In his first weeks as a FOCUS missionary at MIT, sleep-deprived and without an apartment, Joseph sat down at a dorm cookout and asked a Baptist freshman a question he never should have led with: have you ever considered becoming Catholic? The answer surprised him, and sixteen years later it still shapes how he thinks about evangelization and the work of the Holy Spirit.

Episode 278 · 21 min · With Joseph Gruber
The Best Missionary Story I’ve Got
Take the Our Outpost Quiz
A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.
Take the Quiz →Key takeaways on Catholic missionary story
- Ask open-ended questions. Borrowing from Sherry Weddell, Joseph asked two students about their faith background. It’s a question that invites a real answer and leaves room to say no politely.
- Sometimes the absurd question is the right one. FOCUS usually starts with a Bible study, then Mass, then the Church. Joseph did the exact opposite, and the student came to Mass that Sunday, joined RCIA and was confirmed at Easter.
- We have no idea what’s going on inside people. We don’t know their backstories or what the Holy Spirit is already doing. Anything is possible in a conversation.
- Pray and keep a list. Joseph prayed every day for the conversations he would have, and wrote down the name of everyone he met in the back of his prayer journal.
- It isn’t about us. One student said yes and the other turned his back. Acceptance or rejection has more to do with what’s happening inside the other person than with how charming or persuasive we are.
“All I did was show up and I made myself available to the Holy Spirit.”
Joseph Gruber
Try this this week
Before a conversation, pray:
Lord, bless this time and give me the words to say.
Then ask someone an open question about their faith background, and listen.
Chapters
- 0:00 Opening prayer and welcome
- 0:36 A story from the mission field
- 1:05 A first-year missionary at MIT
- 1:43 Homeless for two and a half weeks
- 2:44 A cookout during REX
- 4:04 What’s your faith background?
- 6:15 Have you ever considered becoming Catholic?
- 7:00 From Mass to confirmation
- 7:58 He remembered it backward
- 10:28 No idea what the Holy Spirit is doing
- 11:18 Praying and keeping a list
- 12:36 It wasn’t about me
- 14:05 The one who turned away
- 16:31 Breaking the rules
- 18:54 A front-row seat
- 20:03 Closing prayer
Mentioned in this episode
- Sherry Weddell, Forming Intentional Disciples, on open-ended questions and the thresholds of conversion
- FOCUS, the Fellowship of Catholic University Students
As an Amazon Associate, Our Outpost earns from qualifying purchases.
Full transcript
Opening prayer and welcome
0:00 Joseph: I’d love to share with you one of the most amazing encounters I ever had as a Catholic missionary. Listen in to find out more. Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives.
In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration, and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee, and by Thee be happily ended. Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.
Amen. Hello, and welcome to A Word from Our Outpost. I am Joseph Gruber, host of this podcast, founder of Our Outpost Marriage Ministry.
A story from the mission field
0:36 I wanted to share with you a story. I don’t do this very often on this podcast. I don’t do this often just generally. I don’t know why, but I don’t share very many stories from the 13-plus years I spent as a Catholic missionary. And I don’t have a good reason why I wouldn’t.
So I wanted to share one of the very first stories that I ever experienced as a FOCUS missionary, as a missionary with the Fellowship of Catholic University Students.
A first-year missionary at MIT
1:05 So I was a first year missionary in the fall of 2009. And myself and my teammates were sent to MIT, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology over in Cambridge, Massachusetts, right across the Harvard Bridge from the back bay of Boston. And I didn’t know very much of what I was doing. I had gone to training.
I had known FOCUS missionaries on the college campus when I was a student, but to actually be a missionary, I didn’t really understand. In one of the very first days that I was on campus, I didn’t have anywhere else to go.
Homeless for two and a half weeks
1:43 I was literally homeless for about two and a half weeks when we first arrived to campus. We were going to get an apartment right next to the girls’ apartment, but it wasn’t available until two and a half weeks after our report to campus date. And so myself and the other male teammate, we spent one night sleeping on the floor at a fraternity.
We spent a night or two at this kindly Hispanic ladies spare bedroom in, I think it was in Brookline, Massachusetts. And then we spent a week and a half or two weeks on a couch and an inflatable mattress at a teaching instructor’s place, who was teaching at MIT at the time. And he lived a ways away from campus.
So I came in the morning and then I was just on campus all day, every day with no clear idea of what I ought to have been doing.
A cookout during REX
2:44 And in these early days, the freshmen had just moved in, but they didn’t really move in. They were going through something called residence exploration. So REX, as they called it, because every dorm had its own culture and you wanted to find the one that was your cultural fit. Like if you enjoyed puzzles,
you probably wanted to be in Simmons. If you didn’t like other people, I think you were in MacGregor. If you were a little bit weird, you went to Random, places like that. And so they had like a week or so of exploring the different cultures of each dorm. And then they could put in to be removed
if they wanted to be. And so they would have these different events and there was a cookout going out, going on at Next House. And I was walking by and smelled the food and I decided to stop by and see if I knew anyone, which odds were good, I didn’t know anyone because I knew almost no one on campus.
I had met maybe like three students up to that point, but they had free food. I was like, I don’t see any sign saying that I can’t have food. So I think I grabbed like a hot dog and a bag of chips. And I sat down on a picnic table at a picnic table
across from these two young men. And I introduced myself and one of the fellows was named Jonté. And the other guy will call him Sean. And
What’s your faith background?
4:04 I asked them what they were studying and they told me a number each, because at MIT, they communicate their courses, their field of study by number, which is a fun little quirk for MIT. And they asked me what I was doing. I said, well, so I’m actually a Catholic missionary, not really sure what I’m supposed to be doing,
but just wondering like, what kind of a faith background do you have? And I got that question from Sherry Weddell’s Forming Intentional Disciples. She talked a lot about asking open-ended questions. And I thought, oh, this is a great question. This is a great question to ask anyone, what’s your faith background? Because then people can say, oh, I was raised this
and I believe this now, or this is what I do, or this is what my family does. And it shows like a life in progress, a life, it also gives ample opportunity to say, I have no interest in faith or I am disinterested in this topic in a like not so mean sort of way.
So I was very proud of myself for that question. What’s your faith background? And so the one guy, we’ll call him Sean, he said Baptist and Jonté. He said, I’m also Baptist. And I didn’t know very much about Baptists. I hadn’t met very many Baptists up to that point, not in high school or in college.
I went to a Catholic K through eight. So I didn’t meet any Baptists there. I didn’t know very many Baptists. So I was really interested. But when I had said that I was a Catholic missionary, Sean had started to turn his body away from me. And at a certain point, he was just,
literally just had his back and his shoulder to me. And so it was just me and Jonté. So I said, well, Jonté, and I don’t know why I said this question. I don’t know at all. It was almost as if I wasn’t totally in control of my mouth. The words just fell out of my mouth.
And I said, Jonté,
Have you ever considered becoming Catholic?
6:15 have you ever considered becoming Catholic? And Jonté said, well, actually, yes, I have. I was astounded. I was like, this what? A Baptist who wants to become Catholic? I was like, well, do you know that there’s gonna be mass on campus? He’s like, oh, I was gonna be looking into that. I said, well, yeah,
here are the times 930, 11 and five, I think were the times, something like that, over at the MIT chapel on Sunday. Can I get your phone number? I’ll be at all the masses. I can tell you what’s going on if you like. And he’s like, okay, yeah, I’ll see you on Sunday.
And that was the end of the conversation. Ladies and gentlemen,
From Mass to confirmation
7:00 he came on Sunday to mass. And I offered to explain things ahead of time. He’s like, no, that’s fine. I’ll just come. And he sat through mass and he came to the whole of mass. And afterward, I was like, oh, how was it? He’s like, that was fine. That was good. And then we talked more.
And eventually in the days to come, I invited him to study the Bible with me and a group of freshmen that I had met in the first few weeks. And he came and he started studying the Bible with me. And he started attending RCIA. And then he asked me to be his sponsor.
And then, you know, Lent rolled around and Easter came about and I ended up being his confirmation sponsor. And he is still to this day, a practicing Catholic. And I know that he’s still a practicing Catholic because I’ve been in touch with him lo these 16 plus years. And because I just talked with him the other day.
And the amazing thing is I asked him,
He remembered it backward
7:58 do you remember when we first met? He’s like, yes, yes, I do. I tell people about it as part of my witness story. Like, wow, I had no idea. One, that that conversation was meaningful to him. And two, that he gets asked to share his witness story. And I asked him what he remembered about it.
And ladies and gentlemen, this is the fascinating thing. This is the wild thing. His recollection was that I must have asked him because he wasn’t quite sure what I asked him. He knew that I had asked him something. He’s like, I’m pretty sure you asked me to come join your Bible study. And then at the Bible study,
you must have asked me to go to Mass. And then I made a decision to become Catholic. And I was like, Jonté. So this is the conversation I had just the other day. Jonté, that’s not what happened. It’s the exact opposite. I asked if you wanted to become Catholic. Then I asked if you wanted to come to Mass.
Then I asked you to join a Bible study. I did the exact opposite of what everybody in FOCUS does. everybody in FOCUS, the idea is, you know, you meet people, you ask them, do you wanna study the Bible with me and some people? Like, the Bible’s a really interesting thing. You’re a really interesting person.
Combine the two, we’re gonna have a really great afternoon or evening or morning or whenever it’s happening. And then the relationship builds from there. You can invite them to Mass. You can invite them to check out the Catholic faith. I was like, Jonté, I didn’t do that. I did the exact opposite.
I asked you if you wanted to become Catholic. That was like the very first thing I asked you. It’s like, oh, that makes a lot more sense of why I don’t remember a Bible study between that. And my first Mass. It’s like, yeah, because there wasn’t one. Because I did things absurdly. That is not how anybody recommends to proceed.
And he said, I’m really grateful that’s how it went down. I’m really grateful that that is the way that it happened. And I was like, I am also really grateful because that moment when I asked the absurd question to the Baptist, if he would consider becoming Catholic, and he said, yes, that moment
No idea what the Holy Spirit is doing
10:28 provoked such wonder in me of the fact that I have no idea. I have no idea what is going on interiorly with people. I have no idea what their backstories are. I have no idea what the Holy Spirit is doing. I have no idea of any of these things. So anything is possible in a conversation.
Anything might happen. Anyone at any point might experience a call to conversion or a call to repentance or a call to deeper faith. And we just don’t know. And we have no idea what they’re ready for. And we have no idea what all is reasonable. But one thing that I do know is that
when I was walking campus for those weeks and I was literally homeless, a homeless man wandering the highways and byways of MIT,
Praying and keeping a list
11:18 I was praying to the Holy Spirit every day that he would bless the conversations I was going to have, that he would be with the people that I would be talking to, that he would be with me, that he would give me the words to say. I was praying for those interactions. And then I was keeping a list of everyone that I met.
I had a little prayer journal in my back pocket. And in the front half is where I was journaling every day. And in the back page, pages it ended up being, was the name of everyone that I met. And so very near the tippity top of that list of people that I met,
Jonté and that other guy named Sean. That wasn’t his name. I’m not going to say his name. It was not Sean though, but Jonté and the other guy. So the guy who said, yes, I want to be Catholic. And the other guy who literally turned his back to me when he discovered that I was a Catholic missionary,
offering the Catholic faith, literally turned his back to me. And I held onto that because I was like, all I did was show up and I made myself available to the Holy Spirit. And that was enough for one person to make a decision that has changed his life. And another person to totally turn his back to me.
It wasn’t about me
12:36 And I realized like it wasn’t about me in either of those instances. It wasn’t like I had a compelling argument. It wasn’t that I was particularly charming. As I recall, I was a little sleep deprived. Sleeping on a couch will do that to you. As I recall, I was not the most engaging
or handsome or compelling character. I’m not a charismatic fellow. I’m not the one that people usually turn to for being persuasive. It wasn’t any of that. It was the Holy Spirit moving and me allowing him to, surrendering to him and not getting in his way for that moment. And who knows what can happen
when we allow the Holy Spirit to work? Who knows what can happen in our lives and in the lives of those around us? It also affirmed to me whether people accept me or reject me, it has so much more to do with what’s going on inside of them than it has to do with me.
That the other guy who was rejecting us has nothing to do with what I was offering and had everything to do with his disposition. I mean, it might have had a little bit to do with what I was offering and how I was offering it. Maybe I wasn’t the most attractive figure, right?
And that had some impact on him, who knows? But to know like, no, the Holy Spirit continues to work.
The one who turned away
14:05 As long as this fellow who we will continue to call Sean lives, I continue to pray for him. He is one of the people I continue to pray for. In no small part because a year later, he met my new male teammate and they got into discussions, multiple discussions over multiple weeks about Catholic versus Protestant and Baptist,
particularly teaching. And this fellow eventually sent in a petition to the Umbrella Christian Organization at MIT, asking for them to remove the Catholics from their umbrella organization. So you had like the Methodists and the Lutherans and the Episcopalians and the Catholics, all under this umbrella organization for the Christians. And he sent in a petition specifically
for the Catholics to be excluded because he so much did not want what the Catholic Church was offering. And he was offended that the Catholic Church said that she teaches the whole of the truth. So not only was he turning his back to me that August day in 2009, in 2011, he was petitioning for Catholics to be kicked out
of everything that’s called Christian on that campus. I’m like, and the other guy who was next to him was a faithful practicing Catholic at that point. These are two very different paths that they went down and it had so little to do with me. I consider myself blessed to have been there in that moment
looking back on it, even the day of I was like, am I allowed to even be in this space? Cause I’m fairly certain it’s for freshmen, but I’m under the impression that other people are wandering around as well and trying to get a sense of the flavor of these different dorms. And that was one of the things I was trying
to get a handle on because if each dorm was a different culture and it was my job to be a missionary, then I needed to understand the different cultures that were present. Anyway, whether or not I should have been there in a technical sense, I cannot say for sure, but both Jonté and I are very glad
that I was there for that moment.
Breaking the rules
16:31 Yeah, so again, I did the thing you shouldn’t do. I did the thing that doesn’t make sense. The thing that probably breaks the rules, breaks the proper ordering of things. And it’s not like I do this often. It’s not like it’s my go-to thing to say to a random non-Catholic Christian, hey, do you wanna just become Catholic?
It’s not a thing that I usually do to the atheists to say, hey, do you wanna just abandon atheism and adopt theism? Do you wanna just, I don’t usually lead with that. In fact, that may be the only time that I really led with that. And it was the time that really mattered
and it was a time that it was really efficacious. And it was a time that both Jonté and I are grateful for. Do I have other stories of missionary moments? Sure. Is this the one that tops them all? I think so. I think it does. Which is such a strange thing that one of the very first interactions I had
as a Catholic missionary on the campus I was called to serve was probably the most amazing of conversations that left me dumbfounded, flat-footed, amazed, that that was the first one. I was like, oh, it’s all downhill from here. I’m like, there’s no topping that. And in a certain sense, that’s not the point.
The point is to receive the moments of grace as they come and to be receptive to what the Holy Spirit is doing now and to live from the fact that the Holy Spirit can do strange and new things. And he doesn’t always obey what we expect. In fact, he’s going to surprise us.
I was surprised when I asked that question. I think he took it in stride, which he reflected back on that. It was a kind of funny thing that he just took that in stride. So funny it was that, again, he remembered the order of operations to become more sensical, like he edited his memory to make it more sensical.
And I don’t fault him for that because it was an absurd thing, but it was what happened. Because when I went through and I said, I think this is the actual order of operations, he’s like, you’re right, that is what happened. And to know like,
A front-row seat
18:54 who knows what might happen today by the power of the Holy Spirit? Who knows what will happen tomorrow? Who knows what is going to happen? When we just say like, Lord, bless my time here, bless my relationships here, bless these meetings, bless these encounters, give me words to say, may I not get in your way?
Make use of me. I actually want to be in the front row watching you work. And the best way to be in the front row watching you work is by allowing you to make use of me. And I am your servant. I am a son of the Father who is here to do the will of the Father.
So that’s probably the coolest story. And maybe that’s one of the reasons why I don’t share that many stories from my missionary days is because that is the coolest story. There is no topping it, but maybe someday I’ll share some of the other stories because there have been some cool ones, not as cool, but some cool ones as well.
So that’s the episode.
Closing prayer
20:03 Do me a favor. If you liked it, please share it, but also rate it and review it. The other thing to do, pray for Jonté. Pray for a deepening of his faith. Pray for him in his preparation for his upcoming marriage, which is great. He came to my marriage lo these 13 years ago
and I got a save-the-date recently for his upcoming nuptials. So pray for him. Pray for the other fellow, the one that I did not name but called Sean. That is not his name, but pray for the other fellow who is beside Jonté that fateful day in August of 2009. And please pray for us.
We’ll be praying for you. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit, amen. Glory be to the Father, and to the Son, and to the Holy Spirit. As it was in the beginning, is now and ever shall be world without end, amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son,
and of the Holy Spirit, amen. From our outpost to yours, thanks for listening, and a special thanks to JohnMarc Skoch. That’s S-K-O-C-H. For the music. Check him out on Spotify.
Keep listening
Share this episode
Listen with a friend, then ask each other: who might be waiting for us to ask a bold question?
