Hate Speech and Phobias

Why are so many disagreements now labeled hateful or phobic? Joseph Gruber argues that modern discourse has lost sight of the virtue of fortitude, the space between fear and anger where a person stands on real conviction, and asks how Catholics can disagree, endure being mislabeled and still love the people they disagree with.

A Word from Our Outpost, a Catholic podcast: hate speech

Episode 251 · 24 min · With Joseph Gruber

Hate Speech and Phobias

Watch on YouTube Spotify Apple Podcasts Pocket Casts

Free · 4 minutes

Take the Our Outpost Quiz

A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.

Take the Quiz →

Key takeaways on hate speech

  • Fortitude is the missing middle. Courage lies between cowardice and foolhardiness: facing what must be faced, by good means, for the sake of the good.
  • Conviction is not phobia. Believing something is true means believing its contrary is not. Joseph argues that saying so can be an act of love rather than fear or hatred.
  • Rest keeps us from being driven by passions. Without rest in what is true, good and beautiful, fear and anger knock us around, and that gives everyone with convictions a bad name.
  • Our neighbors are the prize. Those who oppose us are not the enemy. Pray for them, and for their blessing.
  • You can’t evangelize without loving those who disagree. Becoming people who can endure misunderstanding with love and joy shows there is a third way.

“You cannot evangelize someone if you can’t disagree with and love them.”

Joseph Gruber

Try this this week

Take one question to prayer:

Lord, what am I still running from, and what am I charging at?

Name one person you disagree with and pray for their blessing every day this week.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Why so much is labeled hateful or phobic
  • 0:13 Opening prayer
  • 0:40 A feature of modern discourse
  • 1:28 Fortitude: between cowardice and foolhardiness
  • 2:47 The Abolition of Man
  • 3:58 Disagreement is not fear
  • 5:46 The irascible passions
  • 6:59 Standing on firm ground
  • 7:57 When fear and anger do run the show
  • 9:08 We need to rest
  • 9:55 Why we evangelize
  • 11:07 Speaking from love
  • 12:28 Staring into the face of suffering
  • 13:09 When a conversation hasn’t begun
  • 14:50 Examining our own fortitude
  • 16:22 Pray for those who label us
  • 17:37 They are not the enemy, they are the prize
  • 19:40 Disagree and still love
  • 22:47 Closing prayer

Mentioned in this episode

As an Amazon Associate, Our Outpost earns from qualifying purchases.

Full transcript

Why so much is labeled hateful or phobic

0:00 Why is so much labeled as hate speech or as phobia? Why is that part of our discourse? What are we to do with it? What should we as Catholic Christians think of that? Listen in to find out more.

Opening prayer

0:13 Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration,

and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee, and by Thee be happily ended. Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Hello and welcome to A Word from Our Outpost I am Joseph Gruber host of this podcast

A feature of modern discourse

0:40 wanted to talk to you today about a feature of modern discourse that I think if we don’t wrap our minds around we’re going to have serious trouble as committed Catholic Christians who want to proclaim the truth of Jesus Christ and his church in the world today and we don’t want to be labeled phobic on the one hand or hateful on the other and

the modern world I think there are a couple of reasons why the modern world is very liable to To attach the label of hatefulness on the one hand or fearfulness on the other hand to almost anyone who disagrees with whatever narrative people tend to believe at the time. Why is this? Well one reason is that the space between

fearfulness and anger is

Fortitude: between cowardice and foolhardiness

1:28 that space that we call the virtue of fortitude. So the virtue is the the mean between two extremes. One extreme is is cowardice. People who are easily cowed by whatever is frightful they turn tail and flee from whatever might be hurtful. They’d want to escape suffering at all costs. So there is that extreme and on the other extreme there’s the foolhardy, the one who is

seemingly brave, but really they’re just rashly running at whatever it is that disturbs them. So you could think about it as flight or fight. You can think about it as cowardice and foolhardiness. But the important thing to think about is that there is space in between where we face whatever needs to be faced in order to pursue the good.

So we will endure whatever needs to be endured in order to pursue the good and we will do whatever is needful in order to pursue the good. So it has to be in accord with the good if we do it. So if like if the way to get to the good is evil, we wouldn’t do that.

We only choose good means to a good end. So that’s the courageous man. That’s the fortitudinous man. And I don’t think the modern world really has a concept for what the fortitudinous man is.

The Abolition of Man

2:47 I think C. S. Lewis gets at this pretty epically in his book The Abolition of Man. If you haven’t read it yet, please do read it. It’s short. It was three lectures that he had given. If you listen to the audiobook, I think it’s a lot easier to take in because it was meant as as public lectures and

it’s very much about how modernity is saying we don’t want people to actually have something solid to stand on. We want them to be pushed or pulled. We want a carrot and a stick and we want to keep using those in order to prompt people and we don’t want people to live for anything that is actually permanent or real.

And we don’t want people to have a sensation that there is something permanent or real, something to be convicted about. So there’s that absence of the space for the fortitudinous man. And so for a man to say, I believe in this and I therefore disbelieve all things contrary to it.

Disagreement is not fear

3:58 I believe in the Catholic faith. Therefore, I disbelieve in Islam. Does that make me an Islamophobe? No. It means that I disagree with anyone who espouses the Muslim beliefs. It means that I think that Islam is fundamentally wrong about reality, about who God is and about who we are. That doesn’t mean I hate them.

If anything, me saying that I disagree with them is the most loving thing that I can do in that circumstance. Because it’s saying I care enough about you to be willing to tell you that there is yet a better truth out there. Something that is more true than what you believe. There are aspects of what you believe that are true, but there is more yet to be had.

Same thing with homophobia or transphobia. Most people who I’ve seen been labeled as homophobic or transphobic or whatever. I don’t actually see fear motivating them. Now, it is possible, and we’ll get to this, it is possible to be motivated by fear. But it seems to be a matter of saying I have a set of beliefs

and this other set of beliefs contradicts what I believe. I can’t continue believing when I believe and believe that those things are true, too. So I have to disagree. Like, if I’m going to be consistent, I have to disagree. It’s not a matter of fear. That’s a rational position to take. That is the only rational position to take if we believe something,

is to believe that the things that are not that are not true. There is no consistency, right? So there’s an abandonment of reason. I’m going on of saying people can’t actually have a rational position that they can defend without an appeal

The irascible passions

5:46 to the irascible passions. So irascible from a word where we get the word irate. The irascible passions are our fear, our anger. And I think the world would say most of our convictions are due to an untamed and untameable irascible passion. And if that’s the case, then any position that anyone takes is either phobic or hateful

because it’s all motivated by a wild, irascible passion. Same thing with hatefulness. You know, people saying, I disagree with you. Why do you hate me therefore? I’m like, well, no, no, no. If I disagree with you, you also disagree with me. So I don’t hate you and I don’t think you hate me.

It’s possible you hate me, but what’s motivating me isn’t hatred of you nor even truly like a hatred of your position necessarily, but a conviction that my position is true. In order to say that my position is true, I have to live in a world where other people believe false things. There is no other place to be.

We can’t have any conviction if we’re not able to say that.

Standing on firm ground

6:59 So I think the modern world doesn’t have a conception of conviction. It doesn’t have a conception of the fortitudinous man of the man who was able to say, for the sake of the thing that I believe in, I speak for the sake of the thing I believe in, I act not out of fear

and not out of anger, but out of a deep seated conviction that this is real. I’m not running from something and I’m not charging towards something. I have, I am standing on something. I’m on terra firma. I am on the firm ground of my conviction. And that is the place from which I act.

And that is the place where I can be at rest. There is something about fearfulness and anger that implies a freneticism that implies a restlessness, but there is a position that we can take where we are not frenetic, where we can be peacefully disagreeing with other people. So I don’t think the modern world by and large has a

conception of that. I think that that is a confusing thing when people come across it.

When fear and anger do run the show

7:57 And I think the second reason why so much is labeled as phobic or as hateful is I think many of the people today, that’s actually the position that they’re in. They are operating very much with an untamed, irascible passion that fear and anger are the things that are running rampant, that a lot of what they’re doing is prompted by a fear of

reprisal and suffering or a desire to eliminate a threat. And I think because there are so many people who are fueled by this, because we’re not coming from a place of rest, that it’s giving everyone who disagrees with a narrative a bad name. So I think this is fed by the the relentless

news media. This is fed by the social media. This is fed by people not actually taking time to think critically and to be coming from a place of rest, but rather in a place of constant frenetic activity.

We need to rest

9:08 And I think this is one of the biggest problems that a Catholic Christian can face is that we don’t take time to rest. And if we don’t take time to rest, we are going to be led by our passions more and more. If we don’t rest in what is true, good and beautiful,

then what is left is going to be the pain and pleasures of this world knocking us about like a badminton birdie. That is what we are going to be experiencing. And because so many people do experience that, everyone who wants to take a position that is reasonable, that is measured, that is for the good, that is in support of truth, that is trying to create a more

beautiful life for themselves and for all those who might hear, these people get lost in the shuffle.

Why we evangelize

9:55 And I think if we want to evangelize the world, which we do, because if we don’t evangelize the world, we are giving up on the world. If we give up on the world, we give in to despair. If we give in to despair, we ourselves are lost. So I think we do want to evangelize the world.

I think that is a thing that we want to do. If you’re listening to this podcast, at this point, 200 some episodes in, and you don’t think that the world is in need of the gospel, that the world is not in need of a savior, that the world is not in need of truth and goodness

and beauty. I’ve been doing a horrible job. That’s on me at this point. You can point your finger at me and say, Joseph, your podcast gets one star. You have convicted me of nothing and I have despaired of the world. But hopefully that’s not the position that you’re in. Hopefully you’re in the position of, oh yeah, this God guy, he’s really great.

This Jesus who was sent by God the Father, that we might know God the Father, that we might be given the Holy Spirit, that we might be adopted into the family of God, that we might be given true rest because we are weary, that we might have a firm place that is not liable to be shifted about upon the sands of

the world, but actually be a firm foundation. You’re like, yeah, that’s a thing not only worthwhile for me, but it’s worthwhile for other people too.

Speaking from love

11:07 Then we need to be able to say to the world, I am not operating out of fear. I am not operating out of hate. I am operating out of love for what is true, good and beautiful. And that includes you. That includes my neighbor. That includes the person in front of me, the person with whom I’m speaking.

I speak for your good. I speak in pursuit of truth. If you’re not actually pursuing truth alongside me, we’re not actually having a conversation. And if we’re not really having a conversation, then whatever it is you’re doing is the thing that’s being motivated by the passions. And you don’t need me for that.

And so there’s that element of, if somebody is truly a relativist, if somebody thinks that there’s only pain and pleasure in this world, and that those are the most significant things that can happen to us, and that’s their mode of interacting. They’re not really seeking a relationship with us. They’re not really seeking truth alongside us.

And we can call that out. We can say, look, I’m not operating from fear and anger. I experience fear and anger. I experience that in the face of injustice. I experience that in the face of suffering. I experience that on the daily. And one of the crazy things about being Christian

Staring into the face of suffering

12:28 is that God is saying, I want you to actually stare into the face of suffering every day. I want you to come into my house and see my son hanging upon a cross, because I want you to know that there is something beyond suffering, that suffering is not the end of the story,

that death is not the final chapter. That’s the world in which we live. That’s the world from which we can communicate. If we’re not communicating from that, people are going to be thinking, probably rightfully, that we are motivated either by fear or by anger. If that’s not what’s motivating us, I think it is responsible for us to be able to articulate.

I want to operate from a place of pursuing the true, the good, and the beautiful with you.

When a conversation hasn’t begun

13:09 If that’s something that you want to do with me, I want to continue this conversation. If that’s not something that you’re interested in, if you are highly skeptical that there even is a truth, give it a chance. If you don’t even want to give it a chance, then maybe we can take a break for now.

We’re not breaking because I’m angry at you or I’m afraid of you. We’re taking a break because we never really started. We’re taking a break because this hasn’t begun yet. A very different thing. That’s not the same thing as saying, I don’t want to talk to you because you’re hateful or fearful or you think that I’m hateful or

fearful. Just saying, we can’t start yet. And that’s a sad thing. That is a thing that is worth praying for, a change that is a thing worth trying to be an example of someone who’s living from a place of rest, someone who’s not afraid of silence, someone who’s not afraid of talking to God about even the worst things, the darkest things, to bring those things to light.

I think it’s worth it. Ladies and gentlemen, I’ve talked with many a person over the years. I was an on-campus Catholic missionary for eight-ish years and a parish missionary for five. And I don’t think anyone ever accused me of being hateful or fearful because I really and truly tried to love them well and listen well and to communicate whatever they were willing to

receive.

Examining our own fortitude

14:50 But if you have experienced that, look, there is always the chance, if you’re listening to this, that you are operating out of fear or anger. There is a chance that there is that lack of fortitude going on. We all lack fortitude to some degree because it’s a virtue. We can always keep growing.

There is a point of heroic virtue, but there’s not a point at which we are done growing in virtue. And so, yeah, take that to prayer. Ask our Lord, Lord, what am I still running from? What am I still charging at? Thoughtlessly, needlessly, hopelessly. Like the man without courage is a man without real hope because a man with courage is willing to suffer

and even die for his convictions because there is hope that it all matters, that it’s all important, that it’s all meaningful. We live in a very meaningful world, and most of the inhabitants of this world are clueless, and we have a chance to clue them in. There is deeper meaning, there is deeper relevance, there is deeper significance that they have yet to see,

and that we can communicate. We can get better at it. This is one of the reasons why I often recommend to friends and to associates that they check out Toastmasters or any other such club to learn how to communicate more clearly. But look, we can all get better. We all should get better because it’s worth it.

It’s worth finding ways to communicate to whomever will listen.

Pray for those who label us

16:22 That being said, there will be people who don’t want to listen. There will be people who are closed off. There are people who are willing to consign us to the same category of either fearful or hateful, and we can’t do much about that other than to fast and to pray. Let there be some internal examination of self from this episode, but also let this

flow into a prayer for our neighbors, for our enemies, for those who would wish us ill to pray for them that they may become friends, to pray for them that they may be blessed even more abundantly than we are provided that we receive all the blessing that we are able. There is no

reason not to desire the good of others. I think the more we pray for people, the more that we pray for them to experience the love of God, the mercy of God, the forgiveness of God, reconciliation with God, the more it’s going to be harder for the labels of phobic and hateful to stick.

If we want to be like rubber and them to be like glue, we need to be men and women of prayer, and we need to be praying for all those who stand against whatever is true, good, and beautiful currently, and realize that they are not the enemy. They may have set themselves against us,

They are not the enemy, they are the prize

17:37 but they aren’t the enemy. They are the prize. The world is the prize. The neighbor is the prize. The enemy is the prize, and this is part of the virtue of courage is to know that so deeply and to speak from there and to live from there every moment we can of every day,

to replace the time that we spend scrolling on our screens, watching random videos, and instead rest in our Lord, and to have minds and hearts turn toward our neighbor to be living lives of intercession. Look, I don’t have a real solution for most of this. You and I, we have to become braver.

We have to become more resolute. We have to become more convicted. We have to become more fortitudinous. That is what we need to do. We also need to be men and women so dedicated to prayer that we can rest in God, and that we can speak from that rest in love to our neighbor.

I don’t know if anything else will help those who are so quick to label anyone and everyone who disagrees with them as either phobic or hateful. They need to see that there is a third option. They need to experience that there is a third option, and ladies and gentlemen, dear listener, that probably will mean that we will have to suffer.

That means we will have to endure, and that means we will have to endure being misunderstood, mistreated, mislabeled, and to do that lovingly and joyfully. If we can do that, if we can endure the worst, then people will see this. This is different. This is not what I expected. A man who is foolhardy or a man who is cowardly would not be enduring this.

You and I, we have to be able to endure, which means we have to be able to encounter and engage with, and to be with people who think ill of us.

Disagree and still love

19:40 And if we can’t do that, if we can’t disagree with someone and still love them, we need to beg our Lord that our hearts be expanded. You can’t evangelize people if you can’t disagree with them and love them. You cannot evangelize someone if you can’t disagree with and love them. You can’t. But if you can love those who disagree with you

about such fundamental things, about who God is, about who we are, about what the sexes are, about what marriage is, about what a country is, or about what a church is, or about what a priest does, or about what the Eucharist is, or about name the thing, name the thing, if we can’t live with people who disagree with us, if we can’t suffer their

presence, then they’re going to be right. They’re going to be right that we are not brave, that we are not fortitudinous, that we are actually acting out of fear or anger, because we are unwilling to endure those who disagree. And so the invitation, become men and women of bravery. That’s what we’ve got to do.

That’s it. I don’t know what else to do. Pray and become the man or woman God is calling you to be. If you’re married, live out your marriage as if you had one life to live and one spouse to love. Because that’s the reality. If you’re married, live like you have one life to live and one spouse to love.

Live like your spouse is your permanent neighbor. And let your evangelical impulses start there and flow from there. You’re not married. Oh, hey, guys. If you’re not married, we still have an online course for those who are single. I went through some of the videos recently. The material is really good. I came up with it.

I get that. I get that I’m biased. But it was a couple of years ago. And going back to it, like the guy who put this together, I think he knew what he was talking about. It was me, which is great. Love that. So maybe you don’t trust that as much. But that

was like past me. Now it’s still available for now you. So if you’re Catholic and single, check that out on our website, ouroutpost.org slash dating. We have other things going on too. Check out our website, ouroutpost.org. We’re here to awaken authentic Catholic culture through holy matrimony. That also means that we want to equip Catholic men and women to live

out the call to matrimony and commission. And so that’s why we continue A Word from Our Outpost, because we want you to be well equipped for this crazy topsy-turvy world that we live in. We don’t want to live as if there’s only pain and pleasure. We don’t want to live with a carrot

and a stick and that that be our existence. We want to live where there is truth worth suffering and dying for, because the truth suffered and died for us first.

Closing prayer

22:47 All right, that’s the episode. I hope it was helpful. If it was helpful, please share it. Let people know that this podcast exists. We exist also on YouTube, on Apple Podcasts, on everything, Spotify, whatever Google plays on now. But yeah, great review on that stuff too. Please pray for us as well. We’ll be praying for you in the name of the Father and of the Son

and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Glory be to the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Spirit as it was in the beginning is now and ever shall be world without end. Amen. In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. From Our Outpost to yours, thanks for listening, and a special thanks to JohnMarc Skoch for the music.

Check him out on Spotify.

Keep listening

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *