Some Catholics long for the world, or the Church, of the 1950s. Joseph Gruber is tired of it. He explains why that decade was the seedbed of the 1960s, how nostalgia keeps us from noticing and nurturing the good in front of us, and why we should be planting now for a glorious 2050 instead of mourning the orchards of the past.

Episode 247 · 18 min · With Joseph Gruber
Focus on the 2050s, not the 1950s
Take the Our Outpost Quiz
A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.
Take the Quiz →Key takeaways on nostalgia
- The 1950s led straight to the 1960s. Wanting the fifties back means wanting the sexual revolution to be just a decade away.
- Nostalgia sees through rose-colored glasses. Romanticizing any era hides what was wrong with it and trains us to keep looking backward.
- Tradition hands on a living torch. Being Catholic means carrying the good of the past into the present and the future, not trying to recreate yesteryear.
- Plant a tree today. Instead of mourning orchards that are gone, cultivate what is planted and plant more. Our children will be adults in 2050.
- History didn’t end. Christ hasn’t returned, so there is still work to do: loving our spouse, children and neighbors, and thinking in decades rather than election cycles.
“We should be thinking about how to best prepare the world for the year of our Lord 2050, not how do we return to the year 1950.”
Joseph Gruber
Try this this week
Swap one backward glance for a forward plan:
Picture your family, parish or town in 2050. What would you love to see?
Choose one seed to plant this month toward it.
Chapters
- 0:00 Opening prayer
- 0:28 Tired of 1950s nostalgia
- 1:05 The 50s led to the 60s
- 1:46 Not the 1250s either
- 2:33 Look toward a glorious 2050
- 3:08 The nostalgia trap
- 3:57 Tradition carries the good forward
- 5:00 No DeLorean
- 5:29 Plant a tree today
- 6:54 Our children in 2050
- 8:50 How can I love better right now?
- 9:57 A town renewed by 2050
- 10:56 Thinking in decades, not election cycles
- 13:20 History didn’t end
- 14:25 Handing on a living torch
- 16:29 Closing prayer
Mentioned in this episode
Full transcript
Opening prayer
0:00 Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration,
and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee, and by Thee be happily ended. Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Hello and welcome to A Word from Our Outpost. I am Joseph Gruber,
Tired of 1950s nostalgia
0:28 here to talk to you today about this weird fascination that some people have with the 1950s and they say, I wish that the world was more like the 1950s or I wish that the church were more like the 1950s church and I’m a little tired of it and I think we should be tired and done with it
as a whole. And I want to tell you why, because this is the podcast that I put out.
The 50s led to the 60s
1:05 So a couple of things. One, the 1950s, it’s a weird decade to be fascinated with because it was the precursor to the 60s. So many of the things that happened in the 60s were a direct result of what was going on in the 50s. So to say that I want the 50s back
is to just say I want the 60s to be a decade away. And that seems silly. That is a silly position to be in, to say I want all of those precursors back such that we will just ride into another weird sexual revolution with a lot of confusion and a lot of debauchery and a lot of
misunderstanding. No, that is silly.
Not the 1250s either
1:46 Now, for those who are wondering, Joseph, do people accuse you of this? No, people do not accuse me of wishing that it were the 1950s. The closest that I got was, if you remember some weeks back, I had Nathan Stanley, a FOCUS missionary on the podcast. And at one point he said that Joseph doesn’t belong in the 1950s, he belongs maybe
in the 1450s or the 1250s. And I took that as a compliment. But no, I don’t think that the 1950s were all that and a bag of chips. I don’t think that in the 1950s are the period of time that we should be trying to ascribe to. In point of fact, I don’t think it’s a healthy practice
just to glorify a particular generation or particular decade or a particular era.
Look toward a glorious 2050
2:33 What I want to propose, ladies and gentlemen, and we’ll get into this a little bit in a moment, is that instead of longing for something like the 1950s, I think we should be preparing for and working for a glorious 2050. I think the 2050s should be mostly what we’re looking toward, not looking back at the 1950s.
So why not glorify the 1950s or why not glorify any particular era? Good question, thank you for asking.
The nostalgia trap
3:08 One, I think there is a tendency to romanticize the past, to say, here are all the good things that were going on then, here are all the things that I liked about what was going on then. And that diminishes all of the things that were going on that weren’t so good. It is looking at it through either blinders, only looking at the things that
you appreciate about that time period, or rose-colored glasses, filtering out all of those discordant colors that make us feel uncomfortable. So I think that the idea of nostalgia being a trap that we get into, one of the pieces of the trap is that we romanticize the past without looking at it honestly for what it was.
I think it also habituates a backward-looking mentality to continue to look back rather than to look at now or to look to the future.
Tradition carries the good forward
3:57 Yes, we need to learn from the past. Yes, if you are a Catholic Christian, you belong to like the traditional experience. That is what we are about as Catholics. We are all about tradition. But that’s not always about looking back and trying to say, let’s try to recreate the conditions of yesteryear. The question is, how does what was going on in yesteryear that is good,
how do we carry that into now and into the future? And one of the other things about this nostalgia trap that I should mention is that many of the people who get trapped in this nostalgia bait are ignoring whatever is good going on right now, whatever that needs to be nurtured right now, whatever that is going on that is worthy of our attention
because they are looking at what has been going on. And ladies and gentlemen, we’re not going back to 1955 anytime soon.
No DeLorean
5:00 The DeLorean that had the flux capacitor in Back to the Future made it back to 1955. That was a 30 year jump for them. We are now another two score removed from that time period. We are 40 plus years more removed from the 1950s than we were in the 1980s when Back to the Future came out.
We’re not going back in time. We’re not going to do it. So I think we need to let go.
Plant a tree today
5:29 I think there’s this expression that the best time to plant a tree was, depending on what the tree was, like a pear tree, apparently you plant pears for your heirs. So the best time to plant a pear tree was probably 40 years ago, but many times the expression is the best time to plant a tree is 100 years ago or the best time
to plant a tree was 10 years ago. But the second best time to plant a tree is now. The second best time to plant is today. And instead, what I sometimes see people doing, and I want to warn you about, to not do, is instead of planting a tree now, they mourn the orchards that have been uprooted in years gone by.
And here’s the funny thing about mourning for those orchards that are no longer here, that are no longer producing fruit. They’re still not producing fruit. They’re still not producing seeds. And so the job, the task right now is to cultivate what is planted and to plant more. And I think many of the people who are longing for what they consider to be simpler times, what they consider
to be better times, what they consider to be more traditional times, what they consider to be more Catholic times, or more Christian times, or more wholesome times are not also doing the attendant work of planting for the future.
Our children in 2050
6:54 And this is one of the things, right? Like, if my wife and I were to have another child, sometime in the next year or so, in 25 years, it’ll be 2050. And that kid will be 20 odd years old, right? Like we will have another adult human being if we decide to have another child, if we are capable of having another child.
That’s always an open question, especially as we’re getting as advanced in years as we are. But in 25 years, when it’s 2050, I have seven children. They will be 25 years older than they are right now. That means that my oldest son will be roughly the same age that I am right now in 25 years.
It means that all of my currently existing children will be adults in 25 years. And my work right now is to do all I can so that they might become the men and women that they’re called to be, that they might grow into Christian maturity, that I’d take the steps today to help them in their
future, both in how I’m raising them, but also the work that I’m doing for my job, also the work that I’m doing in my community, in my parish, that I should be doing all that I can so that my children can receive the best of all possible worlds, building on whatever is good now,
affirming whatever is good now, and trying to initiate anything that is lacking, anything that can be begun now. This is one of the reasons why my wife and I started a marriage ministry, because we want to help other Catholic husbands and wives to love each other so well, that the children that are produced by that union grow up in a world where they long to be
as good and holy as their mother and father. That would be an amazing thing.
How can I love better right now?
8:50 If we spent most of our time obsessed not with a question of how can we make things like the 1950s and more obsessed with a question, how can I love my spouse better? How can I love my children better? How can I love my brothers and sisters better, my coworkers, my neighbors, my parents?
If we are obsessed with those questions about right now, how am I called to love? Right now, how am I called to serve God and neighbor? That is going to be a lot more effective than saying, wouldn’t it be nice if we could just get into a time machine? Wouldn’t it be nice if we could just snap our fingers
and suddenly we could undo a lot of the damage that has been done? It would be nice to do that. We can’t do it. So what can we do? What ought we to do? How are we supposed to respond to the situation of today? Learn the lessons from the past? Sure. We do need some
amount of time of learning from history. We do need some amount of time of garnering the best of all possible practices, and that should not distract us from the work at hand today and the preparation for the future.
A town renewed by 2050
9:57 I want to see the community in the town that I live in to blossom, to flourish in a way that they’ve never actually flourished yet. Like I live in a relatively small town in Michigan. In 2050, I hope that this town is radically renewed and transformed by degrees better and better until it can become the kind
of city that we all want to be in. Not like a 1950s suburban life. I don’t think suburbia has done humanity a whole lot of favors, just FYI, but that would be authentically Catholic inside and out, but that requires both a desire to evangelize such that the residents of this town have an
opportunity to respond to the gospel. It also requires a vision for the city that is larger than myself and larger than right now, that is looking decades down the line. One of the
Thinking in decades, not election cycles
10:56 biggest problems we have in our political order right now is that they have two to four years as their guideline for planning, and even that is oftentimes foreshortened. So they’re not thinking about how do we legislate, how do we run a city or a town or a county or a state in such a way that in 25, 30, 50 years, the community will be better because of it.
They’re looking for short-term solutions, and sometimes what I’m afraid of is that those who are obsessed with whatever era of the past, whatever time period they think was the best of all possible times, is that it’s actually inhibiting them from planning long-term for where they are right now and where they would like to be.
That’s who I want to be having discussions with. That’s who I want to be working with. I want to be working with the men and women who say, I want to build the world brick by brick into the world that it’s most conducive to flourishing. I want to help my spouse to do that.
I want to help my children to do that. I want to help the neighbors that we have to do that. Those are the kinds of conversations that I want to have because ultimately Christ didn’t come in the 1950s in his second coming. The end of the world didn’t happen. The end of the world has not yet happened,
and while that is still yet to be, that means there’s still work to be done to prepare the way of the Lord, and that means there is work to be done in my heart to prepare the way of the Lord for his coming, both sacramentally but also at my final death, my final hours, but also if
I live to see it, the end of the world as well. Who knows if I do? But the work also that I have to do to prepare for Christ coming in the hearts and the lives of those I love. We have a seven year old son, and he’s preparing for first holy communion right now.
That should be uppermost in my mind. How do I prepare him to receive our Lord? And how do I prepare our 12 year old to continue to receive our Lord in a way that actually draws him closer into the Paschal mystery and helps him to become the man that he’s called to be?
And then how do I help the whole community to prepare for the coming of the Lord sacramentally but also at the end of history?
History didn’t end
13:20 History didn’t end in the 1950s, history didn’t end in the 1550s, history didn’t end in the in the 1250s or in the 350s or whatever. History continues on, which means that there is still a task, there is still a mission, there is still a way forward, a next step for each and every one of us.
There is always a next step to become the saint that God is calling us to be. There is always a next step to become the saint that God is calling us to be. And that should be something that we are practically obsessed about. It should be something that we take seriously. How is God calling me to be a saint today?
What is the work that he’s calling me today? And what is it that I’m called to help participate in building? In my home? In my community? What is it that I’m called to help create? Again, the 1950s had a whole lot of problems. This is not an episode to discuss all of those.
There are plenty of people out there who have dissected that decade.
Handing on a living torch
14:25 I do want to just get at this whole idea that we are a people of nostalgia. We are a people of tradition, which means we pass on that which has been handed on to us. That means that we are called to pass on a living torch to the next generation. That means we should have abundant gratitude to those
who have handed on something to us. That means we should, in that gratitude, hand it on to others. And that means we should be thinking about how to best prepare the world for the year of our Lord 2050, not how do we return to the year 1950. That’s the episode. That’s the message.
Don’t get trapped in the nostalgia trap. We don’t need to be trapped in the nostalgia trap. When we’re talking to people who seem to be stuck in the nostalgia trap, ask them, okay, what are we going to do today to help create the world as it ought to be in the light of God’s love?
What are we doing today to help the Lord who has called together all men scattered and divided by sin into the unity of his family, the Church? How do we do that? What are we called to do today? Let’s talk about it. Let’s actually get into it. Let’s actually do it because, ladies and gentlemen, this is our life.
And at every time and at every place, God draws close to man. And we’re not always responding. And we’re not always helping other people to respond. And we can. We can respond moment to moment and we can help other people to respond more and more. And that is the great task of the Christian life.
That is the great task of being a Catholic evangelist. That is the great task of being a Catholic disciple. That is the great task of being a baptized member of the family of God, the Church. And so let’s get on it. Let’s do it. Let’s be about that. Let’s be about our father’s work
that we might help one another to experience the love that he has for us.
Closing prayer
16:29 That is the episode. You can check out our work at ouroutpost.org. My wife and I run a marriage ministry and we would be happy to help you in any way, shape, or form that we can. Also, while you’re poking around on websites and the like, also please take a moment to rate and
review this podcast. And if you found it helpful, please share it as well. Please pray for us. We will be praying for you in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Glory be to the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Spirit as it was in the beginning,
is now and ever shall be world without end. Amen. In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. From Our Outpost to yours, thanks for listening and a special thanks to JohnMarc Skoch for the music. Check him out on Spotify.
Keep listening
Share this episode
Know someone stuck longing for the good old days? Send this their way.
