Fewer people are getting married, even among faithful young Catholics. Pete Burak, vice president of Renewal Ministries, joins Joseph and Crystal to talk about why: a generation formed by the sexual revolution and a culture of death, feelings treated as truth, and a missing culture of courtship. Then they turn to solutions, starting with a better question than “How do I know they’re the one?”

Episode 178 · 52 min · With Joseph and Crystal Gruber and guest Pete Burak
Why People Aren’t Getting Married, with Pete Burak
Take the Our Outpost Quiz
A free four-minute self-assessment for Catholic couples and singles. Tell us who you are, answer a few questions, and get personalized results emailed to you, with at least one way we at Our Outpost can help you answer the call of matrimony.
Take the Quiz →Key takeaways on why people aren’t getting married
- Life is worth living, sharing and multiplying. Drawing on Aquinas and Pinckaers, the natural law inclines us to all three, and the culture has undercut each one.
- The sexual revolution came to fruit. Divorce, contraception and abortion formed a generation that struggles to see why life is worth sharing.
- Feelings are good companions but bad leaders. When feelings define identity, disagreement feels like hatred, and humility has no room.
- Finish the question. “How do I know they’re the one… to serve and lay down my life for?” changes the whole search.
- Keep the long view. Christians live grateful for the past, present in the moment, and aware of eternity.
- Marriage is caught more than taught. Open your home so others can see a good marriage up close.
“Feelings are wonderful companions on the journey of life, but they are horrible leaders.”
Pete Burak
Talk about it
For singles, couples and mentors:
How would I finish the question, “How do I know they’re the one…”?
Where am I letting feelings lead instead of accompany?
Who could we give access to our marriage and family life?
Chapters
- ~0:00 Meet Pete Burak
- ~6:35 Life is worth living, sharing and multiplying
- ~9:05 The natural law and the three inclinations
- ~10:45 Captive to the sexual revolution
- ~13:55 DINKs and the missing step
- ~16:00 Where it came from
- ~19:15 Humility and discord in marriage
- ~20:05 Feelings as identity
- ~22:55 How do I know they’re the one?
- ~24:30 No weddings scheduled
- ~25:50 “I don’t have time to date”
- ~30:35 Finish the question
- ~34:25 How Pete knew
- ~38:05 The long view
- ~46:05 Marriage is caught, not taught
- ~51:20 Closing prayer
Mentioned in this episode
- Renewal Ministries, including Pete Burak’s booklet What Must I Do to Be Saved?
- Morality: The Catholic View, Servais Pinckaers
- The Sources of Christian Ethics, Servais Pinckaers
- St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II, q. 94, a. 2
- Venerable Fulton Sheen, Life Is Worth Living
- Aristotle on the three kinds of friendship
- Alpha
As an Amazon Associate, Our Outpost earns from qualifying purchases.
Full transcript
Meet Pete Burak
~0:00 Hey, Crystal. Hey, Joseph. Do you want to talk about why people aren’t getting married? Could we do it with Pete Burak from Renewal Ministries? Yes we can. Listen in to find out more. Welcome to A Word from Our Outpost, with Joseph and Crystal Gruber — a podcast for Catholic disciples who are wrestling to be missionary-minded in their normal and everyday lives.
In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Direct, O Lord, our actions by Thy holy inspiration, and carry them on by Thy gracious assistance, that every word and work of ours may begin in Thee, and by Thee be happily ended. Amen. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.
Amen. Hey, Crystal. Hey, Joseph. Hey, Pete. Hey, guys. Thanks for joining us today, Pete. Oh, this is exciting. I love podcasting, and I think we’re going to have fun, so that’s going to be great. I’m looking forward to it. Would you start by telling our audience a little bit about who you are and how you like to spend your time?
Sure. So first and foremost, I am a disciple of Jesus Christ. I fell in love with him when I was about eight years old and really met him and gave my life to him and been raised Catholic and kind of been trying to follow that path and follow him ever since. Not perfectly by any means, but he is definitely the Lord of my life.
And then I am married to a beautiful woman named Kate for the last 12 years. We met at Franciscan University in Steubenville, Ohio. She was the point guard on the women’s basketball team, and I was the point guard on the men’s basketball team. Love and basketball worked out pretty well, and we have five wonderful children we love.
We love them constantly. We like them most of the time, and we’ve got three girls, two boys. Youngest is soon to be 12, and the youngest is 20 months, and then I work for an organization called Renewal Ministries. I’m the vice president, and we do Catholic renewal and evangelization all over the world, preaching, teaching, forming, wherever we’re invited.
We try to just help people become disciples, and then what do I like to do for fun? Well, I don’t know. I haven’t done a lot of that in a long time in the sense of most of my life is, and I’m joyful about this, but hear me, this is not complaining, but most of my life is consumed by what the children consider fun, which generally speaking, I also find pretty fun, but I have recently discovered pickleball, and it’s a bit of a problem how much I enjoy it.
It’s a thing. Anybody that I know that plays pickleball is worried about being addicted to pickleball. It’s, addiction’s a strong word, but it probably applies in this case. I think about it, and an unusual amount of time is consumed by my desire to both play improve strategy. It’s bizarre. It came out suddenly.
I don’t know where it came from, but I played it, and then all of a sudden it was like, I want to do this every day, which I don’t, but I would love to, so yeah. So pickleball anyway. Yeah. I bet you didn’t expect that, but you asked what I’m enjoying these days, and that has very much been a part of our life, and my wife would love to join me in that.
She’s super competitive, and so she’s ready to get better as well. So we’ll see. Once the weather turns a little bit, it’ll be interesting to see how much it consumes our family life, but yeah. So those are the highlights of Pete Burak these days. One question, do your children play basketball yet? Yes.
They’re all required to try it at least once. They don’t have to like it. They don’t have to keep playing it, but they do have to try it, and so far the top three have all tried it and enjoyed it and are playing it, and we coach most of their teams, and so actually every Saturday morning right now is consumed from about 8 a.
m. to about 1 p. m. of games in the gym, and the younger kids seem to be fascinated with it and distracted by it, and so far it hasn’t been too much of a burden, and growing up around the game for both my wife and I, we love it. I mean, the sights, the smells, the whole thing is just part of our DNA, so it’s not a burden for us.
That’s interesting. You know, when you said that, I thought, well, that does not sound like how I would want to spend my Saturday mornings. But then I thought, well, I grew up skiing with as much, like tons, lots, lots of time at the ski hill, and I thought, but I would love to spend that time at the ski hill, and so now I’m realizing, like, oh, if that’s what you grew up doing and you love doing it, it makes sense that it would be super fun to do it as a family, so that’s awesome.
So if we wanted to take- Yeah, it’s pretty wild to consider. Oh, I’m sorry, Joseph. Go ahead. No, no, go ahead. No, it’s kind of wild to consider, you know, like, I hadn’t actually really thought of it that way until you said it, but, you know, from the age of basically six for me, from six until 23, I basically every single day did something with basketball.
So there were, so kind of resetting that with my children has been, it’s been an interesting dynamic because it’s not me who’s playing, obviously, but it’s almost like putting on an old coat. It’s like, oh, I forgot I had that coat, and you put it on, you’re like, oh, it’s still as warm and comfortable as ever and very familiar.
So yeah, I hadn’t really thought about it that way before, but you’re right, it is amazing how quickly you can kind of snap into something that you once loved. Okay, so I think maybe this is where you’re going to go, Joseph, because this is a really neat segue into what we wanted to talk about.
It was, yeah. So you’re, we’re just, we’re talking about, like, life that you share with somebody in the context of marriage, and then you get to share that, you get to multiply it with your children. And I mean, basketball is an example of how that’s like being lived out with the Buraks, but something that Joseph and I have been really exploring as we’ve been growing our marriage ministry is understanding that
Life is worth living, sharing and multiplying
~6:35 life is worth living, life is worth sharing, and life is worth multiplying. And what we’re seeing in the culture today is people aren’t getting married. People don’t think life is worth sharing, let alone multiplying. And so that’s kind of, I think, the heart of what we really wanted to spend some time talking with you about today, Pete, of like, why aren’t people getting married?
What is going on? You know, yeah, what, what, what do you see about this? What are your thoughts about it? And then solutions, because if we ended with like, what’s the problem? That’s an easy podcast, Pete. Solutions, that’s the, that’s actually the reason why people would want to continue listening, I think. Yeah.
Yeah, for sure. And maybe I can’t wait to talk about this because it’s going to be a fun conversation and there’s going to be lots of different ways, angles we can go. But I’m curious, Joseph, remind me how long have you two been married? And like, as you started the ministry that you’re running, what is the conceptual framework that would defend even what you just said in the sense of like you, I love the three things you just laid out, Crystal, like that’s really good.
Did you give me a little bit more of like where that came from? Because I would love to be able to speak into that. But I’m, I’m actually, my brain’s like thinking about those three things as a, as a construct for it. And I’d love to hear a little bit more of where that came from.
Yeah. So we’ve been married, I’d have to consult a calendar, I think 20 odd years, 11, we’ve been married 11 years. This is Joseph spit. He’ll be right on average, God willing anyway, we’ve been married, the, the marriage ministry. So we have different aspects of it. Some of it is preparing people for marriage.
And we’ve been focusing a lot on how to prepare single people to date well. So we think that’s actually holding a lot of people up. That’s where a lot of people are making some very basic mistakes. And then the bulk of our effort is on marriage enrichment. So those couples who are married, how to help them to live out the fullness of this sacrament of matrimony.
And then where we got the life is worth living, sharing, multiplying. Have you ever read Servais Pinckaers? What was it called, Morality: The Catholic View? I have it. Okay. He’s got a longer book that I have not read called The Sources of Christian Ethics. But
The natural law and the three inclinations
~9:05 he talks in the end about the natural law and how the natural law is, can be articulated as inclining us toward different things. So the most basic of which is do good and avoid evil. That’s the sum of the natural law. But then you can also kind of particularize this and he’s drawing this from the first part of the second part of the Summa question 94 article two, where Aquinas is talking about these inclinations in the natural law based on the fact that we partake of the vegetative, the animal, the rational.
And so based on the purely vegetative aspect, the desire to maintain oneself and even to pursue excellence and then the sort of animal, the desire to procreate and educate our children. And then, and that’s where you get the sharing and the multiplying and then the rational, the fact that we’re made for truth and that we’re made for a real communion with others.
But yeah, to express some aspects of the natural law that we basically need to understand that life is worth living, the Fulton Sheen line, the Fulton Sheen title of his radio show and then TV broadcast, the life is worth living. So then to take that another step, it’s also worth sharing and to take that the third step, it’s also worth multiplying.
Is that helpful? Super helpful. I love that. So many thoughts that come to mind regarding this in terms of now, Crystal’s question of like, well, why aren’t people getting married, you know? And I think we can unpack that in a few different ways. My first inclination is that our generation, so we’ll just say, let’s just say everyone under the age of 40 is basically
Captive to the sexual revolution
~10:45 held captive by the effectiveness of the sexual revolution. So the seeds that were planted and watered in the sixties and seventies have really come to full maturity and fruitfulness, if you will, in our generation. So when you introduce into a culture in a society, the no-fault divorce and contraception and abortion, and you start to, you could see with the living, sharing and multiplying, all three of those right there, abortion, life isn’t sacred enough to let live, sharing, contraception.
I’m actually not going to share my full self with you. And then multiplying, again, contraception, and even you could apply that to the divorce culture where part of what happens in a stable family is the multiplication of that DNA of that family into a cohesive extended family unit, which for sure, the nuclear family is in many ways the building block of all culture.
But the extended family unit is also an absolutely essential component of the flourishing of children and the flourishing of life, that if you don’t have a tribe experience, not tribal or tribalistic, but like this, people that I’m running with that are not limited to simply just my spouse and my kids. But there are grandparents, multiple generations, aunts, uncles, friends, this tribe experience.
When you break down all those things, what you’re left with is our generation who don’t understand really why life is worth living, just at a fundamental level, because we’ve actually been raised in a culture of death. So death is actually seen as a great good. It’s the pathway to liberation. In order for me to be free, I have to be able to kill my baby.
And in order for me to be accomplished, I have to be… In order for me to live, I have to… There has to be death in this case. Or and then at the end of life stuff, we’re seeing more and more instances of like, it’s not why would you want to live in any sort of diminished state when you could just take this pill and be done with it, you’re not a burden to your family, you’re not a burden to the society, all that type of stuff.
So we’re formed in why, I don’t know why life is worth living because I’ve been formed in a culture of death. I don’t know why life is worth sharing because everything has been made about me. I’m the center of the universe, I’m the protagonist of my story. My feelings, my desires are the most important thing and actually the source of truth for me and basically everyone else.
As long as my truth doesn’t impede too much on yours, we can live in this weird kind of nebulous state next to each other where your truth is your truth, my truth is my truth and my truth is actually based on how I feel. It’s not based on some sort of rational thought, it’s not based on natural law or some institution’s understanding of truth, it’s whatever I feel deeply enough makes it true.
I feel that for where I am. And then multiplying is, I mean, there’s this trend right now on TikTok and Instagram of this, you know, this term Dink, have you seen this? It stands for D-I-N-K. It stands for
DINKs and the missing step
~13:55 dual income, no kids. And these couples who are either married or just in like some sort of long term relationship with each other, they’re sharing their income and it’s ironic because it’s such a twisting of this, they are seemingly living because their life is full and they’re doing all these experiences and they are seemingly sharing because they have a dual income and they’re in some sort of committed relationship with each other.
But they’re not doing that final multiplying step and they’re just celebrating the freedom and we get to, you know, stay up as late as we want. We can take trips to Europe and we can drink wine at two o’clock in the afternoon and we don’t, you know, I’m not waking up and dealing with vomit.
And like, there’s all these ways that they’re trying to present this as like, oh, we’ve discovered the really the best way to live in your 20s and 30s, which is live with each other, kind of have this full, robust life, share resources to make it even more robust, but not with the burden or not with the ball and chain of not, not a relationship.
The ball and chain isn’t a relationship. It’s children. Um, and so those are my initial thoughts of just like, yeah, it’s not a, it’s not so much a wonder that we’re here because this was the very project that the, the leaders of the sexual revolution in the sixties sought to see happen and now, and it worked.
I mean, our culture has, has totally bought the life. Boom. That was very succinct way. Uh, yeah, that was neat to see that, that pull. I haven’t thought about it in context of the impact of the sexual revolution. Um, but everything that you said, I’m like, yep, yep, yep. I agree. Um, oh, go ahead.
No, no, you go insist. Okay. So Pete, do you think like the architects of the sexual revolution had this in mind that there would be, you know, this generation of, uh, almost enforced narcissism that allows our culture to just Peter out it, like, what, what was the end goal here? Well, I mean, I think the, the, the originator or the,
Where it came from
~16:00 the thought leader of the sexual revolution was the evil one. So I think it came right out of hell and what’s the, the evil one’s desire is to rebel and destroy God. And since he can’t do that, he wants to destroy God’s beloved creation. And what is a more effective way to destroy what God has set in motion than the archetype of, of God, that being the family and at the center of that, the union of a man and a woman.
And so the sexual revolution, I think initially started to really try to destroy, um, marriage and the family from a sense of, uh, separating sex and the effects of sex from, from marriage and de-incentivizing why, why what, why should I get married? Like I can have as much sex as I want and I can still live with this person and the culture doesn’t, there wasn’t any kind of faux pas associated with that anymore and at the end of the day, the outside of a moral incentive, the incentive to commit to somebody, um, other than like your taxes.
Um, became really, it was all decentralized and deconstructed. And then what has unfolded in the last, let’s just call it like 15 to 20 years is while that was very effective, uh, they’re going further and they’re really trying to destruct the person. Um, and now we’re, now we don’t even know what a man or a woman is anymore.
You know? And so now how could we talk about marriage if, if we can’t even identify what our biological forms are revealing to us about who we are and what we’re made for, and so you can, I think you can, I don’t know if I want to give full credit to like some of the early thinkers in the sixties to say like, they anticipated in 2024 that, you know, all the various applications of what we’re describing at the same time, there’s a very twisted logical flow of what, when you start to introduce concepts like contraception, it, it does lead to the whole slippery slope adage is, is appropriate.
It just conditions people to be more and more comfortable and willing to move further and further away from the truth. Yeah. Yeah. Satan, uh, he doesn’t like us. This is a, this is something that we have to come back to again and again, my wife and I, it’s like, I don’t like it when people don’t like me and yet this guy just won’t like me ever, there’s no winning with him.
Yeah. Often times when we have like are sensing a discord between the two of us, one of us will stop and be like, Satan hates what we’re doing. It just that like, remember that like, excuse me, the evil one is like trying to sow sorts of discord between the two of us and that 98% of the time, the second we recognize that we’re able to get back on the same page very quickly, there might be real discord that we can address, but, but the fact of the matter is the evil one is like trying to niggle in there in a way that’s not necessary.
For sure. I mean, one of the things he hates the most is when we, uh, I mean,
Humility and discord in marriage
~19:15 he hates humility. I mean, that is one of the most abhorrent things to him is the humble person. And so in moments of discord often somewhere, and at least I’ll just speak for our marriage in moments of discord, there’s usually some through line of pride or kind of self concern. Uh, why didn’t you know to do this?
Or why did you say it this way? Or why didn’t you acknowledge that I did this? You know, there’s some sort of thing. Which when we live in a world that says I’m right, what I feel is true. Then like that there’s like reinforcement, there’s reinforcement for that. There’s not room for humility for like, I’m not right.
Which means there’s a whole lot of space for the evil one to just work his little way in and stay there. And where that goes really in a very interesting but very problematic way is
Feelings as identity
~20:05 when your feelings become you, they become foundational to your identity. Then when somebody disagrees or kind of, um, yeah, identifies a way that they would disagree with your feelings or would even introduce reason to show why your feelings are irrational. It’s not, it takes it from the realm of like, well, we can discuss this rationally to a personal attack.
You are now attacking my identity. You are, you’re, you’re hateful towards me and therefore you should be shut down because it’s a hateful thing to attack somebody’s identity. And so what we see, and at least I would imagine your marriage and our marriage is like, because we’re, we’re, we’re living hopefully more and more in a transformed mind, we can have moments of like, okay, this emotion is real, but it doesn’t mean it wins.
And I’ve heard it said before that, you know, emotions are, and feelings are absolutely wonderful companions on the journey of life. They are like necessary mates along the way, but they are horrible leaders. Like you never want to be led by your feelings. You need to, you need to recognize them. You need to acknowledge that they’re there.
You need to kind of give them their due, but you never want to give them authority. And that is completely flipped in our society. It’s, it is, I am, I am how I feel. If I feel it deeply enough, it makes it true. And if it makes it true for me, then it needs to make it true for you.
And if you don’t agree with me, it’s because you hate me. It’s not because you have some sort of reasoned explanation. It’s you just, you must hate me and therefore you’re evil and therefore I should shut you down, cancel you, ignore you, whatever. So this strips away the whole foundation of sharing life with somebody authentically through the good and the bad, like the, the, the three kinds of friendship that Aristotle lays out, the virtuous friend, the true friend that is, then the ones based on pleasure.
And then the ones based on use, like this is saying that everything has to be based on pleasure, that it has to be an emotionally united reason. Like this, this has to be the foundation. In which case I only love somebody in so far as they make me feel good. And I will only wish they’re good only in so far as they’re good helps me to feel better.
And that’s just, that’s an insufferable way to live with someone. It’s a great way to spend an hour or two with someone, but. So this is interesting because I don’t know you’ve, I’m be interested to see. If you have the same experience people, one of the questions we get asked most frequently when we talk about dating and just talking to young adults and injured in general is
How do I know they’re the one?
~22:55 how do I know if they’re the one, right? This idea of the one and it, it’s almost like the question is, is like, how do I know that somebody will always be able to please me, right? Like it’s a very selfish question. And, and if we have this idea that like, Oh, I, I sh if somebody doesn’t acknowledge my internal reality and feelings perfectly, or somebody makes a feeling come up within me that is negative, then yeah, they hate me.
They’re no good for me. Then it’s like, well, nobody’s going to be the one. Nobody’s going to fit into that. Whereas if we’re willing to understand like, Oh, if when, when you do something that I find uncomfortable or hurtful, like I can talk to you about that and we can have a conversation and we can both do better next time.
Or at least try to and learn. So, okay. So we’re, I feel like we’re like wrapping our hands around the problem. And, and this idea of like, Oh, well, my truth is my own truth. Like we’re talking about part of the problem is this is like, it’s, it’s re it’s a very insipid lie that seems almost impossible to overcome.
I’m sure that it’s not because Jesus rose people from the dead. But I feel like we need like that. That’s the bar for a solution here. And I think because the problem is now so widespread and, uh, so we’ve, we’ve mentioned this before, I think on this podcast that at our current parish for the year 2024 in the year of our Lord 2024, they have
No weddings scheduled
~24:30 zero weddings scheduled, which is very few, right? Um, and this is, yeah, yeah. And it’s, it’s not as if the parish that we belong to is atypical. And this has been something that’s been happening more and more. My, you know, 11 years ago when we got married, we looked into, uh, my old home parish to see if it was available around when we wanted it.
And he said, you know what, what date do you want? They’re all free. The cathedral on the other hand was like full house, you know, two, three weddings a weekend, but that those were like, that that’s a different, that’s a different beast, but they’re like home parish in general, that used to also have a pretty booked schedule.
Did not. Yeah. Widespread problem. Very, very, uh, uh, pervasive. And it’s so pervasive. I think even in talking to young people that like are really trying to be faithful practicing Catholics, they are still like not able to date and are very skittish about dating. And they are like, you, I can see the infection in them, even though they’ve like are doing things to fight against it.
Like they’re just like, don’t see how wormy this is. Cause they don’t know what to do. Yeah. Right. Well, yeah, there’s so much to impact there because I got some, I have some hot takes on some of that stuff. I’d love a hot take or two. Yeah. It, I, I,
“I don’t have time to date”
~25:50 I rarely have met a young adult who doesn’t actually know what to do. It’s just whether or not they have the conviction and the discipline and the willingness to sacrifice something else for this thing they say is really important to them because every, darn near every human being I know has plenty of time for the things they care about.
Um, I am very busy objectively. If you look at my calendar, there are lots of things on it. And I rarely ever miss a Michigan football game. Like I, I, and it, because I love it and it’s, it’s leisure and it’s fun and I enjoy it and I’m willing to sacrifice real things.
Time, my talent, my treasure for Michigan football. So there is, there is such a annoying mindset. If I can say it that way. Uh, a lot of people who are like, I, I, I, I don’t have time to date. It’s like, well, I don’t know if that’s true. That might be true, but I, I, I don’t take it at face value anyway, most of the time anymore.
But again, part of what it, what we’re talking about though is what do I feel about something? So when I think about dating, I feel anxious, I feel overwhelmed. I feel like it’s going to be hard. I feel like I don’t know what to say. I don’t, I, I feel like it’s just this, this thing, this problem that I, I can’t solve.
So because I’ve been so conditioned to validate and be kind of held captive by my feelings, then, well, then it must be true. Dating must be hard because I feel like it’s hard. Dating must be, um, beyond my ability because I, I don’t know. I just, I don’t know how to feel about it.
And so we get wrapped up in this, this thing, which in some ways is completely understandable and not a young person’s fault because so much of dating and flirting and courtship and marriage is something that, that society has to pass down. It’s not necessarily intrinsic to a young person’s life to understand what wholly virtuous relationships look like.
I mean, think about that. No, what, what 13 year old, 14 year old, 15 year old, 16 year old boy or girl is even close to being incapable of what we would consider a healthy, uh, male, female, long-term committed marital relationship. I mean, they’re, they’re so far beyond that. And we know that we’re there.
And that’s, that’s okay. They’re, they shouldn’t be expected to be ready. But part of the project of society and part of the project of adults in the society is to create the guardrails and the understandings and the expectations that then lead them to the fulfillment of this hormonal explosion that’s going on in them.
They have all this desire, right. But desire alone doesn’t mean it’s ready or perfect or purified or even good yet. The desire is, is neutral when it comes, it’s more of how are you going to express that desire? And so it’s, it’s understandable that a 15 year old boy could get massively trapped in pornography because he has this desire for self gift.
And he has this desire for the fulfillment of his sexual identity. And if society says, great, actually here’s every website you can imagine with no constraints and you, you have a laptop in your computer. And as long as it’s late enough at night, your parents aren’t going to know, then it’s no wonder that a young man would get completely captivated by that because he has no, he hasn’t been formed in the skills and the, the character really to be able to navigate those desires.
And so then if that continues for years and years and years, all of a sudden you have a 28 year old guy who, um, is still kind of trapped in a, he’s a 28 year old man, but with a 15 year old desire set and skill set in order to channel that desire set.
And on one angle you could look at it and be like, grow up, man. Like it’s time to, to own this. But on the other angle, it’s like, man, I have an incredible amount of empathy because if you haven’t been informed in it, if you haven’t been challenged in it, if you haven’t been, if something hasn’t been bestowed on you in this process, then, um, yeah, that my heart breaks because that it’s just, it’s understandable how you could get to that place.
Yeah. So do you have the solution then? Jesus. Okay. Catholic school answered everything. Yeah. Um, well, I want to go back to something Crystal said, which, how do you know you’re the, the person’s the one I think in that question is so important if you force the person to finish it a little bit more of like,
Finish the question
~30:35 how do I know they’re the one dot, dot, dot, the one for what, or like, how do you complete that question? Is it, how do I know they’re the one for me? Well, that’s pretty revealing as to how you’re thinking about it. How do I know they’re the one that I can spend the rest of my life with?
Okay. That’s actually still also very revealing about how you’re looking at it. How do I know they’re the one that I’m, I long to give, to like, give myself to, to, to, to serve and to lay down my life for, if that’s the question you’re asking, we can have a conversation, you know, like if, if, if your mindset is I, I need help finding the person that I can die for, that I can, I remember right after, um, Gracie, our first born was born.
My dad was in the waiting room, uh, and I came out and we celebrated and he gave me a hug and he said, welcome to the dead man’s club. And what he meant by that was like, you know, in marriage, your life is not your own, but with children, your life is really not your own.
You have officially died to this, this person. And he had this big smile on his face and it was like, it’s the club that all men are kind of higher, hardwired to be a part of whether, whether you’re a priest or a husband, we’re hardwired to, to, to give, to die, to, to expend ourselves for others.
Right. Yeah. And, and it’s just like, if that’s, if that’s what you’re desiring, if that’s what the Lord is forming you and that’s what, or better yet, if that’s what you’re pursuing, even if you’re not fully there yet, because most of us aren’t until, you know, the occasion for it arises, uh, then we can have a conversation about, okay,
well, then how do we move about courtship if it’s still more about like, how do I, who’s going to fulfill me, who’s going to be the right person for me, then there, that’s revealing to me a, an unresolved, uh, problem or wound around that self, that self again, like, uh, the self concern, the, the emotional side of
things that again is understandable, but often, uh, neuters the ability to find that person because what you’re really searching for is your, your identity in somebody else. And that either will, you’ll never find, or you’ll find somebody who seems to kind of give you what you want in your identity, but then it won’t be founded on the right stuff.
And that’s why divorce is so rampant. Yeah. I love that to have people sort of finish, don’t let that be the, and where the question mark stands, but say like fill in this, I’m totally going to steal that. I think that’s a really helpful way to, to put it. Cause I think we, we have, you know, have thought through and talked about a lot of like, what are the reasons why you might be asking this question, um, yeah, that what, let’s not let that be the question.
Let’s fill in some more. I think is a really helpful way to consider where my own heart stands and how to move forward from there for a person. If they’re saying like, Hey, actually I kind of want to get married, but I’ve got this question. Like, how do I know the person is right for me?
Or how do I, how do I know they’re the one to, to say like, okay, how do I know they’re the one, like you said, for me that I can die for that I can, you know, like, that I can share life with, like finishing that question and growing in maturity of what that can look like, is it really neat, um, at least way to get thoughts going for a person.
Yeah. Yeah. And
How Pete knew
~34:25 I know for my own life, like there was a big moment in my junior college, where I were right before my junior year, where I felt like I really discerned that the Lord was inviting me to, to be married, which even that statement alone says a lot, right? Like I had a relationship with Jesus.
I was, I wanted to do his will and my, the fulfillment of his plan for my life was his decision that I wanted to participate in. Um, that I wanted to be obedient to, but just fundamentally is, is a posture that changes the whole dynamic of you’re the Lord and I am not.
And so, and I believe that you can, you not only can, but want to reveal to me what you’ve made me for. And so in, as I had made that determination to pursue marriage, uh, and then when I met Kate and we started to, to show interest in each other and that was all fun, what, what started to develop, which was very startling was the first time I’d ever been in a relationship or in some sort of romantic scenario where I realized, wow, she loves me as much as I love her.
And I, I love her a lot and she loves me the same amount. Every other relationship I’d ever been in, it was somebody liked or loved kind of the other person more, whereas it’s like, I was more interested than the girl was, or the girl was more interested in me. There was some discord in levels of affection and, um, care for each other.
And I found myself just being like overwhelmingly preoccupied with how to bless her, love her, serve her, uh, just give it myself to her. And what was so startling was not only was she receptive to it, but she, she, she desired more of it. And the more she desired of it, I didn’t find that annoying.
It more, I wanted to give and, and then she was in turn doing the same turning around and kind of laying down her life for me. And I didn’t find that annoying. I didn’t find that pushy. I didn’t find that clingy. I found that remarkably refreshing. And the more I responded to it, the more she wants to.
And so that like, if you’d asked me like, how did you know she was the one? Eventually, what it came to is I actually heard the Lord. I felt like I heard the Lord in prayer say this one, you know, like I discerned it with, but that was part of a broader context of like, whoa, there was a, there was a harmony, there was a synergy that far, so far transcended feelings.
I mean, the feelings were there, of course, like so many feelings, but that was not the basis of what convinced me of anything. It was, yeah, the feelings were there, but whoa, look at, look at what our life looks like together. Look at the way that see how they love each other. It was like, wow, this is, um, this is really different, you know?
And so that’s not going to be, obviously, that’s not like just a template that anyone could follow in the exact same way, but there’s principles embedded in everything I just said that, that absolutely can be applied to other people’s circumstances. Yeah, that was awesome. Thank you. So I’m, I’m feeling a little torn because part of me wants to like unpack that a little bit and talk about some of those principles, but there’s one other point that I, I’d like to get to, and I feel like we’re running out of time, which is I’m interested in, in discussing a little bit like
The long view
~38:05 the long view, because I think a lot of times when people are thinking about marriage or thinking about having children, they’re thinking about like the right now, right? This is because it’s, this is, our feelings are happening right now. And I had this moment, I don’t remember if you shared it on the podcast or not, but I was sitting at a table, um, with Joseph and some of his brothers and his mom, and they were having this really wonderful philosophical conversation.
And I looked at his mom and I was like, man, when you like were with like all these like little boys, did you think about like getting to sit with like adult men having this awesome conversation? And she was like, no, I was just trying to get through the day, you know, but for me, I think about that all the time when I’m with these little people and I’m struggling with my own selfishness and my own sin, I’m like someday they’re going to be adults.
And if I do my job well now, they’re going to be the coolest adults I’ve ever hung out with and this like long view. And then I had this lady come up to me after a particularly challenging day at mass with the kids. And she’s like, I’m, I don’t remember. She said she was 80 or 90, but she said, you know, I’ve got nine kids and they just bless me and take such good care of me all the time now.
And like, it’s totally worth it. And you’re going to get through this and just that, like, you know, when I’m 35 and getting to trek around the world and not have kids and I’m like, whoa, celebrating all these fun things. I’m not thinking, okay, but when I’m 75, I’m going to be lonely and I’m going to have nobody to take care of me.
And like, not only am I not going to have my own kids to take care of me, but there will doesn’t matter how much money I have. I will not be able to hire help to take care of me because nobody is having kids and there’s just no thought towards that. And so, yeah, so I guess I’ve gone down this train now.
Do you have, do you think that like… Yeah, you’re pretty well committed to this train at this point. Do you think that like the lack of the long view is something that we consider? Is it part of a solution or is it just part of the problem? No, I mean, I think one of the consistent themes of Christianity is that we live kind of in three directions.
We acknowledge the past and we are grateful for it and we learn from it. We live very much in the moment with the people that were called to be around and serve in this exact moment, because in some ways that’s all we actually have is this moment, but then we never lose sight of the eternal perspective.
We never lose sight of what the Lord will do kind of at the macro level and what that means for us at the micro level. I mean, the saints are preoccupied with their death because they know that they’re made for something more. And so I think it’s extremely… It’s one of the marks of a transformed mind that St.
Paul talks about to be able to live in all three phases in a way that is consolidated and is harmonized in one coherent person, you know, where you don’t find somebody just pining for high school. Oh, high school was the greatest. It’s like, well, that’s not healthy. And you don’t find somebody who’s so like consumed by the here and now that they can’t see anything that’s coming, that’s not healthy.
And nor is it, oh, it’ll be better someday. Like, if we could just get through the phases of potty training, then it’ll be better, you know, because the cares and concerns for today are enough because the cares and concerns for tomorrow will be enough. But your point’s well taken, Crystal, that kind of out in culture, in the futures…
Who wants to think about the future in some ways because, like, I don’t want to consider my own death. That’s so morbid. That’s so… That’s not fun. That’s like, who wants to think about that? It’s like, in some ways, all we have is the here and now. So we’ll worry about that when we have to worry about that.
It kind of causes me anxiety to think about it anyway. So I’ll just, you know, I’ll just focus on the here and now. And it feeds into that kind of narcissistic, feeling-based reality of like… I… The delayed gratification is also not something that we are very good at. We are not as a culture…
You know, I get annoyed right now if my Amazon package doesn’t arrive the next day. I just start saying things I don’t even understand. I’m like, you know, oh, where… Sales funnel. And like, I say all these things like, infrastructure, what’s happening here, you know? Supply chain. And I don’t even get it, but I’m like annoyed that it’s not there, you know, the next day.
So this idea that something could take time and build and the fruit or the validation of something would come in a year, five years, 10 years, 30 years. That’s not something that most of us kind of value right now. Yeah, so delayed gratification, certainly not part of our culture. But I think the way that you set it up, Crystal, is that you’re saying, people are selfish now.
Couldn’t we just take them that little step and help them be selfish about how they will be? And I think that’s an… Yeah. Well, I’m not even sure if that’s going to do it, because it’s still just an appeal to their own self-interest. It’s just projecting it into the future. Like, fundamentally, if somebody is only concerned about themselves now, until the end of their life, that still will make them insufferable to live with, and still will make the whole raising of children a chore that just has no upside.
Well, to earlier on in our conversation, I was also realizing like, oh, well, if this is like, I only want life when it’s fun, then you’re actually not going to want to live when you’re that age, when you need somebody to take care of you. And then it’s really handy that we’re popularizing euthanasia, which is really terrifying and awful to think about.
Yeah. It’s almost like what we actually need is a transcendent source of truth, who is himself loving us and giving us that which we need, so that we can be secure in our identity in that transcendent other. Well, and maybe back to Pete, your point. Yeah, no, absolutely. It is the… I agree with all that has been said and have only to add.
Like, what you described of like that discernment process with your now wife, Pete, of like loving each other well, there’s an entering into the transcendent in that kind of being mutual gift to each other and mutual relationship and how beautiful that is. And we like, as you were describing, I was like, oh, man, like, well, I already wanted to meet your wife and hang out with you guys.
But like, there’s like, we want to be around people that have that kind of relationship with each other. We want to share life with people like that. And I think that that’s a really beautiful way to encourage people to get married, is to like let them see our lives and like love each other well and share that with people, maybe.
No, I mean, to that point, why would I want to enter into an institution that fails at the epic rate that it does? Why would I want to shackle myself to someone when it becomes a ball in the chain, when it limits my freedom, when all of a sudden sex becomes boring because it’s the same person every time?
Like, there’s so many narratives that have emerged to validate people’s perspective towards marriage that one of the antidotes to that is something that’s
Marriage is caught, not taught
~46:05 more caught than taught. It’s like, I want to give you access to my life. And instead of telling you marriage is great, I want to show you. And the only way you can see it is if I grant you access to it. You know, and this is just another way to understand discipleship.
Discipleship requires accessibility between the person who’s further ahead, who’s trying to lead somebody into something. And so one of the things we felt from the very beginning of our marriage and family life was we were just going to we have basically what we call an open door policy where people know they can come over basically any time.
And very few people have actually taken us on it on the completely random. But there have been a few times where people just like doorbell rings and it’s like somebody was like, hey, I just needed a place to come. It’s like, awesome. Welcome. We’ve, you know, we’ve had people living with us for most of our marriage.
We’ve that are not in our family. We’ve had, you know, we’ve run Alpha courses. We’ve just done all sorts of things to try to grant people access to our life. Not because we’re perfect, apart from it, but because we’re we’re striving, we’re going for it. We and we are willing to acknowledge both the good and the not so good.
And and we we’re seeing some of the most true from that is actually just in our neighbors where people who are all over the place in a religious context, who have all sorts of different understandings of marriage and family life. I mean, we are a very confusing but alluring family in the neighborhood.
People are simultaneously like who are these people and simultaneously play. Man, there’s something something there, you know. And that gives us the access as we build trust and friendship and everything to talk about what that something there is. You know, I’m not waiting for, say, for somebody to ask me about it. I want to be able to use my words and share with what’s going on.
But yeah, I think there’s there’s a certain way where Christians are remarkably good at kind of disguising our Christianity or hiding or kind of not letting people into the reality of what’s going on in our hearts and our minds and our lives. And just kind of hoping people will like naturally pick up on it.
And I don’t know, I don’t I don’t that doesn’t happen very often. And especially something with marriage is it’s such a generational thing. It’s such a thing that needs adults need to form in children. And the next way that they there’s even something like flirting. Flirting is not something like in my experience, flirting is something that really needs to be taught.
It needs to be modeled. It needs to be acknowledged as a real thing. And whether or not you like the word flirting or courting or wooing, whatever it is, that’s something that is that is passed down and is, again, bestowed in our culture. We just don’t pass a lot of things down and we don’t really bestow a lot of things.
We either just hope it kind of happens or we’re passing down the wrong things, the wrong types of models that we’ve now been talking about. Yeah, you have a face like you want to wrap up because it’s like a time. But I don’t know how long he can actually stay so we can check with him.
Well, we might just have to do another episode. We could do another. I come back and talk all just just about flirting and dating and all that because we didn’t even touch on that. But that yeah, I still have plenty of hot takes for that. Yeah, I definitely learning like a disciple. I don’t know if this would be possible, but it would be super fun to have you bring your wife and you guys can demonstrate with each other.
You want to. OK, a little little role play flirting here. Yeah. Yeah. Now we’re now we’re now we’re really going off the rails. Joseph, this is fun. I like it. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It could go well, it could. This is a super fun conversation. I would love to have more conversations. Yeah. I mean, cool.
Awesome. Well, any other last things you want to share or last thoughts? Before we wrap it up. Is there anything you would like to plug or any way that people can like check you out? Yeah. Yeah. If they’d like anyone like more information about what we’re doing with Renewal Ministries and you can just go to renewalministries.
net. We have several podcasts ourselves and different things that I think would be a blessing to people. I just wrote a booklet that the first copy is free. If anybody wants it, it’s called What Must I Do to be Saved. It’s all about salvation and what Jesus actually says about salvation. And yeah, but I mean, this is super fun.
And if the opportunity arises to do it again, I would make it a priority. So hopefully, hopefully the audience has enjoyed it as much as we did, because I enjoyed it. But there’s still lots that we could unpack. Yeah, love it. You too. Would you close us in prayer, Pete? Will do. That’d be great.
In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Oh, Jesus,
Closing prayer
~51:20 we love you and we praise you and we thank you and we bless you. And we glorify you and we worship you, Lord Jesus. We thank you for the gift of our lives. We thank you for the gift of our sexuality. We thank you for the gift of other people’s lives. And we thank you for the great gift of marriage and that wonderful, infusing, mysterious, awesome, potent vocation.
Lord, we just pray right now, Joseph, Crystal and I, for everyone who’s listening, that wherever they are in their walk, in their vocational life, they would first and foremost encounter you today in a new and more powerful way, Lord, that you would reveal yourself to them, that their hearts would burn with love for you as they learn to love others.
Amen. Amen. The Father of the Son of the Holy Spirit. Amen. Amen. From Our Outpost to yours, thanks for listening. And a special thanks to JohnMarc Skoch for the music. Check him out on Spotify.
Keep listening
Share this episode
Know a young adult, parent, or pastor puzzled by why so few people marry? Share this conversation.
