Why did Jesus curse that fig tree during Holy Week, when it was not even the season for figs? Joseph Gruber looks at where the tree likely stood, reads it alongside Psalm 1 and Ezekiel 47, and finds a message about the temple, true worship and beginning again.

Episode 103 · 27 min · With Joseph Gruber
Why Did Jesus Curse That Fig Tree?
Take the Our Outpost Quiz
A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.
Take the Quiz →Key takeaways on Jesus curse that fig tree
- The story seems petty at first. Matthew and Mark both tell it, and it troubles believers and skeptics alike.
- The tree likely stood by a stream from the temple. Water and sacrificial blood from the temple flowed into the Kidron Valley, recalling the tree by streams in Psalm 1.
- Ezekiel’s vision was not yet fulfilled. Ezekiel saw trees by the temple’s river bearing fruit every month, but this tree offered leaves with no fruit.
- Jesus offers himself as the fruit that satisfies. Days later, blood and water flow from his side, the true temple and source of baptism and the Eucharist.
- Be willing to begin again. Like the leafy fig tree, we are tempted to look fruitful rather than admit we must start over, as the saints’ nunc coepi reminds us.
“I desire steadfast love and not sacrifice.”
Hosea 6:6
Begin again
Questions Joseph is asking himself:
Where am I putting on a show of fruitfulness instead of admitting I need to restart?
Am I willing to be a beginner again in prayer, conversation or my vocation?
Chapters
- ~0:00 A confusing story
- ~1:55 Matthew 21 and Mark 11
- ~3:30 So many questions
- ~5:50 Where was the fig tree?
- ~8:05 Psalm 1
- ~10:15 Ezekiel 47
- ~14:55 What Jesus hungers for
- ~17:45 Blood and water from his side
- ~20:05 Beginning again
Mentioned in this episode
Full transcript
A confusing story
~0:00 Jesus curses a fig tree. Have you ever wondered why? I know I have. Listen in to find out more. Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.
Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration, and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee, and by Thee be happily ended. Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. It’s just me today.
Life has been getting a little bit on the busier side, and my wife Crystal is getting a little bit more on the pregnant side, and so a few more episodes are just Joseph episodes. Thanks for tuning in anyway. For this episode, I’d like to discuss a story that has often confused me and frustrated me, and I know that it has confused and frustrated other people because I’ve been bringing it up the past few weeks, and it turns out many people have been confused and frustrated with this.
This takes place during Holy Week, about a day after Jesus arrives in Jerusalem. He walks to the city of Jerusalem, sees a fig tree, and then curses it, and it shrivels up it and dies. Well, dear listener, why take my word for it when I can just read to you from the Gospel of Matthew, chapter 21, verse 18 and on.
Matthew 21 and Mark 11
~1:55 In the morning, as he was returning to the city, he was hungry, and seeing a fig tree by the wayside, he went to it, and found nothing on it but leaves only. And he said to it, may no fruit ever come from you again, and the fig tree withered at once. When the disciples saw it, they marveled, saying, how did the fig tree wither at once?
And Jesus answered them, truly I say to you, if you have faith and never doubt, you will not only do what has been done to the fig tree, but even if you say to this mountain, be taken up and cast into the sea, it will be done, and whatever you ask in prayer, you will receive if you have faith.
Because Mark offers a detail that Matthew does not, I’m going to read Mark’s account as well. This is in Mark, chapter 11, verse 11 and on. On the following day, when they came from Bethany, he was hungry, and seeing in the distance a fig tree and leaf, he went to see if he could find anything on it.
When he came to it, he found nothing but leaves, for it was not the season for figs. And he said to it, may no one ever eat fruit from you again. And his disciples heard it.
So many questions
~3:30 So many questions. Why was he hungry? If he was coming from Bethany, the home of Mary and Martha and Lazarus, why didn’t they give him a good breakfast? When he sees the fig tree, does he not know that there are figs? When he sees that there aren’t figs, why curse the fig tree?
Why not bless it and have it produce figs? What’s the deal with saying you could toss a whole mountain into the sea? Seems, I don’t know, a little overboard. And overall, it just seems a very odd tone for Holy Week. It seems sort of arbitrary, maybe petty. On first glance, it seems maybe Jesus is being hangry.
It’s an odd story. Were I writing the Gospels, I would probably leave this one out, because it’s just sort of weird. It wasn’t like they were running out of material. Holy Week seemed to be a pretty busy time. They could have said something else. I personally would have loved or heard how Lazarus was doing post-revivification.
We don’t get that. Instead, we have the withering and cursing of a fig tree. This passage is frustrating enough that I know some agnostics and atheists point to it as a passage that makes believing in the divinity of Jesus seem really, really hard to do. Why worship a guy who’s just going to curse a tree for seemingly no good reason?
In Mark’s Gospel, it’s explicit. It was not the season for figs. It sounds like he was totally unjustified for cursing the tree. That’s sort of the weight behind this story. If there is no good reason for him to have done what he did, or no discernible reason for why he did what he did, it becomes sort of scandalous.
If there is a good reason, we should probably talk about it. I’d like to offer a bit of a reason. I was bothered enough by this that
Where was the fig tree?
~5:50 I decided the first thing I’m going to do is look at a map of where this probably was. He doesn’t spend the night in Jerusalem until he’s imprisoned there, so forcibly made to spend the night between Holy Thursday and Good Friday. It seems that all of the other days of Holy Week, he spends outside of the city at night.
So if he’s coming from Bethany, likely he’s either going over the Mount of Olives or along the side of the hill of the Mount of Olives, and then climbing up the hill at the top of which is the Temple of Jerusalem. So he’d be skirting along the edge of one hill, going down into a valley, and coming up another one to enter the city.
So it’s somewhere on that path, and my suspicion is he did not see the fig tree on the hill called the Mount of Olives. That’s just a shot in the dark. So perhaps it’s actually on the hillside where the temple is. Why is that significant? Well, in between the hill of the Temple Mount and the hill of the Mount of Olives, there’s a valley called the Kidron Valley, through which runs a stream.
One of the sources of that stream happens to be the side of the temple. Whenever there is a sacrifice in the temple, the way they cleared the blood from the sacrifice would be they would unleash some water from underground springs, which would clear off the paving stones of the temple and flow out the side of the temple.
And then that water and blood that would wash the temple would come down the hill and enter into the stream of the Kidron Valley. So this fig tree has good odds of being a tree planted beside a stream, and the stream is fed by the blood and water that flows from the side of the temple.
Why is this significant? Well,
Psalm 1
~8:05 a place where we see a tree beside a stream in Scripture is actually Psalm 1. If you go back to Psalm 1, it says, Blessed is a man who walks not in the counsel of the wicked, nor stands in the way of sinners, nor sits in the seat of scoffers, but his delight is in the law of the Lord, and on his law he meditates day and night.
He is like a tree planted by streams of water that yields its fruit in its season, and its leaf does not wither, and all that he does he prospers. So here’s a literal tree planted beside a stream that is perhaps supposed to evoke this idea of a man who meditates upon the law of the land, a Lord who is fruitful in his season.
And that seems like a delightful image. So why would the tree be cursed for not producing the fruit that it’s not time for it to produce? So there seem to be two things that are complementary that are helpful. One is that apparently fig trees become fruitful around when they start to leaf. So sayeth a friend of mine who recently spent some time in a Mediterranean climate around fruit trees.
So for a fig tree to be in leaf and not to be fruitful is somewhat deceptive. A deceptive tree, you say, Joseph. That doesn’t sound at all reasonable. Trees can’t be dishonest. You’re right. You’re right. And yet here it is, being deceptive. What do we do with that? It has all the seeming of fruitfulness without any real fruit.
Why would a tree planted beside streams of water want to appear fruitful and yet not actually be capable of producing fruit? It is possible that this is supposed to evoke
Ezekiel 47
~10:15 another image of trees beside a stream watered by the water that flows from the temple, or at least from a temple in a vision. By which I mean the vision in Ezekiel chapter 47, where Ezekiel is told to go out and measure some multiple of thousands of cubits out from the side of the temple, from which the stream of water continues to grow and grow and grow.
Until at last it says in chapter 47 verse 8, And he said to me, this water flows toward the eastern region and goes down into the araba. And when it enters the stagnant waters of the sea, the water will become fresh. And wherever the river goes, every living creature which swarms will live.
And there will be very many fish, for this water goes there, that the waters of the sea may become fresh, so everything will live where the water goes. Fishermen will stand beside the sea, from En-gedi to En-eglaim. It will be a place for the spreading of nets. Its fish will be of very many kinds, like the fish of the great sea.
But its swamps and marshes will not become fresh, they are to be left for salt. And on the banks, on both sides of the river, there will grow all kinds of trees for food. Their leaves will not wither, nor their fruit fail, but they will bear fresh fruit every month, because the water for them flows from the sanctuary.
Their fruit will be for food, and their leaves for healing. Ezekiel 47, verses 8 through 12. So in this vision, the trees planted beside the stream that flows from the sanctuary are not only doing well, like the tree in Psalm 1, they’re doing unbelievably well. They have both leaf and fruit all of the time.
Every month, a new crop of fruit. But this is not how the fig tree operates, planted by the stream flowing from the sanctuary in Jesus’ time. That tree, whose root systems are steeped in the blood and water flowing from the temple, is not the tree prophesied by Ezekiel. The vision of Ezekiel is not yet fulfilled.
The water does not increase as it goes. It actually seems to trickle and peter out. The water does not enliven the trees such that they are always fruitful. And the water certainly does not make the water of the Dead Sea living. So when Jesus comes to this tree and finds that it is deceptive, that it’s trying to show a reality that is not yet there, he puts a stop to it.
He says this is not actually the kind of tree with the kind of fruit that we are looking for. There is something unsatisfactory about everything that is going on in this system, beginning with the sanctuary in the temple and flowing out from that. The commentary on the fig tree is not just a commentary on the fig tree, but on everything that’s streamed forth from the temple.
And why is this? An oft repeated quote in the Gospels is from Hosea 6-6, which says, For I desire steadfast love and not sacrifice, the knowledge of God rather than burnt offerings. There’s this theme in the Old Testament where prophets and other such leaders will note, God doesn’t actually need our sacrifice. God doesn’t actually need a whole herd of cattle and sheep, flocks and grain for his good.
Something else is being aimed at in these sacrifices. And there are times when the Israelites seem to understand that and times when they do not. And for Jesus to enter into time to become incarnate as the Son of God and to look at the fig tree and say, This is not satisfactory. I, who am God, who desire mercy and not sacrifice, who desire steadfast love and not sacrifice, can see that this whole system is not producing the thing that I desire.
What Jesus hungers for
~14:55 There’s a significance, right? When Jesus says that he is hungry, or when he’s described as hungry. He’s described as hungry twice. Once, after 40 days of fasting in the desert, where you’re sort of like, Come on, evangelists, duh, he’s hungry. He should probably be dead, but hungry, sure, we’ll go with that. And the other time is here, where it doesn’t make sense to say that he’s hungry either, but for the opposite reason, because he probably enjoyed the hospitality of Mary and Martha and Lazarus while he was staying in Bethany.
And I just can’t believe that they didn’t feed him well. So if it was hyperbolic in the first description after his fasting, it’s not unreasonable to believe that in this case, it’s also some kind of exaggeration or some kind of expression beyond itself. Just like when Jesus says he is thirsty, he says that he’s thirsty twice, once in John 4 to the woman at the well, and then once on the cross.
What does he thirst for? He thirsts for souls. What is he hungry for? In John 4, it says very clearly, I have food to eat, of which you do not know. And then he says in verse 34, My food is to do the will of him who sent me, and to accomplish his work.
So for him to approach the fig tree and to say, there is no fruit here for me to eat. He is saying something is now lacking in this whole system. Something is out of whack. And I think if that was all he was saying, if that was all that was being accomplished, where he said, this system doesn’t work.
He goes on to say, you guys could say to this mountain, it could be cast into the sea and it will be done. And what mountain is he talking about? He is probably not talking about the Mount of Olives. He is probably talking about the Temple Mount. He is probably saying, hey guys, if you have real faith, if you have true faith, you can get rid of the temple because that is not necessary.
If that was all that he came to do, it would be such a negative statement. And we might be saying, well this is sort of unfair. They are doing the best with what they have got. If we don’t realize this is in context, because
Blood and water from his side
~17:45 a few short days from now, he is going to offer himself as that which will actually satisfy. For in a few short days, from his side will flow blood and water. If you have seen the Passion of the Christ, you see that the soldier is splashed by this blood and water and he is quite surprised at it.
And if this is a detail that John the Evangelist will note, that blood and water flowed from his side, and this is what the Church points to, that what comes out as a thin little trickle from his side, that this blood and water stands for the water of baptism and the blood of the Eucharist, and that these
two things flow ever more deeply, and that as we go, we can see that those who set their lives beside our crucified Lord, and are watered by the blood and water that flow from his side, which is love and mercy itself, that they produce the fruit that does satisfy, they produce works of mercy and steadfast love, that
the fulfillment of Psalm 1, the man who meditates upon the law day and night, is the man who places himself at the foot of the cross, and the fulfillment of the prophecy of Ezekiel is the one who measures everything from the true temple, which is Jesus himself. So for Jesus to come and to curse a fig tree is not just him saying, this fig tree was unsatisfactory, it’s him saying this whole system is not capable of producing the fruit that I long for people to enjoy, and so I will offer myself to be the fruit, to be the food that satisfies.
Far from being an arbitrary and hunger-induced cursing, it’s a reinforcement of a consistent message of Jesus saying that he desires mercy and not sacrifice, that he is true temple, and that true worship will be with him. But then we come back to this question,
Beginning again
~20:05 why are we talking about a fig tree being deceptive? Did you also think I didn’t really address that? I know that I didn’t really address that, that’s why I’m coming back to it, because I think there’s a temptation that this is exposing, a temptation in my heart and perhaps your heart to say, we’re already there now.
We’ve already made it, we’ve already gotten all that we can get, and so we want to put on a show of being more than what we are, because to do otherwise might actually mean starting from square one again. I was talking with another friend about running, and they realized they had to make a pretty radical change to their forum while they were running, that they had never noticed an error that they had been consistently making, and so all of the gains they thought that they had been making all of this time, they had to let
go of and start from scratch because they weren’t using all of the right muscle groups, and so they had to retrain their bodies, and a whole new set of muscles became sore, ultimately for the better because their joints weren’t hurting as much over the long term, but it did mean letting go and beginning again, and it’s hard
to begin again. There’s this question that’s been lingering in my mind, why aren’t we better when we know that we could be better, when we know that there are other ways of being out there, and I think part of it is it requires a restart, it requires a going back and saying, I have to go back to the beginning, I
have to go back and admit that I don’t know what I was doing, and I think it’s easier to just put on a show as if we are being as fruitful as we ought to be now, rather than taking the humble position of saying, I’ll have to become a beginner again, because this is not yet as it
ought to be, and this is a huge thing, this is the elimination of pride, this is the embracing of an idea of growth in which we are pretty well perpetual beginners. This is why several saints have as their motto, nunc coepi, now I begin. This is why they say that professional athletes and musicians are always beginning again, because they go to where they don’t know how to do the thing, and that’s where they spend a decent amount of their time as a beginner, as someone who’s still learning.
And this is how we know someone is a good conversationalist if they don’t think that they know what we’re going to say before we say it. If they’re willing to say, I’m going to treat this conversation fresh, I want to listen, I want to hear you out, I want to be a beginner with the same kind of zeal as a beginner, we can sense that.
We know that we like it better when that’s how other people respond to us, and yet, dear listener, at least for me, it is a hard thing to let go of, this idea that I actually know what people are going to say before they say it. It’s a hard thing for me to say, I’ll have to begin again.
It’s a hard thing for me to say, well, I might have to scrap everything I’ve done and redo it. And yet the times that I do it, I’m ever so thankful. As Louis said, the best kind of reading is rereading. And part of that, I think, is because when we reread, we’re capable of restarting and seeing things with a fresh eye with a context of having seen it before.
So never quite a true beginning, but always a restart. And this is what the Pharisees, the elders, the chief priests, were not willing to do. This is when their intractability, their pride, their comfort, or their stiff-neckedness, stiff-neckedness, quality of being stiff-necked, anyway, their hard-heartedness comes to clash with Christ who desires to make all things new.
And that’s a scary thing. It’s a scary thing to say that Jesus might make something new, because that’s a new beginning. And it’s so often easier to continue with how things have been than to imagine that things might be different and to know that that will require a letting go. And perhaps even an admission of fault, or at least of error, it’s a difficult thing.
If we have a whole orchard of fig trees that are pretending as if everything’s hunky-dory or already the fulfillment of a prophecy, maybe what we need is Jesus to walk into our lives and say, this isn’t producing fruit. This is not real food. We can start again. And for him to say, if you have faith, you can actually go straight back to the beginning.
I will teach you true worship. We can uproot anything that is not of me, anything that is not right religion, anything that is perhaps idolatrous or smacks of pride. I can go to the very root of it. I can go to the very source, and I can be your source. In some of the documents from the Second Vatican Council, they talk about the liturgy being the source and summit of the Christian faith, about the Eucharist being the source and the summit of the Christian faith.
The summit of the Jewish faith at that point was the temple, and it was the source of blood and water which flowed down into the Kidron Valley and watered the roots of a fig tree. The source and summit of the Christian faith is the Eucharistic presence of our Lord, present in all the tabernacles of the world.
And he’s waiting to see if we will be blessed and meditate upon his law downstream from his blood and water, which again, is love and mercy itself.
Keep listening
Share this episode
Where in your life might Jesus be inviting you to begin again?
