. But again, if we’re not loving God first and then loving our neighbor, they’ll never listen to us, and really, they shouldn’t. And with that, I bid you all adieu. From our outpost to yours, thanks for listening, and a special thanks to JohnMarc Skoch for the music.

Check him out on Spotify. And I’ll see you next time.

Keep listening

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *