Things to Know When Seeking Spiritual Direction

What do people most need to hear when they finally sit down with a spiritual director? Joseph talks with his brother, Fr. Peter Gruber, about the foundational truths he finds himself sharing again and again: why poverty is the starting point, how fear and pride warp our image of God, and why meekness makes real forgiveness possible.

A Word from Our Outpost, a Catholic podcast: spiritual direction

Episode 260 · 86 min · With Joseph Gruber and Fr. Peter Gruber

Things to Know When Seeking Spiritual Direction

Watch on YouTube Spotify Apple Podcasts Pocket Casts

Free · 4 minutes

Take the Our Outpost Quiz

A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.

Take the Quiz →

Key takeaways on spiritual direction

  • Poverty is an opening. Feeling like you lack something is not a reason for shame. It is the space where God can give, and true gospel poverty means receiving freely and giving freely.
  • Gratitude answers excess. Every “one more video” is a small ingratitude. Concrete, specific thanks, even in suffering, reshapes how we see our lives.
  • Fear is the beginning of trust. Pride is often born of fear. From the depths of our fears we can call out to God, who is not out to get us.
  • Righteous anger is about action. Emotions are not good or bad in themselves. What matters is what we do, and meekness is the habit of acting well when anger rises.
  • Anger is the beginning of forgiveness. You can forgive from the depths of your anger. Forgiveness makes a gift of what was taken; it does not require forgetting, and it is not the same as reconciliation.

“We do not love in spite of our wounds. We love through our wounds.”

Fr. Peter Gruber

Try this this week

Before bed, name one thing and offer one thing:

One specific gift from today you are thankful for, even a small one.

One hurt you are still angry about, offered to God for the person who caused it.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Intro
  • 0:52 Opening prayer
  • 2:40 Meet Fr. Peter
  • 6:29 Poverty: where we all come in
  • 8:17 Poverty is about receiving and giving
  • 12:22 Gratitude and our tendency to excess
  • 17:08 Thanksgiving offerings and the Eucharist
  • 19:05 Thankful in the midst of suffering
  • 21:57 A team gratitude text thread
  • 25:48 Pride, the great enemy
  • 28:58 Pride is born of fear
  • 35:15 Fear is the beginning of trust
  • 41:08 Loved more than healed
  • 45:40 Meekness, a misunderstood virtue
  • 49:12 Moses, the meekest man
  • 54:43 What righteous anger really is
  • 59:14 Doing the good and delighting in it
  • 1:01:19 Anger is the beginning of forgiveness
  • 1:08:57 Forgive and forget?
  • 1:14:49 We love through our wounds
  • 1:15:56 Worry and grasping
  • 1:19:46 Forgiveness is not reconciliation
  • 1:21:38 Christ has felt it all with us
  • 1:24:11 Come to me, and closing prayer

Mentioned in this episode

As an Amazon Associate, Our Outpost earns from qualifying purchases.

Full transcript

Intro

0:00 Hey Father Peter. Hey Joseph in your experience as a priest What’s some territory you often have to cover with the common lay person? Well, let’s find out Listening to find out more real quick before we get into this episode I wanted to invite you to learn more about Our Outpost Marriage Ministry something that my wife and I do to equip

Catholic couples to live out the sacrament of matrimony. We do some things to help prepare Catholic singles to date Well and to marry better. We do some things for Organizational health of a family we do things for greater spiritual depth in the family we do things for basic human formation in the family and

We are we’re working on a project to really target newlyweds up to five years married So if you know any of those people that look out for things that are coming Now on with the show

Opening prayer

0:52 Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration,

and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee, and by Thee be happily ended. Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. which is I think the first time he’s ever told me that but he tells me it might be the second

It might be I look up to Joseph as an older brother So it’s very hard for me to bring up something like a prayer that comes from the liturgy You should have something of that character, but I’ve taken it out of the liturgy and put it in a podcast Yes, it should still have a liturgical character.

Everything we do is through Christ our Lord. It’s true It’s implicit all of my email signatures are in Christ Which is and we are way off target ladies and gentlemen. I want to get back onto target This is going to be a targeted episode Filled with all sorts of great nuggets of wisdom.

This is going to be the kind of episode you’ll want to share This is the kind of episode that Father Peter will want to share because it’s going to be including his wisdom and with that Father Peter

Meet Fr. Peter

2:40 you’ve been a priest now for over eight years. That’s right, which is a little mind-bending to me wild and In that time you have been a priest at the Oratory of St. Philip Neri in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania You’ve been doing campus ministry. You’ve been doing retreats. You’ve done spiritual direction. You do all sorts of things

For the the good of your community and the good of the the students there and for this episode I wanted to focus a lot more on your experience as a spiritual director as someone who has been Shepherd of souls and really trying to find out. What are the things that maybe are truly basic foundational concepts that you

Often find yourself sharing with people because they’re there these gaps in our formation and our understanding of the spiritual life our understanding of God of ourselves So that’s my my intro to you because that’s what you said you wanted to talk about Essentially, right? I think something I can share with people and I want to maybe preface this by it’s not really it’s wisdom

I’ve gathered but it’s not a complete wisdom. It’s from a very limited slice of priestly ministry It deals with areas of the internal forum that are accumulated over the years But also it’s my own experience things that I wish I would have known and things that I some of which I only really found

Out or internalized deep into my my short priesthood so far So it’s uh, I’m a very I’m always very anxious to share these things with people Especially when it comes up and I thought it’d be really cool to have this in a podcast format So I could easily say to someone hey check out this podcast

These are probably some of the things we’ll talk about and if you have any questions I would love to talk about that with you more. Yeah, I think I think that’s a great idea I think that’s why I pressed record. So let’s dive in What do you think? Asking like what’s the most foundational thing that people misunderstand maybe there are a bunch of them

Uh, but where where do you find a good place to start with people tends to be? Well, I think just where they’re at People’s common experience when they reach out to a priest is they feel like something’s lacking They’re missing something They they don’t yet have what it takes. What do they need?

Are they there’s something they’re supposed to discern and figure out a lot of times I’m dealing with college students and they’re in this cusp Of a major decision about their lives Or it might be that they just feel like they’re missing out even us cradle Catholics We get the feeling like I don’t

I don’t have no experience with this. I remember in college people talked about Liturgy of the Hours That was such a confusing concept to me Like what is that and I feel like am I less of a Catholic because I don’t even know what that is Or uh, like oh, you don’t know the the the Salve Regina chant

Like or the Memorare sure. I remember that was a big one in college Everyone seemed to know the Memorare in the Catholic community So yeah, and there’s all these feelings of lack as a result I’m missing something And I I hear of my friends They they’ve gone to spiritual direction and I haven’t done that and I probably should you know

I probably should just go to spiritual direction because I’m probably missing out on something the fear of missing out is a big one for myself especially And so they they go to a spiritual director and they they go and they lay bare their hearts And and they think they’re not enough And that experience of not being enough.

I think we could describe under the uh, what we call poverty So not not being enough not having it what it takes not knowing enough about the faith not knowing how to pray Not having the experience that others have had. I haven’t heard the voice of God. Am I doing something wrong?

Poverty: where we all come in

6:29 Poverty, I think is the the fundamental disposition of our own hearts, especially since the fall It’s also one of the basic prerequisites for the spiritual life Yeah, so the the the Beatitudes begin with poverty. So like that’s the beginning of Christ teachings to the masses like there there is there is something in that poverty

That is a blessing Which is a mind bendy sort of place to start But it also makes sense, right? Like if somebody’s coming to spiritual direction, they’re not coming because they have everything Right, like those are the people who are not showing up at spiritual direction Yeah, if you are self-sufficient, you have no need of help.

Yeah so So it makes sense that would be like the foundational concept Uh, there there’s a lot of shame involved with experiencing poverty Right, like we don’t see that as a blessed thing We see that as a place of weakness It’s a vulnerable place, right? Like So there are those elements going on

So are there things that you particularly are able to articulate about poverty to? To the human heart Well, one thing is that is the positive Explication of what poverty actually is We think of poverty as a a lack not having something we might even think of evangelical poverty when you have a Religious brother or sister that have vowed poverty.

They don’t possess anything So poverty is not having and okay. Well, that’s the that’s the Christian sense of it, but that’s only one side of it That’s the negative side of things poverty Positively understood is not about not having

Poverty is about receiving and giving

8:17 Poverty is about receiving and giving So Uh, and instead of seeing here is a lack that I should be ashamed of To see this is a space in which I can receive Is that Fair to say absolutely Um that the very place where you don’t have enough Is where God is acting That’s where you end and God begins the fundamental disposition of poverty is having that emptiness.

That is a readiness to receive And having received much We give much we don’t hold on to anything True gospel poverty is not about uh, not having it’s about receiving freely and giving freely Jesus says when he sends out the apostles and the gospel of Matthew Free gifts you have received free gifts.

You are to give you go out then as on mission with no extra tunic no money bag, um Um a walking stick But no extra sandals, you know, yeah You you go out poor. Oh, you have to have sandals because you have to shake dust from them. That’s right Right. No, no, no, no extra sandals with my bible’s over there.

We can get it if now we don’t we don’t need it That’s what I’m saying. That’s not what you’re saying But the idea is that you go out and because God works through you in your poverty And a lot of times people don’t recognize that and maybe they’re afraid they’re not doing something.

They’re not doing something right But to understand you’re actually right where God wants you because you need you you need him You’re utterly dependent You’re like a child you’re like an infant and think of your your son Felix You know, he just he’s so he just puts his hands up anytime he wants to go up.

He has no height He’s a very short little toddler. He’s his locomotion is incomplete In fact, he’s even hard to understand the poor kid years later Felix You’ll hear this podcast and you’ll be amazingly articulate because you’re a very intelligent little kid But right now you it’s hard to understand you there’s a poverty there and that’s our experience going before God

well, and that’s the interesting thing because his poverty does not incite Wrath on my part. It doesn’t incite Uh any amount of frustration because it’s the poverty appropriate to him as he is It it it actually inspires my fatherly heart to pick him up to hold him Right like this morning he got up early and it was a morning that I hoped to sleep in

But that meant that I got to hold him And and just hold him for a long stretch of time and that’s what he needed he needed to be held that was it and uh, I I think When it comes to the spiritual life Uh, sometimes we’re afraid to admit that we need to admit that we’re incomplete

Uh, so but but this is this is the the wondrous thing that you find then with spiritual direction is people are coming So it’s already a revelation of poverty. So it’s something you can affirm and contextualize Because we have a context of this is the negative thing but it’s actually something to uh

To learn how to foster a proper sense of poverty like the Christian life Should never be without a certain kind of poverty And that’s right And you can see see that um True poverty is living in the gift You know to go to the end of Saint Thérèse’s life You look at what she said and one of her last things that she uh, she said that was written down

Everything is grace All is gift We’re living in God’s gifts. We don’t deserve anything. We don’t even deserve our own existence God holds us in being he redeems us He pours his grace upon us Everything we encounter even the things that are rife with suffering God is acting and he’s loving there Everything is gift

Gratitude and our tendency to excess

12:22 And what is our response to gift living in this kind of gospel poverty? gratitude most people we we all suffer from lack of gratitude lack of of thankfulness And why I mean I I think of your previous podcast about streaming How common is for people myself included to give into the excess? one more video

Just one just a little bit longer swiping on my on my screen scrolling Uh getting to the end finding the bottom of YouTube There is a bottom. Is there a bottom up to YouTube? I’ve been there. Yeah And I have to report And every time It’s a lack of gratitude because every time I say one more video I’m saying what I the video I just watched

Was on enough I need more Well, and that’s you know referencing the podcast earlier that that’s how they’re designed the the YouTube algorithm actually advocates for It pushes the videos that make you feel like that wasn’t quite enough. It was enough to keep watching And to elicit a kind of hunger that will never be satisfied by that which you feed upon

uh, so that Yeah, um, it is It is the ideal way to keep distracting ourselves from our poverty that we have we have technologized a distraction so powerful that uh We may never feel poor again Yeah, it is a our self-mastery over the world around us It is the technological progress of man that we can just entertain ourselves into oblivion

It is the technological against the mysterious to use Gabriel Marcel’s words He talked about how there’s the technological end. There’s the mystery mystery approaches things Something to be participated in something to enter into it involves us. We are implicated in it Technological, uh, we we put out a distance We make separate from ourselves we get analyzed and other other things

But we end up being ruled by it rather than entering into this greater thing greater than ourselves gift and mystery go together And there’s an insight there about the our tendency towards excess Every time there is excess there is ingratitude And this is the case with our uh, be on social media This is the case with food gluttony is in gratitude

But the proper response how we show gratitude is through sacrifice restraint holding back Think of Chesterton’s quote. We should thank God for beer and burgundy by not drinking too much of it To say that was a great that was a great bourbon. I just had Thank you God for that. I do not need more.

I can be thankful for this gift acknowledge it give thanks Going back to your son Felix, of course named after Saint Felix of Cantalice. Of course as uh, a Capuchin brother He was called Brother Deo Gratias because he would always be saying thanks be to God Yeah And that is the I think the fundamental Christian attitude is that of thanksgiving?

Well We happen to be recording this on the feast of Saint Nicholas But this point will it’s in the Advent season when this will be released Uh, the other Chesterton kind of line so feast of Saint Nicholas We put candy in the shoes and then on christmas we put candy in stockings and

Chesterton has this line about how you know We put these things in our stockings one day of the year so that every other day of the year We might remember how wondrous The fact that we get to put our feet in them that we put our legs in them To be grateful for that gift for that gift 364 days of the year

By one day of the year putting something else in it That is sweet and reminds us of He’s much more Chesterton is more pithy than that. He’s he captures it much better than that But that’s the the essence of it. It’s the one that’s first time I’m hearing that That explanation. Oh, isn’t it delightful?

I don’t think so very much. Oh, thank you Yeah Oh, so you can see in the attitudes of within living in poverty living in gift It is to be fundamentally Eucharistic where to be configured to the mystery that we receive the Eucharist Eucharistia Is thanksgiving There’s a thanksgiving of Christ to the Father

He who was in the form of God in every regard equality with God something to be grasped rather He emptied himself becoming obedient even the point of death death on a cross This is how Christ did it was the kenotic love the self emptying love he became poor Yeah, and the

Thanksgiving offerings and the Eucharist

17:08 the fascinating thing about thanksgiving offerings in the old law Right you you had certain offerings that were burnt offerings. They were they were wholly consumed by fire There were certain offerings that were offered to God, but also went to the priests to the Levites And then there were certain offerings That you offered

That went to God and to the priests and the Levites and to everybody else And those were the thanksgiving offerings Right like 120 loaves of bread offered as a thanksgiving offering that you were supposed to consume by the end of the day Which you couldn’t so you had to share And so like this this idea of thanksgiving is that it wells up as a sacrifice to God that also in in the very self-same

Sacrifice becomes a gift to everyone else as well it’s an amazing piece of uh, the old law that we don’t have access to that right like there was a span of time when Christians and the old temple ways were were doubled over that they they Shared time, but when that temple was destroyed

We lost a sense of those sacrificial systems And it’s good to be reminded every once in a while right like thanksgiving offerings Had had were multi-directional And and that’s how the the Eucharist is designed as well that Jesus is offering to the Father is also an offering to the world Anyway, so other things that’s I don’t I don’t know.

We haven’t exhausted poverty I think there’s a little bit more to say on that that like I said, we haven’t exhausted it. That’s okay Considering when people come to spiritual direction, it’s often because there’s something wrong something’s amiss Maybe they’ve been hurt by someone. Maybe there is there’s a lack that there is a fundamental injustice about

And one of the things that I never want to be divisive or to to separate people and like pile on against someone else You want to hear someone out? But to help them

Thankful in the midst of suffering

19:05 to be thankful in the midst of suffering This is one of the greatest marks of holiness is to be thankful in the midst of suffering there was um, I was reading Erik Varden’s book The Shattering of Loneliness: On Christian Remembrance And he was talking about this woman whose life was a completely utter

Complete tragedy. She said I had to mainly I’m not going to make it a tragedy but he’s he noted in her that She She made a gift of what was taken from her So even if that lack Is completely unjust To give a gift of what has been taken We have that choice.

We don’t always have a choice about things being taken Whether it’s like childhood innocence whether it’s uh Some great injustice. Um, someone has defrauded you we don’t always have that choice But we do have a choice to make a gift To have the attitude of of Job the Lord gives the Lord takes away

Blessed be the Lord But to even complete that in the deprivation We offer ourselves and thanksgiving and of course, where do we see that? perfectly lived out You’re gesturing to the crucifix behind us if you’re watching on YouTube, you would know that if you’re listening There’s a crucifix behind us Figured very centrally.

Yes Well, and that’s and that’s the perfection of thanksgiving It’s even in the midst of terrible felt abandonment. My God, my God. Why have you abandoned me? That Christ says father into your hands. I commend my spirit And with that I think even just looking at I use kind of poverty as the overarching theme about these particular things and

They’d always come up first within spiritual direction But one of the big things I will try to press whether it’s and the confessional or or what’s meeting with people is actually Give thanks And let your things be concrete. Let it be particular Let it get down into I am thankful for this particular thing for this thing that was said to me that affirmed me

On a deep level I’m thankful for the fact. I didn’t crash my car Uh in driving here today. Let the gratitude be real. It doesn’t have to be felt In fact, sometimes it is the opposite of feeling grateful But gratitude is to make a gift of ourselves It is to reciprocate because we’ve been given much

And even when there’s been when we much has been taken away to make that gift of ourselves Um, and so do that and go through your life Look at your day look at the people that God is giving you look at the circumstances even blessed with even in the midst of terrible anxieties

Give thanks St. Paul says all circumstances Give thanks I know

A team gratitude text thread

21:57 One of the years that I was an on-campus missionary with FOCUS Things seem to be really rough on that campus. We weren’t making much headway. The students didn’t seem to be responding Uh, we as a team were becoming a little despondent And and one of my teammates said, you know, I think we need to practice gratitude

and I was like, yes That feel that that sounds correct. It doesn’t feel right because I don’t feel grateful, but yes, let’s do that And we started, uh a little text line as a team And I said I want you to text All of us as often as you can everything that you’re grateful for especially about this campus

So if somebody showed up to study the bible with you, I want to see a text that somebody showed up Don’t tell me about the people who didn’t show up Be grateful for the one who did if you had a conversation with someone and it didn’t seem to go well You can be thankful that they exist you like however, you need to say it find the thing to be grateful for

and within a matter of of weeks the whole Spirit of the team shifted And and we were excited about our work and we were excited about Reaching out and we started to see the the good even in things that the maybe Maybe it was a little bit more difficult until we had been practicing gratitude

Our other otherwise our tendencies to turn inwards is to give into the resentment and to to leech that out in our Conversations with others we become the the company of scorners and the first Psalm Yeah, not good company to keep right and this is something as a parent to to teach my children not to to be grumbly

uh One of my sons recently told us that he decided instead of getting grumpy about his schoolwork He’s just going to set a timer and do it And when the timer goes off, he’ll be take a break and then he’ll come back and he’ll do it again And he just won’t think about how much he doesn’t like it.

I’m like, yes, that is that is a great next step And your son’s not even in college yet. No, he’s not even in college yet But he’s showing such maturity Anyway, there’s a lot to be grateful for there. Yes so much to be grateful for All right, so poverty and and and the intersection of gift

Which these are not two thoughts that are immediately coming to mind when you mention one or the other but I think when we see that poverty is the exposure of space In which we might receive Then it becomes a lot more plain like that. This is like the the both natural and supernatural

Corollary to receiving a gift there had to be space for the gift to be received. That’s exactly right. There’s an openness there’s a stretching that And that emptiness right now we’re recording this in the season of Advent Advent is about that that openness That is for receiving the gift Which can be a difficult thing, right?

Like the whole of the Old Testament from like page three on Is this waiting and stretching and waiting and there’s a lot of suffering that happens in that process But it’s also, you know page after page of God working in the world things to be thankful for things to praise God for So, okay poverty that feels like a pretty big thing

Poverty is a big thing and I and we can talk about under the aspect of poverty, which we did for the purposes here But I think it’s actually helpful too because

Pride, the great enemy

25:48 what is the greatest enemy of the spiritual life? What would you say? What’s the what’s the worst vice? I think the Dietrich von Hildebrand answer would be pride and concupiscence. Yeah, there you go And explain that a little bit because I don’t think our our listeners quite know what you mean by that

I think most of our listeners know no Dietrich von Hildebrand. He was a phenomenal phenomenologist of the 20th century one of the great Catholic minds a philosopher and uh, he Basically said like where where do we go wrong? It’s either in pride right like having an inflated view of ourselves a wrong view of ourselves

uh, or uh being preoccupied with our passions with our base desires and ignoring the the The the glory the weight The the good around us that we ought to be responding to So either having this idea of ourselves that is not accurate And and pride can go two ways pride can having it there.

There’s a kind of pride That is uh, uh an inflated view of oneself But also under the aspect of pride is a kind of false humility of having a deflated view of oneself Uh, so that both of those and then uh with concupiscence Is just this preoccupation with these desires in and of themselves.

They are good, right? It’s good to have desires It’s good to have passions God gave them to us for a reason, but when we are ruled by our passions and not uh tempered then Uh, we’re not actually capable of responding to the other we’re not capable of responding to the good of the person before us

The good of the situation that is requiring something of us the good of God who is asking for our attention and our Love because he has given us everything uh, so I would say those two things that that’s how I would approach it. That’s that’s exactly right now Yes, I would just hone in on pride especially because yeah, what my problem is pride.

I’m just so prideful Well, what is pride? It is turning inwards on oneself Yeah, the curve Curvatus est or something like that the the Augustinian idea of curving inward. That’s yeah, that’s right And um, you do that with uh, you add that to um, some desire you do that with uh hunger And in the the joy of eating we have gluttony

You add, uh pride the turning in on oneself to sexual desire we get the sin of lust And that’s why pride is the mother of the other seven capital vices So pride is the great enemy and what? opposes pride humility And so you already mentioned that false humility that that uh, we might just think ourselves as worse kind of the self accusation

A lot of that is based on fear And you might even say like there’s um, uh, I remember Bishop Barron was talking about this recently Oh, where does pride come from and he quoted I forget who uh, oh, but it was a 20th century. Um, I believe French Um, we’ll find out if you start speaking French writer.

I I don’t I would be in English. Um, He said this apparently this writer said that

Pride is born of fear

28:58 pride is born of fear And it’s so common that in the spiritual life that we allow fear to take over It’s not intellect and will it’s not us knowing what is good and choosing it It is instead what am I afraid of? I’m afraid of getting in trouble I’m afraid that I’m doing something wrong

I’m afraid of being a bad priest So I gotta do the right things I gotta do I gotta I gotta make sure to pray my holy hours and do my prayer rosary And pray Liturgy of the Hours and I got to make sure to to never be a bad person in public This fear is locking me into this and fear has to kind of take over because it’s such a high risk

You know, maybe apply some principles of game theory And well, it makes sense to be utterly afraid because that terrible thing that could happen, which is uh sin Is really really bad And so we use fear as that motivator And maybe in some in some sense it’s helpful at a young age It helps us to fear is helpful and and showing us what to be alerted to

We need to use our intellect and our will to actually know what is good deliberate figure it out and then to choose it and so often Uh, we we let we let fear kind of rule and fear cuts us off From actually being grateful too anxious. I’m too worried I’m collapsing on myself and you know what it’s actually

That’s pride mixed with fear. That’s cowardice This is how we often live our lives and we and then we get to the point where it’s everything’s going badly And I just have to go to a priest because I’m doing something wrong and I I need to condemn myself for something again Be better about it and it turns out I’ve been living my whole life sort of upside down

The passions have been ruling me. I just picked the the passion that’s going to result in the Usually the least amount of sin But fear tires out it’s subject to fatigue. It’s a bodily thing. It’s cortisol response and you can’t keep that up Fear will end up making you succumb to the very thing you’re afraid of so many people hold things at a distance from them

But at the same time they Put their hands around and hold on to it Fear has the tendency to hold on to the thing that you are actually pushing away And that’s a huge danger to danger in our our moral lives It’s with you know, you could lead towards sin venial or sin even mortal sin

And it’s uh, it’s an epidemic Because it seems that fear is how we’re supposed to live our lives you go online and you read the comment sections or you Go to Reddit or you try to find these popular Catholic influencers And what you kind of get from that is well fear needs to kind of be operative, but we’re not thinking about it that way

Just so scared Not not that we’re terrified, but it becomes a consistent anxiety that infects us Robs us of peace And what there’s no room for in that Usually is love Perfect love casts out fear. Yeah, so I I think honing in there’s a fear of failure that Uh friends of mine in the educational world have pointed out that that’s been

On the rise for years now And I think the the online world where one wrong word one weird picture one Odd post And you can be torn apart online Right you you you read a story about somebody who sends out uh some sort of posting on social media And then they board a plane and then they land and find out that they’ve been fired from their job because of a random post

that they didn’t think through right, like the repercussions of Uh acting wrongly Feel hyped up to to a point that it’s unlivable like we we are Uh designing a world Where the fear of missing out is is preying on people and then the fear of actually engaging meaningfully truly as ourselves Uh without of a facade

Is just the risk is too great. So so we don’t want to miss out, but we don’t want to be fully present And and so we have to craft an image Right. Well, we we need to And I get I I have a YouTube channel. I have a podcast. I have uh two podcasts actually technically

Uh one going out on monday one going out on wednesday’s ones for Catholic married couples ones for any Catholic missionary disciple Up and so I I get that uh, but I don’t post on social media all that often In part because like feeding into that system Doesn’t seem to be the right move

But but we we’ve constructed a world Uh, or world has been constructed around us that we have been kind of passively receiving where uh The the name of the game seems to be be fearful And we construct the image of ourselves as that failure as uh, we let shame dictate to us who we are

Accusations are not from others. It’s usually from ourselves We have our own false vision a view of ourselves a false image That is very much influenced by the designs of the evil one the accuser And at the same time What is our vision of God? Like if you think that like one little thing is going to entirely derail

your quest for sanctity What what kind of vindictive God do we have? Like what is our vision of God? Is he he’s looking to get us in trouble? Is he looking to get us on a technicality if we don’t know what we’re doing wrong Is he gonna hold us at fault for that?

And where does that come from a lot of times there’s this terrible wound we have Where maybe it’s a father wound maybe someone in our life Maybe it’s a betrayal at some point that has taught us you cannot trust And so we don’t But the reality is and this is the good thing is that we’re gonna have fears.

I have so many fears

Fear is the beginning of trust

35:15 Fear is not opposed to trust Fear is the beginning of trust It’s from the depths of our fears The depths of our woundedness we call out to God and we are confident because we choose to be confident That he hears us true humility Is seeing God as he truly is and seeing ourselves as we truly are

And that is not utterly despicable. That is not totally depraved We are loved Our identity is beloved sons or daughters of God the Father We hold intention our unworthiness and our worth Because everything is gift and God himself is not out to get us He’s not looking to punish us He does punish he does judge

Everything he does though is out of love And we’re never going to make a mistake If we overestimate God’s compassion Like there’s no danger in that there’s no danger like oh, no, I don’t want to think I don’t want to be uh I don’t want to give it a license. I don’t think

Uh God wants me to just uh, you know, I don’t have that view of God where I can just get away with anything You know what? You’re probably not going to do that Because when you actually receive God’s love there’s no way you’d want to hurt him This is not license This is a relationship of God’s heart with yours through Jesus Christ

This is like how wrong have we been in our if we look at ourselves and I look at myself how I’ve The default of how I’ve seen God has been so off and you cannot have true humility if you view God So wrongly you cannot have true humility if you view yourself so wrongly

Yeah, so this is one of the things with pride then is Insofar as I have pride I have not only misjudged myself, but I have misjudged God Right, like I am a creation of God. I am beloved by God and if my view of myself Is is off Then my view of my creator is also going to be off and I think this is

Uh a really important point because Certain views of God. I don’t want in my life and and The reality of God I do I actually need him And so if if I have this intellectual Hurdle these lies that I’ve been telling myself That feed the image that I have constructed that keeps me safe that keeps me out of danger

Also keeps me from God There’s a kind of stuckness there. There’s a kind of paralysis in the spiritual life then Because why would I want to go to that God fellow as long as I still have this view of myself? And I think this is one of the the great things about talking about

Uh the Christian Story is one of divine revelation Because divine revelation pierces through Our misconceptions like God actually has the power to speak into our lives through other people through scripture through the liturgy Through the the the acts around us the the the the circumstances of our life Uh that he has the power to communicate himself to us and he he is doing so

uh So that that gives us hope right like This this seems the the setup is almost an insolvable problem Right, like I have this weird view of myself that I need to maintain because it keeps me safe And this weird view of myself keeps God out Uh, so something has to be able to pierce through

Right, like and this is why like when we say we need a savior We’re we’re being very technical there. We we need something from outside of us Because in our closed system, there is no longer room for God. He is an unwelcome guest Uh, he is he’s not welcome here, right? um So

Yeah, and I think this is one of the things uh When people are coming for spiritual direction to say like you’re revealing an openness there. This is a good thing This is a this is a thing to to To go back to gratitude to be grateful for this is a thing to hold on to

Um, is it possible that you might be wrong? Is it possible that you have misjudged yourself? And in so misjudging yourself You actually may have misjudged this God guy, too I think it’s a very fair question and something that we need to ask We’ve got if you answer the question, how do we view God?

I think a lot of us would say all the good normal things We don’t recognize that our view of God is actually very tainted. We’re just so used to it being so off and um And now I I can see the role as a as a priest and in the context of spiritual direction

It is a participation in the fatherhood of God And it’s an instrumental participation. Hopefully God uses me and I can be a help be used to bring that person Into a greater a greater love of God At the same time someone might come in with terrible misconceptions with great fears and not understanding the gift

Um by making genuine efforts and even be excelling at holiness None of the things we’re talking about here actually are obstacles to holiness And having the right perception of it is not a guarantee that you’re going to be holy either

Loved more than healed

41:08 God is more concerned with loving us Than uh, he is concerned with healing us You think about remember say that again God is more concerned with loving us than he is with healing us. Okay, can he love us through healing us? Yes Remember the man that was paralyzed and they couldn’t make it into the building because uh, there are too many people

So they went up on the roof and uh, they they dropped down and lowered him down on uh, four Four ropes to stretch her down to where Jesus was Jesus looks at that man And he says to him Your sins are forgiven And we’re like That’s not the reason misplay that you know, that that’s not that that’s not the play there lord.

He is crippled. He is paralyzed. He is uh That’s not the problem, right? No. No the problem is he he needs a sense forgiven Yeah, he needs that blockage to be taken away. He wants that guilt to be gone That’s what he’s been desiring. Jesus recognized that And he said so that you might know that the Son of Man has power to forgive sins

I say to you rise take up your mat and walk But that was secondary the thing that mattered more and if that man was not healed He he would have been at peace because interiorly There was a deeper healing which so like the the the healing of that Paralytic was not for the paralytic that was for the other people so that they might know that Jesus’s words

Were good Uh that that he had What he needed to back up what he had said I think it’s fascinating you look into the lives of some saints, especially more recent ones like Saint Louis and Zélie Martin That especially looking at Saint Zélie that she seemed to have suffered from Anxiety and depression and for good reason she had suffered terribly as a mother losing several of her children

That was very difficult I don’t know. I don’t think I don’t know if we have evidence that she ever was God over that anxiety and depression Maybe not And she’s a saint Because God can do more in our poverty than we can do through being successful Although if we could have both if we could have both

That’s no bad thing. No, it’s good. And it’s like it’s like, um, well someone could be uh, If they’re ignorant of of the faith could they be could they still be saved and okay, that’s possible But we still want to tell them Because all these things are freeing And we’re meant to live in that freedom and where the the spirit of the Lord is there is freedom

Spiritual lives spiritual direction. This is living the life of the spirit to live a life of gratitude a life of gift This is how we are are to live as Christians and it’s definitively different from the rest of the world And it’s definitely different than living in a cage of fear And all of these things I would just stepping back looking at what we talked about so far

I I talked started with poverty because I think it’s just good to recognize. That’s how we where we come in. That’s why we have a need But it’s all under the auspices of humility Humility is to see God As he truly is to see ourselves as we truly are we see the gap and in that gap we see everything is grace

Everything is a gift And that in humility, the only real response we can make is gratitude Humility is you know is the pre-condition For holiness It is that childlike dependency that trust and that confidence that we have to give over to God And when we come in so poor so damaged We have the raw material of holiness

But then I I remember What does Jesus say many times? Uh, he says many things Um, but what are the two virtues? That uh, he ever told us to learn from him I mean he was courageous wasn’t he he was um, what other virtues prudent prudent Right now hanging out in the company of drunkards, but not getting drunk himself

All of these things but the two virtues that he said you wanted us to learn from him learn from me for I am meek And humble of heart So the third thing we want to talk about then well, it was really I was really kind of thinking in two categories I was thinking like we got we got the humility.

Uh-h, and that’s where we’re kind of honing in on it’s all humility Uh, but then now the second part is meekness And

Meekness, a misunderstood virtue

45:40 meekness is a very misunderstood virtue. Sometimes we substitute the word gentleness, which also can be misunderstood Oh, I mean the word gentle has so much history to it and so many meanings in that history that it’s uh We are to be the gentleman right of of uh, that Newman talked about that Newman talked about the gentleman

Uh a certain state in life or a certain kind of behavior But it also talked about people who owned land but who owned the land Those were the people who were the gentry who were the gentry They were the ones related to the king because uh the the gen part Is where we get genus

And so it just means to be familial I didn’t know all this Oh, yeah Yeah So like to be a gentleman to be a member of the gentry is usually to say that I have a connection to the king Or I have a connection to the Lord uh And and therefore I have this land

and then certain behaviors then were ascribed to them right like uh, they were meant to be Serving the the poor they were meant to to be mindful of their position in society They were meant to be an example to others And so those virtues the word gentle, uh And gentlemen, like I said long history and uh

Very misunderstood, uh, so some happy, um overlap though with uh with meekness Because meekness, you know, no, I think gentle and I just think like soft You know, and that’s okay fair. Okay, but uh Meekness meekness sounds like weakness, right? You know, it doesn’t does not seem to sound very appealing. What is but meekness is possession of oneself

To be able to not respond it No, st Thomas Aquinas talks about meekness as the virtue that we need to counter the excesses of anger And we haven’t really talked about anger. We talked about fear and we um, but we didn’t talk about anger Which are very much like these are the irascible passions

These are these are the passions that uh will move us the the fight or flight response that we experience. This is a either being fearful or being uh Like lust for blood kind of thing Uh, so like these are important parts of being human Especially for men. These are things that we experience.

I think Maybe a lightly more heightened or is it more pronounced or it’s definitely more emphasized with men But fear and anger So anger the the answer to anger is meekness. Tell me more meekness helps to Put a cap on and put a restraint on it. It resists that tendency to turn inwards

Typically anger it can go from zero to ten very fast. Maybe not ten tens like that’s a lot That’s a lot But maybe nine and that’s really hard to to not act on let it control you The same way we just let fear take over our lives so many times we let anger take over

He had it coming. He deserved that that was righteous anger because it was it was good for me to be angry there And look at there’s some deep misconceptions misconceptions about what righteous anger means Anger can alert us But we need to act in accordance with what we know to be good And to do that habitually is the virtue of meekness

That is the the Thomistic understanding and it dovetails really well in what we might say the biblical understanding Blessed are the meek for they will inherit the earth. I do hope that the Thomistic understanding dovetails with the biblical. But yes, because when you see like who is meek before Christ?

Moses, the meekest man

49:12 Moses he is the meekest man on the face of the earth Isn’t that a wonderful thing to say about oneself? Moses the author of the Pentateuch wrote that he was the meekest man of all the earth. He didn’t say humblest. No Well, what does it mean to be meek? Let’s look at Moses

He he who not actually tried to like make himself into this leader God chose him because he saw that he was capable of receiving He had taken on the sufferings of his people And that had resulted in an expansion of his own heart And as a result God saw that Moses could receive this revelation

of uh his word of uh his law He can be the the the instrument that he uses to rescue his people Israel Moses was the meekest man on the face of the earth. He spoke to God as he would to a friend And I think it’s important to realize he’s coming from a position of anger

Right, like one of the first stories we hear about him uh I mean Just after he he’s uh rescued from the the river Is he’s an adult and he comes upon an Egyptian who is his beating a Hebrew slave And he kills the Egyptian And then he buries the body in the sand where like his response is

uh quick to anger right and quick to act and uh And because of that he flees because of that he is no longer in Egypt And he goes and he becomes a humble shepherd and he becomes someone whose concern is for these dumb dumb animals the sheep And so he learns meekness if you if you get frustrated with sheep, you’re going to exhaust yourself

Right, just like if you’re if you are frustrated with a toddler you are going to exhaust yourself Which is one of the reasons why in the whenever lord says learn from me for I’m meek and humble of heart That just fits so well with the image of him as a good shepherd So Moses was meek and it’s also interesting that his failure was a failure of anger

Where he gave in his wrath. He hit the stone twice when he was told to merely command it to bring forth water And that actually cost him the entrance of the promised land Moses was meek was the meekest man in the face of the earth But what we see what that actually means is that his heart had been expanded

We go back to Psalm 4 And it says and it’s usually translated I don’t say badly but differently um But the one translation is in my travail you have enlarged me My sufferings You made me larger. You’ve given me this expanse This expanse of heart. Why does the meek man inherit the earth?

Because the meek man has been expansive in his own heart and reward is that expanse of land That freedom through which you know that uh, he has there with God Meekness is often misunderstood But this meekness, you know, we’re talking with poverty how we relate to God Most of that is about how we relate before God our image of God

and humility But meekness, we can see that more in relation to each other and also to God, but Well, what happens with others typically? Well God is not actually harming us. We can at least intellectually say that he’s not out to get us But other people other people sometimes are We’re actually sometimes very significantly hurt

and there’s severe injustice And one time I was uh, there was a picture on the Pittsburgh Pirates. His name was Trevor Williams He’s been known as a Catholic and when he was in Pittsburgh. He gave a talk to the young adults And he was a great talk. He was you know, his faith was on display and it was it was really genuine

And after the talk I went up to him and I I and I noted that the previous week We were playing the Cincinnati Reds and um when he was pitching a A fight broke out between the the two benches And everyone got up to get in the fight And in this picture that was on the front of the sports section and the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette was our pitcher

Catholic pitcher Trevor Williams holding the An opponent of the Cincinnati Reds and getting ready to hit him in the face with his whole uh with his own face contorted in terrible anger And I was like, oh, that’s our Catholic pitcher. So I said, hey trevor. I I saw that picture in the Post-Gazette

He’s like, oh don’t worry father he had it coming that was righteous anger Oh, no, I said, oh, well I’m gonna let that slide. Uh, but um, More or less as a joke just make light of a Situation and violence is not supposed to ever be funny To be clear That also imagine getting punched by a pitcher, right?

That’s a man whose arm is well practiced At at at swinging. I would think not the same thing as a boxer. I know it’s not the same motion Still though it’s going to be a mighty arm coming at you I will say that The idea that there are some things that it’s okay to give into our anger because we are meant to be angry

Is a total misconception of what righteous anger is So define it tell me more about this righteous anger. The righteous does not apply to whether or not you are angry Like how angry you are it’s good for you to be angry that there was actually an injustice therefore you could do whatever That’s not how it works.

What righteous anger really is

54:43 The righteousness is how you act Emotions, this is a big point Whenever we’re talking about fear. We’re talking about anger hunger any emotion you have is Amoral Meaning there’s no not moral not moral. There’s not it doesn’t mean unmoral or immoral. Yes immoral or or good Um, it’s not that there’s some there’s good emotions and there’s bad emotions

They are not good or bad I mean, it’s probably good that you feel emotions. Yes that fundamentally is probably a good thing about being human is that uh We’ve been so designed that’s really we’re like farming. Yes. I want to affirm that It’s a particular emotion that you’re experiencing right now While you’re listening to this

Or what you experienced later on today or what you experienced earlier today That doesn’t have moral weight What does have moral weight is your actions? right like what we do As a response to the situation not as a response to our emotional state But as a response to the right thing to do in that moment

Right our emotions won’t tell us necessarily what the right thing to do is Our emotions will tell us what has happened Right like they they are a response to the stimulus. They’re not telling us what to do next They are they are a feedback mechanism about what has already happened That we we can then be aware of we can respond to

Uh, we can communicate about right like with our loved ones They probably want to know if something really irked us or if something really was lovely and we appreciated that’s something we can give feedback on Uh, it’s not nothing our our feelings do have uh, they they do matter They are facts of our existence, but what we do with them what we do

in the the the the experiencing of the emotion Uh, that that is the thing That matters so we can have anger and not do something rash And I think that’s what people miss out like they think that anger is permission to do the rash thing That’s exactly right. And it’s not of course, it’s not we we need to know what is good and to choose it

Our anger might actually prompt us to think really fast about what is a good thing to do in this situation? And not just let give our control over to anger. It might be actually really helpful I sometimes find that I’m able to reason through things pretty quickly when I’m angry because I’m very motivated to get to the bottom of it

Um, I think hopefully anger rightly used But the idea that well, I just need to give into it It just seems erupt in me and I need to lash out. I need to say that negative thing That’s well, no, that’s that’s not okay That’s done without the due deliberation. It’s not done with charity love towards your neighbor in mind

um, so anger Um, and I think it’s really good to to say that your emotions are good, especially as they are coming from you You are good. Yeah Even if your emotional state doesn’t make sense It’s still good to have it right, like that Even if you think everything is misfiring and everything is off

uh It’s still better to have feelings We don’t want to kill our feelings. I know some men especially Uh that I’ve talked to over the years would be like I just wish I didn’t feel this anymore I wish God would take this feeling away from me. I wish I didn’t have this feeling it’s like

actually If you were a saint if you were the man you were called to be you would experience feeling Of depths that you don’t you can’t even comprehend right now It’s not about feeling less. It’s about doing the right thing and becoming the kind of man who delights in the right thing That’s what virtue is is a man who not only

Can intellectually see the right thing and will the right thing but then One’s passions are then in accord with that and our right response to the good that we have done that we have discerned Is the delight in doing the right thing? Right, like and I think we we don’t have a picture of that.

We don’t have an image of that anymore but it’s something Uh, my wife Crystal always comes back to she she with her mom friends with with women who come to workshops of ours To say like

Doing the good and delighting in it

59:14 the goal is actually to do the right thing and to delight in it That’s the goal. That is that is actually what we’re made for That that actually is a possible thing Over time so like my son who right now he is in the process of becoming a studious young man He is saying I’m going to go from not doing it

to doing it with complaint To doing it without complaint And a lot of people will say well, that’s the end goal No, the end goal is to do the the good And to actually delight in it and uh If we allow our emotions to rule us Then our emotions are going to cloud

our capacity to see the right thing and to do the right thing and uh That is a dangerous thing. Now there is a sense in which again with the Dietrich von Hildebrand slant to things that I tend to have That that we are called to to have a right response in our heart to the to the

Situation at hand like the the formation of our heart is a very important thing and that has an affective Dimension that has a the realm of feeling is associated with it. So Yeah, and our feelings do change over time Like the things that used to irk me very much with one of my children

Uh no longer irk me. They still do the thing But I’ve trained myself to act rightly and in the acting rightly. I am now learning to delight in them. Uh and Learning how to help shape what they’re doing so that they don’t irk other people because part of my job is to make sure that

Then when they go into the world, they’re not Constantly irking other people I would say to them when people come into spiritual direction It’s not usually because they are so angry with someone they want to just act out or they want to They know they’re looking for an excuse to give in to their anger.

I let it control them

Anger is the beginning of forgiveness

1:01:19 Usually the issue is going to be I’m not forgiving this person. What’s wrong with me? I still feel this anger. I don’t know what to do with this Am I doing something wrong? Am I am I holding a grudge? Am I giving into resentment because I still feel this anger towards the person that has hurt me

And here’s where we we need to like understand that the goodness like your heart You matter so much You are hurting and God hurts with you in Christ He who is meek and humble of heart has made room for you to share in his sufferings So he looked at Christ as our perfect example

And he though yet he what was done to him was the Worst injustice he made he’s ever done put put God to death and our our nature And he did not revile He did not lash out He instead said father forgive them They know not what they do Even he excused us while we were crucifying him

And he said father into your hands. I commend my spirit He offered himself so totally that Eucharistic sacrifice And it wasn’t a sacrifice simultaneously of thanksgiving because thanksgiving and sacrifice always go together He offered himself to the Father for us I don’t think this is a the right etymology. I think this is totally wrong when I say this and I think it’s almost trite

But if it helps you remember something We’re gonna go with it It requires more words then so it doesn’t actually work but forgiveness is to give yourself over to God For the sake of the person who’s hurt you. Yeah. No forgiveness is related to giving. Yeah Yeah, I mean, I know giving’s in there, but I mean like that’s I know but I’m just you’re good

Okay, good. I had you worried. I’m sorry. You had me so worried. There are so many weird misconceptions about forgiveness Well, there’s that but also weird ways to use words And that that was okay. I mean, I know you’re good. I cautioned you enough. Okay, put me on edge I haven’t put that in a podcast before

There’s their sense which what does it mean to forgive? I give myself to God in my pain in my sufferings and to go back to like when we experience a lack that that privation that that thing that ought to have been there and we Uh, we make a gift of it that that literally is what forgiveness is when we made a gift of it

That’s amazing that that is what forgiving is is to say this thing that you owe me that you have deprived from me I am now turning it into gift when you think about forgiveness. It is actually economic language Yeah, yeah. Yeah, it is economic language It is entered into the world of relationships as well

Uh, which makes sense right like economy Uh Is a a way of capturing relationships between people we we associate it with the exchange of goods and services But it’s it’s about relationships with people the word economy even comes from uh household yeah, the the the Economos is the Oh, how does it go?

Um It’s the law of the household, right? That’s right. Yeah Uh, so the these this economic language is a language of relationship And it is one where we can say this thing that you owe me I will now make gift And this was a this was a really weird thing for me Uh years and years ago.

I was robbed at gunpoint Literally money was taken from me at gunpoint thirty five dollars or twenty at ten and five right because I had had sixty dollars And I bought a hoodie earlier that week and that was what it remained I told the story long many enough times that apparently it stuck

uh, and so I I I they were they were captured that night these two robbers and Brought to court and I went as a witness And I expressed words of forgiveness like I I forgive them They did this thing. They these were the two guys who absolutely held a gun to my side and took my money

Yes, we had a conversation about it. It was those two guys I affirm that uh Personally, I forgive them And so I felt really weird when like several years later. I got a check in the mail for thirty five dollars from uh, I think Allegheny County or something like that. So like part of their restitution was to to pay back

But like literally I had forgiven them So I didn’t know what to do with that money Uh, but I deposited it anyway because it was from the county Anyway, but like that that sense of like no, I I’d actually let go of that money I don’t I don’t need to hold that against them

I can I can give that to them I was actually prepared to make a gift to them if they had just asked that was the one of the weird things about being Robbed is like wait a minute if you would just ask me for thirty five dollars Do you know how easily I would have given that away?

Goodness gracious men every every injustice done There is a need for restitution Now money is convenient when someone steals like of course, but you punch me damage our relationship You owe me you bruised me and you owe me something now Yeah, like you got to do something make up for it. We feel this we feel that injustice

We need to do something make up for I think we don’t quite understand punishment anymore So often is construed when it’s applied I think our judicial system just isn’t we’re not there thinking about punishment in these terms as much No, I mean there there’s a focus on rehabilitation in the language of punishment, which is an element of punishment, right?

Like there should be some rehabilitative element to it, but but it’s because it’s supposed to also be restorative When we forgive someone though, we’re saying I am not punishing you. I’m not exacting this from you anymore And even like why don’t you appreciate how much you hurt me? It’s my way of saying I want you to hurt

I want you to have some kind of share in this punishment and that’s not forgiveness No forgiveness and now we think okay if I’m angry I’m not forgiving that is so totally false Because it’s actually in the depths of anger that we forgive Anger is not opposed to forgiveness Anger is it is the beginning

of forgiveness from the depths of our Pain and our injustice done to us as we’re wanting to cry out We forgive and a lot of times this in spiritual directions like well, I’m not forgiving because I I’m still I’m still angry No, you’re called to forgive from the depths of that anger You don’t have to wait until the anger goes away or it’s not a sign that you’re not doing a good job and forgiving

You are right now exactly where God wants you to be and he wants you To be joined to Christ to take that yoke upon yourself and learn from him that yoke that piece of wood That joins two oxen together and one task of carrying behind itself a plow That is together the the cross beam and the vertical beam of the cross that you are called to carry with Christ

You are Simon of Cyrene Called to share in that burden and is not a burden because Christ takes the majority of it He takes you along with it and when you forgive as Christ forgave you yourself are unbound That’s the where where I want to lead people in in spiritual directions that meekness

It’s a radical meekness to forgive from the depths of that suffering Does it always mean telling the person? No, it doesn’t mean you have to be reconciled with them and pretend everything is okay No, I don’t think

Forgive and forget?

1:08:57 forgive and forget is a Christian expression. No, I I haven’t found it in scripture I have not haven’t found it in the church fathers one time. I was at a marriage workshop And it was a little game of the shoe thing. It was a fun little game. What’s the shoe thing? Well, they have um, they take the couples and they they have chairs

Um with their backs to each other. Oh, oh, oh, oh, yes. I’ve seen this at a wedding maybe and they exchange shoes So they have one shoe of theirs and one shoes of their their um, in this case their uh, fiances and um Who is more likely to do the dishes and they raise the shoe according to that?

And it’s funny to see the discrepancies sometimes or that it’s just so obvious Oh, of course the the wife’s going to do the dishes and one of the questions was Who is going to be the first to forgive and forget? Oh And I said that that’s not that’s not Christian. That’s probably like a prediction of like

uh Some like, uh amnesia like yeah, that’s right. Who’s most likely to get who’s most likely to have a blow to the head and Yeah, and that’s fair. That’s probably what they meant that I hope so because because like forgetting is not That’s not the aim of the game Did Jesus forget that he loved us to the point of dying for us laying down his life for us in the cross

Did he that doesn’t sound like this? Did we remind him a lot? Did his wounds go away in the resurrection? Remind that we make a lot of crucifixes. We don’t Yeah, we remember uh My my uh, six-year-old would say jinx at that point, but I didn’t do it because we’re not we’re Catholic

We don’t believe in jinxes Oh There’s like that spiritual sense of jinx. I wasn’t I mean, it’s I wasn’t even thinking about that I’m not trying to create new sins. He just wants a a soda. It’s just like it’s a fun thing We call it pop anyway Um, we go back and forth that misconception though about anger is a very troubling one

Yeah, the forgiven forget one, right? Like if if I have forgiven them, that means I’ve forgotten fresh slate is like well No, it’s not a fresh slate. Like they did this thing. They might not actually be trustworthy. This is not Forgiving them doesn’t mean that they have changed. It means that you Have changed but if you’re not reconciled, are you really forgiving?

That well, that’s up to the other person Right. Yes, that’s right because because If they are sorry for their sins, they make restitution and they they actually help to repair the damage is done And now this is not a one-time thing. I’m sorry. Forgive me. Okay. Now we’re perfectly reconciled This takes a lot damage trust is really difficult to repair

But that can be done. There can be even a deeper reconciliation. I recall last year. I um, I had uh, uh an altercation with uh, um someone I’m close to and we talked about it afterwards and uh, and it was We were so much closer now as a result And someone who was really concerned said I’m so sorry.

I I just don’t want to see you guys fighting And I said we’re actually closer now Yeah, and this is this is a huge misconception in in marriage Um, I had just so I’ve just recorded an episode about the death of Ivan Ilyich. Have you read it? Yes Oh, I haven’t finished reading it but I recorded a podcast about it.

I hate to tell you what happens at the end He does. Oh spoiler alert Uh, it’s not a spoiler because it begins with uh, like visiting the wake of Ivan Ilyich Uh, but this sense that he spent his entire marriage avoiding conflict. He spent his entire marriage Not wanting to address the things that they had between them he and his wife

And how common that is and how sad it is and how they’re missing the great adventure of life together And I think it’s because we we see well, there’s conflict But we don’t know many of us that there’s something beyond conflict. We can actually pass through it to the other side um yeah, and so

Some people aren’t good at conflict. Some people avoid conflict. Some people Uh will try to use conflict as an opportunity to manipulate And in those situations reconciliation is not all that possible. You need to find someone who actually wants to reconcile Who is willing to express that they want to reconcile? Uh, that’s the only place where reconciliation can happen

um so You can’t forget what people have done That that’s nobody’s asking us to forget but What we are being asked are we making a demand upon them or not? Are we going to hold it against them? In the sense of hold it over them and demand that restitution They can offer restitution.

They can they can offer to repair Um, but are we going to demand it as our right? Or are we going to make a gift of it in our freedom and I think yeah, I and then uh If we made a gift of it We don’t need to forget it in fact, we want to

Let those wounds be transformed Like the wounds of Christ. They’re not there to say I’m holding this against you guys. You did this to me You put me on this cross No, it’s saying look at my hands and my feet. You’re not unbelieving but believe They’re marks of his love for us He retains them because of his love

He doesn’t say I forgot I’m okay. Now. We know forgive and forget guys. Hey, everybody. It’s all copacetic um, but no like this is This is a sign of love. This is a sign of Uh, this is a sign of my fidelity right like that. That is what the wounds of Christ are we do not love

We love through our wounds

1:14:49 in spite of our wounds We love others through our wounds Which is a hard thing to swallow right like and you’ve you’ve said some things that are not necessarily the most Obvious right like that poverty is actually the beginning of Uh, what was it the beginning of I think uh, I think fear is the beginning of trust fear is the beginning of trust

You’ve said another one that anger is the beginning of forgiveness And then what were we just talking about? Before that no just now like the other thing that’s hard to swallow We love through our wounds. We love through our wounds. Here we go Yeah, it was another beginning of expression. No, it wasn’t another beginning of that that would have rounded it out

But we love but that’s how we love. It’s that is how we love. It’s not saying I am not wounded It’s okay. We hide them. No, we love through them. Oh, yeah No, we we don’t say no worries. No harm. No foul. I say no worries all the time. I do say no worries too often

That’s okay. Well, maybe not don’t be worried I mean, you don’t have to worry. You don’t have to worry worry is a pagan prayer What?

Worry and grasping

1:15:56 Worry is anxiety where you turn inwards And so it’s pride added on to the the anxiety which is kind of the chronic fear And it is the way of making yourself miserable so that you get a good result This is how pagan prayers, pagan sacrifices worked. How can you feel most miserable? Burn your crops next year.

It might work out better for you Oh, yeah, I know like with the prophet Elijah and the prophets of Baal like just stab yourselves a little bit more It’s a frenzy now. Just make yourself even more miserable because if you make yourself miserable, guess what good things happen and where do we learn this?

from The prophets of Baal No, you learn this from being a baby How does a baby get it’s uh anything done for itself? It A baby needs to be fed. It cries baby needs, uh a new diaper Christ may be slightly differently if you’re really perceptive We don’t we’re men. We don’t know don’t know and then what if a baby is uncomfortable?

cries again or tired Apparently my uh youngest eight months old his cry is more of a grunt I I’ve been able to discern that one over time because my wife told me well That’s I mean, but all those things he has to make himself miserable and that causes him to cry out And his needs get met

No, that’s necessary because we have limited in communication what we do as a baby But as we get older we learn to communicate we use our words and then we don’t need to make ourselves miserable But that pattern gets created and where does like are these addictions come from? Why are people constantly turning back to the thing they know is utterly making them so miserable the things like mortal sin

because This is what you’ve learned you are making your pain is what you’re addicted to You want to make yourself miserable You hope that there could be something good on the other side In fact, you might convince yourself of it. You might give into that lie. This is just something you need I’m just going to grasp after this

I would say too in one other principle we can talk about it’s probably more relation to poverty is grasping versus receiving That tendency of Adam and Eve that all of us have to just go after that thing We do that through making ourselves miserable. We don’t need to do that So we can’t say no worries.

No worries is okay. No worries But back to the um, yeah, I think the person though that coming into spiritual direction You are angry Probably because you’re hurt Do you know why you’re hurt? Have you talked to our Lord about it? Is it reminding you of another time in your life? Will you’ve been significantly hurt?

Is there someone that you would want to forgive or don’t want to forgive? from the depths of that that pain that negative emotion That is indicative of your heart aching Offer yourself to God Do it through concrete actions I’m gonna pray a rosary for this person. There’s a kid in my class in grade school did not get along with him

I recognize now he was a very He was a very hurt individual I made a point to forgive him and I I offered a decade of the rosary for him Or maybe a whole rosary And it was like I don’t need to be negative against him. Actually, I can see it say now

I was like he was a very hurt person. I had no idea the crosses that he had had to endure Um, and I still don’t But that forgiveness can be real now. I have not been able to say it to him I just haven’t seen him in 20 years However, that forgiveness can still be real and it could lead towards a reconciliation but does not have to we’re not required to reconcile

With every person that’s hurt us. It’s not realistic Now when God forgives, this is true God reconciles but for us

Forgiveness is not reconciliation

1:19:46 Reconciliation forgiveness are not the same So and that and as you mentioned if someone’s continue to hurt you, you know need to be around that person if you’re subject to abuse You don’t need to be around that person. Yeah out of love of yourself and love of the other person There’s no there’s no reason to

Prolong suffering with someone that you do not need to be with And that’s that’s good to know that’s a good thing especially Early on to know like Oh, I don’t actually So, you know Father Peter you mentioned early on like we don’t deserve existence. We don’t deserve Anything everything is gift uh But also we really don’t deserve

Mistreatment we really don’t deserve abuse like and it’s not good to be in a relationship where that’s going on It’s not good to be in a relationship where We are allowing that it’s bad for them and it’s bad for us That’s not good And you can bring all of these things together even even in situations of abuse.

This is hard to say but There’s in all circumstances Give thanks God is there in the midst of this not because he’s saying it’s good for you to be hurt like that No, no, he is suffering this with you There’s not a suffering that you’ve ever endured not a wound that you’ve taken upon yourself emotionally spiritually

What physically that Christ did not take on himself in love for you And so I think this is another thing that is probably worth pointing out When when it comes to the the emotions in our spiritual life Is that Christ has? experienced it all with us Right, like if we really and truly believe in the omnipresence of God

If we really and truly believe

Christ has felt it all with us

1:21:38 the first paragraph of the Catechism God infinitely perfect and blessed in himself in a plan of sheer goodness freely created man to make him share in his own blessed life For this reason at every time and at every place God draws close to man Which means there is no point in time in which God has not drawn close to us

Which means that there is no point in time When we have suffered that he has not been there and so we can actually talk to him About what we have suffered and how we have felt about it We can also ask him His experience of it and and how he feels about it

Right, like he is willing to reveal his affective nature his His emotions his response to the reality of our life And one of the cool things about God that isn’t true for anyone else Is that he has a right response to reality all of the time because it’s the thing that he made

So he always is responding rightly to it So we we can actually learn from his heart We can draw close to his heart right like the the beloved disciple in the upper room drew close to the heart of Christ Right. The beloved disciple was at the foot of the cross and and saw the blood and water flowing from the heart of Christ

uh, and I know like that’s a physical organ, but it’s also metaphorical for the affective life and it is Something we have access to as as as baptized Christians as Catholics That he wants to give us his heart Right, like there’s the expression the the evangelical might say, you know, have you given Jesus your heart?

and uh a Catholic response that I’ve read is Yeah, I’ve also received his heart right like he’s given me his Sacred Heart Uh, so we have access to that we can talk to him about it like That that’s a thing that we can do Anyway, that’s my two cents right there. I think it’s worth a lot more than two cents two cents

Uh, which you can’t even get from the U. S. Treasury anymore pennies are absolutely And I I think it’s probably good enough to kind of wrap things up we can wrap but looking at like, what does Christ say? Many things he says many things and I think you can go through the Beatitudes each time

You’ll look at each one, but I I always go back to uh, Matthew 11:28-30

Come to me, and closing prayer

1:24:11 Come to me you who labor and are heavy burdened and I will give you rest Take my yoke upon you and learn from me For I am meek and humble of heart and you will find a rest for your souls My yoke is easy and my burden light I think we need to take Christ seriously about that and these are just some misconceptions

I would probably listen to this podcast years from now and be like, oh man We are missing some major things And I hope to I hope to learn more about how God works with souls But as just like an introduction and things that I I common see commonly saw on myself and that I’ve worked through

Still have more work to do Um, I I want to make sure to share this with others and I really thank you joseph for inviting me on this podcast Oh, absolutely delightful to have you and uh Delightful to to share you with our audience so with that If you did find this helpful, do feel free to share it

Uh, we share these episodes on social media if you’re not following us on social media My wife and I always are debating whether or not social media is something we even should be on but while we still are You can go on and find these podcasts and share them there. You can share them with friends just by pressing the share button

uh And yeah pass it along Now Father Peter, would you close us in prayer? In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit Amen glory be to the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Spirit as it was in the beginning is now and ever shall be

World without end amen in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit From our outpost to yours, thanks for listening and a special thanks to JohnMarc Skoch for the music check them out on Spotify

Keep listening

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *