Vulnerability Part 1- Why Be Vulnerable?

Why be vulnerable? In the first episode of their vulnerability series, Joseph and Crystal Gruber explain that the ability to be wounded is the same ability that lets us be touched, healed and loved, and why Christ calls us into more of it, not less.

A Word from Our Outpost, a Catholic podcast: why be vulnerable

Episode 74 · 19 min · With Joseph and Crystal Gruber

Vulnerability Part 1- Why Be Vulnerable?

Spotify Apple Podcasts Pocket Casts

Free · 4 minutes

Take the Our Outpost Quiz

A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.

Take the Quiz →

Key takeaways on why be vulnerable

  • Vulnerability means able to be wounded. The Latin vulnus means wound, and a vulnerability is an area where we might be hurt.
  • We are built for vulnerability. Walking upright, we enter a room with our most vulnerable parts exposed, which also lets us meet others eye to eye.
  • The same openness lets us be healed. Shielding ourselves from every hurt also shuts us off from the healing that comes through relationship.
  • Say I forgive you, not no worries. Admitting we were hurt keeps us in relationship and lets the hurt be repaired.
  • Christ is the ultimate in vulnerability. God clothed Adam and Eve in skins after the fall, but in baptism we put on Christ, whose arms are open wide on the cross.

“We can’t protect ourselves from the bad and still get the good.”

Crystal Gruber

A family habit worth trying

When someone apologizes in the Gruber home:

Instead of saying don’t worry about it, say I forgive you.

Let the hurt be real so the relationship can be repaired.

Chapters

  • ~0:00 Life-changing and culture-making
  • ~2:10 What is vulnerability?
  • ~2:35 Built for vulnerability
  • ~4:40 Wounded and healed
  • ~7:45 I forgive you
  • ~10:25 Clothed after the fall
  • ~13:15 Putting on Christ
  • ~16:50 C.S. Lewis on love

Mentioned in this episode

As an Amazon Associate, Our Outpost earns from qualifying purchases.

Full transcript

Life-changing and culture-making

~0:00 Hey, Crystal. Hey, Joseph. Would you like to talk about something that’s life-changing and culture-making? Let’s! Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.

Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration, and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee, and by Thee be happily ended. Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. So, life-changing and culture-making?

Yeah. What’s that? Vulnerability. Oh, I’m just kidding. Let’s not talk about it. There’s no going back now. The recording button has been pressed. All right. All right. Why? Why are we going to talk about vulnerability? Well, a bunch of different reasons. One, it’s still a relatively popular topic ever since Brene Brown had her TED Talk nine years ago, maybe more.

Yeah. On vulnerability. Which, dear listener, you have not watched it. We will place the link in the show notes, pause, and go watch it. You can watch it at like one and a half or double speed if you like. It’s very good. So, it’s a popular topic. It’s also deeply important for human beings.

And part of being formed for the apostolate is human formation. It also bleeds into spiritual formation. It also bleeds into intellectual formation. Oh, and it also bleeds into practical formation for the apostolate. So, you think being vulnerable might be important. Yeah. For being an integrated person. Yeah. Hmm. Hmm. What? What is vulnerability?

So, I’m glad you asked.

What is vulnerability?

~2:10 Vulnerability is the ability to be wounded. Vulnus in Latin means wound. A vulnerability is an area in which we might be wounded. But this is the kicker, right? We’re built for vulnerability. Like physically built. Anatomically built. Anatomically built for vulnerability. That’s my claim, and I’m sticking to it. Tell me more. Well,

Built for vulnerability

~2:35 we’re bipedal. And that has implications, right? When we walk into a room, we walk with the most vulnerable part of ourselves right in the middle. Easy access for quick stabbing. Which, you know, is what most people think of when they walk through a door if they’ve been watching John Wick movies. Mm-hmm. Anyway, other animals, when they come into the scene, they come with their weapons first.

They come in teeth first, snout first. They come with their claws at the ready. They don’t come with their viscera first. Their organs of generation first. Their sensitive tissue first. But we, as human beings, two-legged, upright, walk into a room immediately vulnerable. Interesting. Like we’re built that way. That is the thing that allows us to be eye to eye.

Also means that we’re going to be vulnerability to vulnerability. So are you suggesting that our bodies matter? And that the fact that we are bodily inherently vulnerable unless you’re like wearing a chest plate or something? Yeah, I am saying that. I’m saying we would have to actually do something to become less vulnerable.

But our initial state is one of vulnerability. Fascinating. Now, do you think… So we can do things physically to make us less vulnerable. Most people I don’t think actually get chest plates or walk around with mail on. I was just envisioning a world in which that was the fashion. I was thinking about envelopes instead of chain mail for a moment.

Anyways, but you suggested that vulnerability influences not only our physical character but also our human spiritual, all the other elements of what it means to be. Yeah. So

Wounded and healed

~4:40 here’s the thing about being vulnerable. It means capable of being wounded, but the same capability of being wounded is also what allows us to be touched at all or reached at all. It’s the same kind of status. Even the word status means standing. It’s the same kind of status as being capable of touched, of being caressed, of being healed, of being made whole.

It shows that we are capable of relationship if we are capable of being moved or acted upon. Think about this in the physical world. If someone, a physicist from MIT, came out and started describing a particle that no one could sense, that didn’t interact with any other particle, that exerted no field, no force, but he said the universe is just filled with these particles, but these particles will never influence any other particle.

He would be talking about nonsense, right? He might as well be talking about a parallel universe. If something is not capable of interaction, of being pushed or pulled, of touching or being touched, then it might as well not exist. If it’s in a parallel universe, that means parallel lines never intersect. There will be no intersection.

If we’re talking about being invulnerable, we’re talking about becoming untouchable, unmovable, which means absented from any kind of community. To try to protect ourselves from being wounded, being touched, being influenced by others, means that we are also blocking ourselves off from being healed. From being healed by being in relationship with others. We can’t protect ourselves from the bad and still get the good.

Yeah. We call it vulnerability, and I don’t think it’s a bad word for it, but it’s certainly not a complete word for it, because the areas that might be wounded are also the areas that allow for connection. Yeah. And so I think it’s an incredibly important thing to realize those who say no worries when anyone does something to them, or they say not a problem, or I’m fine, or didn’t bother me, what they’re saying is, I don’t actually want to be as part of this community as you think.

I’m absenting myself from having to be touched by you, by being affected by you. But insofar as we reject being hurt by them, we’re also rejecting the possibility of being healed by a relationship with them. Interesting. This makes me think, I mean, just like practically speaking, this out, what can that look like?

I forgive you

~7:45 Something as simple as if somebody apologizes for something, and we’ve had this happen recently, where somebody, you apologize to somebody, and they’re like, oh, don’t worry about it. And you’re like, no, I hurt you. I did something wrong. And if somebody’s blocking themself off from saying, oh, no, that didn’t actually hurt me, it’s not a big deal, they’re actually refusing to be as much in relationship as possible.

And so this is why we try as a family to have a habit of when somebody says, I’m sorry, to respond by saying, I forgive you. To be able to say, like, you’re right, you did something wrong, and that hurt me. And I let it hurt me, because I want to be in relationship with you, and I trust that any hurt that we cause each other, because we will cause each other hurt, can be restored and can be repaired because we’re in relationship with each other.

Yeah, the risk is worth it is another way to put it, which makes me immediately think of the board game risk, where the only interaction happens is along borders, right? If two countries are not touching one another, they cannot interact. There is no interaction unless they abut. And then when they do, there is risk.

But if they don’t, there is no gameplay. Like, if each country were its own little island, there would be no interaction, and the game of risk would be the game of nothing. So this is beautiful, because to think about vulnerability as being capable of being wounded, but then also being capable of being healed, or being capable of having hurt versus being capable of having joy, that this vulnerability, this capability, comes specifically into reality in relationship, in connection with people.

Which, according to… I mean, according to Christianity, it’s what we’re made for, but also according to Brené Brown’s research, she says that that’s what humans seem to be wired for. Yeah, I mean, anatomically, it makes sense that we’re made for relationship. Historically, we all came from relationships. We all desire relationships. And so, to become invulnerable is to deny our nature.

Clothed after the fall

~10:25 I was studying Genesis 3 with some guys. As our faithful listeners know, I never really leave Genesis behind. And we were talking about the clothing of man and woman after the fall, and then the clothing of man and woman by God after that. So first, they clothe themselves so that their shame can be hidden, because this shame is this realization that they might hurt one another.

And so they put up barriers to being hurt by one another, barriers to being used by one another. But there’s a curious thing that God actually does. He doesn’t strip them. He actually clothes them, not in plant-based fiber, but in animal skins. And to say, actually, here’s the thing, there is a cost to covering, and I want you to see it.

So, like, plants, I mean, maybe they feel pain. Who knows? But in order for an animal skin to be used as clothing, an animal had to die. I know Peter does not like this part of the story. That’s one of the reasons it gets skipped over so often. So this notion that God is saying, yeah, you’re right, you guys can hurt each other.

You’re right, you do need some protection in place. You’re right, some boundaries are more appropriate, and I can actually help you set those boundaries now that you are fallen. And for him to say, you’re not wrong. You’re not wrong, man and woman, that you might hurt each other. But the thing you don’t realize is how very much you could hurt one another and how very much I want to protect you, but I also want you to see that there’s a cost even in protecting and in completion, right?

Like, he’s doing something that is not yet fully revealed because what is ultimately going to be the clothing of man and woman at the end of time, you know, we have put on Christ. You know, he gives us an animal skin after the fall, but after our redemption in our baptism, we get to put on Christ.

And so that which was shielding us in the animal is actually laying us bare because Christ is the ultimate in being made vulnerable.

Putting on Christ

~13:15 One of my favorite topics on campus would be to ask students what they thought about the importance of vulnerability in relationships. And on a very liberal campus, a very irreligious campus, they recognize how important vulnerability was for a meaningful relationship. And I was able to tell them, this is what Christ images for us.

On the cross, the reason why Catholics have crucifixes everywhere is that he is a sign of ultimate vulnerability. Arms and legs spread wide, well, arms spread open, legs nailed down. Totally open to whatever may come his way. And we put on Christ in baptism. So that which is prefigured in the animal skin is fulfilled in the putting on of Christ.

And so he’s saying, this is, you’re right, you guys might get hurt. And I do want to protect you. But what I’m going to actually give you is even more vulnerability. Your capacity to be wounded, your capacity to be in relationship is going to be magnified ultimately in Christ. And so it’s a super important concept to have because this is what being fully human is going to be when fully lived out in the Christian idea of man.

And so it’s super important on a human level to recognize there are risks. If we always mitigate risks, we’re going to be mitigating our relationships. But ultimately in our path with following Christ, it is a path that leads us to ever more vulnerability. And that requires something of us. And so we’ll be talking over the course of the next few episodes a little bit more of the shape of vulnerability, what actually constitutes something being vulnerable, how to receive somebody’s vulnerability and how to endure when people do not receive us well and we get hurt.

And I think this is really important because it’s fundamental really to what it means to be human. And I think we see a lot of lack of understanding of what it means to be human and a lot of trying to protect. I mean, I do it myself. I see people doing it all the time.

And I think to have a more full understanding of what vulnerability actually is and looks like is really helpful too. Because we don’t want to just be vulnerable thoughtlessly or for the sake of being vulnerable. We don’t want to become like doormats where we just take a beating for taking a beating’s sake.

Yes. So there’s a rightly ordered way to approach vulnerability. But the fact that it does make us more human and we can be more fully alive and this is what it means to follow Christ, right? To be fully alive. I think it’s a really important topic. And I’m excited to continue to explore it with you.

Me too. You found a really wonderful quote. Oh yeah, so I did. Shall I read it? Yeah. So

C.S. Lewis on love

~16:50 this is by C. S. Lewis. And it’s from The Four Loves. And Lewis says, [Crystal reads C. S. Lewis’s well-known passage from The Four Loves on how loving anything means risking a broken heart, while a heart locked away for safety becomes unbreakable and irredeemable.] That’s what I’m saying, man. I don’t think I want an irredeemable heart.

But an unbreakable one. Unbreakable and impenetrable. Sounds interesting. But irredeemable, not so much. No. To be redeemed. Interesting the bringing up of selfishness because he’s sort of putting selfishness in opposition to vulnerability. Yeah, when we prioritize ourself, we’re going to protect ourself. And when we protect ourself, we crowd out anyone else from being in the same universe as us.

The virtue of meekness is the virtue of making space for others. The vice of selfishness is saying, there is no room. There is no room for other people. I will not allow other people to be persons. I am the only I. Everything else is in it. There are no thou’s. Well, I am excited to explore with you, my dear Joseph, how to make space for other people.

And with that, shall I pray? Sure. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Come Holy Spirit, fill our hearts. Break our hearts of stone. Help us to have hearts of flesh. That we might be vulnerable most ultimately to Christ. We may be made like Him.

That we might share not only in His suffering but also in His joy. We ask all this in your Holy Name. Amen. Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen. Outpost to yours. Thanks for listening. And a special thanks to JohnMarc Skoch. That’s S-K-O-C-H. For the music. Check him out on Spotify.

Keep listening

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *