After reading G.K. Chesterton’s essay on the family for episode 100, Joseph and Crystal talk it through. Why is it so much harder to know the people on our street than the people we meet after Mass? What would Chesterton say about his own family? And what does it look like to face the life we did not choose as an adventure rather than a problem?

Episode 101 · 35 min · With Joseph and Crystal Gruber
Discussing Chesterton’s Essay on the Family
Take the Our Outpost Quiz
A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.
Take the Quiz →Key takeaways on loving our neighbors and our families
- Our neighbors stretch us. Getting to know the person next door who sees the world differently can widen our minds more than a trip abroad.
- Someone has to go first. Joseph and Crystal have often been the only ones to knock on a new neighbor’s door, and they still find it hard.
- Describing the truth is easier than living it. Even St. Alphonsus Liguori reread his own book on God’s will, because he could describe it better than he lived it.
- Being born is the supreme adventure. We do not choose our starting point, but we have just enough freedom to be heroic in it.
- Face your origins. Running from where we come from leads to a smaller world. Even when distance from harm is needed, we can love as individuals rather than reject people as a group.
- Say hi to a neighbor. Examine where fear has kept you from your neighbors, then take one small step.
“A man has control over enough things to be the hero of a novel, but if he had control over everything there would be so much hero that there would be no novel.”
G.K. Chesterton, paraphrased by Crystal Gruber
Talk about it
An examination of conscience, then a step:
Where have I held back from a neighbor out of fear?
What in my family or my origins am I still running from?
Who is one neighbor I can greet this week?
Chapters
- ~0:00 Discussing the essay
- ~2:30 Snowed up in our street
- ~5:30 How hard it is to know our neighbors
- ~7:55 A bigger world next door
- ~9:00 Who goes first?
- ~10:55 Chesterton’s own neighbors
- ~12:40 Chesterton’s own family
- ~18:55 Describing the truth vs. living it
- ~20:00 The supreme adventure is being born
- ~22:30 Just enough freedom to be heroic
- ~24:20 Facing the problem of evil
- ~25:10 Facing our origins
- ~26:10 When family is toxic
- ~31:45 Fear of neighbor, and a challenge
- ~34:15 Closing prayer
Mentioned in this episode
- “On Certain Modern Writers and the Institution of the Family”, G.K. Chesterton
- Heretics, G.K. Chesterton
- Uniformity with God’s Will, St. Alphonsus Liguori (free e-text)
- Uniformity with God’s Will from TAN Books
- The Twilight Zone, “The Monsters Are Due on Maple Street”
- The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald
- Chesterton Academy
As an Amazon Associate, Our Outpost earns from qualifying purchases.
Full transcript
Discussing the essay
~0:00 Hey, Crystal, yes, Joseph. Would you like to discuss that GK Chesterton essay that we read last week? I sure would. Listen in to find out more Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives.
In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration, and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee, and by Thee be happily ended. Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.
Amen. We read a Chesterton essay last week for our hundredth episode. Oh, yeah So that would make this 101 That’s so exciting so about that Essay, mm-hmm. I almost called it an episode. It was an episode of the podcast About it There’s so many so many things so much in there So if you’re listening to this without having listened to episode 100 or without having read the essay by GK Chesterton From the book Heretics entitled “On Certain Modern Writers and the Institution of the Family” We invite you to either to listen to that episode or read the essay or you can just keep listening It’s not gonna hurt too much if you’re just coming to this cold But he covers a lot of ground.
He brings up a lot of interesting points. He really does and in pure Chestertonian style he He points out not only that points in opposition to his point are not great also other points that he Agrees with are poorly articulated ie also not great Yeah, he takes the arguments against the family and says don’t you guys see this is this is why the family’s so important The things that people are saying there are not actually Grasping the the essence of it.
Yeah that in reality when we really look at arguments against the family they ultimately circle back into a need for the family and and for community and real relationships. Oh Yeah, there can we start with this line that he has in here about how
Snowed up in our street
~2:30 if we were tomorrow morning snowed up in the street in Which we live we should step suddenly into a much larger and much wilder world than we have ever known There’s an episode of the Twilight Zone from the classic Twilight Zones. I think it’s called nightmare on Maple Street or something like that and the idea is that the power goes out in this suburban neighborhood and Everybody starts wandering out and Suspecting, you know, we saw something in the sky This guy was a ham radio operator.
This guy looks suspicious and they end up like killing each other. Oh Yeah and it turns out aliens were actually behind the The power outage and they said this is how we’re going to take over the world. This is how we’re going to destroy humanity We’re just we’re just gonna turn every neighborhood into Into its onto itself, right making the neighbors actually talk to each other and they’re so bad at being neighborly They’ll just destroy themselves Do do do do do do do do is that have the Twilight Zone?
Yeah. Yeah, that’s it. You got it Feels really fitting with that story because it’s from the Twilight Zone Yeah, but this is kind of the it’s like the opposite of what Chesterton says. Well, it’s I mean Chesterton leaves it as an option, right? I guess it is an option Like he doesn’t say we’re gonna do this.
Well, but he is saying things will be more difficult and more challenging and harder to be Neighborly with our neighbors and to be with our neighbors then To go out into the world and be part of a club and to be in our comfort zone Yeah, because our our neighbors Most likely are not part of our comfort zone.
They’re different than us And that that’s what the Twilight Zone was trying to bring out in that episode And and what Chesterton is saying is yeah, they they are really different. We don’t know how to handle that difference anymore And and we need to we’re losing something essentially human And the fact that you know a generation after Chesterton, you know, Chesterton writing Heretics What was it in the 20s?
And then in the 50s they come out with this episode of the Twilight Zone basically asserting Yeah, we don’t know how to how to love our neighbors at all We we are so caught up Not in clubs and cliques anymore But in everybody just staying inside and listening to the radio and watching television Like the very fact that people sat and watched the Twilight Zone episode rather than talking to their neighbors Reinforced the fact that we don’t talk to our neighbors So that’s kind of scary.
It is scary. I think
How hard it is to know our neighbors
~5:30 the thing that’s especially scary to me in this is Um, I mean we have felt it really acutely in most of our moves of yet not feeling really challenged in our ability to Talk to our neighbors to find them to connect with them to encounter them in a meaningful way and so I Yeah, I I get that that it is hard and that it is more challenging Than meeting somebody after Mass Yeah, because at least the person at Mass We have something in common.
We have the last hour or so In common Yeah, I know that there’s a shared experience that I can relate to And yet you’d think that living on the same street would also create some sort of shared experience that we could relate to You would think we’re in the same driveway for one of the places we lived You would think So we’re bad at this This is one thing that I don’t like to let on Is that I know the good And I don’t do the good well and So I don’t want to say we don’t do the good.
We could do the bit good better And we could try harder and I’d like to learn those things but when we have tried We have tried you’ve had neighbors outright refuse to give you a phone number um It’s true. Yeah, and so the The amount of effort and the amount of rejection is Is is a lot Which makes it very discouraging to keep trying Even especially because there are people that we can get along with better that we know that we can Because we meet them in circumstances where we know we have common interests Yeah, and
where they will give me their phone call and then their phone number and then they’ll return my calls and then we become friends Yeah So it makes sense why where we meet resistance We tend to stop And then where we meet less resistance we continue and Chesterton’s saying face resistance Yeah, and and he’s I love that when
he talks about Something that was really striking to me in this essay is this idea of
A bigger world next door
~7:55 how big is our world? And how we want to travel to other places to expand our minds and to have this bigger vision of the world And I mean I I’ve spent most of my life believing that that’s true and doing that and Seeking that and and I was I’m really challenged by him saying Actually learning how to develop a relationship with
the person that lives next door to you that has a different world view Is going to expand your mind and your understanding of reality more than a trip to Japan and and that That’s that’s really challenging And I think that’s part of why it’s so hard to to pursue those relationships because Because there isn’t this easy relatable
moment and thing to to launch off of And because we might disagree and I’m it’s hard to do that. Well with a stranger it is And it’s hard to because we are
Who goes first?
~9:00 almost always in the position of the initiator right We we introduced ourselves to a neighbor sort of caddy corner from where we live Who was just moving in, you know? Within a few days of the moving van unpacking You know, I don’t remember what the circumstances were such that we didn’t get over there earlier But we made it there within a few days and we introduced ourselves And we asked, you know, have you found a warm reception in the neighborhood?
And uh The woman said no, we were the first to stop by and say hi And so we got her phone number and she invited us to a little housewarming party that she was having and We asked have you had a warm reception in the neighborhood and she’s like, oh, oh, no You you’re the only ones who
have stopped by in this realization like It’s it’s not as if other people are doing this too so it’s not like we have One the accountability of other examples to look toward and two Uh the example of people doing that with us Yeah, when we moved in nobody came knocking on the door Mm from the neighborhood from
the neighborhood from the neighborhood. Yeah We had other visitors from other places in town But from the neighborhood, no So this is this is an interesting thing. He challenges us knowing full well That most people will ignore his advice Because he’s seeing this tendency. He’s seeing this ability For us to ignore one another more and more and and the degree to which we can do that today Is utterly astounding.
Oh, yeah There’s an interesting thing in this article that you pointed out Joseph that I’m interested in your thoughts on Is he talks about these sort of?
Chesterton’s own neighbors
~10:55 Fictitious neighbors And he gives them names like Elizabeth and I don’t know George and Henry Henry and maybe Nancy or something like that Yeah, he comes up with these Circumstances where somebody likes a restaurant somebody else likes drama And I had this kind of question in my mind he had neighbors and he Talked to them Why doesn’t he include stories from?
His life Right the little I know of his life and I’ve only read like a Wikipedia page and one biography of his And heard other various anecdotes But it seems as if He was a very congenial neighbor. He was You know often walking around he was talking to people inviting people over It seems like he did live what he was talking about And so I have this question of why not include those kinds of stories and maybe that’s just too personal for him But I would have found it a little bit more helpful Had
he talked about it from from his perspective right from from You know, I myself I’m a practitioner of this I realized that the the general mode of British journalists and the like is is to not inject the personal into Essays, but I still wish I had that from him more I wish I was his neighbor Right that
that is what I want. Maybe that’s what’s really going on Um Like to be able to walk through a neighborhood with Chesterton and to see him interacting with people with joy and gratitude And to learn that from him I I would like that So
Chesterton’s own family
~12:40 the other piece about the personal if we can transition a little bit now Is when he’s talking about the family and the difficulties found within the family He came from a family and he himself was a married man And I again, I understand his Habit and and the general tendency of not including the personal in the essay But to hear from him a little bit more about the kinds of things That he faced in his family I remember in the biography Chesterton had two siblings.
One was a sister who either died when he was very young or before he was born and So his mother was sort of obsessive about health And also would never want to talk about the daughter that she had lost And I would love to hear Chesterton Talk more about that. Like what what is that to live?
With a woman who is preoccupied with death, but we’ll never mention death You know his younger brother Ended up dying during World War I Not apparently as a result of any battles from World War I But on that I’m less sure But during World War I he did die And prior to his death and prior to going
off to to be in World War I he Was involved in exposing some kind of a scandal which ended up landing him in court and it was a big ordeal for him and a big ordeal for Chesterton and You know Chesterton defended his younger brother and would continue to defend his younger brother And to hear a little
bit from him about What that looks like, you know a brother who is willing to wade into scandal And you’re left sort of on the sidelines you know Committed to defending him And I don’t know the particulars of the story. Maybe his brother acted admirably every step of the way I don’t know but these these kind of real world examples of tragedy and scandal and Making these tough choices And learning how to walk on eggshells These would be interesting things to know And I think it it’s helpful in terms of his conversation that Again in the way
that being part of the neighborhood is more challenging and eye-opening and stretching being part of a family also Invites us to encounter Challenges In a way that we I mean people I was gonna say we can’t run away from people do run away from their families And so I suppose we can but but where it’s a lot
It’s a lot more isolating to not deal with what’s going on within the family and Which makes it when we do encounter those things head on whatever whatever things they may be in Chesterton’s example of The brother and the sister, you know that like when we Face these things together and learn to deal with them together that
that Opens it makes our world bigger Because it’s it’s stepping into somebody’s life who is Being different than me However in the family there’s a shared dynamic as well Yeah, the sense that family is Not that which is chosen And that which we are sort of stuck with like you said, we could run away But in running
away, we run into a smaller world not a larger one Yeah, because we run to where we want to run Instead of dealing with the reality that is before us we kind of create the reality that we want Instead of dealing with the reality that we have that feels like sort of like what he gets at both
Yeah, well and that’s Maybe again, maybe I just I would just love to sit and talk with him more about his own family And that’s more what I’m experiencing as I look over his essay is just Oh Chesterton. I I wish I knew more how this played out in your life because these examples about drama and and Somebody being obsessive about a restaurant that I don’t quite understand that’s not as meaningful to me about How you handled the loss of your sister or how you handled the loss of your brother Or how you dealt with the burden of infertility?
Because he and his wife though they really longed to have children were never never able to conceive Right and they they faced that and I By all accounts, they seem to face that really well. They were Very involved in in their neighborhood and in the the lives of the children around them They put on plays and they had dinner parties and and such and Yeah to hear how how the These realities impacted him how he faced them How he integrated them into his own life Or or hearing how he struggled to do so.
I mean one of the reasons why he continued to write essays for Different papers and and was the editor of a paper was that he took over the editorship for his brother who was probably more Capable of being an editor to the editor than Chesterton Chesterton was much too slapdash to be a good editor And so did he did he really process the loss of his brother?
Did he really let him go? I don’t know And so I wonder sometimes, you know, Chesterton is painting this picture of what ought to be And and how we might become the best That we could be and I I wonder is is Chesterton a little bit like me in that it’s still Further away than he would like And that would be consoling.
It’s similar to I heard this recently. There’s a wonderful very short book called
Describing the truth vs. living it
~18:55 uniformity with God’s will uniformity to God’s will Something like that something about being united to God’s will by St. Alphonsus Liguori It is a very short book But apparently he would reread his own book often And when his eyesight failed him the one thing he would have people read to him outside of Scripture most often Would be his book Uniformity with God’s Will And I think it’s because he realized He was able to describe The truth better than he was able to live the truth thus far and so continuing to hear that Was instructive to him And so yeah, I I don’t want to beat myself up too much In my inability to to measure up to what he describes here Um, but maybe I would be more reassured.
Anyway, we’re talking a lot about the life of Chesterton And I want to talk a little bit more about the content. Yeah, so I’d really like to talk about What
The supreme adventure is being born
~20:00 the romanticism that he discusses in regards to the family. Yeah. Yeah, go ahead. Um, and and Maybe this is I think maybe to tie it in what you were just talking about with Chesterton. I think something that I I see in his writing is this sense of Wonder and this sense of trying to explore and understand Human nature, right which I think is what you’re talking about is like what he’s doing with his writing and what he’s Trying to unpack and explore and and in this towards the end he starts talking about Romance, right?
Like we’re we’re looking he says This sublime and special romance like and he’s discussing what are we looking for and how we often think the romance is falling in love and How love does take us and transfigure us and transform us and it breaks our hearts with an unbearable beauty And he goes on and talking about yeah the romance of falling in love But he also talks about how there is a choice in that even in the falling in love It’s not a truly it’s not truly more romantic.
It’s not truly adventurous. It’s It’s we’re because we’re choosing it and we could choose To not fall in love with this person or even if we felt like we were quote falling in love we could Choose to not continue on in that relationship with that person But he says the supreme adventure is being born which I feel like this is sort of a classic Chesterton quote Yeah It is a res Well now it could be considered a response to This lament of the nihilist.
I never asked to be born Right, like why do I even exist? Why do I have to suffer the burden of my own existence? Why do I have to suffer? I never asked to be made And Chesterton saying this is the supreme adventure This is what has been placed before us the romantic Idea that we are born into a world not of our choosing There we do walk suddenly into a splendid and startling trap It is true And this line Where he talks about this is in the final paragraph.
This is the the piece That I think is so profound he says
Just enough freedom to be heroic
~22:30 a man has control over many things in his life He has control over enough things to be the hero of a novel But if he had control over everything there would be so much hero that there would be no novel And this idea that we don’t choose our setting We don’t choose our initial conditions But we have just enough will we have just enough freedom To be heroic But that whatever the circumstance that is before us We have this opportunity to be heroic so for our listeners Crystal and I are going to be helping to found a Chesterton academy In about a year’s time.
So we’re starting the the laying of the foundation not a literal foundation because Building a building in this day and it now doesn’t make as much sense as trying to find a building but laying the foundation of getting all the Finding teachers finding students finding a location Finding money all of this is starting to happen now And we’re starting to hit a few hiccups along the road where some people Don’t want us to start a Chesterton academy.
We’ll just say that for now and to say I could I could lament That this is happening. I could I could throw up my hands in despair or I can say okay I have before me the opportunity to be heroic. I can make a choice now that is a choice Enough to be heroic.
I can face what’s going on and face it well And we’ll see what comes of it and this is you know This is one of the brilliance brilliant pieces of Chesterton’s thinking Is that when he is confronted with
Facing the problem of evil
~24:20 the problem of evil he says this is not a problem to be solved he says this is This is a romantic adventure to be heroically faced All right. We don’t solve the problem of evil as if from my armchair I can cure cancer I mean theoretically maybe somebody from their armchair could cure cancer.
That would be wonderful but to say that His insight is that we become who we are Truly when we’re actually facing the reality around us And facing it head-on is the heroic thing And the family is that set of initial conditions That we first have to face And that we continue to have to face I think it’s been it’s been since high school since I read
Facing our origins
~25:10 The Great Gatsby And so I only have a fleeting recollection of random details But I seem to recall Him being mightily ashamed of his father This Gatsby fellow You know, he had changed his name. He had tried to to escape his past And he just had this deep shame about his origin And I think this is one of the things that Chesterton is saying like we We have to face our origin.
We have to live in reality We don’t become more ourselves when we divorce ourselves from Where we’re from so this maybe and I know we wanted to wrap this up a little bit, but Maybe tying this problem of evil with what he’s talking about with the family One of the things if I could sit down with Chesterton and talk to him about Would be I’ve I’ve met people who have been in
When family is toxic
~26:10 abusive family situations. I’ve met people who A friend of mine actually Emancipated himself from his family as a teenager because it was so toxic And I I wonder what Chesterton would say for for such situations Yeah, I mean That was a can of worms to open the um, but I think There’s there are ways to face reality without having to continue to endure Some of the suffering within the context, right?
Like I think it’s possible Not that this is it’s also possible to not do this, but I think it’s possible to remove ourselves from from actual harm’s way And still acknowledge that this is this is my origin This is my reality. This is part of what makes me who I am To be able to move forward and continue on I need A buffer between here and there is a very different thing then I’m gonna move out move up and move on and pretend like none of that ever happened Yeah, so the idea that Oh, what’s the more like psychological term to suppress?
Is that the kind of language that would come up? Maybe suppressing memories and and trying to just excise that whole chunk of our past rather than trying to face it and integrate it and learn from it and Yeah to to learn what love looks like in that circumstance Right, you know God’s commandment to love our neighbor Doesn’t just include our neighbor that has done good to us Right.
It also includes the ability to love our enemy And to love our enemy does not include Letting our enemy walk all over us that that’s actually less loving for our enemy uh, if nothing else and I think one of the distinctions here, right is actually Facing the reality of a particular individual in my particular individual life He approaches In this article and in other places in his writing right like this Nietzsche’s sort of dislike of like the mob of humanity and And Chesterton basically is saying I as an individual am always encountering another individual My encountering of humanity isn’t supposed to be Seeing humanity is this mob group It’s me seeing George my neighbor.
It’s me seeing I forget what his Clive my brother. That’s not his brother’s name. Maybe anyways um Like it it’s but it there’s an actual person that I’m talking about here And I think that that’s what’s really beautiful to me in this is that it’s sort of it’s basically saying whenever we group People together in such a way that the individual Is lost in my mind There something is lost In me
And so to be able to say oh I’ve left my family Generically behind because my family generically as a group Has been hurtful Is a is a different way Is a different thing than saying My father has hurt me and that’s that’s not okay and that sorrows me And reparation hasn’t been possible and so Separation is what
I need from my father in particular And that might actually be something different than what I need from my mother or from my brother or from my sister and that like That he he in this article is saying We need to encounter a person and not just Well, and this is the boldness of The the Christian moral
life is that we say we can actually separate both for our good and As the way to love the other Right to to put that buffer in Not just because of love and self-preservation but also so To to love the other well Is a the most loving thing I can do for you right now is to step
away from you And we say that we actually are capable of that kind of heroic love that our hearts can actually Be expanded such that we can love those who hate us and have hurt us And that is bold right that that is something that is Unless we have seen it. It is hard to believe That it is possible And even viscerally we might have this response of is that even desirable?
Because you know our longing for for justice and our longing for Retribution May cloud our ability to love rightly uh I mean true justice won’t cloud our ability to love right? It’s it’s more the disordered kind of um self-justification and and Desire for retribution that would would cloud love And I think this is one of the challenging things about This essay is that Chesterton is saying Yeah, your heart can expand this far.
It can expand even further you we can we can love our family we can love our neighbors and That means to try to relate to them In ways that maybe we aren’t accustomed to And just the notion that that’s possible It’s a freeing thing. It’s saying like there is a reality out there that we may have been afraid of But we can face it Right when we when we’re afraid of a reality our life is more constricted and I think So I I don’t know about you guys dear listeners, but
Fear of neighbor, and a challenge
~31:45 this past year or so I think there’s been a little bit of training intentionally or not to to not Love our neighbor and to indulge in fear of neighbor Sounds like a good little call to action to wrap up with I I think it does call for an examination of conscience Where have I held back in fear?
Like have I looked out the window and seen a neighbor And said well, I can’t talk to them Have I have I taken a walk in the neighborhood? And purposely crossed the other side of the street before I reached a block where another passerby might be Like am I living in fear of my neighbor?
And do I want to live in that small of a world? And then conversely Do I desire to love in such a way that will transform me? Or do I want a smaller and smaller world? Until I have a hell of self So I feel like there were other things we wanted to talk to talk about in this essay.
It’s packed. It’s jam packed I mean we could talk about this essay for a long long time, but we’re not going to tonight. We’re going to challenge our listeners to Find a neighbor I was going to say start with the examination of conscience But also if you’re up for it, let’s just say hi to a neighbor Yeah, it doesn’t have to be like an intense conversation or like having somebody into your home for dinner They’re probably just as afraid of you as you are of them Smile and say hello How are you today even from maybe even from across the street?
But just some Level up level up the interaction or jump over the garden wall into your neighbor’s yard and pretend as if you live there Your choice dear listener I leave that to you and your freedom also if you Give this a shot. We’d love to hear about how it goes either in our email hello@ouroutpost.
org or Instagram or Facebook at our outpost and You can feel free to rate review and share this podcast I’m going to pray us out now In the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit. Amen Heavenly Father.
Closing prayer
~34:15 Thank you for our neighbors. Thank you for calling us to love our neighbors and pray for the grace to um Do the next right thing We ask all this in your holy name. Amen. Name the father and the son of the Holy Spirit. Amen person to reference From Our Outpost to yours. Thanks for listening and a special.
Thanks to john. Mark scope. That’s S-k-o-c-h for the music check them out on Spotify
Keep listening
Share this episode
Know someone who wants to love their neighbors better? Share this conversation.
