Comparison as the Thief of Joy

“Comparison is the thief of joy,” a line usually credited to Theodore Roosevelt, applies squarely to marriage. Joseph and Crystal Gruber explain why every marriage is unique, why trying to copy another couple is a target you can’t hit, and how knowing what makes your family unique brings freedom and joy.

Love Your Marriage, a Catholic podcast: comparison

Episode 6 · 16 min · With Joseph Gruber

Comparison as the Thief of Joy

Watch on YouTube Spotify Apple Podcasts Pocket Casts

Free · 4 minutes · For Catholic spouses

How is your marriage doing, really?

Take the Love Your Marriage quiz, then have your spouse take it and compare your answers. You’ll get a picture of an apostolic marriage and a few next steps that fit where you are.

Take the Marriage Quiz →

Key takeaways on comparison

  • Your marriage is unique. Two unrepeatable persons, with their own gifts, history, place and apostolate, make a marriage like no other.
  • Don’t be a carbon copy. Borrow what’s good from other marriages, but trying to replicate one means always falling short.
  • You’re free to fail. Nobody is grading you; try what fits your calling, learn and try again.
  • Knowing your family brings freedom. Couples who know what makes them unique find it easier to say no, and yes, to the right things.
  • Same bones, different flesh. Every Catholic marriage shares the same goods and sacramental meaning; how they’re lived out can look very different.

“When we know what makes our family unique, we stop struggling with comparison.”

Joseph Gruber

Talk it over

Together this week:

What makes our family unique?

Is there something we’re doing only because others do it?

Chapters

  • 0:00 Welcome and opening prayer
  • 0:42 Comparison is the thief of joy
  • 1:26 Your marriage is unique
  • 3:17 Unique in every way
  • 5:19 Non-trivial differences
  • 6:36 Free to fail
  • 8:30 Knowing what makes your family unique
  • 10:00 Saying yes and no
  • 11:24 A tool to try
  • 13:01 Same bones, different flesh, and closing prayer

Mentioned in this episode

As an Amazon Associate, Our Outpost earns from qualifying purchases.

Full transcript

Welcome and opening prayer

0:00 Hey, Joseph. Hey, Crystal. Do you know what steals joy from marriages? I do, actually. Several things. But today we’re going to talk about comparison. Listen in to find out more. In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee and by Thee be happily ended.

Amen. In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.

Comparison is the thief of joy

0:42 So a thief of joy, you say, is comparison. Comparison is the thief of joy. As far as I know, the source for this quote is a letter by Theodore Roosevelt. I always thought it was, like, a C. S. Lewis quote, or that it was from the Bible, or from a Church Father, but apparently it was from one of the presidents of the United States of America, in a letter that he wrote.

Comparison is the thief of joy. And I still think he was right. I still think he had a good point. I don’t think that he was way off base. I think comparison

Your marriage is unique

1:26 does deprive us of joy. And so a way to combat comparison — we should probably think about that. And this is a way that you can love your marriage, is to combat comparison. So something that’s helpful to know as we talk about how to combat comparison: it is important to know that your marriage is utterly unique.

You are not actually supposed to live your marriage, your family life, your home life just like everybody else. You’re not — you’re not supposed to be a carbon copy of the marriages of your parents — even — even if their parents had a great marriage, you’re not supposed to be a carbon copy of it — your neighbors, your friends, or the marriages you see in stories.

We don’t have to imitate everything. It’s great to see things that are good and beautiful in any one of those kinds of marriages and to integrate it into your own, but we don’t want to be a total and complete carbon copy of anybody else’s marriage, because your marriage is unique. And if you don’t live the uniqueness of your marriage, A, the world is deprived of whatever it is you were supposed to bring to the table, but B, you’re not — you’re gonna always be comparing yourself to this thing that you’re trying to copy, and you’re not going to measure up.

Well, maybe people don’t believe you. Maybe they don’t think that their marriage is unique. Do you have any proof that their marriage is unique? They’re unique and unrepeatable mysteries themselves, so you can’t possibly have the same thing with two unique people that are different than the people that they’re comparing themselves to.

Unique in every way

3:17 Yeah. So unique in experience, unique in gifting, unique in skills acquired, unique in location, unique in vocation, in terms of the kinds of work that you might be called to, unique in apostolate: the — the neighbors that you have, the family that you have, the friends that you have, the parish that you’re in, the co-workers that you have.

All of these things make you unique, right? Like, your fingerprint is a unique thing, although I did hear that they did find two people who had identical fingerprints, or at least one of the fingers was the same, or something like that. Bound to happen sometime, I guess. Who knows? But you’re unique, and your spouse is unique.

You probably know that better than most people, that your spouse is unique. And there are probably a lot of similarities and a lot of stereotypes that you can use to categorize them, but again, as far as gifting and experience and relationships and personal history, and where they’ve devoted time and effort and where they haven’t devoted time and effort, and biologically speaking, what they’re dealing with, what their particular excellences are in — they’re all going to produce somebody unique.

And the two of you together, that’s two unique persons together, united. Neither one of you ever existed before — reincarnation is not a thing. Neither one of you are ever going to live in this world and marry again to each other in this way. I mean, totally possible one of you may die and the other one will remarry, but that marriage will be unique and different

Non-trivial differences

5:19 and — and not the same as the prior marriage. So if you’re trying to compare your own situation, which is fundamentally different, to your neighbors’ or your parents’ or your friends’ situation, it’s not — it doesn’t make sense. It’s not going to make sense. These differences are non-trivial, right? It’s not a trivial thing where you live.

It’s not a trivial thing how old you are, or a trivial thing about how many kids you have, or the kinds of kids that you have. These are non-trivial differences that change your marriage and make it not like any other. And so to say, I want to be just like this other couple, or, why aren’t we more like this other couple, or, why is our family so far off the mark of perfectly imitating this other family — because you’re aiming for a target you’re just not capable of hitting.

Now, one of the things that is difficult about figuring out who you are as a unique family is that you might try things and fail. And here’s the thing: if you try to do things just like everybody else, you’re also

Free to fail

6:36 going to fail. So you might as well try to do things that you feel called to and feel consistent with who you are and what your marriage is about, and fail at that, and then learn and try something else. Yeah. You’re free to fail. Nobody is grading you. Nobody is saying, hey, you’re not measuring up.

You — most people don’t pay that much attention to you. Let’s be real. They don’t pay much attention to anyone outside of themselves. We live in a pretty self-centered world, both because of personal sin, original sin, and just, like, a weird technological, unexpected result of people just constantly engaged with their own profile and their own of brand — brand.

So nobody’s paying attention. You can try things and fail. You might be like, oh, we’re the kind of family that prays two rosaries a day. Like, maybe give it a try. Keep trying. Wonderful. Great. Or try something different. And yeah, the reality is, a lot of questions about life and love and raising kids and growing in intimacy with your spouse — these are a matter of prudential judgment.

Don’t do what you know is wrong, but don’t be afraid to do what you think would be right because nobody else is doing it. Like, that’s not a reason not to try the thing that you think would be right. Thinking that you might fail — just another way of saying that it’s something that’s probably worth doing.

And so we’ve mentioned, maybe last week, that we are restarting this marriage membership that we’ve done in the past. And as we’ve been doing this, one of the things that we did was talk to several

Knowing what makes your family unique

8:30 of the people that were involved when we’ve done it in the past, and one of the things that we heard repeated is that they were brought to understand more fully what made their family unique, and that that was exceptionally freeing for them. That when we know what makes our family unique, we stop struggling with comparison.

So if we wanted to have a joyful family, and comparison is the thief of joy, and we live in a culture where a lot of comparison is happening, then to know what makes your family unique, and to try that out, and to figure that out, is an antidote to comparison, and also super helpful in becoming more joyful.

Because when you’re doing what you’re made to do, there just is joy, even if there is suffering also. And so having that — that space to figure out what makes your family unique, some — some tools to help figure out what makes your family — family unique, is something that we’re really passionate about and something that we’ve seen make a tremendous positive impact on couples that we have worked with.

I mean, it certainly has made a huge difference to us. We make a lot of decisions that other couples don’t make, and that’s really okay, that other people don’t make these decisions, because we’re here to make them. Yeah. And — and it’s when you know what makes your family unique, it’s a lot easier and a lot freer to say no to things that a lot of people are saying yes to, and to say yes to things that maybe not very many people are saying yes to.

It also is more freeing to say

Saying yes and no

10:00 yes to things that lots of people are doing, because we love — maybe you’re — your family really loves football, and maybe that means you’re still saying yes to playing football, and maybe that’s a place where you can evangelize, and that’s awesome if that’s what God is calling you to do. So this doesn’t mean, like, being contrary for the sake of being contrary, but this means knowing what you’re about, what your family’s about, and saying yes to those things and those things only.

Did you bring up the football example because we’re founders of a high school where it’s, like, basically baked into it that they will never have a football team? No, I didn’t bring it up for that reason, but I just — like, we’re very not into football, and I think we have friends that are, like, anti-football for the sake of being anti-football, and that’s — if you — that doesn’t need to be the case.

Yeah, I’m not against football in the sense that I want it to never exist. I just was never very interested in it, and I don’t follow it. So it’s okay. That’s a fun fact about us. Yeah, we’re not into football. But maybe you are. Great. That you don’t have to be like us, and we don’t have to be like you.

It’s wonderful. Yes. It’s splendid. I’m really, really happy about not being into football, even though people are really into football in our town, and we’re not, and that’s okay. If you want to learn a little bit of, like, I don’t know, next thing to do, if you want to — a call to action, if you will — take comparison in the face,

A tool to try

11:24 to love your marriage well, there’s this book, Three Big Questions for a Frantic Family, by Patrick Lencioni — if you’re watching YouTube, I’m showing it off — that we love. And he talks about how to create a unique family statement. So this is something you can do that’s — I think — I think it’s quicker and easier and more helpful than creating a family mission statement.

Mission statements are so funny. They’re weird. So Three Big Questions for a Frantic Family is a great tool for that. If you — we just did a relaunch of our marriage membership. Right now we’re focusing in on those members, but if you’re interested in learning more about that, and learning about when we might open it again sometime, you can join our wait list by going to ouroutpost.

org, or Outpost slash — but with that, we’re really hoping to build a community of couples who are trying to live differently, who are trying to live their unique family call, that are different from the surrounding culture, that are different because they’re owning that each couple is unique, and different oftentimes from what they used to be doing.

They’re able to make changes. We want to work with couples who are trying to make progress, who are trying to love their marriages more and more. Because that’s — that’s kind of — if you’re — if you’re not trying to do that, maybe it’s worth giving that one a go. Maybe that’s — maybe that’s something that shouldn’t be so unique.

Maybe it should be a more widespread thing, that the couples who are married should love their marriages. I mean, to be fair, before

Same bones, different flesh, and closing prayer

13:01 we close out, there are things in the Catholic sacrament of matrimony that make every sacrament of matrimony similar, right? They have the same ends, they have the same purposes, they have the same meaning, essentially, right? Dietrich von Hildebrand talked about, like, the purpose of marriage is procreation and education of children, but the meaning of marriage is the love of the spouses.

And then Casti Connubii, with Pope Pius the 11th — I think he — I don’t know if he got sloppy or — or what, but he basically was like, yeah, there’s two purposes to marriage: it’s, you know, the love of the spouses and the procreation and education of children. And this third thing, the elevation of the relationship to a sacrament, where it becomes that which it signifies.

It — it is a sign of the love of Christ for his Church, embodied in husband and wife. So those things — every Catholic marriage has those things. Those are the — the bones, the skeleton. The flesh of it, though, can be all sorts of different sizes and shapes and colors, and internal organs obviously can shift around a lot.

We have this picture from anatomy textbooks that, you know, everybody’s insides look the same. That’s just not true. Everybody’s insides look different, because organs have different sizes and shapes and placements. Makes surgeons’ lives kind of wacky. General— generally. But that’s an aside. That — that was an aside. Marriages do have a fundamental character to them.

Your marriage is unique because you are unique, your spouse is unique, your relationship is unique. You have a unique calling, and we would love to help you to live that out, to continue to serve you however we may with this podcast, with the other things that we’re offering, because we just want to awaken an authentic Catholic culture through holy matrimony.

And we’re going to do that by equipping Catholic men and women through formation and accompaniment. Amen to that. Should I close this out in prayer? Sure. In the name of the Father and of the Son and the Holy Spirit. Amen. Heavenly Father, we just pray for anybody listening, that they might want to participate in the awakening of an authentic Catholic culture through the sharing of their love, and that pouring out into the world around them.

We ask all this in your holy name. Amen.

Keep listening

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *