What is the Gospel? Joseph Gruber answers by setting two bookends side by side: the fall of Adam and Eve and the response of Christ. Read together, Genesis 3 becomes our first parents’ apology, and the harrowing of hell becomes Christ’s answer to it.

Episode 204 · 30 min · With Joseph Gruber
What is the Gospel?
Take the Our Outpost Quiz
A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.
Take the Quiz →Key takeaways on What is the Gospel
- The fall keeps happening. Every time we sin we repeat the pattern of putting ourselves in God’s place, and history shows no moment of untouched harmony.
- Genesis 3 is a confession. The story of the fall was passed down from our first parents as an apology to their children: we messed up, and you have been harmed.
- Christ takes on every curse. Thorns become his crown, sweat becomes blood, bread becomes his body, and the pattern of sin ends with him.
- His first stop is Adam and Eve. In the harrowing of hell, the icon of the Anastasis shows Christ raising our first parents by the hand.
- A new pattern is possible. We can stop digging, be pulled out of the hole, and live in the freedom of doing the good we want to do.
- We are invited on the mission of mercy. To be forgiven we must forgive, following Christ through the cross and the depths and back to heaven.
“Genesis 3 is the apology letter of our original parents to us.”
Joseph Gruber
Tell it yourself
Take some time to reflect:
If I were asked what the Gospel is, how would I tell it?
What part of the Christian story moves me most, and what still doesn’t fit?
Chapters
- 0:00 An evergreen question
- 1:45 Two bookends: Adam and Christ
- 3:00 Did the fall really happen?
- 5:25 Genesis 3 as a confession
- 9:55 Christ takes on the curses
- 14:35 How is that good news?
- 14:55 The harrowing of hell
- 18:10 A new pattern for living
- 21:25 The mission of mercy
- 25:00 How would you tell it?
Mentioned in this episode
- Genesis 3 and Genesis 3:15, the protoevangelium
- Romans 7 on doing what I do not want to do
- Dante Alighieri, Inferno
- The Apostles’ Creed and the harrowing of hell
- The Anastasis icon
As an Amazon Associate, Our Outpost earns from qualifying purchases.
Full transcript
An evergreen question
~0:00 Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration, and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee, and by Thee be happily ended.
Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost. I am Joseph Gruber, host of this podcast. And today I wanted to talk to you about a question that I think is ever relevant, evergreen. And I think we could all use some evergreen content right now.
So the topic is, what is the gospel? What is the good news? How to articulate what is the Christian cry to the world? What is the world in need of hearing? And what are the Christians saying in response to that need? And I think there’s a really good way to approach it that is absolutely breathtaking and beautiful.
So I’m going to try to share that with you today. If it goes well, you’re going to leave this episode with a sense of, oh wow, the Christian story. It actually is a really good story. If it doesn’t go well, well, here we are. Hopefully that’s enough of a hook for you to keep listening.
Here we are anyway. So
Two bookends: Adam and Christ
~1:45 the story of the gospel, I think, is very much tied with understanding Adam and Eve and their plight on one hand and the response of Christ on the other hand. If we can see both of those things clearly, then I think we’ll understand the gospel in a much richer sense. So the story of Adam and Eve, this is a familiar story for us all.
Original parents were given every good gift. In response to that gift, they decided to subvert the divine order, to replace the divine ruling with their own subjective ruling, to put themselves in the place of God and determine for themselves what would be good, rather than to live in accord with the cosmic order.
And in so doing, they fracture the harmony that had been established at their creation, the harmony between them and God, them and each other, them within themselves and them and the whole rest of the created order. And that each successive generation has felt the pain of those disharmonious relationships, that we feel like everything isn’t quite right anymore.
So many people will ask,
Did the fall really happen?
~3:00 did the story of Adam and Eve really happen? And there are a couple of responses that I like to give. I don’t mean them to be facile, I don’t mean for them to be glib, I mean them in a very sincere sort of way. On the one hand, not only did it happen, it continuously happens.
This is the story of each time we sin, that we are being subverted, we are being inverted, that when we choose not God’s way, we are instead instituting our own order. And by so doing, removing the possibility of the life of abundance that God has offered to us, that this is the consistent way for humanity from the beginning.
So on the one hand, to say it’s still happening, right? That’s one way. And the other way to say is, can you imagine the first humans not acting this way? Can you imagine what a fully human life would be that wasn’t touched with acting not in accord with our nature? That we’re actually kind of almost, we would see that as not alien, but we wouldn’t quite recognize it, we wouldn’t know what to do with it.
This is why when Christ comes into the world, we don’t really know what to do with him. And we’re much more comfortable with the story of Adam and Eve. So did it happen? I don’t really see anything in human history that points to a time when there was true harmony, when there was mutual understanding, when there was such a great respect for the divine order, for the natural order, that we wouldn’t say, hey, yeah, that’s it.
That’s the moment of paradise, which leads me to believe that humanity has been touched by this problem from the get-go, that we realize that there is a better way to live that we don’t choose, that there’s a better way, and we are distant from it. And I think the story of the fall is one of the best explanations of it.
So you have this original couple, and this is the mind-blowing thing, ladies and gentlemen, about understanding the gospel.
Genesis 3 as a confession
~5:25 How do we know the story of the fall? I asked this question at a retreat recently. One guy said, well, Moses told it. You know, we know it through Moses. It’s like, great. How did Moses get it? And that stumped them for a moment. They’re like, well, he must have heard it from somewhere.
Great. Where do we get this story from? And the way that we seem to get stories like this is that they are passed down from one generation to the next. So if you think about that, that means that the original parents told this story to their children to explain why things weren’t as they ought to be.
So whatever difference there was between animals without a rational soul and humans, this difference that is not just a degree, not just a kind of quantity of something, but a real difference qualitatively. This is a different kind of being, a different way of existing in the world, a kind of self-consciousness, a kind of questioning, questing, upward turning that is distinctly human and distinctly not like any other creature.
That that original set of parents communicated that they fell and their fall was their fault, which means that Genesis 3, the story of the fall, is not just a record of our first parents. It’s their confession. This is their apology to the world. This is their explanation to their children and their children’s children of how they messed up.
I think this is one of the most beautiful things about all of scripture, about Genesis, about the first 11 chapters of Genesis, is that Genesis 3 is the apology letter of our original parents to us. And that is half the story. Half the story is we messed up and we know that we messed up and we know also that we have been sinned against.
So in order for them to tell the story, they were also telling their children, you have been harmed by us. So this story is practically speaking, impeding your life. You have been sinned against. You are also now seeing laid bare what sin looks like. So when you sin, you will be able to recognize that this is indeed what you have done.
That you have allowed your base appetites, your creaturely desires to subvert your will and your intellect to be led astray for your desire, for status, for your desire, for wisdom, for your disordered desire, for these things that is not in accord with right reason. That pride and concupiscence have taken over. You’ll see that and recognize it.
Yes, this is not just the story of me having been sinned against by my original parents. This is also the pattern that I have adopted. This is the pattern that I am stuck in. This is the pattern that St. Paul articulates in the letter to the Romans. I do the thing I do not wish to do and I don’t do the thing that I do wish to do.
This sense of fallen man is being communicated in the beginning of scriptures. It’s an apology. It’s an explanation. It’s a chart that shows you the problem, but it doesn’t quite give us the solution. It hints at the solution. We have Genesis 3. 15, which we sometimes refer to as like a proto-evangelium, a first precursor to the good news where God talks about how the seed of the woman will crush the head of the serpent.
And we see that. We also see all of these other curses and we’re left thinking, okay, bad things happened as a result of the fall. Bad things happen every time we sin. We are setting ourselves up for a worse life because we don’t act in accord with the natural order. So that’s the bad news.
That’s the setup. That’s the one side of the bookend. The other side of the bookend is what Christ does. So
Christ takes on the curses
~9:55 Christ, in a very fitting way, takes on all of the curses of Genesis 3, as well as, you know, all of the other curses all throughout the Old Testament. He takes them on. He takes them square on. He says, I will endure all of the worst effects. I will take upon myself the results of all of the sin, but I will not participate in the pattern of sinning myself.
It will end with me. And so we see that this takes place. We see that the thorns and thistles that are going to be plaguing man become the crown that Christ wears. We see that the trial in the garden of Eden becomes the agony in the garden at the Mount of Olives, and again in the fight with death in the garden behind Golgotha, where he’s buried.
We see the sweat that comes upon the brow of man because of his toil, that Christ sweats so profusely, that he is, in fact, sweating blood, that he takes it to its extreme, that God says that man shall eat of bread and Christ becomes bread at the Last Supper, that he will return to the earth because that is where he’s from, that is what he was taken from.
So Christ is buried in the earth for three days. We see too also that the curse that the woman experiences. Most translations will say that you will suffer greatly in childbearing. And certainly that is one of the sufferings that many women endure. My wife has endured. There is a fair amount of suffering involved in the birth of the child.
I think the Hebrew is actually indicating that you will suffer in the beginning of the child, in the conceiving of the child. And that, ladies and gentlemen, is what Christ endures on the cross. The teaching of the church is that the church herself is born on Pentecost, but she is conceived in the heart of Christ when he is stabbed on the cross, that that is the conception of the church.
And that is the great pain that he is willing to endure for the conception of Holy Mother Church. We see that this is him taking on these curses. He also takes on the curses of Cain. He becomes a wanderer on the earth and the people seek out his destruction. We see he takes on the curses of Canaan, the son of Ham, because he is going to be a servant of the servants.
He didn’t come to be served, but to serve. We see that he takes on the curses of Israel. He himself is forced to flee in exile for a period of time after his birth to avoid the rampage of Herod the king. We see that he is willing to undergo the destruction of his person, just as cities had been destroyed as part of their curses.
He takes on all of that. And this is the crazy thing. So he is willing to suffer the worst things that we have ever done or had done to us. He is willing to take on the consequences of all of our sins. So when we look upon Christ on the cross, we see a man who is willing to undergo the worst things without repeating the pattern of sin that we ourselves have been participating in.
And that’s wild enough. That’s wild enough to know, okay, this is a guy who didn’t deserve it and he’s receiving it anyway. The suffering of the innocent is made manifest most purely in the suffering of Christ because he not only did no wrong, he also lived a life that we would have understood.
We would have rationalized anything wrong that he would have done had he done something wrong. And he didn’t do anything wrong. He didn’t give in to sin, though there’s always opportunity to sin. That’s one of the things about being a creature and having free will is that there’s always an opportunity to choose not God in this life and that Christ was fully committed to living out the will of the Father.
Okay,
How is that good news?
~14:35 how is that good news for you and me? The reason it’s good news for you and me is because he was able to endure all of that. And then the crazy thing that we teach in the Creed, we profess every time we recite the Creed, in particular the Apostles Creed, we say that
The harrowing of hell
~14:55 he descended into hell. In Dante’s Inferno, we have not only his voyage into hell, at various points Dante notices some of the destruction that was wrought by Christ’s harrowing of hell. And this is the wild thing. Adam and Eve, the first bookend, were given everything. They were the ones who patterned what life would be like for all of humanity.
They were given everything and they betrayed their benefactor. The very depths of hell, according to Dante, the final circle of hell is reserved for those who betrayed their benefactor. And so foremost amongst them are Judas Iscariot who betrayed Christ, his great benefactor, and then Brutus and Cassius who betrayed Julius Caesar. And these three men are eternally being chewed upon by Satan himself.
This is the crazy thing. Adam and Eve betrayed God and had the most given to them and lost the most for themselves and everyone else. Their betrayal was the worst betrayal that humanity could possibly have done. So if there were any two people who deserved to be in the ninth circle of hell, if there were any betrayers of benefactors that most deserved it, Adam and Eve it would seem would fit, except that we have their confession.
We have also in the beginning of Genesis 5, we have this hint that they begin to call upon the name of the Lord after they have their son Seth. That there is some sign of repentance, both in the text itself and the very existence of the text is a sign of their repentance.
That they confessed, that they desired reconciliation, that they realized that they had messed up and they realized they couldn’t fix it. They could not fix it themselves. They had dug themselves a hole and all they had left was a shovel. This is the gospel, is that Christ immediately upon his death through the bloody crucifixion that he endured, his first stop was to rescue Adam and Eve.
His descent into hell was to bring all of the souls that were waiting for his consummation and to reconcile with them. There’s a beautiful image, it’s probably going to be integrated into the YouTube thumbnail for this episode, so if you are watching this on YouTube, you saw the image on the thumbnail called the Anastasis, which is Greek for resurrection.
It’s the image of Christ reaching out his hand to Adam and a hand to Eve to raise them from their grave. This is the gospel, is that we who are broken by the sins of others and our own sins, who cannot get out of the hole that we are in, if we recognize that we’re in a hole and if we just stop digging, there is someone to pull us out, there is someone to rescue us, there is someone to give us a different pattern by which we might live.
A new pattern for living
~18:10 The pattern of Adam and Eve does not have to be the pattern that we pursue from here on out, that Christ gave us a new life, a new way of living. And it’s a better life, it’s a one that’s actually in accord with right reason, with the natural law and with divine law, that there is more freedom and joy in this, that there is peace in doing the right thing.
We don’t have to be at war with ourselves, we don’t have to be at war with our members, that we can actually rest secure knowing, this is good and I can do it. I can do the good that I want to do and I don’t have to do the evil that I don’t want to do.
That is what true freedom is, to be able to do the good that I know that I ought to do, that I want to do, that will actually fulfill me and change me and grow my heart to its proper dimensions, that I’m able to love God and neighbor rightly. I can do those things and I don’t have to do the evil anymore.
The pattern of Adam and Eve is an incomplete pattern that we have been sinned against, that we sin, that we can confess it, but it actually requires reconciliation, which we cannot effect on our own, that we need divine intervention, we need the role of someone who can suffer with us, to be with us, to meet us in the depths and to take us by the hand and to bring us up.
This is what Christ does. This is the invitation of Christ is to welcome us to a higher way of living, higher in the sense that we aspire to it, we look up to it. I mean, creaturely, we’re bipedal, which means that unlike most of the animals, we have the ability to look not only at the horizon, most animals look down, we also have the capacity to look up and we are the creature that looks up.
That is what it is to be an anthropos. To be bipedal is to be able to see the horizon, but to be human is to be able to look up, to gaze at things that are unchanging, things that are true, things that are beautiful, things that inspire awe. The gospel is not only are we to look at those things, but we are invited to participate in those things, to participate in an order that is beautiful, life-giving, life-affirming, dignifying, and pretty awesome.
That’s the goal. That’s the whole idea of understanding the gospel, that if we have been sinned against, Christ knows what that’s like, and he’s offering us a way out, that he is inviting us to go with him on the message of mercy,
The mission of mercy
~21:25 to be able to forgive those who have sinned against us, which is built into the very fabric of the Our Father, the prayer that Jesus taught. He didn’t teach other prayers, he taught one prayer, and smack dab in the middle of that is this weird condition that we have to be able to forgive those who have trespassed against us if we want to be forgiven ourselves.
If we want to be forgiven, we have to be able to forgive others, which means that he is inviting us on the same journey that he himself took from crucifixion to the depths of hell, on the rescue mission of mercy. That that is one of the most amazing things we could be invited on, and he is doing that.
He’s saying, this is the path of freedom, to follow me through the crucifixion to the depths of hell and back to heaven. That that is the way to heaven now. The way to heaven is no longer this other course that maybe could have been prior to the fall of creation, following God’s law, and then ascension into heaven.
Now, it is one that involves suffering and a willingness to descend, to offer mercy, and to also receive the mercy of God and to receive his forgiveness and to be reconciled with him. There are other ways to articulate the gospel. There are other ways to get at our brokenness and our need for a savior.
There are other ways to get at how Christ actually affects that. This is the way that I’m most moved by. This is the way that just hits me over the head every time I think about it. That our original parents say that they’re sorry, and we have to be able to forgive them if we want to be forgiven.
That the cycle of sin and being sinned against and sinning can and does end in Jesus Christ. That that is the end of sin. Sin meets its demise on the cross. If that’s not an amazing thing, if that’s not enough for you to say, huh, I wonder if this Christianity thing is worthwhile.
If it doesn’t make you scratch your head and say, hey, maybe this Catholic faith thing, maybe it is relevant to me right now. Well, then I’m just going to have to work on it from a different angle because I do think it’s worthwhile. I do think it’s relevant. I do think it is the most freeing thing I’ve ever heard.
This is someone I’ve read self-help books. I’ve read leadership books. I’ve read novels. I’ve read epic poetry. I’ve read foundational texts of the Western civilization. I’m not the brightest guy out there. I am someone who is consistently moved by what Christ does and amazed by the fact that he is inviting us into that dynamic.
All other stories, if they really resonate, it’s because they’re partaking in some way, shape, or form of this foundational storyline. I think this is something worth talking about, worth sharing, worth proposing to other people to see if this is something that moves them as well. It’s also something worth saying, okay,
How would you tell it?
~25:00 if I were asked what is the gospel, how would I present it? If I was given unlimited time, there’s no limitation to this podcast because apparently there are podcasts that can go three plus hours and I’ll listen to them. Given unlimited time, how would you actually articulate the gospel? What are the pieces that make the most sense to you?
How do you wrap your head around the Christian story and the message of hope and the message of healing? I’d be interested in hearing, so if you want to drop me a line at [email protected], I’d love to hear it. I think this is incredibly important for those who are single or married or anything else.
We run a marriage ministry. It is very much founded on this idea that there is a more beautiful way of living, that we can have beautiful evangelical homes, that men and women can learn to live a different way, and that different way is instantiated, made manifest, made possible in the story of Christ, meeting the story of our brokenness from the beginning of time.
I said you could have unlimited time. It looks like I’m only going into the 20-ish some minute range, which is fine. I know sometimes our episodes go a little bit longer. Here we are. I think this is one worth. I’d love to hear pushback. I’d love to hear your takes. But most of all, if you have a moment to just pause and just reflect.
What is it about the Christian story that moves you? What is it about the Christian story that means nothing to you? What are the pieces that fit so neatly that you are amazed? What are the pieces that still just don’t quite make it in your mind and in your heart? And to spend time with that.
Spend time with what is actually resonating and what isn’t, and figure out what is going on there. That’s my invitation to you. This is a podcast. You’re listening. I’m grateful. If you enjoyed this episode, I’d love it if you could rate or review this episode on Apple Podcast. If you want to rate it on Spotify, if you want to give it a thumbs up on YouTube, if you want to add some comments on the different platforms, that’d be fine too.
The biggest way that people find this podcast though, is I believe through word of mouth. So you can do all of those other electronic things, but if you want to let people know that this podcast exists, that might be the best way to go about it. We do have a website, ouroutpost.org.
I try to post blog articles about dating and about marriage, because both of those seem to be good topics to continue to explore for people running a marriage ministry. We have another podcast called Love Your Marriage. Those are shorter episodes. Hopefully they’re helpful. They’re meant to be at least generative of discussion between spouses.
And then we have some events that will be taking place. If you want to check out ouroutpost.org slash events, you’ll see some of the events that either are about to happen or maybe just happened, depending on when you’re listening to this and how often we have to update that page. I think that’s all I’ve got.
Jesus loves you. You have a life that can continue to improve in how you love God, how you love neighbor. You don’t have to be condemned to a cycle of sin. You don’t have to be always the victim, if and only if you decide to identify with the victim, the saving victim, with the priest victim, the Lamb of God, Jesus Christ.
In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Glory be to the Father, and to the Son, and to the Holy Spirit. As it was in the beginning, is now and ever shall be world without end. Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.
From Our Outpost to yours, thanks for listening, and a special thanks to JohnMarc Skoch for the music. Check him out on Spotify.
Keep listening
Share this episode
How would you explain the Gospel to a friend in five minutes?
