Redeeming Institutions

Redeeming institutions starts with seeing that the word does not have to be an insult. Joseph and Crystal Gruber define what an institution is, from marriage to the Eucharist to the grocery store, and how understanding them frees us to evangelize within them.

A Word from Our Outpost, a Catholic podcast: redeeming institutions

Episode 10 · 30 min · With Joseph and Crystal Gruber

Redeeming Institutions

Spotify Apple Podcasts Pocket Casts

Free · 4 minutes

Take the Our Outpost Quiz

A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.

Take the Quiz →

Key takeaways on redeeming institutions

  • Institutions incarnate ideas. An institution is a pattern of practical life and ordered relationships through which our ideals can take on flesh and endure through time.
  • Marriage is the archetype. Adam’s cry of joy in Genesis 2 is followed by a pattern all couples can enter, and the Eucharist is the institution the Church gathers around.
  • Healthy institutions remember their purpose. They know the ideal they are formed around and respect the dignity of every person in them.
  • Mind the scopos and the telos. Everything has a short-term purpose and a final end, our sanctification; we can be too nearsighted or too farsighted.
  • Evangelize within the form. A gracious, attentive way of ordering a meal can witness to Christ while honoring the situation.
  • Start at home. Revisit your own family’s habits, learn the institutions around you, pray, and love well.

“Everything exists for the salvation of souls.”

Joseph Gruber

Look at your own institutions

Talk it over as a family:

Why do we do the things we do at meals, at prayer, and at bedtime?

Where is one institution in our lives where we could love a little better?

Chapters

  • ~0:00 Are institutions boring?
  • ~2:05 Institutionalized
  • ~3:35 Redeeming the idea
  • ~4:45 What is an institution?
  • ~5:35 Marriage, the first institution
  • ~8:10 The institution of the Eucharist
  • ~9:05 Three kinds of institutions
  • ~10:20 Signs of a healthy institution
  • ~12:05 Scopos and telos
  • ~15:15 Ordering a salad with love
  • ~18:30 Fear or prudence?
  • ~20:25 Knowing the institutions we live in
  • ~25:15 What we can do

Mentioned in this episode

  • True Leadership from the Habiger Institute for Catholic Leadership at the University of St. Thomas
  • Genesis 2:23–24
  • The fifth Luminous Mystery: the Institution of the Eucharist
  • The Code of Canon Law

As an Amazon Associate, Our Outpost earns from qualifying purchases.

Full transcript

Are institutions boring?

~0:00 Are institutions boring? Joseph doesn’t think so. Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives. Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration, and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee, and by Thee be happily ended.

Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Thank you, Joseph, for posting one of our talks last week. You’re welcome. Anytime. Since I was hanging out in the ER with our daughter. It was on my way to the ER to be with you and our daughter.

So I’m glad that all worked out. Yeah. She’s back home. She is back home after five, six days in the hospital. Not a big deal. Thank you, Jesus, for hospitals and for their care. Hospitals are kind of institution. I don’t like the word institution. It makes me feel a little funny. I’m grateful for the institution of the hospital, especially the one she went to.

They were great for the most part. You seem to like talking about institutions. I do. Should we talk about that? Sure. No, I think you also have a funny feeling about institutions sometimes. I think a lot of people do. It’s one of those words that can be used more of as a pejorative than something encouraging.

I think one of the more, I was going to say pungent, but I think I mean poignant moments where I’ve heard the word institution used as a kind of epithet, as a kind of like negative thing is

Institutionalized

~2:05 in the movie Shawshank Redemption. Yes. So there’s this moment where Brooks, this old man who is essentially like the librarian of Shawshank, he gets released on parole. He finds out he’s supposed to be released on parole and he’s so distraught. He grabs Heywood and threatens to kill him so that Brooks might stay in jail in the prison and fortunately Andy Dufresne was able to walk into that situation and talk Brooks down and Heywood ends up being fine.

But Andy Dufresne is very confused by this and he talks to Red, Morgan Freeman, about it and he’s like I just don’t get what happened and Red explains Brooks was institutionalized. He grew too comfortable with the walls around him and there’s a sense of being institutionalized as being like warped by something external to myself and indifferent to me.

It seems like this negative connotation often also draws into sort of the anti-organized religion ideas. Yeah, anti-organized religion, also anti-authority. We talk about you know you can hear on the college campus people laying claim to institutionalized gender discrimination, institutionalized racism, institutionalized different kinds of phobias. The idea that somehow these negative things have wormed their way into a system or with organized religion they might say the whole system is bad.

Right? Mm-hmm. So what do we do with that? Are institutions bad? Some are.

Redeeming the idea

~3:35 But the idea of an institution is not a bad idea. In fact, it’s a necessary idea and I think it’d be good to take some time to redeem the notion of institutions for our listeners but also for them to see how understanding what an institution is can give them freedom to be more evangelical within it.

Right? I think some people see the different institutionalized patterns of their life and say you know therefore I can’t have it evangelized but to see like no if we lean into what an institution is we will be able to evangelize more fruitfully is the hope. But for that we should probably define institutions.

So there’s this really excellent book it’s called True Leadership it’s put out by the Habiger Institute. That’ll be in the show notes. It’ll be in the show notes but it’s from the University of St. Thomas, St. Paul, Minnesota and they have a couple of chapters on institutions and Crystal’s about to read the definition of an institution from the book.

What is an institution?

~4:45 So he defines institution as an institution is a form, a pattern, a nexus of practical life and ordered relationship made concrete and held together by a combination of law, system, practices, art and architecture, words, anything that comes of the stuff of the created world within which and through which our ideas, our ideals, our understanding of our world and ourselves and our hopes for eternity can be incarnated sustained grown and come to fruition through time.

It’s on page 154 just in case you want to take a look. The PDF is free online so you could just open up the PDF and scroll down to it. Anyway, yeah, so the idea that an institution is basically incarnating an idea and

Marriage, the first institution

~5:35 one of the prototypical archetypal moments where this happens is in Genesis chapter 2, right? So Adam doesn’t have a helpmate, God makes him a helpmate, he wakes up and in this moment of ecstasy he says, you know, now it lasts as his bone of my bone and flesh of my flesh and right after this explosion of joy, of love, of everything is right as it ought to be, there’s this line saying, for this reason a man shall leave his father and mother and cling to his wife and the two shall become one flesh, right?

That they enter into a common life in a way that has been established, a pattern that Adam and Eve establish is one that we all enter into and it’s this amazing moment because it’s like this moment of absolute freedom and this is what the heart longed for but what the heart longed for is a pattern that can be entered into, right?

So the sacrament of matrimony is this moment of people entering into that same pattern and saying, I want a common life with my wife, I want a common life with my husband. Which is helpful in terms of knowing that we actually are signing up for the same thing. If we have whatever we want marriage to be defined in our heads, how do I know that I have the same definition as you have unless it’s an institution that has been defined outside of you and me?

Right. And it’s not like it was imposed on us but we actually recognize that that was something that our hearts longed for. We heard what the church said marriage was and we knew each other and we’re like they’re one and the same and where we differ from the church from time to time from moment to moment is where we’re less than we ought to be.

The idea that the ideal is calling us to something higher, calling us to live out even more purely the hope that we had on our wedding day. So marriage is an example of an institution. We mentioned the church. With the church, it’s also good to know like to redeem the word institution. Every time people pray the luminous mysteries,

The institution of the Eucharist

~8:10 the fifth luminous mystery is the institution of the Eucharist, right? Like Jesus institutes the sacrament of his love, his presence that we’ll endure, right? And we enter into that institution. We participate in that institution as the Catholic church. And it’s around that, it’s around the Eucharist that the church really finds its coherence.

Which is appropriate if we’re saying an institution is an incarnation of an idea and the Eucharist is the word made flesh. Are there other kinds of institutions that we interact with on a regular basis that we want to talk some more about? Well, we want to keep these shorter, but we can talk a little bit.

Even just what are other kinds of institutions that we interact with on a regular basis? Yeah. So in the True Leadership book, which again I recommend,

Three kinds of institutions

~9:05 it talks about there being three different kinds of institutions. The first ones are that if you’re human, you’re participating in this or you ought to be, that would be the family and then the church, both of them divinely instituted. Then there are ones that are necessary for social life and public life. So the state, the economy, education and charitable work, right?

And then within those four categories, if all these particular kinds of institutions and all these other kinds of institutions that will come up. So people starting a non-profit, people starting a business, people starting a neighborhood group, all of these will start to gain a little bit of form and coherence as they work out like what is it we’re actually intending and how are we going to build it in the world.

So what does it look like? You mentioned earlier that when we have this bad taste about institutions, part of that bad taste is because we can see where we get formed by institutions, whether they’re good institutions or bad institutions, whether they’re forming us for worse or for better.

Signs of a healthy institution

~10:20 How do we know when an institution is doing its job, when it’s actually helping us for better? Yeah. I mean, there are a couple of signs, right? One, do the people participating in the institution still know what the ideal is? Like what it is that they’re formed around? Two, are they respecting the dignity of each person within that institution, right?

When an institution no longer respects the dignity of the human person, it’s fundamentally rotten, right? I think those are two of the biggest ones. I know that there are other things you can be checking as far as like major red flags. And this was the problem of Shawshank, right? The prison in the movie Shawshank Redemption is that their purpose was the rehabilitation of these convicted criminals.

But everything about that was a joke, right? When red walks into the parole board meetings, it’s always a joke. He says the same lines, they ask the same questions. There’s no real desire for change in him. And nothing about their environment is actually there to effect a change to rehabilitate. So like they’re monstrously mistreating the people and they have no idea why they’re there.

So we’ve talked a bit about the scope and the telos of institutions previously. Can we kind of talk about what those pieces and parts are now and how that influences how to… Have we talked about that on the podcast though? Just you and me? Oh yeah. Well, we’ve talked about that with other people, not just you and me.

So yeah,

Scopos and telos

~12:05 two Greek words, scopos and telos. They’re helpful for understanding a whole bunch of things. Institutions being the one that we’re talking about right now. Telos would be like the final end, like what’s it all for ultimately? And then the scopos is like, what is my like short term goal? What am I going for next few steps?

And to realize that when we’re talking about the created order, everything’s ultimate telos always, without fail, is our sanctification, our union with God. This couch exists that we might be made holy. It is a good couch insofar as it fulfills its couchiness, its scopos is allowing us to sit comfortably and we’re not actually sitting on the couch right now, we’re sitting on the floor.

So it’s a little bit funny, so it’s failing. But it also really fills out its purpose, not only through being couchy, but by making us holy, right? When we can see how its existence draws us into the divine. So when we look at an institution, we can say, you know, what is its short term purpose?

Like a supermarket is there to provide goods for people, usually for their immediate needs like food and other perishables and some non-perishable kinds of things, right? But if that was the only reason it existed, that would be woefully insufficient because it also needs to participate in its final end, which is to make us all holy.

So with the prison example, that one’s almost easy to see how with the scope being reforming ideally so that people could be reintegrated back into society, how if we’re pursuing holiness, that would easily flow into the telos, the final end of that holiness. This just occurred to me. Do you think the fact that people in general seem to not be pursuing holiness, so the telos is gone, does that make the scope less effective in some of these organizations or institutions?

Yeah, I think we can fall into two different traps. One is being too nearsighted, right? And this is what you’re talking about where people are not thinking about their final end at all and they’re only worried about what’s right in front of them. And then that world keeps constricting and their hearts keep constricting.

And then the other problem is being too farsighted and saying, you know, everything needs to be about the proclamation of the gospel explicitly right now, here and now, let’s do it. And you’re not letting people actually buy their groceries, right? There exists a ground in which we can hold these things at the same time.

We can have both. We can buy groceries and work toward the salvation of those around us. So that just made me think about a time where

Ordering a salad with love

~15:15 I was out to eat with somebody at a restaurant and the somebody that I was eating with has celiac and so needed to be very careful not to have any gluten. And the way she ordered her food evangelized me, she was so gracious with the waitress and made it a point to make eye contact and acknowledged that the waitress was there to serve us food and said something to the effect of, you know, Susie, I know you’ve got this great kitchen back there.

I have celiac. Are you familiar with that? Explained it to her and said, would you make a salad for me? And could you do this, this, and this? And she did it in this loving, gentle, beautiful way that to me was I could see the sort of the telos, the pursuit of holiness in her own heart and her desire to share it, but yet also her sort of maybe completely honoring the scope of the situation that this woman was here to serve us food.

So she was going to ask her to do that in the most beautiful way possible. And I mean, I don’t know if it evangelized the waitress, but it certainly had an impact on me because this was like eight years ago now. Do you think that that’s a decent example? Oh, yeah, I think it’s a great example.

Yeah. Living in an institution, seeing the incarnation happen. Right. I mean, we talked about last year in last week’s podcast about incarnational evangelization. What news am I incarnating right here and now? And to realize there’s a mode of expressing that news appropriate to the situation at hand. And this is why we should be not ignoring the institutions around us, but we should be really attentive to them.

We should be aware of like, what is my role in this? What are the bounds of right action? Like if your friend had gotten up and walked into the kitchen in the back and started to make herself a salad, I think we have this innate gut check like, that isn’t right. That would be her going beyond what she is capable of doing in that scenario.

So in some of our earlier podcasts, we talked a bit about how the topic at hand applied to love of God, love of neighbor, love of self. And one of the things that occurs to me as we’re talking in terms of all three of these things, as we interact with institutions, and as, at least for myself anyways, as I try to understand the telos versus the scopos and how that affects how I interact with the people around me, is oftentimes I have accused myself of not doing something or not sharing the gospel with somebody or not even just talking to somebody out of fear.

And it seems like it’s actually a decent litmus test to say,

Fear or prudence?

~18:30 am I not doing this out of fear? Or am I not doing this out of this actually isn’t appropriate right now? Not to say that the Lord isn’t going to call us to do awkward, uncomfortable things from time to time in situations where our pastor, not our pastor, one of the priests that preaches at our parish from time to time told the story about how he prayed for a man in a bathroom at an airport.

And he had a little conversation with the Lord like, Lord, I’m in the bathroom. Okay, so sometimes the Lord might call us to these awkward things. Men don’t talk in the bathroom, men don’t talk in the bathroom. And yet, and yet, and yet he was had a step out of that institutional form and prayed with that man.

But it is interesting to me to be able to take that in that prayer in the moment to say, okay, there is an institutional norm and it’s here and it may even be here for a reason. And so if I am going to step outside of it, having this moment of clarity and this moment of prayer can be helpful to either overcoming the fear or not blaming myself for saying no, actually following the institutional norm right now is appropriate.

And me having a smile on my face is actually the most evangelical positive thing that I can do for the Lord right now. And I think I would add, this is why it’s really important for us to be aware of the different institutions that we’re participating in, right, right. I didn’t realize until a couple of years ago that

Knowing the institutions we live in

~20:25 canon law for the church applied to me, you know, that there’s actually a whole legal system that I’m participating in blindly, right. I mean, less blindly now that I’ve discovered it, but still very much in the dark about like what are all of the different responsibilities and all the different pieces of the church.

And I’ll read different articles and they’ll mention, you know, this canon or that canon. I’ll be like, I didn’t know that was a rule. I didn’t know, like, I didn’t know that me as a lay person that I actually have the right. I’m not quite sure what the correct language is when we’re talking about canon law.

Somebody will probably correct me, quite likely family members. But I do have a right to approach my pastor if I find that there is something lacking in the mass. How I go about doing that, you know, obviously I need to do that with prudence and respect and all that, but that I have that right is really interesting.

And to understand, like, we live in a particular state, in a particular town, and there are laws governing this state and this town and this country, most of which I’m oblivious to. You said something interesting in what you just said is that how I go about doing that matters. But also, having an understanding of the institution itself is helpful.

It gives me freedom to act if I know, like, at the hospital, I get to call, push the call button if I want someone to bring me water. I don’t just have to be thirsty all day, I can just press the call button and somebody will bring me water. Especially when you’re in isolation and you’re not allowed to leave and get yourself water.

Right. So not understanding that that’s one of the functions of that button is horribly binding but freeing to find out what it is that I can do. Well, and with the hospital example, also understanding we have a right to deny or request particular services for our children or for ourselves if it had been us, but in this particular instance for our daughter when she was in the hospital.

And the how we do that impacts that participation and the evangelical impulse within the institution. And I think maybe to bring this back full circle to where we started that when institutions are leaving a bad taste in our mouth, sometimes there’s something fundamentally wrong with the institution, but it seems like more often than not, it’s actually that there are people within the institution that are not pursuing, they might be pursuing the right thing but not in the right way.

So we’ve talked about how institutions can leave a bad taste in our mouth, but how they actually are important because necessary we live in time, right and space. And we have to build a life in common. And that building takes on many different forms and it has to because there are many different things we need for the creation and sustaining of life.

And if we just every day had to recreate systems, we’d be wasting most of our time. I think I’ve been trying to do that for most of my motherhood recreate systems every day. Yes, it’s exhausting. Oh, we started not doing that as much and do tell you have clean laundry in your drawers.

I don’t know if you’ve noticed, but I just awkward that I didn’t notice. But when we do have these habits of life in common with others, it frees up time, it frees up head space. We don’t have to constantly be thinking, when should I be doing the dishes? How will taxes be collected?

When will streets be plowed? There are systems in place where those systems break down, we then have to turn our attention to them. Or when they’re losing sight of their whole purpose, but also how that purpose is there for our sanctification, which I mean, quite frankly, that’s what most of the systems we’re participating in these days, they’re forgetting about that, like you said.

So a lot of institutions are out of our circle of influence. So how maybe to wrap things up,

What we can do

~25:15 is there anything we can do that’s within our circle of influence to help make the institutions that we participate in better, even if it’s only a little bit better? I mean, start with our own institution, if the listeners are part of a family, which by definition, if you’re human, you participate in some sort of familial structure.

What are the institutions there? What might need to be revisited? And what might need to be, you know, take a step back, it’s like, why are we doing this? You know, why do we have this family meal? Why aren’t we eating family meals? What does family prayer time look like? Why does it look like that?

Then the things that are less in our control, but still very much in our circle of concern, I think we need to learn about them more. I think we live in a country that allows for more, not audience participation, but just like regular run of the mill people participation, you know, we can send in petitions.

We can call our senator, we can, you know, have coffee with a councilman, and we can actually talk to them and see like what is in the field of doable and what is the timetable for it? And we can just learn like, what does the school that we’re sending our kids to, what is that as an institution?

How is it falling short? How is it really doing well? And where it’s falling short, can we be part of the parent teacher organization? Or should we start our own school and just institute a different form of life, different nexus of what was the rest of the definition, rewind to the beginning and listen to the definition again?

It’s that big gray box. Right. But the nexus part. It’s like the first line. Oh, a nexus of practical life and ordered relationship. There we go. There we go. Okay. Any other things that we can do? I mean, pray. Ah, good one. And love well. I mean, I think that example of ordering food at a restaurant, just being mindful of being kind and being thoughtful.

And like you said, when you when you’ve learned about the institution, it’s easier to be thoughtful about what’s realistic to expect of the people around you, what’s realistic to ask the people around you. And to really lean into like, we participate in these institutions, both for their short term benefit to us and to those around us.

But ultimately, for the salvation of souls, like everything exists for the salvation of souls. Couches exist, floors exist, stars exist for the salvation of souls. And so to do schools and hospitals, road systems, neighborhoods, all the things, the YMCA, everything exists for the salvation of souls. And if we’re not aware of that, and aware that all of these things are tending back to the creator, and that it’s our job to keep on keeping on with that.

If we’re not aware of that, we’re just going to become more and more short sighted until we’re just living in a bubble. It’s all about me. That bubble. It’s tricky one. Any other final thoughts about institutions? Not at the moment. Yeah, it’s late. It’s been a week, hasn’t it? It has been. Shall I say?

It’s late. It’s been a week, hasn’t it? It has been. Shall I close us in prayer? Sure. In the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit, and Heavenly Father, thank you for the gift of institutions. I pray that you would open my heart, open my mind, those listening to seeing your goodness and your plan in giving us institutions.

I pray that you would help me to see you incarnated, see your will incarnated more fully everywhere I go, and help me to be more like you. We ask all these things in your holy name. Amen. Amen. Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, amen. From Our Outpost to yours, thanks for listening, and a special thanks to JohnMarc Skoch.

That’s S-K-O-C-H. For the music. Check him out on Spotify.

Keep listening

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *