How do we foster healthy masculinity in our sons when the culture doesn’t want them to be sexually healthy? John Bishop, who wrote his doctoral dissertation on the crisis of men and masculinity and now leads the family formation apostolate FORGE, talks with Joseph and Crystal about remote preparation for marriage: models boys can aspire to, communities of men, fathers at play, and real conversations about sexuality.

Episode 180 · 52 min · With Joseph and Crystal Gruber and guest John Bishop
Fostering Healthy Masculinity with John Bishop
Take the Our Outpost Quiz
A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.
Take the Quiz →Key takeaways on healthy masculinity
- The witness of the father matters most. Congregations skew female, and research keeps finding that a husband and father’s faithfulness is the strongest single predictor of faith in the next generation. Focusing on men responds to a weakness, not a claim of superiority.
- Give boys models they can aspire to. Not every boy will be a pro athlete. The lanky, joking father who protects his family in Life Is Beautiful is masculine too. If boys don’t find positive images of masculinity, they will find bad ones.
- Be strategic about the men around your sons. Invite friends with different gifts, ask one to pull your son aside at the barbecue, and make room for him in the man circle. Men unite around a project, and it builds friendship between fathers too.
- Fathers are called to play. Men provide, protect and procreate, but they are also called to play. Entering the world of your son’s play takes time, the way G.K. Chesterton’s father built a puppet theater with his sons.
- Talk to your sons about sexuality. Even in devout families, many men never heard a word about sex from their fathers. If you don’t open that channel of conversation, someone or something else will.
“If we don’t give our boys positive images of masculinity, they’ll find bad ones.”
John Bishop
Talk about this together
Two questions for you and your spouse this week.
Which men in our lives could our sons naturally look up to?
When will we start the conversations about sexuality our children need to hear from us?
Chapters
- 0:00 Opening prayer
- 0:52 Meet John Bishop
- 1:36 Remote preparation for marriage
- 3:28 The crisis of men
- 4:33 The witness of fathers
- 7:23 Making space for men to lead
- 10:39 Models they can aspire to
- 12:50 Life Is Beautiful
- 17:43 Other men at the barbecue
- 22:15 Friendship between fathers
- 24:10 Initiation into a community of men
- 26:50 A place in the man circle
- 30:03 The Intentional Father
- 31:47 A seat at the Bible study
- 36:12 Men at play
- 38:50 Chesterton’s puppet theater
- 43:42 Talking to your sons about sexuality
- 47:25 FORGE’s Fathers and Sons course
Mentioned in this episode
- FORGE and its six-part course, Fathers and Sons: Conversations on Sex Ed, Marriage and Masculinity
- Jon Tyson, The Intentional Father: A Practical Guide to Raise Sons of Courage and Character
- Life Is Beautiful, John’s favorite film portrait of a father’s masculinity
- The Our Outpost Quiz, four minutes for Catholic couples and singles
As an Amazon Associate, Our Outpost earns from qualifying purchases.
Full transcript
Opening prayer
0:00 Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.
Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration, and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee, and by Thee be happily ended. Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.
Meet John Bishop
0:52 Amen. a family formation company, but we have a strategic emphasis on men. And in fact, for our first couple years of operations, we’re working exclusively with men. Getting up to this point, I served as director of formation for FOCUS, the Fellowship of Catholic University Students.
And yeah, during that time, I got a doctorate in theology from Catholic University of America and wrote my doctoral dissertation on the crisis of men and masculinity in the church and more or less about where we go from here. Awesome.
Well, as a mother of four sons, I’m very excited to dive into these topics and learn more about what you have to say and have some hope.
Remote preparation for marriage
1:36 And maybe to set some context, we talk a lot about marriage enrichment, and we talk about marriage prep, and we recognize that marriage prep has these three stages. One is the immediate prep that comes from a man and a woman saying, I want to marry this one.
And that preparation, then there’s the proximate preparation, which is the preparation from essentially puberty on and learning how to be a citizen of the world, citizen of one’s country, I suppose more technically, and how to interact with people of the opposite sex, how to be truly a man or a woman.
And then before that is remote preparation, this preparation we receive in the home from observing marriage lived out by watching mother and father, by watching neighbors, by watching other extended family members, people of the community.
And we spend most of our time between the marriage, post marriage enrichment, and like probably the other big chunk is our proximate marriage prep stuff. But we thought maybe today would be a good day to dive into especially the remote preparation.
So how do we raise sexually healthy masculine sons, especially recognizing that the world does not want them to be sexually healthy? Right. Yeah. Well, hey, I yeah, this is this is something that I’m really excited to talk about, and something that I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about.
So I’ll go ahead and you know, it strikes me that perhaps the best way for me to begin on this is to talk a little bit about what motivated me to make this topic such a big deal in my own life.
The crisis of men
3:28 So a lot of people will talk about the crisis of masculinity, the crisis of men, both in the church and the culture. And what in the world does that mean? A lot of people might not might not see it in their own lives.
I depending on what area of the country I’m working in or speaking in. Sometimes I run into communities of people who don’t seem to have any man problem at all. It was interesting. About a month or about a year ago, I was in West Virginia.
And when I was in West Virginia in this particular town, I went to a church and I was giving a talk on masculinity. And the church was filled with men, almost no women there at all. And they when I was talking about the crisis of men and masculinity, they were just like, What do you mean?
Yeah, we’re, we can’t get the women to come to church. But for most places, that’s not the case. So on any given Sunday in the United States of America, both for Catholic churches, and for mainstream Protestant denominations, your average church congregation will be about 62% female and about 38% male. All right.
The witness of fathers
4:33 When it comes to marriage and family, I usually just give simple kind of human observations, like the fact that if anybody’s going to leave a family, and we’re, you know, neglect their responsibilities, when it comes to their spouse, their children, it’s usually not going to be the woman who just sort of like, you know, at least in a manifest way, it just kind of packs her bags and heads out.
Oftentimes, it’s the man who leaves and statistic after statistic, the most recent one being a study done by an organization called Communio in June of 2023 showed that the number one, if you were to isolate just a single factor that would cultivate faith, or at least would be an indicator of faithfulness in the next generation, that single factor with the highest predictive power would be the witness of the husband and the father of the male.
All right. Of course, that’s nothing against women. And people ask me all the time, gosh, you know, why are you putting so much emphasis on men? Isn’t that chauvinistic? And I say actually, it’s quite the opposite. My emphasis on men is more a function of male weakness, you might say, than male strength.
It’s the fact that we see such declining statistics, such declining participation in religious life, such declining participation in family life on behalf of men, that we need to buttress and provide support, you know, for that sort of, I hate to say weak link, but at least in contemporary society, that’s, I think, what it might rightly be called, that we put a lot of emphasis on men.
So the general flight of men away from the family and away from the faith in this generation is certainly a problem, but it’s even a bigger problem for the next generation.
So it’s for that reason that I think organizations, really any organization that has a touch on marriage, that has a touch on family life, needs to reckon with this issue, which is masculinity, and then how do we cultivate a positive sense of masculinity in our sons?
So that just kind of lays the stage. When I started thinking about masculinity a lot, thinking about the formation of masculinity, I was coming from working in professional ministry and sort of seeing these statistics firsthand, and then decided to write a doctorate on the topic of the crisis of men and masculinity in the church and in the culture and where to go from there.
So I don’t know if that sort of resounds, gets any traction in your experience, Joseph or Crystal, but anything that you might add to that, you know, does that seem off to you? Anything your listeners might be wondering about, you think?
Making space for men to lead
7:23 Yeah, well, there’s two things that come to mind. One of which, when we give talks on dating, we often get asked, like, because we say that men should ask women out. So invariably, a woman will be like, well, why can’t I ask men out?
And I say, look, you can. That’s not the problem. The problem is, is you want to marry the sort of man who’s going to take initiative and be a leader of the house.
And if you start out your relationship where you are the one woman taking initiative and being the leader of the relationship, that’s what you’re going to have for the rest of your life. And any woman that I’ve talked to, that’s how the relationship starts.
They feel like their husband is another child in the house. Yeah. Yeah. And you don’t want that for your marriage. So don’t start dating. Yeah. Yeah. And you might think that when it, when it comes to particularly things domestic, all right, things in the home, like you said, women just naturally, for a lot of hardwired biological reasons, are going to forge bonds and connect with their children, become enlivened by all things domestic, just naturally from the get go more than men.
And so if you want to have a true, a true partner in crime, if you will, while you’re doing the family thing, then it’s almost like you have to sort of create the space for men to step in and lead.
Because otherwise, just, just kind of given the, the, once again, the natural, I don’t want to say deficiency, but the women are just sort of like quicker ordinarily on these things, that it’s almost like you have to give men to just sort of clear a wide space for them to step in and initiate.
Right. And if it’s, it’s, it’s so easily stifled, that masculine initiative in the family, so easily strangled. And so anything that you can do to cultivate it is certainly a worthwhile endeavor. I love that. Yeah. Is there a second point?
You said there were two things was, Oh, I, that was, I had come across a similar statistic of the one you shared that was more recently done by Communio. When I was a missionary on campus with FOCUS about the impact of the faithful husband, the faithful father in regards to family life.
And, right. And as I was a missionary and meeting students invariably, the kids that were still practicing the faith, dad went to church. Like maybe he wasn’t even Catholic, maybe he hadn’t even come into the church, but he like went to mass with the family every Sunday.
And so as I started thinking about marriage for myself, that became really important to me of like, I, I want to marry a man who will go to mass every Sunday unquestionably. Right. And so then you just ended up with me. He’s got a lot of other great qualities.
And he goes mass every Sunday. So, so that, that one just really resonates with me a lot. And yeah, seeing, seeing the impact of that and what that means and looks like. So I would love to jump into then what does this look like for parents?
What does it look like for that? Yeah. That remote prep, like how, how we love our sons. Well, yeah. So I’m going to start off with some really basic points and then we’ll just get more and more specific as the conversation goes on.
Models they can aspire to
10:39 The first exceptionally simple point that I’d like to make is making sure that your son has models of masculinity in his life that he can actually aspire to. Okay. Now here’s what I mean by that.
Oftentimes I think we fall into a bit of a trap, particularly in the new evangelization Catholic world that a lot of people in ministry run around in where there’s unwittingly a kind of machismo version of masculinity that is upheld as kind of good Catholic masculinity, if you will.
So this is nothing against, against sports heroes or anything like that. But if you go to your typical kind of Catholic conference, there’s going to be a man talk usually as a part of that conference.
And the kind of go to person to tap on the shoulder for that man talk is usually like some sort of robust professional male athlete. All right. You might think of Philip Rivers or Harrison Butker or whoever you have. Ra Ra Harrison Butker, I was certainly rooting him on in the Superbowl and he’s an exceptional man.
So this is nothing against those people. But for many of the men, Just to be clear, I do know who that one is. Okay. That’s good. Kicker for the Chiefs. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Proud of you, Joseph. Thank you. Well, for anybody who doesn’t know Harrison Butker is a devout Catholic man from everything that I can tell.
I don’t know him personally. Remarkable husband and father who serves as the kicker for the Kansas City Chiefs and performed very well in it and winning the Superbowl this past Sunday. So there you have it.
Harrison Butker, you have guys like that who are oftentimes kind of put on the stage as the kind of paradigm of all masculinity. Now, that’s not to say that they aren’t shining examples of masculinity, but it might not be a witness of masculinity that all of the men in the audience can sort of resonate with. All right.
Life Is Beautiful
12:50 So for example, one of the best examples that I’ve ever seen of masculinity is from an old Italian film called Life is Beautiful. If you guys ever seen this, it’s entirely in Italian. It usually kind of comes up as one of the greatest films of all time.
I’ve heard of it, but I don’t think we’ve seen it. We have not seen it. Okay. The narrative in the story is this, that there’s an Italian town and there’s a journalist in the town. The journalist, young man, Jewish man falls head over heels in love with a woman.
They get married, have children, and this man without kind of giving away the end of the film more or less goes throughout the entire film, protecting his daughter, protecting his wife from the various attacks of the Nazis to find them, put them in concentration camps, what have you.
And while he does this, he does it in the way that a kind of goofy journalist might do it. He’s not machismo. He’s sort of a tall, lanky character who rides a bicycle around town, is always joking and just kind of having fun playfully with every person that he encounters.
He doesn’t exactly fit the mold of, I don’t know, Bruce Willis masculinity or something like that. He’s a sort of different manifestation of it, if you will. He’s a journalist. He’s not a professional athlete. And you might think of his profession as kind of sort of representative of his personality at large.
There are different kinds of men. And just as, I think sometimes when people hear me say that, they sort of cringe because they’re like, well, does that go contrary to the sexual binary or anything? No, of course not. The church is always recognized as sort of range and personalities.
I mean, after all, when it comes to femininity, there was indeed people like, I don’t know, Thérèse of Lisieux, but there’s also another canonized saint, Joan of Arc, who’s being a warrior was not in any way an affront to her femininity in the same way that the masculinity of Saint Joseph might look different than the masculinity of John de Brébeuf or another Catholic saint.
So in your life, think about your son. And does he, with his own dispositions, with his own talents, with his own personality type, have men in his life to whom he can aspire to be like? Okay, so just speaking for myself, I have two sons, and I’m not banking on either of them becoming NFL football players.
And if they’re like me, they might not even have an interest in professional football, they might be sort of more thoughtful types who get lost in books and things of that nature.
Can you have men in your life to whom that kind of kid can aspire in the same way that the young athletic man, you know, has images of masculinity that he can aspire to. And here’s why that’s critical. If young boys don’t, or how do I say this?
If young boys aren’t given an image of positive masculinity, they will find masculinity somewhere else. It’s hardwired in them to want to be men. And if they don’t get an image of masculinity, a taste for masculinity in the community of their own families, say in their church, or in some wholesome setting like that, then they’ll look elsewhere.
Ordinarily, they’ll look for images of masculinity on things like YouTube, right, or on the streets, or what have you, they will find masculinity somewhere, because it is built into their DNA as human males to look for guidance when it comes to the flourishing of their own male potency.
And the flourishing of that male potency is, of course, masculinity. If we don’t give our boys positive images of masculinity, they’ll find bad ones. And they’ll mimic those in their own lives. Does that make sense? Do you see that? Yeah. Yeah.
What would be some concrete examples you’d listed going to a conference and putting a man on the stage who is some exemplification of masculinity? But what would be other ways of giving these examples to a son? Yeah.
So, you know, there are kind of grandiose ways of doing it, like putting the right kinds of speakers on stages at Catholic conferences. But let’s pause for a moment now and just talk about some very simple ways of doing it.
Other men at the barbecue
17:43 I think that the best way to raise children is amongst communities of parents doing the parenting thing together. All right. So, obviously, parents are primary educators of their children, and you, Joseph, and you, Crystal, are having authority over your own children, a window into their own formation that nobody else has.
Nevertheless, you benefit, and I’m sure I’m preaching to the choir here, by having other complementary adults alongside you that can provide a complementary witness to your sons and daughters. Now, today, we’re talking particularly about sons, but let’s just picture this. So, the Grubers are having a barbecue on Saturday afternoon at their house.
And obviously, you two are there. But let’s just say, Joseph, that you also have four or five of your friends who also come over for the barbecue. And one of those friends is a successful businessman in town, but is a masculine man in his way.
Another of those friends is something of an artist. He’s great with the guitar. And, you know, maybe he works as an educator in a local school. Then you have a doctor, you know, it’s somebody else with some other profession. And when you think about your four boys, they each have their own personalities.
Those boys might look up to different of the men at that barbecue. And I think what it looks like to cultivate masculinity and your sons, for you, Joseph, to be quite strategic about getting your sons around the men who will support your witness, your formation, in a complementary way.
So, everybody does certain things that kids don’t like to take from their parents. You can say it a thousand times. And it might get your kids 90-95% of the way there. But you need some other parents alongside you to take the other five percent.
The same with masculinity. I remember being a young boy myself. And I respected my father. I have kind of a champion gold medal dad who did so many things right. But there was an attorney in town when I was growing up who was very eloquent.
He really just kind of knew how to make an argument. He loved to, he was very well read. And it was almost as though he and my dad conspired, which I found later on they explicitly did, you know, to help guide me along a path to adulthood.
Who are the men in your life? This is a question for all of the husbands and fathers listening to this podcast. Who are the men in your life to whom you think your boys might naturally get, might naturally aspire?
And next time you’re around them, can you say something like, hey, we’ll just say, Bob, you and your wife are going to come over for a barbecue next Sunday. Would you mind just some time over the course of the afternoon when you’re at our house?
Just pull my son aside. Have a quick conversation with him. I’d love for him to connect with you a little bit more. And you know, he’s actually struggling a little bit with XYZ. And if that topic comes up, I wouldn’t mind if you spoke with him about it a little bit.
And what that does is kind of like gives boys a sort of track to follow along as they traverse the perilous journey from boyhood to manhood. So do you see that quite concretely? Does that give you a little bit, little taste of what you’re looking for?
Yeah, it’s interesting. Because as you were like describing the theoretical situation, I’m like, oh, you know, I’m thinking about parties we’ve had and the men that have been there and which ones kind of fill into that. And then there’s another You’re thinking about the doctor and the businessman and the lawyer and the educator who come over.
Who’s the doctor? He’s in Guatemala now? Oh, yeah, we lost him. Yeah, you’re right. But then there’s another family that’s coming to my mind that I’m like, ooh, we need to be friends with them because this one son would connect with him. So, Yeah.
Yeah. So I like what you’re talking about. You’re not just saying, you know, let it happen only by osmosis, you know, just, you know, trust that chance will make them have conversations and connect, but actually set them up for success, actually plant some seeds for healthy relationships to form.
Friendship between fathers
22:15 The other thing I love about this, and I don’t know if this is intentional on your part, but in terms of thinking about there’s such a deficit in male and man friendships. Yeah. And this is a really beautiful way to strengthen the friendship between those dads.
Right. In a way that feels very honoring and acceptable. And it takes out like some of the weirdness that I think some guys have. And it’s, and it, it like undergirds a way to give another man a compliment without it being a compliment, if that makes sense.
Like, like, there’s just harder for them to resist the recession. Like if you were like, Hey man, I really admire like the virtue with which you run your business. He’d be like, uh, thanks, I guess. But if you were like, Hey man, I think my son like might be interested in the kind of business you run.
Could you kind of talk to him about that sometime? If the opportunity presents itself, like you’ve given him a compliment, but he doesn’t have to feel like awkward and weird about it and might not even realize that it was a compliment until after the fact.
And then you also give him something to do about it. Yeah, I just, that’s just, it’s genius. I love it. Yeah. Men unite around a project, right? There has to be something out there that they’re going towards. Right. And, and, and the pursuit of that thing unites the parties who are in pursuit of it.
Right. And so it’s almost like the, the formation of the boy and more broadly, you know, the flourishing of the families, the project, and if, if, if the husbands and the fathers can conspire, you know, towards that common end, then I think you, you naturally get this friendship.
But point, the point that you just made, Crystal actually, um, gives me an opportunity to highlight another thing.
Initiation into a community of men
24:10 And it’s, it’s the value of having a community of men into which you can invite your son. All right. So, uh, one of the things that I spent so much time researching and thinking about during my doctoral studies was the prevalence of initiation rites across time and place, particularly male initiation rites.
Um, the same parallel doesn’t hold for women. But if you consider this phenomenon, which is the male initiation, right, which exists in excess of 99% of societies across time and place throughout history, up until the very, very recent, like last few decades past, um, in, uh, in the United States, those were powerful and they were part of male formation.
It seems to be the case that young boys who ordinarily grow up in an environment that is sort of flavored feminine have an innate desire to enter into a community that is obviously masculine. Let me kind of sort of put some detail on that real quick.
If you think about it, I’m kind of being funny here, kind of not every human being, regardless of sex, it begins in the most feminine of all feminine environments, literally the womb, you know, right.
And then they go from there, you know, to, I mean, you might think of nursing, you might think of all of the needs of like very, very young children. Most of those needs are more readily met or at least more frequently met by, by the mother.
So there’s a way in which all boys start out in this kind of feminine space, which gives a kind of narrative to the fact that in a certain sense, more than women, more than females, boys have to have this step along the way where they exit that space and they go into another space, right?
You know, typically the space event, like you’re no longer doing the thing, you know, uh, around the camp with the women, you’re now going out and hunting with the men, right? Boys want that. They want it so bad, which is why they search for masculinity so hard.
Now, what does it look like for a husband and a father in 2024 to have some kind of intentionality in ushering his son into healthy masculinity? Well, you can do big things in your life that, that I would hardly recommend to people like, you know, taking your son on backpacking trips and things of that nature.
But those sorts of things, you know, are, are kind of bright moments along the way, if you will, that you should certainly engage in.
A place in the man circle
26:50 But let’s go back to the barbecue for a second. Okay. In a lot of the barbecues that I go to, it just seems to naturally happen. It doesn’t always happen, but you’ve, you’ve got families together and they’re almost inevitably ends up being a man circle.
It might be around the grill. Um, it might be some other point in the house, but you’ve got your man circle. Okay. And let’s just say that you’ve got like an 11, 12, 13 year old son, who’s kind of starting to wrestle with questions about life and sexuality and masculinity and whether he can articulate those questions or not.
You can kind of tell they’re at play in him. What’s a really simple thing that you can do to kind of usher your son in to a sort of wholesome understanding of masculinity? Just make him a space in the man circle. All right.
You’re kind of like, step over, bring him in and say, Hey son, we’re talking about X. What do you think about it? And then compliment him on the point that he makes. And all of a sudden, in a very small way, your boy has become part of the crew, right?
Of the hunters, if you will. Now those hunters are now like insurance salesmen and things like that. So it’s not like the all too grandiose about this, but I give that as an example of the kind of very simple thing that fathers can do to usher their sons into communities of men in which those sons can identify, right?
I’m part of this crew, you know, like this is, this is my dad. This is friends. This is, you know, I’m his son. And this is this, you know, community of men in this town and me, the 13 year old kind of wrestling with questions about my own masculinity.
I’m starting to identify with a group of men and something deep. I could talk for hours about the deep psychological things that are at play when that’s happening to a boy, but it’s important and it’s critical.
There’s a reason why you see these initiation rites, celebrations of masculinity, of kind of entering a brotherhood of men across time, across place without any exceptions. And there needs to be a similar way for us to meet that need for young boys in today’s culture.
Do you see that? Any kind of immediate questions that come to mind on that front? I mean, there’s a concern that many men don’t host barbecues. Okay. So there’s like the without which there is not a man circle, which is the right, the gathering of families in the first place.
Yeah. Yeah. We don’t currently have that problem, but we do know that there are many. Well, and we don’t have that problem because we host, right? We create that space and have not yet, although I think we’re making progress, changed the culture in our town such that other people also are doing this.
A couple of people do. Yeah. But this is like a huge cultural shift to make invitations, to bring people together, to have no ulterior motive other than the desire to be with other families who are seeking the good life. Yeah.
The Intentional Father
30:03 Fatherhood requires intentionality. You know, it’s so, gosh, antithetical to today’s culture, as you said, Joseph, to run in that direction. There’s an incredible book by, oh gosh, the book is called The Intentional Father. Author’s first name is John. I can’t remember his last name, but if there’s any book, it’s not Bishop.
No, I wish. But this book, The Intentional Father, more or less makes the case that for husbands and fathers wanting to raise masculine sons, it is incumbent upon those husbands and fathers to create intentional male, really kind of all male masculine spaces in which their sons can kind of stretch out into their masculinity.
And it doesn’t have to be complicated. You know, it can be, okay, gosh, I like to go fishing, you know, or I live in Colorado and I like to go for a hike. All right. And I usually bring a couple other men with me.
Well, so long as those are wholesome other men that you have with you, invite your son. Okay. It doesn’t have to be the man circle at the barbecue, but introducing your son to all male spaces such that he starts to identify with the men who are in those spaces, it’s almost like every time you do that, you create a little masculine initiation, right, in which your son can start to identify with wholesome masculinity, as opposed to some other version of masculinity that would ultimately be detrimental to his marriage and to his family. Yeah.
A seat at the Bible study
31:47 So I think another example, so I used to host regular times to study the Bible with men and one of my sons for first communion got a really nice Ignatius RSV Bible, hardback. And he was so excited. He said, can I come to your Bible study now, daddy?
It’s like, well, you can come for the beginning. And so he would come and be there for introductions and catching up and then opening prayer and reading the story. And then we would see if he had any comments on it. And then I said, okay, now it’s time to go to bed.
Thank you for coming. So this moment of allowing him, at least at the beginning of the discussion, because he was only seven, eight years old. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think that’s a really beautiful example, Joseph, of you inviting him into your life. Well, he invited himself.
Let’s be clear. Because he wants it, right? That almost reinforces the point more is that he’s intrigued by that, the thing going on, the adult men, I want to be part of that. I think it’s a perfect example. And then the fact that it’s almost like you wet his appetite by giving him a taste of it.
And then saying, son, yeah, maybe another year, maybe a couple of years from now, we’ll give you a little bit more and a little bit more and a little bit like you’re leading your son along a path that eventually culminates in his own flourishing, right?
I think, yeah, whether you knew it or not, I think that’s an absolute wonderful example of the kind of thing. Yeah, no, absolutely without intention, totally by accident and osmosis. The evidence of your brilliance, Joseph, clearly.
Well, it’s interesting because I think that that’s, you brought up the point earlier, John, of there are different kinds of men and what are the things that we like to do.
And I think I’ve seen this in our time and in space in life of when men don’t feel like they fit into this like sports, whatever guy, there’s this question of like, well, what do I have to offer as a man? And what does masculinity really look like?
And how am I upholding that? And the fact of the matter is, is if you are paying attention to who you are and how you’re wired and doing the things that you love to do and that bring you to life, again, so long as they’re wholesome, which if they’re not wholesome, they’re not actually going to bring you to life.
So there’s that. And then to do those things and to pursue those things and to see that not as a selfish endeavor, so long as it’s helping you grow in virtue, but as creating a space for your sons.
And again, we don’t want the means and the ends to get all mixed up here, but that is a benefit of- Yeah, I don’t have a flourishing life so that my sons, but because I have a flourishing life- And it’s not selfish to have a flourishing life.
Truth. And it does also, right? Because one of the things that I see happen, and I see this happen in Catholic circles in a way that really gets my goat, but there’s this like the workaholism of the dad.
I’m like, okay, sure, maybe you’re open to life and maybe you have six, eight kids, but your wife is really unhappy because you’re working 80 hours a week and you’re not actually different than your neighbors that don’t go to church and have different ideals.
Like the shape of your rhythm of life, like you don’t have a relationship with your kids, you’re working too much, but there’s this like, but I’m providing for my family mentality. And it’s like, money is not what they need. They need you. Yeah.
I think you’re so right on that crystal. And I kind of just want to take out a highlighter and under just emphasize what you said for a moment here. And would you mind if I spent just a minute or two on that point and why I think you’re absolutely correct? Please. I love being right. Yeah.
Men at play
36:12 So men are providers, men are protectors. I don’t deny those points, but they’re certainly true. Yeah. Okay. And sometimes, I was reading an article, I think this was from the Art of Manliness website, which is generally a great podcast and a wonderful source of good wholesome masculinity.
And there was an article that talked about the three P’s of masculinity, provide, protect, procreate. So you have to, those things are true. And I would certainly call men who are called to procreate, to procreate, and men are indeed called to be providers and protectors.
Fundamentally though, I think there’s a deeper gift that men have to give in that husbands and fathers in particular are called not only to procreate, to protect, and to provide, but also to play.
And there’s perhaps no deeper formation that you can give your son than to enter into the intimate world of his play and to, within that space, witness to masculinity. You can’t do that if you don’t give him time.
And just recently here, the apostolate that I run released a series just called Fathers and Sons, Conversations in Sex, Ed, Marriage and Masculinity. And there’s a man who was part of the development of that series, who was a very successful attorney. And he’s got eight kids.
He is a partner at an international law firm. So no slouch, Ivy league educated guy, clearly a bright, hardworking individual. He made a resolution that in any given week, he throughout the whole of his raising his children would spend intentional one-on-one time every week with every single one of his eight kids.
And he talks about more than the multimillion dollar a year salary that he was able to provide, the beautiful home that he was able to give. He was very, very intentional about wasting time with his children.
It was, I think that kind of thing is sometimes under emphasized in the, even the very Catholic circles, and unfortunately sometimes maybe especially in the very Catholic circles, our understanding of masculinity.
Sure, men are providers, protectors, they should certainly procreate, but can you be a man at play, you know, and that you give your children an invaluable gift. Do you see that? Does that resonate with your experience, Crystal? Oh, yeah. It’s very Chestertonian, right?
Chesterton’s puppet theater
38:50 What was the example of GK Chesterton and his father? Apparently his dad had finances such that he was basically a stay-at-home dad and he built a puppet theater for his son, for his sons. I didn’t know this about Chesterton. Well, yeah, they would put on these little puppet shows.
GK would write little plays and he and his dad, and then his younger brother eventually, they would play act. And then when he and his wife weren’t able to have children, which is very sad, the idea of GK Chesterton with a whole posse of kids would have been a delight.
But that was not in the cards for them, if we believe in the predictive power of cards, which we don’t. Idioms, man. Idioms. Thank you for the clarification. I appreciate that, Chesterton. No, it’s helpful. Not going to be derailed. But he was a fatherly figure in his community.
So he actually made little puppets for kids in his community, and they would put on plays for the kids, he and his wife. They would have families over. This idea of the man at play was very much a Chestertonian thing.
Yeah, and you might think of it, too, as a kind of fulfillment, kind of almost pinnacle of masculinity. When you’re learning how to be a man, I think in gradients, you progress in, you might say, starting out every adolescent male is able to at least perform the action, barring medical difficulties of procreating.
There’s something sort of basic about that. And then it is incumbent upon men to learn the trade, you might say, or some means to provide for your family, to have the wherewithal for the modern equivalent of protecting your family, say, from the negative effects of digital media or things like that.
And these things become harder and harder and harder. But it’s only a man who is really at peace with his masculinity, I think, who can enter into, confidently, things like silliness with his kids. Yeah, that’s something that, as you’ve been talking, I’ve been thinking about is, this is maybe a tremendous negative impact on the woundedness of men.
Because I know even for myself, I have a hard time playing, and I see that as a sign of a deficit and a sign of woundedness in myself. And so this idea that… And then also, it brings to mind, I mean, earlier, we were talking about this, the professional football player, what is football?
It’s a game. It is a game to be played. And so that we’ve disordered play in a certain… It’s like, on the one hand, there’s something really beautiful in that, but then on the other hand, it’s become not to play. And so there’s just the understanding around play.
And then the other direction is when work… When you’re really good at something, it becomes playful. Mastercrafts meant they enjoy the work. They have fun in the doing of it. And that could be the spirit in which we do all sorts of things.
When I have my sons help me to reorder the living room, I can either come down harshly and yell and say, why aren’t you picking up this mess? Or I can say, all right, come on, guys. Here’s fun. We can sing a song and we can enjoy this.
This is an enjoyable thing. We can make this room beautiful for your mother and we can have fun. You can choose either one. You can do both, I suppose, but probably one is better than the other. Yes. Yes. Play seems to be a kind of pinnacle in more ways than one.
And thereby, you might think a challenge to men who really desire to be deeply masculine. In this same vein, you’re talking about the heights of masculinity, if you will.
I want to make another point here that I think is critical for men, particularly devout Catholic men, as I suspect a lot of the folks listening to this podcast are, when it comes to the raising of their own sons.
Talking to your sons about sexuality
43:42 Like I mentioned before, I recently went through the process about six months or so of interviewing a lot of psychologists, theologians, philosophers, and just experienced fathers across the country asking the question, how do you raise a sexually healthy son in a sexually toxic culture?
And one of the things that I found over and over and over again, even in very devout Catholic Christian circles, were men who spoke to their sons about so many things, who were involved, who were intentional, who took their kids on camping trips and who gave them a great education and read them books at night and what have you, but who never spoke to their sons about that thing, which constitutes perhaps the chief channel through which most men, many men become confused.
And that’s sexuality, that the number of men who I encountered who had never had even a single conversation with their father about things sexual. And I’m talking families who are open to life, who are obedient to 110% of all church teachings, going to Mass on Sunday and many other times throughout the week.
But the topic of sexuality comes at particularly the young boys through about 10 other sources and not the father. This is a tragedy. And it seems to just kind of redound through the generations that like, I literally spoke to one man, I remember having a conversation with him in a coffee shop.
And he said, this man was in his mid 50s. And he said, well, you know, my father was a staunch World War II vet, super, super Catholic man, you know, kind of defends his dad. He never spoke to me about sexuality. I just kind of figured things out in conversations with my friends.
And so for that reason, I just felt like I didn’t really know how to do it. So I didn’t talk to my sons about it either. This deficit is, is very problematic.
If our children don’t hear from their parents, you know, both, you know, the good examples, you know, the implicit and the explicit things that you know about what wholesome sexuality in a marriage looks like, then they will pick up an education in sexuality elsewhere.
Okay. And I just want to, I just want to kind of emphasize that now that, that men are so easily manipulated through their sexual desires. And if you manipulate a man, especially from a very young age through his sexuality, you can wreck a family, you know, you can keep him from being a patriarch, if you will, by, by messing him up as an adolescent in this way.
Carving a channel of communication with your son that enables you, albeit imperfectly, but that enables you to have conversations with your son, explicit conversations with your son about sexuality is critical. Because if you don’t do that, some, someone or, or something like a computer certainly will.
And so that’s, it’s kind of a challenge to all the men listening today, they, they need to hear words from your mouth. I mean, think about it after all it was, it was your sex that created them, right?
So, so who better, you know, to, to kind of inform them, you know, of this beautiful mystery, which is sexuality than the father. So I’m so passionate about that right now, given the research that I’ve done, particularly recently, even in very Catholic circles that I, I kind of want to highlight that for, for all the listeners.
FORGE’s Fathers and Sons course
47:25 So I’m guessing that you have some resources to recommend to that end? Yeah. Would you look at that segue? Would you look at that? Appreciate it. Yeah. So we are in this kind of intergenerational downward spiral when it comes to, to masculinity, to what it means to be a good husband, a good father, just a good man period.
And for that reason, FORGE, the nonprofit that I lead, put together a course, it’s a six-part series. We interviewed about 25 psychologists, experts in the sort of theological dimension of the family, and then just dozens and dozens of very experienced parents on best practices when it comes to steeping children, particularly sons, in a proper, empowering, wholesome understanding of sexuality.
So if you go to myforge.org, M-Y-F-O-R-G-E.org, you can see this six-part series. It’s available to all of you. Each, each of the modules, the six modules has about a 20-25 minute video, and then a 15-20 page written resource.
So if you want to jump on there, I think you would find it to be not only worth your time, but transformative in your own, in your own fatherhood. So commend that to all of you. Awesome. And that is written particularly for fathers.
Particularly for fathers. We’ve had about 500 men do the course thus far. We have gotten a lot of rave reviews. I do know that a number of those men have just done it in their marriage.
The course is written at the center of our strategic focus is the Catholic men’s group, say of men between the ages of, you know, 23 to early 50s who have sons at home, ages two to 15, you might say. But it’s kind of being used in a lot of different contexts.
I just heard from a school principal last week who’s using the series for all the teachers in his school in New York City, just to help the teachers, to help empower the parents in their community, to have a better understanding of this. I know a priest who’s leading a group of couples in the course together.
And so you can, you can adapt it to a variety of different contexts. But if you’ve got a Catholic men’s group, fathers with sons at home, the course is made specifically for you. Cool. Very cool. I love it. Well, thanks for chatting with us, John.
I have a lot more questions, but we might have to just have you on again sometime because it sounds great. I enjoyed it. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you. It’s been a blessing to be with you guys. Love everything that you guys are doing with our outpost.
It’s an extraordinary mystery. Well, thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. All right. Would you mind closing us in prayer? Oh no, his audio went out. Can we hear you? Can you hear us still? Crystal, would you close us in prayer? I will do that.
In the name of the Father, Son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen. Heavenly Father, we thank you so much for this time, for this conversation. And I pray that you would bless our listeners and especially give the courage and grace needed to men who are feeling called to take some next steps based on this conversation.
We ask all this in your holy name. Amen. In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. From our outpost to yours, thanks for listening, and a special thanks to JohnMarc Skoch. That’s S-K-O-C-H. For the music. Check him out on Spotify.
Keep listening
Share this episode
Listen with a friend, then ask each other: who are the men who helped shape us, and who could do that for our kids?
